Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder why so many people choose to have such a short age gap between their children?

616 replies

Lightningfast · 12/01/2023 20:28

I hear of so many people with two children two years apart and can’t for the life of me understand why anyone would want

a. To be pregnant with a child of around only a year old
b. To have a newborn baby when the older one is still a toddler and therefore still needs support in so many really basic ways. Sure, they don’t need the same level of support as a new baby but still...

I’ve heard the ‘they will be close enough to be friends’ theory but in practice I have seen at least as many if not rather more siblings who are close in age but are not especially close emotionally and it feels a rather weak reason.
I see this happening so often, even with mothers who have really struggled with getting their first baby to feed, sleep etc. and yet seem hellbent on having another only a matter of months later. Just...why?

If this is you I’m not judging, just genuinely interested in what you are getting out of it.

OP posts:
BigBoysDontCry · 15/01/2023 13:49

I don't think you can predict at all. I have only two, both boys, 13 months apart and apart from toddler squabbles, they have always been close and protective of each other and would certainly still (in their early 20s) consider each other their best friend. They wanted to (and did) share a bedroom until teenage years. I have a friend who has 2 girls (now adults) with the same gap who hate each other and haven't spoken for many years and who didn't even invite each other to their respective weddings.

Another friend who has a 6 year age gap (older boy and younger girl) who adore each other and a colleague with exactly the same where they hate each other and where they are jealous of the air the other breathes.

I'm one of 7 with various age gaps, we all get on but some get on more closely with some siblings than others.

Yb23487643 · 15/01/2023 13:40

I think people with bickering children think all siblings are like that. They’re not. In my experience 2 kids of same gender close in age fight horrendously and intense sibling rivalry. Much less noticeable if siblings of different genders. Much less noticeable if bigger age gap. More noticeable if only 2 kids, 3 seems better if close together in age. But I think gender more of an issue for sibling rivalry than age gap. Seems to persist into adulthood.

Angelil · 15/01/2023 13:04

Honestly I really don’t get some of these arguments. You don’t have to rebuy everything…it all just goes into storage or the lift and comes out again for the second child. Similarly there are people here claiming that it’s less damaging to their career to have a small age gap but then in the next breath people saying they took seven years off to be at home with their children before they started school…how is that less damaging than me taking 7 months off work in 2018/2019 when I had my son and having 7 months off now (in 2023) for my second child?

cadburyegg · 15/01/2023 12:56

I should have mentioned the pros of a 3 year gap I guess - maternity leave with my dc2 was the best year of my life, loads of time with both children, dc1 didn't need watching 100% of the time so I could change dc2's nappy without worrying too much, he was old enough to understand my attention was elsewhere, he was eligible for the funded hours,

cadburyegg · 15/01/2023 12:52

Each to their own, a couple of my friends have waited until their dc1 was in school to have another and are having to do the school run on no sleep. I have a 3 year gap and at least if I was late getting dc1 to nursery one day or if he didn't go at all, it didn't matter as much.

I can see the advantages of a smaller gap, my ds2 started school in September and i admit I was losing patience with having a preschooler at home at that point, after having a baby/toddler/preschooler for 7+ years.

But sometimes it isn't planned, the 2 families I know who had 2 under 2 didn't plan it. Both said it was hard work in the beginning but it's great now they're older. Equally some people might have wanted a smaller gap than they ended up with, I would have had a smaller one if my second pregnancy hadn't ended in miscarriage.

MeridaBrave · 15/01/2023 12:24

So many reasons, for me it was because I didn’t get pregnant quickly the first time so thought why wait too long before trying again, assuming it was take same length of time. It didn’t. Sorry you post is so judgemental assuming people always choose. Other reasons are get baby and toddler phase out of way. Kids closer in age makes things easier (less time with kids at different schools etc)

wingingit1987 · 15/01/2023 10:13

ShaunaTheSheep · 12/01/2023 20:38

Sorry OP but you do sound judge despite your protestations.

My DC's age gaps are what I was blessed with and I wouldn't have it any other way. They ARE great friends etc etc.

Exactly this. Mine are very close- because I have a bigger family there is always someone for them to play with. It’s also allowed me more time with the older ones really, as maternity leave has meant I’ve been home more than I would have been otherwise.

wingingit1987 · 15/01/2023 10:01

I’ve got 5 children. Each with a 2 year gap. I don’t find it overwhelming. I don’t struggle with lack of sleep or anything. Only my last baby was actively “tried” for and the rest were a case of “not trying/not preventing”. I genuinely absolutely love having a big family and, while I found my last pregnancy harder going now that I’m 35, I don’t see any downsides to it at all. While OP might find having them close in age a “weak reason”, I don’t think I need a reason other than that all my children were wanted and the age gap doesn’t faze me.

AnxiteacupStorm · 14/01/2023 21:18

There’s not even a year between mine.
Told repeatedly mw’s hv’s and gps “oh you’re bf’ing you’re covered you don’t need the pill” .. evidently that was wrong. Yes I should’ve insisted, yes I should’ve looked into it myself but I wouldn’t change it. Like others have said it’s tough in the beginning but I can’t imagine doing the school run with a newborn on an hours sleep being much easier.

Alittlenonsensenowandthen · 14/01/2023 21:18

Well the first two were a minute apart but that wasn't my fault and the third wasn't planned 🙂 I had a big age gap as a child and always envied friends who had siblings close in age.
It was chaotic but they are all good friends and it's easier to plan activities that they all like as they're the same stage.

CurlyC12 · 14/01/2023 21:04

I have a DD who is nearly 2 and am currently pregnant with my second… we weren’t sure we were going to have another.. this has been a bit of a surprise but we are over the
moon and I’m so happy with the age gap. I also have 13 year old step daughter and I find it tough trying to keep both girls entertained as they enjoy doing totally different things. I had and still have an amazing relationship with my sister who is 22 months younger than me so I hope for the same with my children. I’m also 36 so I felt
like I couldn’t have waited too much longer anyway.

KennedyD22 · 14/01/2023 21:02

Also just to add - yes pregnancy with a baby to look after is challenging. My DD1 was 9 months when I fell pregnant with DD2.

But you know what I find harder? Working when you’re pregnant! I was still on maternity leave and so I just stayed at home for pregnancy of DD2 - it was lush! Could just handle the sickness, heartburn, fatigue all from the comfort of my home whilst cuddling my eldest on the sofa (I’m lucky she’s very low maintenance, good sleeper, eats anything and prefers playing on her own than with me) Much preferred that than trying to work too. Helps when you have a supportive partner too that takes on half the night feeds.

KennedyD22 · 14/01/2023 20:52

Haven’t read the whole thread but think this post is pretty judgemental. Who cares what other people do?! There’s benefits and cons to all age gaps, there’s no ‘perfect’ age gap.

I have 18 months between mine - I could not stand the idea of waiting 5 years, the eldest starting school and life finally getting that bit easier and then doing it all over again! You lose so much sleep in those first 5 years, I’d rather lose a lot of sleep in 5 than 10 years! Like I like my exercise (HIIT training) higher intensity, shorter time rather than lower intensity, longer time.

To be honest, I don’t see many cons with my age gap, it’s been nowhere near as hard as I thought it would be and my two girls always have each other to play with - if anything this has given me more time and less guilt to do housework, because they are never lonely & always have each other. Soon we’ll be done with nappies and milk and night feeds & we won’t have to do it all again. It also suits my career life - I’m a student nurse atm and won’t have to take maternity whilst I’m working and can focus on my career when they start school.

RussianDolls146 · 14/01/2023 14:54

Madaboutthecat · 14/01/2023 11:08

On the other hand, I wonder why leave a big gap between children. Just when you start (sort of) getting your life back, BOOM … right back to sleepless nights, puke and nappies. No thanks. Get it out of the way. But, each to their own.

There are 5 years between my children. I would have liked a closer gap, but it didn't happen. Mine get along OK.

saturdaymorningbored · 14/01/2023 14:43

I think a lot of it is to do with what we grew up with. The majority of my friends when we were younger all had brothers or sisters with a 2 year age gap
I have a similar age gap between my 2 and found it to be fine. Much easier to find things that they both enjoyed doing on days out compared with having to entertain a 3 year old and 8 year old

climbthathill129 · 14/01/2023 14:38

Mine are close together and (for me) it hasn't been as difficult as I had thought. Everyone told me how brave I was and how difficult it would be. But it's been completely fine.

You are already in the routine of nappies and bottles etc. They both have about the same schedule now so it's just great. They also have the same interests so it's really easy. They can share toys etc. We have done the newborn phase & no sleeping phase and I'm so glad I never have to do that again!

Being pregnant with a toddler was tiring towards the end but my family were so helpful in making sure my eldest was entertained & having great fun.

They now have a lovely friendship and it's so nice to see.

Workawayxx · 14/01/2023 14:31

I have 9 years between mine and can see the advantages and disadvantages of close or larger age gaps. One thing with a closer age gap is that there will be activities that work for both - films, soft play, trampolining, theme parks etc. plus they will be able to play together to sone extent even if they arent best friends.having said that I make sure ds still gets to do activities, they are just one on one with me and leave his little sister at home which is nice to have that focused time. My 2 are lovely together and have a great relationship so far but it’s very different t to a smaller gap relationship. Ds is like a third parent at times!

QueenoftheNimbleFlyingCat · 14/01/2023 13:19

I just wanted to get the baby stage out of the way, I wasn't sleeping anyway so a few more hours of missed sleep didn't make a difference.

At my age, I was in my 30s and didn't want to wait for a big age gap. I also wanted them to be a similar age so we could do the same activities and that they would be friends. Thankfully, they had each other during lockdown and it made the biggest difference to my sanity!!!

Benjispruce4 · 14/01/2023 13:12

DH has a brother who is 16 months his senior and one who is 7 years younger. He is much closer to his youngest brother.

Moversnotshakers · 14/01/2023 12:27

There is exactly a year between my two gds. Born same day a year apart! Not really planned but my son & DIL coped brilliantly..

WineDup · 14/01/2023 12:20

My kids are 6.5 years apart and I love it. It wasn’t particularly planned this way - initially I wanted a smaller age gap but I’m glad for the fairly large gap now.
My daughter got my full attention when she needed it, and my son wasn’t born until she naturally became more independent. So I feel both my children have been able to have lots of my undivided attention.
My daughter really benefitted from my second maternity leave - I was able to do school drop offs, pick ups etc. - a toddler wouldn’t really understand the quality of this time. And also when I went back to work after my son, my daughter was old enough not to be upset by the change in routine.
My daughter absolutely adores her younger brother, and he loves her too. She’s old enough to understand his needs so I can leave them together for 10 minutes to grab a shower. It wouldn’t be easy to leave a baby and a toddler in this way.
Financiallyit worked out too as we had a lot of time to save up in between kids, to the point that we are now able to both work part time, which both children benefit from.
It has extended the time we have small children for - I love the baby stage and both my kids are great sleepers, if we had a small age gap after my daughter I would now be coming to an end of this stage where I get to enjoy it all over again (without having to have more than two kids!)
As my eldest starts to question santa, the elf and so on, she still gets to experience the magic through her little brother.
The kids probably won’t fight over toys/clothes etc because of their interests being so different.

we are able to do proper activities that everyone enjoys 🙄there is no age limit on family walks, trips to the zoo, beaches, museums etc.

I love it and for us, it’s the right thing even though it wasn’t specifically our plan.

pastayeti · 14/01/2023 12:16

@TheOriginalEmu aww how lovely! Bet you had a busy and fun household but lots of help with the twins too with their older siblings on hand. Your story is lovely - and also quite spooky. Just shows everything happens for a reason…

TheOriginalEmu · 14/01/2023 12:02

Mine are 13 months, 15 months and 11 months apart respectively. I knew I wants a relatively large family but had planned on waiting until I was early 30s to start trying. GlaxoSmithKline had other ideas and I got pregnant accidentally with dd1 at 22, I had ambitions to go back to university after some family issues meant I had to drop out when I was 18. I was, in fact, weeks away from starting a course when I found out I was pregnant putting it on hold. So we decided that we would have them close together so we could get all the baby stuff over and I could go to uni.
we had the oldest 3 one after the other, then decided to stop and I had a coil fitted at my 6 week check, however nature again decided that wasn’t going to happen and I got pregnant again. With twins. Who came 8 weeks early.
it was absolutely nuts for a while with 5 kids under 4 😂 but they are now 19, almost 18, 16 and 15 and they get on great. The youngest 3 are all in the same year at school and are inseparable.
And as fate would have it I was diagnosed with cervical cancer when the twins were 10 months and I had a hysterectomy so had I waited til my planned age chances are I wouldn’t have had any kids.

graysquirrel · 14/01/2023 12:01

For me many reasons.
*I was an older mum so didn't want to wait too long. Was an only child myself so definitely wanted more than one, so needed best stab at it I could give.
*I wanted to concatenate the hit on my career.
*I could afford it and overlapping childcare costs etc.
Wanted them close in age to be friends/peers which they absolutely are. Holidays/activities much easier to deal with as are pretty much interested in same things at same time and get on extremely well (realise that's luck as much as anything).
*Husband has large age gap between him and sister and they are not close because of it. He's always treated as a little boy by her, even though now in 40s!!

Gilead · 14/01/2023 12:00

Some people don’t have a choice.