Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder why so many people choose to have such a short age gap between their children?

616 replies

Lightningfast · 12/01/2023 20:28

I hear of so many people with two children two years apart and can’t for the life of me understand why anyone would want

a. To be pregnant with a child of around only a year old
b. To have a newborn baby when the older one is still a toddler and therefore still needs support in so many really basic ways. Sure, they don’t need the same level of support as a new baby but still...

I’ve heard the ‘they will be close enough to be friends’ theory but in practice I have seen at least as many if not rather more siblings who are close in age but are not especially close emotionally and it feels a rather weak reason.
I see this happening so often, even with mothers who have really struggled with getting their first baby to feed, sleep etc. and yet seem hellbent on having another only a matter of months later. Just...why?

If this is you I’m not judging, just genuinely interested in what you are getting out of it.

OP posts:
Highabovethetrees · 04/01/2024 15:45

allfurcoatnoknickers · 04/01/2024 15:36

@Olinguita I've got a deliberate 4 year age gap for similar reasons (terrible, complicated HR/IUGR pregnancies, PNA/PPD, bonkers expensive nursery) and it is WONDERFUL. I'm always a bit baffled by the negativity/stigma on Mumsnet.

Still trying to work out what activities you can't do with both of them (does anyone want to enlighten me?!) or why they can't play together. DS is 4 and already plays with DD and she's only 8 months old.

Being on mat leave with DS started reception was also great. because we got a couple of months off paying for childcare, and I could also be around for the transition, which was pretty tricky. DD was still in the loaf baby stage, so while she required physical attention, I could dedicate a lot of emotional energy to helping DS settle in his new school.

Seriously considering a third with another 4 year gap because it's been so smooth. I'm seriously in awe of anyone who can do small age gaps, because I don't think I would be able to cope at all.

The activities thing is as they get older, so eg whilst your 4, 5 and 6 year old will still very much love soft play, your 8, 9 and 10 year old will like it less so (and likely too old for some places anyway).

Same for things like going to other indoor play places, farms, etc... Also likely won't want to see the same films at the cinema, theatre shows, your older one will be interested in particular museums and exhibitions that your younger one will be too young to enjoy...

And as they get older, it's unlikely a 10 year old boy will want to play very much with a six-year-old girl. They'll likely have very different interests.

Ballsygal · 04/01/2024 15:40

This!!! Absolutely agree! I simply cannot fathom why anyone would choose to do this!!

allfurcoatnoknickers · 04/01/2024 15:36

@Olinguita I've got a deliberate 4 year age gap for similar reasons (terrible, complicated HR/IUGR pregnancies, PNA/PPD, bonkers expensive nursery) and it is WONDERFUL. I'm always a bit baffled by the negativity/stigma on Mumsnet.

Still trying to work out what activities you can't do with both of them (does anyone want to enlighten me?!) or why they can't play together. DS is 4 and already plays with DD and she's only 8 months old.

Being on mat leave with DS started reception was also great. because we got a couple of months off paying for childcare, and I could also be around for the transition, which was pretty tricky. DD was still in the loaf baby stage, so while she required physical attention, I could dedicate a lot of emotional energy to helping DS settle in his new school.

Seriously considering a third with another 4 year gap because it's been so smooth. I'm seriously in awe of anyone who can do small age gaps, because I don't think I would be able to cope at all.

RidingMyBike · 03/01/2024 19:59

EmeraldA129 · 03/01/2024 09:29

I’m surprised so many folk are talking about wanting to get the baby stage out of the way! I’m loving every minute of that stage right now… and that along with my age is making me want to do it all again asap!

Crikey, no, many people don't feel like that! I hated the baby year. Was bored, miserable and the time dragged on for ever. I regret not going back to work sooner
rather than sticking it out for an entire year. It's much more fun when they're older.

Mags57 · 03/01/2024 18:12

pointythings · 12/01/2023 20:31

Well, I was going for 3 years, not 2. However, we started trying early because it took a long time for me to fall pregnant with DD1. And we were older than we had been, obviously.

Then I got pregnant first time of trying because of course I did.

Fortunately this was in the days before the world went completely stupid and so I could afford to keep DD1 in nursery whilst on (6 months) mat leave with DD2, and could also (just) afford to have them both in nursery. And once DD2 started talking fluently they were incredibly close.

This happens so often. I’m sure it happens more than we know too since many will likely not want to share their private business.

SouthLondonMum22 · 03/01/2024 14:34

EmeraldA129 · 03/01/2024 09:29

I’m surprised so many folk are talking about wanting to get the baby stage out of the way! I’m loving every minute of that stage right now… and that along with my age is making me want to do it all again asap!

It's not my favourite.

If I had left it 3-4+ years then I wouldn't have done it again because I wouldn't have wanted to go back into it.

So getting it out of the way ASAP is what we're going with.

Yb23487643 · 03/01/2024 13:07

A 2-4 year age gap is pretty normal and doesn’t stop kids playing together and they learn from each other. Kids with a much bigger age gap play nicely too. Have friend with 2 under 2 who are full on competition for eachother ALL OF THE TIME. Like no let up. Competition with friends, parental attention, all the same classes - gymnastics, dancing etc etc. Daily meltdowns if one better than the other at anything. No chance to say “well you’ll be as good as X when you’re their age if you keep practising”.
count my blessing daily that I don’t have any of that!

Yb23487643 · 03/01/2024 13:03

I don’t think close ahe always leads to good friendships. Seems to cause a lot more sibling rivalry. Depends on other things like personality and genders of course.
Same gender and/or close together in age seems to breed world war 3 situations in friends & family - grown ups and kids!
Seeing that & having that myself growing up put me off having 2 close together.
Some people will assume family life has to be mad, full of arguments, crying and combative but it doesn’t have to be at all if everyone gets enough “good attention” and aren’t too stretched to maintain respect and good modelling etc.
I know I’d be a worse parent if kids close together and more stretched but horses for courses, some people thrive on it.
Is why is a personal choice, except of course planning for babies isn’t always a choice

Mammyloveswine · 03/01/2024 12:53

I didn't plan a 2 year gap but nature had other ideas! I was on the pill so was very shocked! But it was fine! Ds2 attended all of DS1s classes and it was nice to have more time with him!

Was knackered but was still very much in the knackered stage when I got pregnant as ds1 was only 15 months old!

They are 5 and 7 now and mostly get on quite well!

anormalperson · 03/01/2024 12:12

Dcs are 15 months apart. Totally planned. Meant getting the baby/ toddler stage done at one time. They're at the same stage, like many of the same things and we can go on trips and holidays without having to cater for different ages. Luckily they're incredibly close despite being opposite sex. Of course there are pros and cons for both, but choosing a bigger age gap was just not for me.

Overloadimplode · 03/01/2024 12:04

I always knew I wanted three or four children. I didn't meet their dad until I was late 20s and didn't want to be an old mum. So I had them at 30, 32 and 35. I loved being on mat leave with my eldest three times in a row. It was wonderful to spend so much time with them all while they were little.

Didimum · 03/01/2024 12:03

As someone with twins, two at the same time (while not mentally ideal!) I can admit has been very financially beneficial. Only one mat leave loss of earnings, benefitted from sibling discount throughout the whole of childcare, twin charity membership has some brilliant discounts on so many things, etc.

underneaththeash · 03/01/2024 12:00

Alexandernevermind · 12/01/2023 20:33

I can't really understand why you would want a larger age gap than a couple of years, quite honestly. Why would I want to get one child to school and then start again with a baby - that's 8 years of being tied up with preschoolers!

Me neither. Close together is much better, you can go on more age appropriate holidays, toddler proof the house then, get rid of everything. Have similar ages toys in. Hand down stuff more easily.

I can't imagine why you'd want a big gap.

Outliers · 03/01/2024 11:53

Getting the suffering out of the way.

ObsidianGrape · 03/01/2024 11:50

I suppose the benefits are getting reuse clothes, pram, cribs etc and get the sleepless nights over and done with in fewer years.

I have a nearly 5 years gap between mine. It was good because I got to raise my son for 4 years with him getting all the attention. Then focusing on my daughter when she was born and my son was old enough to not need me as much. The negatives being that I got to enjoy a few years of sleep after my son then having to restart the sleepless nights over again. Also I ended up getting rid of most of my son's baby stuff as it was taking up space and we weren't sure when we would have a 2nd child. So had to rebuy pram, crib, cot, most clothes etc! So that wasn't great having to buy same things twice! Also, the age gap does mean that they enjoy different things. We have had a few holidays that are hotel and pools related, at the moment the kids both enjoy it, but worry as they get older the eldest will want to go to different places that my youngest wouldn't be interested in.

I still think a gap worked out better for us as it meant childcare costs were only for 1 child at a time. Not having to experience having two babies/toddlers at the same time. Also now that parents have to contribute towards university costs, I'm glad we have that 5 year gap so only needing to help one at a time if they go to uni.

Runningandtired · 03/01/2024 11:43

For lots of reasons! Nappy baby stage over quicker all at once. Maternity leave all close together so mother can further her career (if she wants) without taking big gaps throughout. If you want more than one and enjoy them when they are older more than the baby stage it's over quicker. Not wanting to drag an older child around to baby activities. The friend ship thing. I have 4 and they are all 18 months to 2 years between each one. Now I have done it, I'm glad I made that decision. We wanted 4 and if I had more than 2 years between each one it would just never end and wouldn't be fair on the older ones. Plus dh is older and he didn't want to be an old dad.

Pacificisolated · 03/01/2024 11:39

I completely agree. The idea of getting pregnant again just as soon as I had recovered from the first and was sleeping well again was horrific.
I don’t understand wanting to get nappies/sleepless nights etc ‘out of the way’ either. I would have been very depressed if I’d had two years of sleep disturbance in short succession. Later on you end up with kids in similarly stressful life circumstances at the same time. Then they move out of home within a couple of short years of one another and you don’t have long to come to terms with it.
Our kids will be just over three years apart. My eldest is much less demanding now than one year ago. I can see how much better it will be for her development having the benefit of focused parental input in her early years rather than having to share us with an even needier baby.

Gilead · 03/01/2024 11:19

@FrenchandSaunders we too have a 3 minute age gap!

Yb23487643 · 03/01/2024 09:53

I agree completely, is so lovely to enjoy your eldest in the baby and toddler stage and have second 3-4y later when the eldest is partially at nursery and then school for the baby & toddler stage for your second.
The first few years of my eldest’s life were absolute halcyon days and I’m so glad I could give all that energy and attention. Was a significant dip when pregnant and had a new born again but luckily at that age eldest didn’t “need me” so much, had finished breastfeeding, was into playing with other kids properly and enjoyed nursery, slept through the night etc.
You’re always divided between your kids but when one is naturally at the age that they need you less (like not breastfeeding, happy at nursery & not waking for feeds overnight etc) that’s really helpful. If mine were closer in age I’d be worried that neither were getting a good deal - like I’d be too stretched between two competing and more equal needs.
Is lovely when eldest can “help” and care more for the youngest, more difficult when they’re just not as capable purely due to their age.

FrenchandSaunders · 03/01/2024 09:48

Well I didn't choose the 3 minute age gap and it was certainly a surprise but looking back it was the best thing ever and they are incredibly close now, in their early 20s.

anothernamechangeagainsndagain · 03/01/2024 09:47

@FUOBDM

Completely agree, mine are 2 years apart and adults now, won't deny there's times when it's harder (2 lots of university living costs!) but they get along so well and have lots of joint friends, especially through teen years

KimberleyClark · 03/01/2024 09:42

I recently watched one of Miles Jupp’s stand up performances on Amazon Prime in which he talks about having 4 children under 4. It was both funny and strangely heart rending.

EmeraldA129 · 03/01/2024 09:29

I’m surprised so many folk are talking about wanting to get the baby stage out of the way! I’m loving every minute of that stage right now… and that along with my age is making me want to do it all again asap!

Sartre · 03/01/2024 09:25

It gets the baby/toddler years out of the way quicker which is entirely logical. If you only have 2 children and have them within 3 years of one another, the baby/toddler years will be done within 6 years. If you leave a large gap between kids, you then have to restart the sleepless nights after years without which is a pain.

There’s also the fact it’s harder to entertain children with a large age gap. If you have two children a similar age, they’ll generally be happy doing the same sort of activities. It gets tough when you have a tween and toddler.

RidingMyBike · 03/01/2024 09:22

@Olinguita an age gap of approx four years was incredibly common at the nursery we used - it was the norm! I think mainly because of waiting for the free funded hours to kick in!

The only people I came across with small age gaps were young (20s) with young grandparents (almost my age!) so they had a lot of help available.