Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder why so many people choose to have such a short age gap between their children?

616 replies

Lightningfast · 12/01/2023 20:28

I hear of so many people with two children two years apart and can’t for the life of me understand why anyone would want

a. To be pregnant with a child of around only a year old
b. To have a newborn baby when the older one is still a toddler and therefore still needs support in so many really basic ways. Sure, they don’t need the same level of support as a new baby but still...

I’ve heard the ‘they will be close enough to be friends’ theory but in practice I have seen at least as many if not rather more siblings who are close in age but are not especially close emotionally and it feels a rather weak reason.
I see this happening so often, even with mothers who have really struggled with getting their first baby to feed, sleep etc. and yet seem hellbent on having another only a matter of months later. Just...why?

If this is you I’m not judging, just genuinely interested in what you are getting out of it.

OP posts:
Yamaya · 12/01/2023 21:30

To be honest I knew I wanted 2, found the first quite difficult so just decided to get it over with in one go.
They are at similar stages so can take them both to the same days out etc.
I know it might not always be this way but they are very close 😊

Stressfordays · 12/01/2023 21:29

Get all the stressful baby days out the way in one go. I had 3 in 5 years. It was hard work but now theyre older its so much easier and I couldn't imagine starting all over again.

NeedAHoliday2021 · 12/01/2023 21:29

We had 3.5 years between ours and that felt right for us… then 2nd pregnancy was twins. I actually love how they have a friend to experience things with, especially now they’reat secondary because they do look out for each other. They weren’t especially close at Primary though and one is closer to dd1 if I’m honest. I still think choosing 2 close in age is madness but then some people love being pregnant and the baby stage whereas I prefer not being pregnant and the teenage years.

BogRollBOGOF · 12/01/2023 21:28

2 years is a great age gap.

Easier having the baby/ toddler years/ nappies/ learning to walk phases overlapping.
Small gaps between being in different nursery/ school set-ups. May be helpful for sibling priority for school admissions.
Toys/ interests more likely to overlap.
Clothes can be handed down soon after not waiting for years going fusty/ out of date.
Trashing your body in a small window of time with just enough recovery when the broody hormones kick in at 18m.
Being slow and pregnant while the toddler dawdles around painfully slowly.
More options on family size for the future.

I know childcare costs are a big factor on school age age-gaps, but the thought of going back to square one just as life gets easier and more flexible was not appealing to me.

Coffeaddict · 12/01/2023 21:28

Big age gaps can also have issues. There is 8 years between DS and DSS. it is next to impossible to find activities that work for both of them.

DSS is growing out of things like legend just as DS is at the age he would enjoy it. If we went to somewhere like alton towers DSS wouldn't want to go to the Chenies part and DS is too small for the proper rides. We go to the beach but DS ( 2 last summer) only paddles in the sea while DSS goes in for hours to body board. Even at home DSS wants to play cards, board games, videogames that aee way over the head of DS. Essentially it means we end up using a divide and conquer approach so family time isn't really that.

I had my second son recently meaning there are 2 years 10 months between the younger boys. While yes I realise they may not get on / have different interests the general concept of age appropriate actives will be easier

theluckiest · 12/01/2023 21:28

We had two relatively close together (2 years). The toddler/newborn stage was hideous. Found it incredibly hard.

However, they are quite close now they are teens.

What I had completely forgotten about was the uni fees. Jesus, having 2 of them at uni at the same time is going to be eye-watering. No-one ever tells you this!!!!

TheGoogleMum · 12/01/2023 21:28

Yeah I couldn't have done a small age gap. Currently expecting baby 2 will have a 4 Yr age gap which feels more doable to me.
I know many siblings close in age that don't get on so I didn't see the point in rushing. 1 toddler at a time will hopefully be easier!

NumberTheory · 12/01/2023 21:27

The reason all my friends who chose to have more than one had them close together was career.

Though a couple who had them youngish also just wanted to have them over and done (they didn’t use those words!) with the idea of being able to enjoy their 40s child-free.

Volhhg · 12/01/2023 21:27

For me it was because of my age, I was going into my 40's with my second. The same for my other friends who have two close together. Although for one friend who is also an older mother she had an important job and realistically couldn't take too much time out raising children.

Highabovethetrees · 12/01/2023 21:27

Have 22 month gap, which was slightly smaller than planned (DC1 took a year to conceive; DC2 took about 20 minutes 😂)

I did want nearer two years than three though, because:

  1. Disliked the baby stage, wanted to get it all out of the way.

  2. Wanted them to be at similar stages at the same time so they would enjoy the same sort of things... As a PP says, wouldn't want to be dragging an older child around to toddler things, or conversely, the younger child missing out due to older child activities. Can do more things together as a family.

  3. I do think in theory that as children, they're more likely to want to play with each if they are closer in age. It's worked out for us; they do argue occasionally, but most of the time are best friends and will spend hours playing with each other, with no input needed from me!

  4. Was mid-30s when had DC2, didn't want to be much older.

  5. I'm more of a delayed gratification type - yes, the first couple of years were tough, I didn't get that respite from lack of sleep, babyhood stage in the middle, but it has definitely paid off now.

My two are now 6 and 4, both at school, both sleep through the night... I see parents with children same age as my eldest with babies and toddlers, complaining of sleepless night and the terrible twos and feel very glad we ended up with the age gap we have.

EileenAdler · 12/01/2023 21:27

KirstenBlest · 12/01/2023 20:31

I didn't find it a problem.
Mother Nature sometimes intervenes.
There isn't really a right age gap.

Yep, totally agree with all of that : It was just the way it worked out. I did have a cleaned though and my mum was local so I relied on her, and my dad.

NEmama · 12/01/2023 21:26

Getting nappies out of the way. Similar abilities for days out once 3/5 soft play etc.

Lurchintowardsyourfavouritecity · 12/01/2023 21:26

Days out and holidays are a breeze because they’re in the same age range for stuff and at a similar level for eg swimming so we plan a day out/holiday and it suits them both. They play together very well and it’s very easy and has been since the youngest was probably 2.5. I have just over a 2 year gap. Even down to reading the same chapter book at bedtime, obviously they sometimes have different eg older one likes Harry Potter, younger one not quite there yet but they’ve both just enjoyed the Christmasaurus together. Now, similar bedtimes, appreciate that may change.

Mummieslncorporated · 12/01/2023 21:26

"You can't enjoy it the baby (because you also have toddler) or enjoy the toddler (because you also have a baby)"

Maybe you can't. You don't speak for me. I did. And surely you could use the argument for any age. You can't enjoy the baby because you also have a pre-schooler/primary aged child etc, you can't enjoy the older child because you also have a baby....

AddieLoggins2 · 12/01/2023 21:26

I have 2 years between mine. These are the main reasons why we want for that age gap.

  • My age. I was 30 and 32 when my children were born so I guess I could have waited longer, but I didn't want to.
  • Work. I was already part-time after DC1 but plan to go back full-time when DC2 starts school. So it makes sense financially to have them fairly close together.
  • Stuff. Bedding/baby stuff/toys/clothes etc were reused. I didn't want to have to store it all for years (they're both boys - but obviously it wouldn't have mattered for toys/cot/lots of basic clothes etc if they had been different sexes)
  • Toys and playing together. They have their own interests but also generally are at roughly the same toy stage. I would have found it hard to have one playing with Lego and one needing jumperoo and playmats. Generally speaking at 7 and 5 they can play a board/card game together, which is much easier. They also have lots of shared interests and shared toys which makes things easier (again both being boys helps here!)
Crispyturtle · 12/01/2023 21:26

We have a 20 month gap, it wasn’t exactly planned that way but we weren’t actively avoiding it either. We were both late 30s so knew if we wanted another we couldn’t hang around too long, and it had taken nearly a year to get pregnant with DD1. I got pregnant with DD2 on the second shag.

Anyway, for us, yes it was hard work to start with but it has ended up working really well. They are into the same things at the same time, they have a lot of the same friends, and they play together brilliantly. I love having them close in age, the only downside is that the small kid stage is over really quickly and I loved it!

Orangello · 12/01/2023 21:25

I'm not a baby person so wanted to get that time over with. And even if you can't guarantee they are best friends, a 3yo and 5yo will still have more common interests than 3 and 13. No regrets.

DoneWithHer · 12/01/2023 21:25

I could not take a break from nappies and sleepless nights and then face back into it again.

denishhol · 12/01/2023 21:25

I struggle with one kid. I just couldn't cope with another baby so close to a toddler. I'd be traumatised. Terribly organised as is. Personally I'd wait til I have an independent school age child, at minimum.

allfurcoatnoknickers · 12/01/2023 21:24

@ComfortablyDazedI'm pregnant with #2 with a deliberate 4 year age gap. I'm in awe of people who can cope with a smaller gap. Reasons why I couldn't:

  • HG pregnancy which was awful and traumatic and absolutely knocked me for six.
  • Because of HG pregnancy, if I got it again, I'd be totally incapable of doing anything with DS. As it happens, I was only wiped out for 20 weeks this time, but having him able to turn on the TV, get a snack and go for a wee by himself at home was a gamechanger.
  • Loathed changing nappies and absolutely DID NOT want to change two sets of nappies at the same time. That's more poo than I could cope with.
  • Hated the newborn phase - I was bored out of my tree and cut my maternity leave short.
  • Fucking LOVED the toddler phase and didn't want to have it ruined by having a newborn. I didn't really hit my stride as a parent until he was about 8/9 months and then I really started to love it.
  • DS slept through the night by 6 months, so by the time he was 1, sleepless nights were already a distant memory.
  • Took me a year to get my body back and back to pre-baby weight and I wanted to enjoy it for a bit.
  • Two in full time childcare would be cripplingly expensive. DH and I both work full time.
I get the theory behind a small age gap, but I would have ended up in a psych ward.
BodyShapeWoes · 12/01/2023 21:24

It took dh & I about 2/2.5 years to fall pregnant (and carry to term) with dc1 with lots of miscarriages, heart ache and everything else involved, we had finally been referred to the fertility clinic and I was 5 months pregnant when the appointment came through

We thought it would take a while with dc2 so I stopped my contraception when dc1 was just over one, and boom pregnant 1st time that’s why I have just under a 2 year age gap 🤷‍♀️

I am glad it happened that way, all the expensive childcare was done in a shorter space of time and my dh is 10 years older than me so worked well and he’s still a young(ish) dad

CrabbyCat · 12/01/2023 21:24

MrsJBaptiste · 12/01/2023 21:12

I can't understand why people say itz to get the baby stage "out of the way"

I loved having a newborn/baby/toddler and would have hated to miss out on those stages. You can't enjoy it the baby (because you also have toddler) or enjoy the toddler (because you also have a baby)

Babies love watching toddlers though, and young toddlers are actually easier to entertain whilst feeding a baby than older children because they live doing the same activity on repeat. For example you can all sit on the floor and the baby giggles while you build a tower of bricks on repeat with the toddler - and their enjoyment increases the toddlers. I found rereading the same book to a toddler 10 times more bearable when I was stuck on the sofa with the baby anyway, and interacting with the toddler made the hours stuck on the sofa seem less of a waste.

Mummieslncorporated · 12/01/2023 21:23

I did this in my twenties. Worked for me.

Meant that my break from work was over and done with in a relatively short space of time, got the nappy stage over and done with quickly. Entertaining them on holidays or weekends was easy as they were at similar stages and so wanted to go to the same things. Hand me downs made sense. Didn't have to have a houseful of baby stuff and primary age stuff.

I honestly wouldn't change it for the world. I would have hated to have a big gap, and go back to nappies after a long break.

OhForGoodnessSake1 · 12/01/2023 21:23

I had endometriosis. As soon as my periods returned after DS1 (when he was about 9 months) I was back to being in agony every month, not wanting to take my usual amounts of painkillers as I was still part breast-feeding. I knew the endo was going to be making it harder again blocking tubes and I didn't want to have to go through another operation to clear things again. No periods was the best thing about pregnancy and feeding :). My two are 22 months apart and we haven't found the age gap a problem.

saraclara · 12/01/2023 21:23

MrsJBaptiste · 12/01/2023 21:12

I can't understand why people say itz to get the baby stage "out of the way"

I loved having a newborn/baby/toddler and would have hated to miss out on those stages. You can't enjoy it the baby (because you also have toddler) or enjoy the toddler (because you also have a baby)

You don't miss those stages! They still happen! And for me, seeing my toddler interacting with her little sister, the baby loving and copying her 'not so much bigger sister' and the way they complemented each other, was one of the best bits of the short gap.

Swipe left for the next trending thread