Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder why so many people choose to have such a short age gap between their children?

616 replies

Lightningfast · 12/01/2023 20:28

I hear of so many people with two children two years apart and can’t for the life of me understand why anyone would want

a. To be pregnant with a child of around only a year old
b. To have a newborn baby when the older one is still a toddler and therefore still needs support in so many really basic ways. Sure, they don’t need the same level of support as a new baby but still...

I’ve heard the ‘they will be close enough to be friends’ theory but in practice I have seen at least as many if not rather more siblings who are close in age but are not especially close emotionally and it feels a rather weak reason.
I see this happening so often, even with mothers who have really struggled with getting their first baby to feed, sleep etc. and yet seem hellbent on having another only a matter of months later. Just...why?

If this is you I’m not judging, just genuinely interested in what you are getting out of it.

OP posts:
Kaylisa · 13/01/2023 12:57

I’m one of 3…me, then 13 months later my brother, then 12 months after him my sister. I personally loved it growing up. I wanted the same for my kids.

mine are more spread out. We have three who are now 18,17,15. And then another two who are 10 and 7.

Obviously I went on to have more, however for me the pros of a close age gap is days out are easier when they’re all similar ages. Once you’re out of the baby stage with youngest then that’s it (if you don’t have more) hopefully a close relationship between siblings.

ThreeblackCats · 13/01/2023 12:52

I had three children in two years. A 2yo, a 1yo and a newborn. It was much easier than getting used to a 6 or 7 year old that slept well and was pretty self sufficient in as much as a child that age can be then starting again with sleepless nights, carrying nappy bags and always having baby vomit on my shoulder..

I always said had I left a large gap I’d have not had another child.

I personally found it easier to have my babies close together. I’ve looked at the new mums arriving at school pick up that are heavily pregnant, then they come with their pram and I wondered, why?

GloomyDarkness · 13/01/2023 12:50

Mine have 19 month différence. If I'd had my way it'd have been 12 months.

I'd have been the same but MW told us to wait a year before getting pg again - to be fair we did ask how soon we could reasonably have the next with no health issues.

I did bf so possibly would have delayed it anyway - though got pg both subsequently times still bf - but we had 20- 23 month gaps - second was immediate conception which was a contrast with first pg.

Jadviga · 13/01/2023 12:43

Mine have 19 month différence. If I'd had my way it'd have been 12 months.

I wanted to get the diapers out of the way and I wanted them to be close /have similar interests. By that I mean, I know of course they're not clones and will have their own passions, but if I do an activity aimed at 5 year olds and my kids are 4 and 6, I know they will both probably enjoy it. Whereas if I have a baby and a 6 year old I'd end up having to cart one or the other to age-inappropriate activities. Not to mention different schools/nursery. Logistics nightmare.

As it happens my two boys are very close and loving and watch out for each other so in my case the close age gap paid off. It was harder for the first year, yes, but I see it as an investment in the long term - now it's much easier because they play together and entertain each other while I cook.

ShesThunderstorms · 13/01/2023 12:33

It kinda comes across that you're judging, OP.
I don't understand why you'd be so confused that different arrangements work for different families. There's arguments for and against all age gaps. I come from a 9 year age gap with my sibling. I have kids who are 20 months apart so I can see both sides and neither arrangement is better than the other, they're just totally different.

RedToothBrush · 13/01/2023 11:37

Three close friends had their kids within two years.

All three said they thought it was almost easier as they could do things together easier rather than worry about age appropriateness and it was better for the kids when they were very small.

They also could quit work completely and then go back quicker.

However they have older children now in late teens or twenties and this meant they could afford to take five years or so out rather than merely take maternity leave. So I think it's rather a reflection of when they had kids as much as choice of space of kids.

I think it's harder to do now because of the child care costs and other financial implications.

Colourinsidethelines · 13/01/2023 11:21

Mine are 18 months apart. It gets it all out of the way. I found the first year with DS horrible so was pleased to get nappies, sleepless night etc out of the way in one go. Now they are 5 and 6 and are at school and I have some of my life back. No way would I go back to a newborn now!

whatthebejesus · 13/01/2023 11:19

Assuming by your post that you don't have them close together OP!

I have 14m between mine. If I had my time again I'd do it exactly the same. My youngest is now 5 and had my husband been on board I'd have had a 3rd straight after the 2nd. I don't fancy a 5/6 year gap so we won't be having more. There are plenty of people who activity choose to wait and have that gap. Neither option is wrong.

The pregnancy was hard but my first DC was a delight as a baby. I wasn't phased at all by having a second so soon. We didn't actively try but didn't prevent either. It might've been different if my first was very fussy or I was struggling but I was ok. Babies are all different.

mightymam · 13/01/2023 11:15

doingitalllagain · 13/01/2023 08:53

This does make for sad reading, I'm 36 weeks pregnant with a 3 and a half year age gap... people saying that kids with that gap didn't even interact together? Shock Oh I so hope that's not true. I desperately want my boys to have a close sibling relationship. Unfortunately a 17 week miscarriage in between pregnancies has left us with a bigger than hoped for gap. I thought they were still just close enough to have some shared interests and get along well (personality dependent!)

5 year age between me and my sister. We were thick as thieves growing up. She's always been my biggest supporter. I say that as someone who has another sister 2 years older than me! It's all pot luck.

ThatOneChinHair · 13/01/2023 10:52

RidingMyBike I didn't have family around for help. I went part time to begin with and the nursery fees swallowed all my salary and child tax credits. But dh and I had planned for it and lived in small 2 bed house to keep the outgoing as low as possible to begin with.

When we had to move for Dh promotion I became a SAHM or took on pt jobs including working in pub on the nights to cut out childcare. Making ends meet was very challenging and draining having to juggle money just so I could buy new socks for the DC, only really buying ebay bundle of clothes for them, Moving/cancelling Direct debits to be able to do a very cheap supermarket shop to feed the family for a week.

The first 5 years were a real struggle financially, physically and mentally. But once the worst of childcare is over its onwards and upwards. I would never have wanted to prolonged the financial struggle even if it wasn't so intense and also prolonged my time out of my career.

The dc don't remember any of our struggle, they just remember days at the park/ beach being fed warm and loved.

DC1 is at uni in London and DC2 is heading off in September. Topping up there maintenance loans is still a breeze compared to those first 5 years.

WaddleAway · 13/01/2023 10:44

The only mums with smaller age gaps for their children were a lot younger and were SAHMs with a lot of grandparent support so weren't affected by the childcare cost

None of those things applied to us. Early 30’s, no grandparents nearby and both worked full time. I was (at the time) a fairly high earner so it still made sense to go back to work even with 2 in childcare.
My third child is disabled however so I’m no longer a high earner.

phoenixrosehere · 13/01/2023 10:41

The only mums with smaller age gaps for their children were a lot younger and were SAHMs with a lot of grandparent support so weren't affected by the childcare cost.

I was late 20s and the nearest relative is 2 hours+ away. In-laws 4+ hours, mine 9+ hours. DH makes at least 5 times more than me and working full-time on my salary as an administrator didn’t cover childcare costs nor could they do flexible working so SAHP until first was in reception and second was in nursery part- time.

RidingMyBike · 13/01/2023 10:34

Loics · 13/01/2023 10:26

We have an age gap of less than 18 months, no. 2 was slightly sooner than planned, but we did want a small age gap anyway. They are very close, so far, and they share toys/enjoy the same activities and playing together because they're similar in age.
It's not been long since our first got his free hours at nursery though, it wasn't an issue for us, but our nursery is quite reasonable for fees and it still came to around £1400 a month for 2.

Hmm, probably area dependent then. That's a lot less than we were paying £1300 a month for one child in 3 days a week until the free hours kicked in and it dropped to about £700 a month. There's no way we could have had two in childcare at the same time.

School wraparound is a lot cheaper as only about £200 per month.

GloomyDarkness · 13/01/2023 10:28

The only mums with smaller age gaps for their children were a lot younger and were SAHMs with a lot of grandparent support so weren't affected by the childcare cost.

We were youngish late 20s early 30s and I was at home - but had no grandparent support. Did know a few like DH cousin who between parents and both sets of GP doing a day or two each had childcare covered so again weren't hit with childcare costs.

Most women who were dealing with childcare costs- they were getting pg nursery years or reception year. So yes it's a huge factor for many families that plays into family planning.

RufusthefIoraImissingreindeer · 13/01/2023 10:28

There is 3 years between 1 and 2 and 17 months between 2 and 3 and they get on incredibly well, brilliant bond

Loics · 13/01/2023 10:26

We have an age gap of less than 18 months, no. 2 was slightly sooner than planned, but we did want a small age gap anyway. They are very close, so far, and they share toys/enjoy the same activities and playing together because they're similar in age.
It's not been long since our first got his free hours at nursery though, it wasn't an issue for us, but our nursery is quite reasonable for fees and it still came to around £1400 a month for 2.

RufusthefIoraImissingreindeer · 13/01/2023 10:26

Ds2 was 'unexpected' we weren't using contraception but we'd given ourselves 8 months to see what fate decided and then we were stopping

The reason he was unexpected was that we'd tried for 2 years and had fertility treatment for ds1, tried for a year and lost that baby and then tried for a year for dd. So I don't think either of us thought our chances were very high

He's adorable though,

a few years after dh had his vasectomy he said we should have had 4 😀

Cuppasoupmonster · 13/01/2023 10:20

My experience too @RidingMyBike and the reason why there will be 3y8m between DD and DS who is due in March. I would’ve liked a slightly smaller gap of maybe 2.5-3 years, but 2 in nursery would’ve bankrupted us!

RidingMyBike · 13/01/2023 10:19

3-5 years seemed a common age gap when I had DD. Most families couldn't afford two in childcare simultaneously so the younger sibling only appeared once the free childcare hours were available at age 3. We considered it but childcare was still more than £700 per month even with the free hours so still unaffordable for two.

The only mums with smaller age gaps for their children were a lot younger and were SAHMs with a lot of grandparent support so weren't affected by the childcare cost.

GloomyDarkness · 13/01/2023 10:04

Same reasons we didn't want the MN ideal of two children - we looked round our extended family and decide a close gap was better.

Also a factor I was left go in first pg and had a Velcro baby - so we thought having them close would mean less career break for me and that I could be home for then - didn't work out like that but it was part of the idea.

Also conceived later pg much faster than first pg - and DH family were at time driving us nuts - one of many issues was fact they insisted we were only allowed one child and I think that may have stoked some subconscious fear on my part DH would suddenly despite loving being a Dad and despite always being happy with idea of at least three kids they'd influence him and change his mind.

I was also despite having a Velcro baby blown away with how much being a mother made me happy - and DH was thrilled being a Dad - we'd have probably overcome our hesitancy about a fourth if the care during pg and birth of third hadn't been so poor and dangerous and we didn't really stop being broody till we moved - and each child had own room and youngest was 6/7 years old. So I think biology plays a role as well.

I was middle of three and it also felt like older sibling was pushed out as they aged - we had half the age gap between oldest and youngest than my siblings had and only felt the age gap when youngest was still primary and eldest was GCSE years. It feel less again at the moment.

It's worked for us - some of that is their personality but I think the close age gap played a role as well.

Hillarious · 13/01/2023 10:02

By the age of 37, I had three under 3.5 years. My friends were all pretty similar. Now they're 22, 24 and 25. They get on extremely well, whilst having their own friendship groups, but get great independent, non-parental support and advice from each other. We've mostly done the same things with them at the same time - eg swimming lessons - and we've been able to do walking and cycling holidays with them all. Don't have to put clothes away waiting for the younger one to grow into them. They just moved from the first child's drawers to the second's to the third's. Six years as a stay at home mum, all quite manageable, but I knew nothing different.

ThatOneChinHair · 13/01/2023 09:54

2.5 year age gap we always wanted 2 children. I was 25 when I had dc1 and then hormones kicked in so why wait for dc2. plus it meant less time either being a sahm or pt working.

Yes it was hard having crying in stereo, getting one to sleep the other then waking them by crying. The sleepless nights. The fact that when dc1 started receptionist DC2 was napping at the exact same time I needed to go for school pick up. I tried everything to change their nap time so it didn't clash but nothing worked.

The up sides though have definitely outweighed the early downsides. All the family Holidays and days out, clubs and activities being of the same stage.
They get on but aren't super close, and we had a year of constant bickering.

I like life going through life stages and moving forward never backwards. Now i'm 45 DH and me are all about us! we can holiday together, go out together at the drop of hat. We're like teens again.

I am secure in my career and have plenty of time to keep progressing, or there is still time to retrain and change career with nothing holding be back.
.

Secondsop · 13/01/2023 09:48

18 months between mine (and then 6 years for the next one).

  • first took years to conceive so we didn’t want to run out of time
  • Age - I was 37 for child 1 [as it transpired age wasn’t an issue as I went on to have child 3 at 44]
  • Baby stuff all out the way (or so I thought)
  • childcare costs and sleepless nights compressed in a smaller number of years (or so I thought!!)
  • being able to easily do activities / holidays with them together
  • Easy to cart around in double buggy rather than a longer stage of having child 1 dictating toddler speed and child 2 in pram.
  • child 1 benefited from me being at home on the second Mat leave while he was still little rather than at school age.

It was hard, but it worked for us. Now they’re 1 academic year apart it works nicely for school as they talk about their topics etc.

Icecreamandapplepie · 13/01/2023 09:48

No reply from op then?

starlight36 · 13/01/2023 09:38

Mine are 26 months apart, boy and a girl. We had a shortish gap as I was 38 when I had my first and therefore didn't want to wait too long before having another. Yes it was a bit of a juggle at the baby and toddler stage. I still remember the sheer joy (and relief) when both fell asleep in the double buggy at the same time!
We had so much fun when they were little as I could take them to the same toddle grouos, library activities, films at cinema etc. They also played together nicely at home and in the garden. As we are now entering the teenage years they aren't as close and there are inevitably different interests.