Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

House sale, 3 adult children, 1 with nowhere to go

266 replies

MakeMineALarge1 · 12/01/2023 17:04

So MIL passed away, she had 3 children ( all children 50 yrs +), I am married to one of them
Adult 1 - I am married to, both him and me in good jobs, 1 dependant child
Adult 2 - Single, decent job, mortgage free
Adult 3 - Single - never had a real job, works hard but plays hard and has never settled down, spend half the year skiing and then comes back lives with mum and goes back again in the winter

MIL passed away, house being kept on as if sold, child 3 will effectively be homeless ( they do have 2 children who both have homes and lots of friends, so wouldn't be on the street ) but he cannot buy the other 2 out and cannot afford to keep the house on his self - the house isn't worth a great deal, say £180,000 ball park figure, so if sold and split equally only £60,000 each, which wouldn't be enough to buy him a place, but would cover rent for a good while until i presume benefits kick in?

Adult 1 and 3 are not pushing for the sale and they will not see number 3 homeless, but this can't go on forever ( its all very recent) I am not getting involved, but would be interested in knowing what others think.

Also this situation very much mirrors my own family with my sibling being very much like adult 3 and I may be facing this conundrum in the future.

OP posts:
ElephantInTheKitchen · 12/01/2023 19:28

MakeMineALarge1 · 12/01/2023 18:03

He does ski, but he also works out there general maintenance, taxi etc, lives quite cheap and cheerful, so not out skiing and drinking etc

Is there work available in the ski resort or surrounding areas during the summer too? I imagine there's maintenance to be done in the off-season, and many ski resorts have a summer hiking industry too.

If it's as cheap and cheerful as you describe, I wonder if living out there full time would be an option - would £60k buy him a flat there? Would he be able to do so post-Brexit?

Testina · 12/01/2023 19:23

MakeMineALarge1 · 12/01/2023 18:40

@toocold54 I have never said that he doesn't work, he works bloody hard and is never without a job - he is however 55 - he just never thought this day would come , but seeing MIL was in her 80's it was only a matter of time

How do you know he never thought this day would come, if you haven’t discussed what to do? Of course he knew it would come.

Georgeskitchen · 12/01/2023 19:20

Time to get tough . 60 grand is good wack of money in these straitened times. He's a grown adult not a vulnerable teenager. Did he expect home for life?
Tough shit. If the terms of the will state equal 3 way split then he needs to get off his arse and get himself some accommodation

Ponderingwindow · 12/01/2023 19:18

The house needs to be sold. Saying all 3 will contribute to maintenance is all well and good when it is 100 here and there, but soon enough there is going to be something like a new roof or a major foundation repair and the arguments will begin. I watched it happen with a spouse and shared ownership of the family holiday home that some family members used more than others. The sooner they sell, the better.

ZekeZeke · 12/01/2023 19:17

Was there a will?
The executors are bound by the will.
If her assets are to be split 3 ways thrn that's what has to happen surely? Ie house sold, debts paid and what's left is split 3 ways.

snowsilver · 12/01/2023 19:16

What does the will say?
The executors have a duty to implement the will. If no specific mention is made of the house being left to one person then all the assets must be liquidated and distributed to the beneficiaries.
If you are not an executor then you have no say in the matter.

Saz12 · 12/01/2023 19:15

It’s well and good to say you don’t need the money. But will you be able to afford your share of upkeep, bills etc for a house that sits empty all winter? And why would you spend that money anyway?

It should be sold. Sibling can choose what he then does - eg have a mortgage on a cheaper flat if he’s desperate for a home base, or whatever he wants.

ZenNudist · 12/01/2023 19:12

Both my dbro and dbil live with our parents in their late 30s /40s. All other siblings do well in life but will appreciate the funds towards eventual retirement.

One day I fully expect the house to be sold and all of us to get our fair equal share.

House needs to be sold. Unless you lot are loaded.

justanotherhappyflunkie · 12/01/2023 19:11

This happpened in my family but was dealt with differently as circumstances different.

One child (adult) had cared for parents until they died (within a few months of each other) and had lived in the house for many years contributing, earning where possible and making sure parents were safe. Had they not cared for parents then ALL the house money would have gone on care home fees.

This child got 50% of house sale and 2 siblings both mortgage free no dependants got 25% each.

Did the adult living with your MIL care for her in any way?

WiddlinDiddlin · 12/01/2023 19:09

Either he sorts out a solution whereby the other two owners have their share protected and costs covered (ie, he pays them rent) and ensure the house is not stood empty whilst he is away (lodgers/tenants)... or yeah, it needs to be sold.

It's fine if HE wants to split his life across more than one country/home, but its not fair for the other two owners to pay for that property/risk their share in the process.

MakeMineALarge1 · 12/01/2023 19:00

@toocold54 he isn't paying maintenance for the 2 children

OP posts:
toocold54 · 12/01/2023 18:58

All those saying 60k is a good deposit, it doesn't sound like A3 can afford to pay a mortgage.

His age may be an issue and he’ll be paying maintenance for 2 kids but as a single adult who works hard he should be pretty well off and I would have thought he could easily get a mortgage.

Or even buy a property outright in certain areas, especially abroad.

NumberTheory · 12/01/2023 18:58

SpottyBalloons · 12/01/2023 18:51

@YourWinter I'd find it hard not to resent the sibling in this situation. If they outlive you you'll never see your inheritance, yet your sibling gets to benefit from it for the rest of their life.

I can see why children could resent this. And with some siblings that might well be justified.

But I think there are situations where the adult child at home has either provided for the parent, physically and emotionally, at their own cost by staying in the family home or been failed by the parent (pressured to stay or not provided witht he same support to leave). And to some extent, the additional right to stay is somewhat poor compensation for the lost opportunity to buy their own place or branch out on their own.

BunchHarman · 12/01/2023 18:56

MakeMineALarge1 · 12/01/2023 18:02

I am answering questions as they come in, I am not pushing for the sale, I am genuinely interested in other opinions especially as I will be in a similar situation in my own family

Me and my husband have already said the money, if we get any will be put away for our children.

Ignore this poster. Their MO is to talk absolute shit and have a pop at OPs. 😆

Iflyaway · 12/01/2023 18:55

All 3 jointly responsible for cost of property upkeep.

What??! Why should the two siblings have to fork out for the one who won't grown up?!

Beautiful3 · 12/01/2023 18:54

Still.need to sell.up and split the money. He will be fine. He could use it as a deposit on a flat, or maisonette if he gets a job.

SpottyBalloons · 12/01/2023 18:51

YourWinter · 12/01/2023 17:28

My mother’s will stipulated that when she died her house would be jointly owned by her three adult children and the one that still lived with her could continue to do so rent free for his lifetime, with all running and maintenance costs at his expense. The two of us who already have our own homes would have preferred it sold and split three ways but the sibling who lived with her couldn’t have bought another property. It is what it is. We all went to an appointment at the Land Registry to put the house in our three names.

@YourWinter I'd find it hard not to resent the sibling in this situation. If they outlive you you'll never see your inheritance, yet your sibling gets to benefit from it for the rest of their life.

AlbertaAnnie · 12/01/2023 18:50

Sell and split the money 60k is enough to put down on a little flat and then he can get a job to cover the remaining mortgage- like every other person in the universe has to do…

NumberTheory · 12/01/2023 18:50

I think the two siblings with their own homes need to think about how much they are prepared to subsidise DB3 both in terms on regular income and in terms of invested wealth.

If I were one of them I would not be prepared to subsidize with income at all, but would probably be prepared to have my wealth (the 3rd value of the house) sit in the property for now. I wouldn’t agree to helping pay to pay insurance or heating etc. to keep the house empty over the winter months so DB3 can live elsewhere and have somewhere to come back to. But I’d probably be okay with not realising the equity in the property right now if DB3 were prepared to pay all bills and upkeep (and not let the property deteriorate any further than it currently has).

But if their mum has just passed I think these sorts of discussions can be left at least until the spring when DB3 comes back. All the brothers probably need a little time to come to terms with their loss. DB3 has both the loss of his mom, his summertime companion and the change to his lifestyle to come to terms with. It’s not surprising if he hasn’t immediately worked out how to cope with that. His time back at the winter “home” may help him work out what he wants going forward.

BliainNua · 12/01/2023 18:48

All those saying 60k is a good deposit, it doesn't sound like A3 can afford to pay a mortgage.

Nixer · 12/01/2023 18:44

There is a ski season in the southern hemisphere so he could work most of the year as a ski instructor if he could be bothered.
Of course it needs to be sold and split 3 ways - it belongs to 2 other people and by continuing to live there without paying market rent he'd be depriving them of their property. If he was less of a CF he could live there whilst it's being marketed and sold but not if he's likely to deliberately mess up viewings in order to prevent the sale.

MakeMineALarge1 · 12/01/2023 18:44

Yabado · 12/01/2023 18:42

You will council tax to pay after 6 months plus insurance gas electric water
so you could easily be paying 200 a month to run an empty house

Yes I know, and no doubt when this becomes apparent it might make them think about how long the situation continues
I am also acutely aware of the fact that an empty house is a sitting duck for break ins etc

OP posts:
Dreamsoffreedomjoyandpeace · 12/01/2023 18:44

If I was him and I had 60k I’d probably buy a really nice camper van. It sounds like he has that sort of alternative lifestyle anyway so it wouldn’t be a huge deal.

Assuming he skis in Europe he could use the van to live in and he’d have enough from his odd jobs to live on. Not a permanent solution I guess but he’s going to be so depressed going from the life he has now to a conventional life and renting is also not a permanent solution because he wouldn’t be entitled to benefits. Benefits aren’t enough for a single person to live on anyway.

There’s also the investment property idea but he’d have great trouble getting a decent btl mortgage deal with no proper job and with the interest rates increasing and property prices starting to drop its a gamble.

Mistymountain · 12/01/2023 18:44

I think they should all agree to sell the house, especially if it needs work doing, it'll just be a millstone round every ones' neck.

It sounds like Adult 3 has the gift of the gab and a knack for finding work, I'm sure they'll be fine and land on their feet.

Yabado · 12/01/2023 18:42

You will council tax to pay after 6 months plus insurance gas electric water
so you could easily be paying 200 a month to run an empty house