Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

House sale, 3 adult children, 1 with nowhere to go

266 replies

MakeMineALarge1 · 12/01/2023 17:04

So MIL passed away, she had 3 children ( all children 50 yrs +), I am married to one of them
Adult 1 - I am married to, both him and me in good jobs, 1 dependant child
Adult 2 - Single, decent job, mortgage free
Adult 3 - Single - never had a real job, works hard but plays hard and has never settled down, spend half the year skiing and then comes back lives with mum and goes back again in the winter

MIL passed away, house being kept on as if sold, child 3 will effectively be homeless ( they do have 2 children who both have homes and lots of friends, so wouldn't be on the street ) but he cannot buy the other 2 out and cannot afford to keep the house on his self - the house isn't worth a great deal, say £180,000 ball park figure, so if sold and split equally only £60,000 each, which wouldn't be enough to buy him a place, but would cover rent for a good while until i presume benefits kick in?

Adult 1 and 3 are not pushing for the sale and they will not see number 3 homeless, but this can't go on forever ( its all very recent) I am not getting involved, but would be interested in knowing what others think.

Also this situation very much mirrors my own family with my sibling being very much like adult 3 and I may be facing this conundrum in the future.

OP posts:
Zizz · 12/01/2023 20:16

Who is the executor? Don't they have a legal duty to deal with the estate by a certain date?

Zanatdy · 12/01/2023 20:13

I would be going ahead with the sale. Doesn’t sound like this guy is working all the hours God sends and still unable to afford his own home etc. He’s choosing to work overseas for part of year doing a hobby he enjoys then not working fully when back. Why should his siblings sacrifice their inheritance so he gets the house? Bet he would sell it and spend it ski-ing etc if that happened!

JimDixon · 12/01/2023 20:09

NoMoreLifts · 12/01/2023 19:29

Went to Rightmove and found somewhere where there were 3 bed houses for that price (within 40 miles of Derby) .
There were 316 2 bed properties for £60,000 or less in the same area, even after I excluded shared ownership. 110 of them were houses.
He'll be fine.

Sure, and he could even this place in Rotherham for £5000 and - er - fix it up a bit:

www.rightmove.co.uk/properties/130520843#/?channel=RES_BUY

RandomMess · 12/01/2023 20:07

Presumably £60k would be a good chunk in a shared ownership property?

That could be a workable solution.

PuzzledObserver · 12/01/2023 20:03

Hankunamatata · 12/01/2023 17:09

If I was siblings I'd get legal documentation drawn up that dc3 pays nominal rent to dc 1 and 2. He is responsible for the household bills. All 3 jointly responsible for cost of property upkeep.

I was going to say the same, except it would be a proper market rent, not a nominal amount. Obviously he would only pay 2/3 of it, 1/3 to each sibling, as he owns 1/3 of the house himself.

All 3 siblings equally responsible for maintenance, he is responsible for council tax and utilities.

He could have a lodger to help cover costs while he’s off abroad.

You say he works hard but plays hard…. what does he do for money?

theycallmejane · 12/01/2023 20:03

I'd be happy to let sibling 3 keep the house as he's most in need, and it sounds like his mum would have wanted him to keep a roof over his head.

However, he needs to change his lifestyle now he's the only one living there. The house cannot be left unoccupied for six months at a time!

My generosity as a sibling giving up a £60k share would be sorely tested if he didn't look after the house he'd been kindly given. I'm not suggesting he's kicked out on his ear (even though legally it would be possible), but I do think his ski season days are over. He needs to live there properly and get a local job.

If that's not something he's prepared to do, I'd go back to the original plan of selling up.

RunRunRunSomeMore · 12/01/2023 20:03

Adult 3 - Single - never had a real job, works hard but plays hard and has never settled down, spend half the year skiing and then comes back lives with mum and goes back again in the winter

How do you work hard without every having had a real job?

pattihews · 12/01/2023 20:02

MakeMineALarge1 · 12/01/2023 17:11

That's a good idea. I will put that one forward. However what happens when he is out of the country for 6 months - he pays rent when he is away, not sure he could afford 2 rents - I think he knows himself it will have to be sold, its too big for one person and needs a lot of work doing on it

Be really careful when you're coming to any kind of agreement to take into account the potentially major amounts of money that may be required to maintain the place. In my family we had a similar situation: three children, one of whom had lived with and looked after an elderly parent in their final years and then wanted the right to remain in the house for the rest of their life as recompense. The other two agreed at first, and agreed to share maintenance costs. Changed their minds swiftly when it became clear the place needed reroofing and rewiring and they were expected to find upward of £15k each to put towards a project that might offer them no benefit in their lifetimes. They ended up forcing a sale.

Nixer · 12/01/2023 20:01

Has probate (or letters of administration if there was no will) been obtained yet? I believe it's taking nearly a year in some places.
Also what did you mean by paying a "supplement" for the house to remain empty for 6 months?

FedUpWithEverything123 · 12/01/2023 20:00

Sorry not RTFT but surely £60k could get him a deposit on a flat? or at least enough to launch him into the real world in some way (rental etc), which is where he should be anyway!!

Justalittlebitduckling · 12/01/2023 20:00

He can get a job in a ski chalet or some other kind of live in job. Or do shared ownership somewhere where housing is very cheap.

Overandunderit · 12/01/2023 19:58

Not RTFT but have your replies

60k is plenty to get Adult 3 somewhere sorted. it's not your DHs siblings responsibly to keep him housed. He's an adult.

If I were your DH I'd push for a sale.

fishstewmyfriend · 12/01/2023 19:54

Could the other sibling use the £60k to buy a park home ? Would work well as not allowed to live on (most) of them 12 months a year - could go to ski when the park is closed annually.

Silvers11 · 12/01/2023 19:52

MakeMineALarge1 · 12/01/2023 18:36

@Silvers11 it has all happened recently and he had to go back as he had work commitments
I am just broaching ideas with other people as I feel I am too close to be making decisions
But yes you're right no formal discussions have been had - I am just looking at different scenarios

Ok - in that case it seems to me that he might be more than happy to just sell the house and you won't know until all 3 siblings can get together to discuss.
It's the most obvious thing to do if they are all happy about that.

But I also think that really, it's up to the three of them to discuss and without input from you. I understand why you have thoughts about it and want to discuss them with your husband but, and I mean this kindly, it isn't your place to get involved - or at least not at this stage. You referred earlier not wanting to be seen as the greedy DIL just wanting to get your hands on the cash. So stand back and leave them to make decisions between the three of them? Otherwise you could be seen to be exactly that if there ends up being disagreements between the three of them

Aleaiactaest · 12/01/2023 19:47

Depends on whether the 60k would make a big difference to the other 2 siblings or not. If not, I would be inclined to give him a life interest and the other two siblings/their offspring to inherit the full amount following his death upon sale of the house. But he can’t sell it during his life time. And has to maintain it/pay all bills. So legal title passes to the 2 siblings but he has a beneficial life interest.

tenbob · 12/01/2023 19:44

ElephantInTheKitchen · 12/01/2023 19:28

Is there work available in the ski resort or surrounding areas during the summer too? I imagine there's maintenance to be done in the off-season, and many ski resorts have a summer hiking industry too.

If it's as cheap and cheerful as you describe, I wonder if living out there full time would be an option - would £60k buy him a flat there? Would he be able to do so post-Brexit?

There is a lot less work in the summer. A huge proportion of the locals who have winter jobs like working the lifts and being instructors will be builders and tradesmen in the summer, so will handle all the proper maintenance and building work for chalets.
People working in the shops in the winter are usually there in the summer.

Jobs for seasonaires over summer are quite limited, especially if you haven’t been doing it for a long time

amonsteronthehill · 12/01/2023 19:43

House should be sold, not at empty for half the year while third sibling is off skiing/working odd jobs elsewhere. I imagine the bills (council tax, insurance, heating, water, etc) exist year round and need to be covered. Plus an empty house could easily become a target for thieves, squatters, etc

SD1978 · 12/01/2023 19:41

Sold and split. He's chosen to piss fart away his chance to build up any savings by skiing half the year, and getting free lodgings for the other half of the year. His lack of ability to fund himself now isn't the issue for the other two siblings.

ICanHideButICantRun · 12/01/2023 19:36

He's 55 and doesn't work in this country. Where would he get a mortgage from?

Kendodd · 12/01/2023 19:34

You say the house is worth about £180. That suggests it's in a cheap area of the country. Are you sure he couldn't buy a small flat, with a small mortgage and get a flat mate in with rent to cover most of it? Has he even looked into this? What has adult 3 said he wants to do?

londonrach · 12/01/2023 19:33

Adult 3 needs to grow up! Sell house and split it....dmil.has stopped adult 3 bring grown up.

Kennykenkencat · 12/01/2023 19:31

I think that the house should be sold and split and adult 3 could find himself a flat somewhere for his £60k

Even if it is a tiny 1 bed or studio or given he does handy man type stuff could he make a bit of a business buying a flat, doing it up then selling it, then buying another etc etc till he gets a better place or even when he has finished a place renting it out, mortgaging it then going off skiing and working and when he returns he does the same again

I think he is the type to land on his feet . A bit of direction and he could be quite successful.

Whoknew42 · 12/01/2023 19:30

I would ask what he had planned to do in this obvious eventuality and can u help him with that? Always makes people feel pretty awkward in this kind of situation.

Hes taking the piss. Doesn't sound like he can't afford to live imo!

Testina · 12/01/2023 19:29

“One of adult 3 children have said to him that he cannot keep the house as its not fair
This has all happened recently and adult 3 had to get back to the ski resort as he had work booked in
I do think when he gets back decisions will be made”

Can you just clarify… this sounds like he was already working overseas when his mother died. You said it was recent, you said he had to get back out there.

What did you expect him to do, whilst he still has what - 4 months? - to work out there?
You’re posting like he’s some arsehole refusing to move, not a man whose main U.K. base has been removed whilst he’s abroad - and you know, lost his mother. When in fact it’s perfectly reasonable that he hasn’t gone into full on sale mode - and your husband or the other brother has already told him they want to sell the house.

So why post like he’s taking the piss, when he’s not? May as well blame MIL for not dying in the summer.

I have a sibling living with parents. None of us would expect her to be out in less than 6 months. And certainly not if she was working abroad for another few months!

NoMoreLifts · 12/01/2023 19:29

Went to Rightmove and found somewhere where there were 3 bed houses for that price (within 40 miles of Derby) .
There were 316 2 bed properties for £60,000 or less in the same area, even after I excluded shared ownership. 110 of them were houses.
He'll be fine.