Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

House sale, 3 adult children, 1 with nowhere to go

266 replies

MakeMineALarge1 · 12/01/2023 17:04

So MIL passed away, she had 3 children ( all children 50 yrs +), I am married to one of them
Adult 1 - I am married to, both him and me in good jobs, 1 dependant child
Adult 2 - Single, decent job, mortgage free
Adult 3 - Single - never had a real job, works hard but plays hard and has never settled down, spend half the year skiing and then comes back lives with mum and goes back again in the winter

MIL passed away, house being kept on as if sold, child 3 will effectively be homeless ( they do have 2 children who both have homes and lots of friends, so wouldn't be on the street ) but he cannot buy the other 2 out and cannot afford to keep the house on his self - the house isn't worth a great deal, say £180,000 ball park figure, so if sold and split equally only £60,000 each, which wouldn't be enough to buy him a place, but would cover rent for a good while until i presume benefits kick in?

Adult 1 and 3 are not pushing for the sale and they will not see number 3 homeless, but this can't go on forever ( its all very recent) I am not getting involved, but would be interested in knowing what others think.

Also this situation very much mirrors my own family with my sibling being very much like adult 3 and I may be facing this conundrum in the future.

OP posts:
Ponoka7 · 13/01/2023 07:51

X post, if there is a lot of work needing doing then to be fair to your children, you might have to force a sale. Unless you will invest in the repairs.

Ponoka7 · 13/01/2023 07:50

Zizz · 12/01/2023 20:16

Who is the executor? Don't they have a legal duty to deal with the estate by a certain date?

No unfortunately. My sister has only just got around to settling my Mum's probate etc seven years on, it's been stressful. People need to be careful about how their wishes are set out and who is executor.

A proper discussion is needed. If both siblings are happy to not force a sale, a lodger situation might be a solution. He isn't going to get a mortgage at 55 with no stable UK employment and being out of the country for six months. He needs to pay the council tax. The buildings insurance is a bit more complex and will take a lot of ringing around if not a broker. If he needs social care/care home they will come after his share of the house. The issue is him being out of the country, it would disqualify him for over 55 housing and many rentals. Subletting the other rooms might be the way to go.

Lacienay · 13/01/2023 07:46

MakeMineALarge1 · 12/01/2023 17:11

That's a good idea. I will put that one forward. However what happens when he is out of the country for 6 months - he pays rent when he is away, not sure he could afford 2 rents - I think he knows himself it will have to be sold, its too big for one person and needs a lot of work doing on it

Then for those 6 months, house is rented out to someone as a short term lease

MichaelAndEagle · 13/01/2023 07:38

hmmmintereting · 13/01/2023 07:01

So much sneering at #3 without even knowing the guy! Not everybody's life turns out 9-5, married with two kids!

Sounds like he's had a charmed life (did MIL like him staying there? - my mum would have loved it). Now she has gone, the house should be sold; that's the right thing.

Totally.
People also keep saying he needs to get a job despite the OP saying he does work numerous times.

MakeMineALarge1 · 13/01/2023 07:26

Kapalika · 13/01/2023 05:29

Either way this will cause resentment. There is no escaping that.
why do parents do this kind of shit??
I say sell it. That’s only fair and it will benefit all the children and grandchildren equally.

But what is a parent to do when a relationship splits up and their child has no where to go?
My mum is in the same situation now with my brother, his relationship has split up and he has nowhere to go, he was sleeping in a wagon! Should she see him on the streets or back in his old room?

OP posts:
MakeMineALarge1 · 13/01/2023 07:24

Thank you for everyone's responses
To know there are other families in this position and have had other dilemma's is reassuring
There is a will, all 3 children are executors, the will states the house is to be sold, but she had always said that adult 3 mustn't be turfed out onto the streets, no one has any intention of doing this
Adult 3 is back from overseas next week and has asked that all 3 siblings meet up to discuss things - I think this is really reassuring
Like I have said - there will be no falling our - we will not see him homeless ( but he is the type of person to land on his feet )
We don't want to rent the house out whilst he isn't here, it needs too much work doing on it, which none of us have the time to oversee and we don't want to be landlords.
He has worked all this life - driving jobs etc - he works whilst he is away and obviously pays rent when away
MIL did enjoy having him at home it was mutually beneficial, he did in no way provide care for her, she was very independent.

OP posts:
BCBird · 13/01/2023 07:07

You say you don't want to.be seen as the avaricious daughter-in-law,which I understand. I.would keep.out of it. I would not be voicing any opinion to the other sibling. The free spirit sibling will have to change his life now as mom's hotel.is no longer available. If he can't fund this lifestyle things will have to change.

hmmmintereting · 13/01/2023 07:01

So much sneering at #3 without even knowing the guy! Not everybody's life turns out 9-5, married with two kids!

Sounds like he's had a charmed life (did MIL like him staying there? - my mum would have loved it). Now she has gone, the house should be sold; that's the right thing.

Leeanne922 · 13/01/2023 06:53

Whats the problem? He has somewhere to go, many places out for rent or for sale- just not for free.

Lincslady53 · 13/01/2023 06:44

Is there a will? If it says that the estate should be equally split 3 ways, the house should be sold. If the will has provision for the 3rd son to remain in the house then the house is not sold.
If it is split 3 ways, £60k would be a good deposit for a property, he will have to get a mortgage on a smaller property or rent somewhere, with a job to pay the rent.

Anycrispsleft · 13/01/2023 05:42

Adult number 3 needs to take his share of the house sale proceeds and use some of it to buy a camper van.

But you as the DIL OP need to stay well clear. You've got to let the siblings sort it out.

Kapalika · 13/01/2023 05:29

Either way this will cause resentment. There is no escaping that.
why do parents do this kind of shit??
I say sell it. That’s only fair and it will benefit all the children and grandchildren equally.

JudgeRudy · 13/01/2023 04:53

Adult 3 needs to man up. He might not be able to afford to buy himself a house outright but that's a nice deposit....obviously though he would need to get a job. The other alternative is he rents.
There's a third option.He could rent it for now for 2/3 of going rate till he makes a proposal. 3 months rent free I'd more than enough. If he wants to stay longer he pays. Has he actually asked to stay rent free or has it just happened? I'd imagine he knows full well what's coming. You're not making him homeless, he's chosen to not invest in a property and will have torrent like everyone else. Give him pick of the furniture and appliances to help him on his way.

BagBoxScuttle · 13/01/2023 04:37

The remaining sibling lives there

The house is shared with a lodger or two
So that the property is not left

Look on Gov.uk a person can earn over 7k tax free if they rent out a room in a property that they live in

SpacersChoice · 13/01/2023 04:14

I guarantee the man has never paid child support, all whilst leeching off his own mother. That’ll be the main reason why he fucks off abroad half the year and has no tangible assets.

NumberTheory · 12/01/2023 22:59

He must have thought about what he'd do when his mother died. Has anyone even asked him?

He may have and they definitely need to ask him. But he sounds like a bit of a Peter Pan and my experience of men like that is that they generally stick their head in the sand and assume things will work out.

Nana4 · 12/01/2023 22:05

shiningstar2 · 12/01/2023 21:55

Nana4 ..that sounds a great solution. You are honouring your mother's wishes and taking care of your brother while also ensuring the fair sharing of the property which your mother also wished for. Really shows what can be done with some thought when the whole family are considerate. 💐

Thank you, that’s very kind of you to say. We have done a lot of thinking and talking ( and juggling with finances) to get here. The main thing I think is to talk everything through honestly, and not assume there is only one solution.

shiningstar2 · 12/01/2023 21:55

Nana4 ..that sounds a great solution. You are honouring your mother's wishes and taking care of your brother while also ensuring the fair sharing of the property which your mother also wished for. Really shows what can be done with some thought when the whole family are considerate. 💐

Nana4 · 12/01/2023 21:38

I am currently dealing with, almost, this exact situation. My mums house is left to the 4 of us equally, my brother has always lived with her and has been her main carer for the last few years. I am the eldest and she has always said, “you will make sure brother is alright”

Apologies if overstepping, and you have already done this, but this is from the beginning, you/the siblings need to discuss and clarify a few facts.

You don’t mention any will so assume there is none.
Did the mother express any wishes regarding the sharing of the estate?
What is the value of the estate, including any money you appear to be already using. Get a proper valuation for the house.

You will need to apply for probate/ letters of administration to administer the estate, no distribution of assets should be happening before this is dealt with.
Go to .gov.uk search probate. Lots of info on there regarding who can apply, the rules, etc.

What does sibling 3 actually want or need. (He is not entitled to stay in the house and you shouldn’t say he can without it all being addressed legally.)
He may even want to take his share an run, if that’s the case you don’t have to look for any other solution.

My brother needs somewhere to live so we are in the process of buying a flat for him. With a loan (family) and savings (his) we can buy the flat, with the loan to be repaid from his share once the house is sold. This gets him settled and leaves an empty house to clear and get ready to sell later, once probate has gone through ( they are quoting 16 weeks for this to happen)
Bear in mind that if your sibling needs to borrow any additional money, he will struggle to get a mortgage beyond his state pension age, so if age 55+ the sooner this is sorted the better as assuming pension age of 67 only 12 years.

Hope this helps

Silvers11 · 12/01/2023 20:48

MichaelAndEagle · 12/01/2023 20:39

Unless I've missed it, I can't see anywhere in the OPs posts that the third brother has opposed or is likely to oppose a sale.
He's gone back to work. I think you're getting ahead of yourself.
He must have thought about what he'd do when his mother died. Has anyone even asked him?

OP has confirmed that it hasn't even been discussed with the 3rd Sibling! He's gone back to ski/work abroad. So she doesn't know what his reaction will be 🙄

AdoraBell · 12/01/2023 20:44

I think the house should be sold and proceeds split between the 3 siblings.

The sibling still living there is welcome to the real world.

MichaelAndEagle · 12/01/2023 20:39

Unless I've missed it, I can't see anywhere in the OPs posts that the third brother has opposed or is likely to oppose a sale.
He's gone back to work. I think you're getting ahead of yourself.
He must have thought about what he'd do when his mother died. Has anyone even asked him?

MakeMineALarge1 · 12/01/2023 20:37

Hi.
I'm going out now, so will update tomorrow and answer more questions

OP posts:
HamBone · 12/01/2023 20:37

MakeMineALarge1 · 12/01/2023 18:28

Yes, not thought about that.

Not a good idea.

I’m wondering about this too, but I’m not knowledgeable in this area.

Would his bothers effectively become his landlords and have to abide by those rules, e.g., provide a tenancy agreement, gas safety certificate, etc.? Perhaps not as he’s a part-owner of the property, but it should be looked into. It could be a nightmare in practice.

JimDixon · 12/01/2023 20:21

PuzzledObserver · 12/01/2023 20:03

I was going to say the same, except it would be a proper market rent, not a nominal amount. Obviously he would only pay 2/3 of it, 1/3 to each sibling, as he owns 1/3 of the house himself.

All 3 siblings equally responsible for maintenance, he is responsible for council tax and utilities.

He could have a lodger to help cover costs while he’s off abroad.

You say he works hard but plays hard…. what does he do for money?

OP says in one of her posts that the property has not been maintained, so depending on the area probably it isn't worth the full market rent.

If he would be abroad for six months of the year, he couldn't really have a lodger. Any person he rented a room to would have a strong case that they were actually a tenant. And he could find they change the locks and don't let him back in when he returns....