Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

House sale, 3 adult children, 1 with nowhere to go

266 replies

MakeMineALarge1 · 12/01/2023 17:04

So MIL passed away, she had 3 children ( all children 50 yrs +), I am married to one of them
Adult 1 - I am married to, both him and me in good jobs, 1 dependant child
Adult 2 - Single, decent job, mortgage free
Adult 3 - Single - never had a real job, works hard but plays hard and has never settled down, spend half the year skiing and then comes back lives with mum and goes back again in the winter

MIL passed away, house being kept on as if sold, child 3 will effectively be homeless ( they do have 2 children who both have homes and lots of friends, so wouldn't be on the street ) but he cannot buy the other 2 out and cannot afford to keep the house on his self - the house isn't worth a great deal, say £180,000 ball park figure, so if sold and split equally only £60,000 each, which wouldn't be enough to buy him a place, but would cover rent for a good while until i presume benefits kick in?

Adult 1 and 3 are not pushing for the sale and they will not see number 3 homeless, but this can't go on forever ( its all very recent) I am not getting involved, but would be interested in knowing what others think.

Also this situation very much mirrors my own family with my sibling being very much like adult 3 and I may be facing this conundrum in the future.

OP posts:
bigbluebus · 12/01/2023 17:45

I'd give him a reasonable amount of time to get himself sorted with an alternative - say maximum 6 months so it's not in the middle of the ski season - then the house goes on the market to be split 3 ways. No point in keeping the house if he's not living on it for half of the year and can't afford to run it.

Who are the executors to MILs Estate? Much easier if it's a firm if solicitors or someone outside of the family - it takes the emotional aspect out of it.

1FootInTheRave · 12/01/2023 17:43

Sibling 3 needs to grow the fuck up.

skyeisthelimit · 12/01/2023 17:43

They need to sell the house and split the money 3 ways. He can use the money to pay his rent if he doesn't work. His siblings should NOT be subsidising his lifestyle.

If they do decide to keep it on then they need a proper rental tenancy agreement for the 2/3 that he is renting out, payable at market value. Get an estate agent to draw up the paperwork and take a deposit etc. He will be liable for 1/3 of the repairs etc. It will need to meet all current criteria for a rental property, EPC, smoke alarms etc.

It would be easier to just sell it.

Edwardandtubbs · 12/01/2023 17:42

This happened in my family except there were 4 siblings. It has been 5 years since the parent died. There's no hope of a resolution as no-one will say anything to the resident sibling.

One of the 4 has since died and so never got their inheritance. The rest are in their mid-late 70s and I can honestly see it dragging on until they have all died and then it'll be up to us to sort out.

I'd urge you (your DH) to get it sorted out before it becomes the next generation's problem.

crimsonlake · 12/01/2023 17:40

This was the situation when my sisters mil died, one unmarried son in his fifties no longer working due to mental health issues still living with her.
Two other siblings with their own grown up children, one sibling very wealthy, the other just comfortable but unable to help his children financially etc.
The sibling has remained in the former home and I imagine lives there rent free and I expect ill continue to do so until he dies.
I never voiced my opinion of course but it would have been nice to see my niece's and nephew's receive a little windfall towards buying their first home.

Southwig22 · 12/01/2023 17:40

Is this even a conundrum?

House gets sold, split equally. What each adult does with the money is up to them.

Would suggest adult 3 uses it for a deposit on a shared ownership or studio property which will leave them with minimal mortgage that they can cover through even basic work.

Rowthe · 12/01/2023 17:39

He needs to start funding his own future but wont do it until he gets a reality check.

Get the house sold.

BliainNua · 12/01/2023 17:37

In an ideal world the house should be sold and money split 3 ways, but we all know families are complicated.

My DM had a similar situation; her DSis worked abroad for most of the year (in a kind of voluntary/missionary role) but when she came "home" she stayed with her DM (my grandma). My grandma died with no will, so house was split between siblings. But as my aunt had no home here, and no real income my DM and her bro agreed to basically give away their inheritance and signed it all over to aunt (their sister). It was the right thing for their family, but can imagine for lots of others it wouldn't have been. She's elderly now & lives in the same 4 bed house all alone.

She has no DC or partner, so I've no idea who she will leave the house to when she dies.
I'd like to think it would still stay in the family, but she could easily leave it to the local cats home.

bridgetreilly · 12/01/2023 17:35

You all stop needing to use the word homeless and start describing the sibling as an independent adult who is responsible for his own choices. Unless he wants to buy his siblings out, the house has to sold. Then he can do whatever he likes.

Yesthatismychildsigh · 12/01/2023 17:30

SpacersChoice · 12/01/2023 17:06

Not much of a conundrum, it’s well overdue that the other sibling enters the real fucking world.

This

NeuroWasabi · 12/01/2023 17:29

It seems quite obvious that adult 3 will have to make other arrangements for accommodation when back in the UK and the house be sold.

It's not fair or practical to do otherwise, unless you wanted to rent out the house for the 6 months of the year that he's not living there? That would provide some income and then he could pay rent to adults 1 and 2 directly when he's in the UK, and I would assume earning an income?

YourWinter · 12/01/2023 17:28

My mother’s will stipulated that when she died her house would be jointly owned by her three adult children and the one that still lived with her could continue to do so rent free for his lifetime, with all running and maintenance costs at his expense. The two of us who already have our own homes would have preferred it sold and split three ways but the sibling who lived with her couldn’t have bought another property. It is what it is. We all went to an appointment at the Land Registry to put the house in our three names.

ICanHideButICantRun · 12/01/2023 17:25

How old is he? He's got two adult children who have their own home, but he doesn't?

boboshmobo · 12/01/2023 17:24

£60k will get him a flat somewhere so he can do that .. it's the fairest thing ... he can't stay in the house forever because he is a loser ..

He has had no doubt free rent for years !!🙄🙄

Hankunamatata · 12/01/2023 17:22

I was going to suggest a lodger too for when he is out of the country but if the house needs that much work then might not be suitable

HarryArry · 12/01/2023 17:22

My SIL was like adult 3, it turned out she had 80k in savings she kept quiet about. When the late parents house was sold she bought a home outright. I guess all the years living there rent free paid off.

FOJN · 12/01/2023 17:21

Most household insurance companies won't insure you if the house is left empty for any period of time and some will even stipulate what temperature the heating must be set at if the house isn't occupied full time. Doesn't sound like sponger sibling will be able to cover the cost of rent and bills if he's only in the country for half the year and you will be saddled with maintenance costs. I'd save myself the headache and force a sale.

If there was background which explained why someone in their 50's wasn't independent of their parent I would be more understanding but in this instance it just sounds like someone enjoying a lovely lifestyle whilst everyone else worries about them becoming homeless.

If the house is worth 180k then 60k would provide a decent deposit for a flat and unless the low house value is to do with condition and location then presumably property prices locally are fairly low and he wouldn't need a huge income to get sufficient mortgage for a flat.

At what age do the family expect this sibling to start behaving like a responsible adult? Refuse to be the solution to a problem you didn't create.

MincePiesAreMyJam · 12/01/2023 17:21

When my Mum passes, we will be in this situation with one sibling (not me) having greater housing needs. Genuinely not sure what we will do...

Preggingswearingleggings · 12/01/2023 17:21

No dilemma here. Go to court if necessary and get the house sold and split. It's not you or your husbands problem what an able-bodied adult does to support themselves. What a chancer.

BarbaraofSeville · 12/01/2023 17:21

MakeMineALarge1 · 12/01/2023 17:17

I don't know if they would be
If they were renting and then stopped work at say 65 would they get housing benefit - I don't know - its not something I have ever thought about to be honest - for what its worth - no I don't think he should.

There's very little state support for healthy working age adults under state pension age, which I assume is 67 for him.

Therefore, he'd get about £300 pm and some rent paid, (likely on a very small place in a cheap area) as an absolute maximum, but he'd be expected to look for work to get that.

LimeCheesecake · 12/01/2023 17:19

Sibling 3 had 2 adult dcs with their own homes - would one of said adult dcs be able / willing to go in on buying a property with their dad (assume if whole house worth £180k in your area, a flat could be bought more like £100k), he owns his half out right and pays rent to his child for their share. Could possibly get a lodger in to help , particularly if sibling 3 is only there 6 months of the year.

saltinesandcoffeecups · 12/01/2023 17:18

#3 sounds like they are using it because it’s convenient… not that it’s your problem but likely they’ll use the money from the sale to fund short term rentals when not traveling.

Not really anyone else’s problem.

totallyhadenoughofthisbs · 12/01/2023 17:18

Sponger sibling needs to move out and pay his way.
When he's off skiiing he's not 'homeless' is he? He needs to get a job and adult like the rest of us. Nice to be off skiiing when you can afford that lifestyle but not at the expense of siblings!

BarbaraofSeville · 12/01/2023 17:17

Do you know that he doesn't actually have any money? If he's lived with his DM up to now, he could have saved/invested enough to buy a house or do what he wants. Was he just partying, or was he working as a ski guide?

Either way, it's not really for you to worry about, except it should be clear that the time has come where he stands on his own two feet.

MakeMineALarge1 · 12/01/2023 17:17

BarbaraofSeville · 12/01/2023 17:13

Why would 'adult' 3 ever be entitled to benefits? It doesn't sound like they are unable to work, just that they've managed to get away with not having to all the time up to now.

It could either be arranged that they rent the house off the other two siblings, or it is sold and the proceeds split. It's not like they'd have nothing, with £60k and decades of experience skiing. If they earn money from this, they could continue to do so, surely?

I don't know if they would be
If they were renting and then stopped work at say 65 would they get housing benefit - I don't know - its not something I have ever thought about to be honest - for what its worth - no I don't think he should.

OP posts: