Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think DH shouldn’t quit teaching?

143 replies

mindyk · 12/01/2023 11:43

Slightly misleading title.

My DH is an outstanding Maths (and Economics/Politics) teacher. He is specialised in Maths so can easily teach Further Maths A Level standard (basically all pre-Uni level stuff) he also runs a successful tutoring company.

DH is a bit of a martyr. We have lots of outstanding / grammar schools in the area which he refuses to go to, saying the kids at bad schools need him. As a result, the abuse, lack of care from the kids and general issues with the profession means he wants to leave.

DH says he will take a pay cut but I know him inside out, the only way he would take a pay cut is because he can supplement with tutoring, this means any job that requires you to work past 5pm or doesn’t allow a WFH finish at 5pm on the dot is not possible.

Any career ideas for him? This is his requirements:

  • WFH at least half the week
  • Minimum £40k salary (he’s currently on around £55k)
  • Must be able to run the tutoring which he must start by 5pm-ish each evening.

his current school finishes before 3pm, he doesn’t bring work home 95% of the time, marking is easy as most kids can barely answer more than 1 page of a paper and he never works holidays. He tutors most evenings from 430pm to as late as 9pm Mon-Thurs. I personally think he should try a better school, maybe take on less responsibility and teach as a back up.

He cannot do tutoring full time due to security and we plan to move in a year or two, once we’ve bought the bigger house etc. he can go self-employed full time.

OP posts:
spirit20 · 13/01/2023 09:30

DinnerThyme · 12/01/2023 19:39

I’m a former teacher and married to a teacher. I’m a lawyer in the City. Starting salaries are about £55,000 so he wouldn’t need to take a pay cut except for when he’s doing his SQE course for a year (I think firms give about £20,000 tax free for that but he could also teach part-time and/or tutor to bring that up - it definitely gets more than the LPC did). Lots of former teachers go into law.

He doesn’t get out at 5 but he wouldn’t need to tutor and his salary would be over £100,000 two year after he started. He should definitely leave teaching, it’s shit and horrible. Hats off to those who can do it but expecting someone else to stay in that awful environment when they want to leave is just horrible.

@DinnerThyme Could I ask how old you were when you retrained? I'm 36 and was considering retraining from teaching to law but was worried I'd be too old.

OP: I'm not overly convinced your details are accurate. What sticks out for me is you're saying he's SLT but only has 6 free periods a fortnight. That is highly unlikely for an SLT, and even seems low for a teachers timetable. 55k also sounds on the low side for SLT.

mindyk · 13/01/2023 09:30

Nimbostratus100 · 13/01/2023 09:27

Teachers dont leave in February?

THAT’S what you took from that?
Schools do have different practice as long as it’s half a terms notice for his I believe. But I will ask him and see if I got the date wrong of when those leave.

OP posts:
mindyk · 13/01/2023 09:28

One more thing, he doesn’t currently teach Politics and Economics due to the school he’s at (doesn’t have sixth form) and he has been at this school 2 years.

OP posts:
Nimbostratus100 · 13/01/2023 09:27

Teachers dont leave in February?

mindyk · 13/01/2023 09:25

DH read what I said and does not agree with some of my points, whoops.

He doesn’t churn out the same lessons, I know this because he always has to change and plan then which is why he goes in first thing in the morning. But it isn’t from scratch and taking hours was my point.

His school starts and finishes early, they only have 30 mins of breaks total. So that’s why 3pm sounds early.

He is stressed ALL of the time because of the abuse of the kids and lack of support from parents. 14 teachers left at Christmas this year. His department halved as so many hated it. A further 10 will leave at Feb who have announced. More to come at Easter.

Not sure why it’s so hard to comprehend, but when you’re very knowledgeable, know EVERY exam question that has EVER been asked for the past 10 years, it is so easy for him to adapt his lessons through his physical presence, they use a lot of white boards as is the current guidance. He always is given the hard classes because he’s the only maths teacher that can tolerate and gain a smidge of respect from them.

This isn’t a thread about whether or not you believe DH’s day to day life, or whether you think he’s a good teacher. It’s a thread about what opportunities are out there and how stark reality can be.

DH has one day every 8 days he has to stay an hour after school for detention, he has 1 day every week he has teaching and learning for an hour and he has 1 day every term he has to stay for 3 or so extra hours. Then obviously parents evenings every year. So 3 days a week he leaves at around 3ish, 2 days he leaves at 4ish. Semantics.

DH employs other teachers in the company. There is someone who runs admin and operations. He could definitely do it full time in the future or if we changed our lifestyle.

We are also looking to have a baby soon.

OP posts:
mindyk · 13/01/2023 09:13

Forthelast · 12/01/2023 13:06

How on earth does he finish before 3? Why is he not putting his back into bringing standards up? There is a lot of work right there that he's not doing.

All his reports are outstanding. He has been promoted every year and he is SLT and head of KS4. Before this school, he was at an outstanding school ranked whilst he was teaching there. He’s obviously good at his job. That wasn’t my question but I love how MN can turn anything into a teacher bashing thread.

OP posts:
Itloggedmeoutagain · 13/01/2023 09:12

Runs a successful tutoring company? Do you mean he employs other tutors or do you mean he tutors in the evening?

mindyk · 13/01/2023 09:10

Catapultaway · 12/01/2023 12:38

Some inconsistencies, he is an excellent teacher who won't leave because the kids need him but "marking is easy as most kids can barely answer more than 1 page of a paper".
He should leave, his hearts not in it, he's exactly the sort of teacher schools and the kids need rid of.
Hope he finds something he likes more.

Disagree with this. He is outstanding. He fights and advocates for those children. He works in one of the most deprived areas in the UK in a school that almost got closed. So yes, children can barely answer more than a few pages of a paper - getting a 4 for a lot of the students is a dream, but it means he doesn’t have much marking like teachers in English or written subjects. With maths, they either attempted the answer or they didn’t.

As much as he hates teaching right now, he has and would never not put everything into the lessons.

To highlight the school, parents have punched teachers, he’s had his personal belongings stolen, children have stolen credit cards from bags of the teachers, attempted to hurt the teachers and some are openly racist. There is always a good child in there somewhere but it’s hard.

OP posts:
yoyo1234 · 13/01/2023 09:08

When do you think you could get your house? I understand you want to get the mortgage etc first. Mortgage companies often want to see multiple years of a self employed persons income (and taxes) before lending so I completely understand wanting him to stay put a while longer.

HaroldeVwilliam · 13/01/2023 08:59

A teacher of maths will have subject knowledge the question is to what degree, literally

hartytype · 13/01/2023 08:14

Subbing?
Flexibility. Gets a chance to check out other schools in the area and widens his scope a bit. It could lead to other opportunities

Forthelast · 13/01/2023 07:57

Postapocalypticcowgirl · 13/01/2023 07:50

In this thread there are lot of people discussing a model of teaching that is now seen as a bit outdated. A more current model is that you teach to the top with every class and provide scaffolding to get them there. For a maths teacher with a lot of experience, a lot of this scaffolding could be done with whiteboard and pen, and directly respond to the class' needs.

And then he could also be making a lot of use if mini whiteboards etc in class, to assess all students, which again is very much in vogue at the moment. As well as peer and self assessment which he then reviews.

There are an awful lot of people who are keen to say how crap he must be based on a few lines of text, when they don't seem to know much about the most current pedagogy.

And those saying the school would be happy to see the back of him really have no idea how hard it is to recruit maths teachers and slt at the moment.

He could be but don't you think he would be eliciting a higher standard of written work if that was the case - or taking action about the awful work he does receive?

Postapocalypticcowgirl · 13/01/2023 07:50

HaroldeVwilliam · 13/01/2023 07:29

Do they need him?
Sometimes teachers with a lower level of maths themselves can make it more relatable than those in the higher echelons...

All the actual evidence on this suggests otherwise and subject knowledge is a key driver of success in maths.

Postapocalypticcowgirl · 13/01/2023 07:50

In this thread there are lot of people discussing a model of teaching that is now seen as a bit outdated. A more current model is that you teach to the top with every class and provide scaffolding to get them there. For a maths teacher with a lot of experience, a lot of this scaffolding could be done with whiteboard and pen, and directly respond to the class' needs.

And then he could also be making a lot of use if mini whiteboards etc in class, to assess all students, which again is very much in vogue at the moment. As well as peer and self assessment which he then reviews.

There are an awful lot of people who are keen to say how crap he must be based on a few lines of text, when they don't seem to know much about the most current pedagogy.

And those saying the school would be happy to see the back of him really have no idea how hard it is to recruit maths teachers and slt at the moment.

HaroldeVwilliam · 13/01/2023 07:29

Do they need him?
Sometimes teachers with a lower level of maths themselves can make it more relatable than those in the higher echelons...

Doidontimmm · 13/01/2023 07:17

I work for an exam board & those that earn over £40k definitely don’t finish at 5pm on the dot & often work evenings & weekends.

Writers are all self employed teachers/lecturers or retired and often have to do the work evenings/weekends.

UsuallySuze · 13/01/2023 06:42

Can you say a bit more about his economics background?

Murdoch1949 · 13/01/2023 06:17

Who says he's an outstanding teacher? Doesn't sound it to me. He's not got much about him if he needs ideas from Mumsnet for new career paths. SLT member but so few non contact sessions, that doesn't happen in any school I ever worked in.

Paulisexcluded · 13/01/2023 00:25

I'm just quite shocked at the number of posters saying such negative things about "bad" schools. I am a teacher, and I have done a lot of supply, as well as experience teaching those who are retaking maths GCSE and who hate maths and believe that they cannot do it.

Does everyone go into teaching to only teach those who are keen to learn? I certainly didn't.

Sorry this is copied and pasted and just one example of what I mean...

"Summerlark · Yesterday 20:15

To be fair maths doesn't change much at the high school level. You wouldn't throw out your lesson plans. I mean circle geometry is circle geometry. You can perhaps work on adding some computer graphics or doing quizzes or doing some hands on demonstrations I suppose. The thing is that children at bad schools don't necessarily need him. If they can hardly answer a question and are badly behaved and he is constantly stressed, he might as well work with bright children in a grammar school who want to learn. My husband is a statistician. He told me about visiting his old maths teacher from 7th form when he got his M Sc. Bright children from better schools can appreciate good teaching too.

One of my husband's relatives was a card carrying communist who was in China prepared to fight on the communist side during the revolution. As a very old man, he told me that he had started out as teacher. He had started teaching in a school in an affluent area and it had been fine. He had then moved to a school in a less affluent area. All his communist sympathies aside, he described the new pupils as completely feral, badly behaved and with no interest whatsoever in learning anything and he promptly left.

.....I think that teaching those who have no interest and are badly behaved is is the most rewarding thing I have ever done.

This is so depressing. No wonder the education system is such a mess.

theworldhas · 12/01/2023 22:48

Look into purchasing a tutoring franchise - or going solo. Given he already has excellent experience and isn’t afraid of hard work/early starts etc he could pull it off and be making six figures in say 5 years. Obviously a significant initial investment would probably be required to get things started.

surreygirl1987 · 12/01/2023 22:47

PS I'm on significantly more than your husband and I'm a Head of department in a private school.

Noodledoodledoo · 12/01/2023 22:47

growinggreyer · 12/01/2023 12:48

He is not an outstanding teacher if he thinks that he can churn out the same lessons every year because 'maths doesn't change'. He is lazy and he knows he won't be able to get away with that in a better school. Stop listening to his flannel. If he quits this job you will not be buying the house you have your eye on.

My thoughts as well. I've been teaching maths 14 years, definitely use some previous lessons but not just as they were.

surreygirl1987 · 12/01/2023 22:46

Maths? He should move into the private school sector. He wouldn't have to take much of a payout to be a standard classroom teacher (my husband is on just under £53k as a private school teacher, no extra responsibilities). Smaller classes, longer holidays, better salary, good behaviour.

newtb · 12/01/2023 22:44

Accountancy?
Pfffft I don't think he'd cut it.
37.5hr week, unpaid overtime because the budget's tight and so there's no money for it.
3 hours a night studying after work
An exam every 2 weeks

Phineyj · 12/01/2023 22:40

I looked at Economics think tanks once (out of curiosity having heard an inspiring speaker) and I was surprised to find they paid a lot less than teaching - and much less holiday etc.

Financial services would pay more of course.

But I agree with the PP who said 5 years to establish yourself doing something new.