Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask if you would pay for GP visits

665 replies

justanotherhappyflunkie · 12/01/2023 11:36

Been talking with various friends who all agree they would rather pay a nominal sum to see a GP rather than the current system.

I have lived in a country that does this (free for children, disabled people, discounts for beneficiaries and long term sickness) and it was great. Same day appointments, good range of doctors, quick referrals.

The UK equivalent of this would be around £20 per visit.

AIBU to suggest it is the system that could help the NHS? prepares for a flaming!

OP posts:
MadeOfSteel · 14/01/2023 23:57

No. It is the start of a slippery slope. Our GPs are our route in to all the other services of the NHS. If we had to pay, even if there was a discount, it would deter many people from going and they'd likely be the ones who need the services most. Ill health is undoubtedly linked to poverty for many.

elliejjtiny · 14/01/2023 23:33

It wouldn't affect me personally as I have only once in the last 18 years seen the gp for something non pregnancy related. And as I'm done with being pregnant I can afford £20 once every 18 years.

but to make it fair, you would have to make it free for people who are entitled to free prescriptions. And offer a pre payment certificate so that people with chronic conditions can pay £200 in advance and get free gp appointments for the rest of the year.

it would work out that only a small minority would be paying for appointments. And those that do would be one of those people like me who only see the gp once every 10-20 years. So the money saved would be minimal.

Desiredeffect · 14/01/2023 23:14

Nope couldn't afford this and wouldn't be fair on my disabled adult dd and I work 2 jobs to try and survive now

monitor1 · 14/01/2023 23:01

lieselotte · 14/01/2023 18:15

But most people don't need to see their GP very often, it just gives you peace of mind if you do. And so there is capacity for those who do need to see their GP every week.

Other than smear tests, and getting a referral to dermatology back in 2017, I can't remember the last time I went to the GP.

Even when you include people like you who never come in the calculations, the average person sees their GP 7 times per year. For which we get funded around £120 per patient.

TizerorFizz · 14/01/2023 18:25

@Havanananana
I agree with you about how other countries fund healthcare but because there are differences, direct comparison of costs, services and success is difficult.We are a country with no funding for health outside the taxation system. So we are different and outcomes are different. That’s clearly why we need revisions.

NI is NOT just for health care. NI Act was 1916. Whilst it had some limited provision for healthcare for industrial workers it was not about setting up the NHS. It still isn’t paying for it. The NHS was set up in 1948. Before that, health care was generally paid for. Your state pension depends on your NI record. See attached from the government.

To ask if you would pay for GP visits
lieselotte · 14/01/2023 18:15

monitor1 · 13/01/2023 14:50

Fascinated to see the service where for £170 you can access unlimited GP visits for a whole family for a month. It would very swiftly go bankrupt. Could you share the website? Presumably you pay extra per visit.

But most people don't need to see their GP very often, it just gives you peace of mind if you do. And so there is capacity for those who do need to see their GP every week.

Other than smear tests, and getting a referral to dermatology back in 2017, I can't remember the last time I went to the GP.

shivawn · 14/01/2023 17:55

@strumpert That's rough. I don't know what your friend does for a living but if they or their partner can get work in a company that offers a health insurance plan then waiting periods for cover on pre-existing health conditions are waived. Just something that's good to know.

Havanananana · 14/01/2023 07:21

TizerorFizz · 13/01/2023 22:56

It’s pointless comparing other EU countries with us. None had the NHS. They do have contributory insurance schemes and more money in the system. We need to generate that extra. So we pay or have insurance. It’s not privatization. It’s an extra income steam.

Why is it pointless comparing the UK with EU countries? Politicians do this all the time, trying to convince the public that the NHS is the envy of the world, when it really isn't.

Why is it not useful to compare the UK's spending on health (far less per capita than other, comparable countries) and the ratios of doctors to patients (far lower in the UK than in some EU countries, many of which have almost twice the number of doctors per capita than the UK has).

Why do Germany, Austria and Denmark have hardly any waiting lists? Why is nobody there waiting 15 hours for an ambulance or 15 months for a hospital appointment?

Most of the EU countries have some for of state/national healthcare service, paid for through various financing models. The compulsory healthcare insurance usually found in one form or another is very similar to the UK National Insurance in that the payment is a percentage of the employees wage, with a similar contribution being made from the employer. The big difference is that the funds are not in the hands of the government and are ringfenced for healthcare.

Excellent healthcare is affordable and available throughout most of Europe. The UK could have this too, but not if the voters keep voting for parties that treat the NHS as a political football, and not if they keep electing a Conservative government that believes that everything has a price, that puts profit over people and that would gladly introduce the American insurance model if it meant profits for their donors and chums.

MensisIanuarius · 14/01/2023 07:12

I had private medical care when I lived in Asia. Whilst it was good at the point of use, it had other problems. The biggest one was the overuse of medication. So, I would go to the doctors for minor things, as was encouraged, and they would throw meds at me;

Sore throat - oh, you need antibiotics.
DC had been offered antibiotics 3 times before he was 2.
Pain in the tummy = 6 weeks of tests for cancer, in the end, a charcoal tablet fixed it.

When everything is private, they start to over treat ailments to maximise profits. I was told by friends to say no to antibiotics unless the illness was quite serious. Funnily enough, where I lived, the locals had a 1st class health service but were some of the sickliest people I ever met because they took meds for everything. They had flu all the time and illnesses that may moderately affect most people but put them in the hospital.

BashfulClam · 13/01/2023 23:50

The fear is thought that I earned too much for any kind of benefits or exemptions but struggled to make ends meet. If I ended up
not seeing a GP just down to cost it could end badly.

Blossomtoes · 13/01/2023 23:47

And how many extra admin staff would that require?

LaurieFairyCake · 13/01/2023 23:39

Well the choice is surely to pay - and then the GP refunds you immediately you TURN UP?

If there are millions of missed appointments that would fix that

Obviously there would have to be a system where if someone was too ill to go and had to go to hospital they also got their money back from the appointment they 'didn't turn up to'

Blossomtoes · 13/01/2023 23:16

Frumpymumma · 13/01/2023 23:11

Id sooner they make it compulsory to pay for missed appointments.

That would be impossible. It would cost more than it saved to pursue the debt.

Frumpymumma · 13/01/2023 23:11

Id sooner they make it compulsory to pay for missed appointments.

strumpert · 13/01/2023 23:09

shivawn · 13/01/2023 19:22

Well I live in Ireland and pay €60 for a GP visit, I'm happy to pay for it. I'm happy to pay it, my GP is amazing and having a good GP is very very important to me. I can always get an appointment on the same day if it's urgent and the next day if it's something small. Health insurance provided through work refunds half the cost and then I can claim back 20% on my taxes so the actual cost to me is €24.

Those on low income, over 70 or under 6 get GP visit cards so they can visit the GP for free. From April, anyone earning under the median household income (46k after tax) will get a GP Visit card - this won't affect my household but I think it's great. It means around half the country gets free GP visits. An awful lot of higher earners in Ireland will have health insurance provided by their employers.

Free GP for all sounds great but my sister in London has to wait a week for a GP appointment. This would be an absolute nightmare for me.

Yeah that's grand but my friend has moved to Ireland from the uk and can't get private health insurance due to pre existing medical conditions.

TizerorFizz · 13/01/2023 22:56

It’s pointless comparing other EU countries with us. None had the NHS. They do have contributory insurance schemes and more money in the system. We need to generate that extra. So we pay or have insurance. It’s not privatization. It’s an extra income steam.

shivawn · 13/01/2023 22:37

@MarshaBradyo That's great and I'm glad that you don't struggle for appointments. Most of my family still lives in the UK and they have a very hard time. I hear from others that there's long waiting times for appointments at their GP's too. It's very stressful for those who can't easily get appointments when they're worried for their health.

@Havanananana As for the poor sods who can't afford to pay, or who live in areas where there are few GPs - well, bad luck.
What I was actually saying is that those on low income (lower than average) shouldn't have to pay, same goes for those with serious health conditions.

GPTec1 · 13/01/2023 21:37

@Havanananana You are course right, i shouldn't believe what i have read elsewhere... Sorry.

Havanananana · 13/01/2023 21:32

@Ski4130 If so many people are missing appointments, why not "over-book" knowing that a percentage won't attend?

This is what hotels, airlines and any other organisation does when there is a finite capacity and a constant and predictable level of "no-shows" in order to make full use of the facilities and resources available.

I've asked the question earlier in the thread. In your experience, what are the reasons why people do not attend? Do they have genuine issues with childcare, transport, getting time off work, mobility etc or is it really as simple as they can't be arsed?

Havanananana · 13/01/2023 21:27

@JackyinaTracky "Yes I get that means less tax revenue to encourage a private health alternative but the savings on tax to get one more person out of nhs surely frees up a bed?"

No it doesn't. There is a finite number of doctors in the UK, and overall a very serious shortage of doctors (and beds, equipment, intensive care wards etc). The UK has one of the lowest ratios of doctors to patients in the developed world - only half as many doctors per capita as in some other European countries.

Every doctor who leaves the NHS and only takes private patients makes the situation worse for those patients (and doctors) left in the NHS system. The Conservatives already did this with dentistry - for many millions of people it is now impossible to find a NHS dentist. If they are allowed to do this with GPs then the whole system will collapse, leaving the poor, the disadvantaged and those living in areas with very low numbers of GPs with nowhere to go. And as you point out, less tax revenue also means less money for essential services such as the NHS, compounding the problem.

Ski4130 · 13/01/2023 20:15

lieselotte · 13/01/2023 14:14

I am not convinced. If people are missing "appointments", it's telephone appointments, which unless they are for a specific time, are not appointments.

Phoning someone at a random time, when they may be working, on the loo, or driving, is not an appointment. If a GP says they'll call you eg between 4 and 4.30 and you're not there, that's a missed appointment, but not a random call.

it’s not telephone appointments - this afternoon alone there were 4 phlebotomy appointments, 2 smear tests and 3 routine GP appointments missed at the surgery I work at. I wasn’t in this morning but I know this afternoon wasn’t in any way unusual. Honestly, it’s soul destroying when you’re having to ask people to call back the next day for an urgent appointment because you’ve got no capacity, whilst someone else hasn’t got the decency to free their appointment up by cancelling it.

People love to moan that they can’t get a GP’s appointment, in the same breath as wasting NHS resources by missing appointments - every missed appointment has a knock on effect.

Should people pay for NHS appointments? No. At least half our patients would struggle to do so. There are private GP’s for people who can afford it.

JackyinaTracky · 13/01/2023 20:01

I would now. But that’s only because I’m lucky enough to be able to afford to. In fact I get private gp via work it wouldn’t cost me anything.
but… it’s not that long ago that I was so skint (and not on benefits, just mortgage, bills and food) that £20 for an appointment might as well have been £20 million. I didn’t have it. Food was going on my credit card and I was living on toast. We both work but if one of us loses a job we’ll be back there pretty quick.
I think people who qualify for no benefits but live pound to pound would end up excluded from basic health care. I know in my skint days I would only have gone if I had to, I wouldnt have gone for a weird bump, or a flutter in my chest, or any other odd symptom but those are things that get us in the end.
just tax people more. I don’t mean everyone, but people who really can afford it (and I include myself in that). And make private health care tax deductible. Yes I get that means less tax revenue to encourage a private health alternative but the savings on tax to get one more person out of nhs surely frees up a bed?

Havanananana · 13/01/2023 20:00

@GPTec1 "almost all EU countries charge and not for just GPs either"

This is not true. For example:

Spain - visits and general check-ups are free.
Denmark - free
Germany - free
Austria - free
Netherlands - free (some patients might be charged but claim back from mandatory health insurance)

The rest can be looked up. There are many different forms of financing primary care. Many are free at the point of contact, paid for through taxation or mandatory health insurance administered by Mutual insurers, so in effect another form of tax. Those that require payment usually have an upper limit - e.g Sweden has a maximum charge of about £75 a year for unlimited GP visits.

Havanananana · 13/01/2023 19:39

@shivawn "An awful lot of higher earners in Ireland will have health insurance provided by their employers."

Is this commercial insurance, where the profits go to the shareholders, or through Mutual Insurance Funds which are for the benefit of the patients (e.g. as in Germany and many other EU countries)?

The NHS budget in England alone is £152 billion. Private providers would love to get their hands on this - if they can turn a profit of even 10% they'll be very happy. Convincing millions of people to pay £20, £30, £50 for a GP appointment as well is a capitalist's wet dream - and the reason why they lobby MPs and are happy to see the NHS run down so that they can reap the benefits.

As for the poor sods who can't afford to pay, or who live in areas where there are few GPs - well, bad luck. Look at what has happened to NHS dentistry and pray that Hunt, Barclay and Sunak, who only value "money and profits" rather than "patients and people," are prevented from letting general healthcare provision from going the same way.

GPTec1 · 13/01/2023 19:37

No issue with paying for GP appointments, we pay for dentist and eye appointments.

This alone would make sure people turned up, almost all EU countries charge and not for just GPs either, almost all medical appointments.

Exemptions for pregnancy, low paid, those with long term conditions & children.

Swipe left for the next trending thread