Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask if you would pay for GP visits

665 replies

justanotherhappyflunkie · 12/01/2023 11:36

Been talking with various friends who all agree they would rather pay a nominal sum to see a GP rather than the current system.

I have lived in a country that does this (free for children, disabled people, discounts for beneficiaries and long term sickness) and it was great. Same day appointments, good range of doctors, quick referrals.

The UK equivalent of this would be around £20 per visit.

AIBU to suggest it is the system that could help the NHS? prepares for a flaming!

OP posts:
babsanderson · 12/01/2023 12:15

And it would make things worse as those who paid £20 would not be happy to have a 3 minute GP appointment, many would demand "their monies worth".

wonkylegs · 12/01/2023 12:15

@catmothertes1
There was an interesting piece on the news last night talking about the French system and saying it's generally good in urban areas however some parts of rural /poorer regions of France are really struggling to recruit GPs and the system doesn't work there even if you can pay because they are also having retention issues. There was an example of a region that had no drs and the waiting list for GP appointments was 4yrs. So I don't think it's completely a bed of roses there either.

MensisIanuarius · 12/01/2023 12:13

I already pay for the GP. It’s called NI, Income and VAT.

SpideyCraw · 12/01/2023 12:12

I would pay if required but I have a problem with the principle of this.

firstly whatever exemptions you put in to ensure people aren’t priced out, people will fall through the gaps, plus it is discriminatory against people with health problems who are more likely to need appointments.

moreover, while it would hopefully reduce missed appointments, it would address the fundamental issue that there are not enough GPs anymore. You would still be trying to shoehorn 100,000 appointments day into 80,000 slots* so the only way it would ease the burden is by people who can’t or don’t want to pay £20 not seeking appointments. That would not be a good thing.

*made up figures for illustration

The government needs to urgently train more doctors and try to retain those that currently are skilled enough to do the job. One way would be get rid of this ridiculous pensions tax which means it isn’t economically viable for a number of GPs to continue to work.

babsanderson · 12/01/2023 12:11

And no way would my dad have gone to the GP when he suspected he had bowel cancer. Do you know how hard it was to get him to go in the first place?

SilverHydrangea · 12/01/2023 12:11

YABU. So we move to a 2 tier system for accessing GP services and people just above the threshold for free service get priced out!

Soothsayer1 · 12/01/2023 12:11

My concern is that if charges were introduced in the UK, primary care would go the same way as dental care
Indeed if you can afford 2k you can have a root canal, if not it's 100 quid on the NHS to pull your tooth out, can't afford 100 quid go down to b&q and buy a pair of pliers.
What would that translate to? If you can afford £2,000 we will treat your foot if not give us 100 quid and we'll amputate haven't got 100 quid go down to b&q and buy a saw than a big bottle of whisky in Tesco, maybe get some strong ropes to tie you to the kitchen table whilst other family members perform the amputation?

justanotherhappyflunkie · 12/01/2023 12:10

levellingleveller · 12/01/2023 12:03

No because it literally never works that way. Low income is always defined by benefit entitlement, unless you are saying people are asked to bring in three months worth of payslips for all earners in the family?

There already are private GP services. Off you go and pay for them if you want them.

Because what you are proposing now means you still get access GPS on what is ‘on the cheap’ for you, but is made prohibitively expensive for others.

The people entitled to the free/discounted appointments applied for a card. They would have had to prove income yes. Please don't personally attack me, I just wanted a debate and see other peoples opinions.

OP posts:
wonkylegs · 12/01/2023 12:10

@justanotherhappyflunkie It's A solution but not one that doesn't come without it's own problems.
A few issues

  • our system isn't regularly set up for taking payments so there would be administrative costs involved in taking payments
  • won't stop everyone from wasting or missing appointments as the payment isn't enough to worry them
  • will disincentivise lots of people who need help from getting it
  • will penalise people who have long term /chronic conditions
  • who decides who can and can't afford it
How long and when does the definition long term' cut in? I have a chronic disabling condition but I don't claim any benefits- do I qualify? My condition took 6mths to diagnose (I was lucky many people take years) I have to have regular appointments to monitor my condition otherwise my drugs cannot be prescribed (too dangerous) - do I pay for these and if so when from? These visits generally manage my condition and have meant that I avoid costly surgery so are generally a cost saving exercise for the nhs. Disincentivising people like me from taking up regular appointments would end up costing more not only in NHS costs but PIP
  • what about flawed appointment systems - my mum has dementia, initially her GP would text her appointment details (not anyone else as they can't) and funnily enough the woman with memory problems would forget them. We finally realised and managed a work around. Problems with dementia patients both pre and post diagnosis is a huge issue and dementia is a huge problem that's getting bigger.
  • what about people in vulnerable domestic situations who are not in control of their own finances?
catmothertes1 · 12/01/2023 12:10

justanotherhappyflunkie · 12/01/2023 11:36

Been talking with various friends who all agree they would rather pay a nominal sum to see a GP rather than the current system.

I have lived in a country that does this (free for children, disabled people, discounts for beneficiaries and long term sickness) and it was great. Same day appointments, good range of doctors, quick referrals.

The UK equivalent of this would be around £20 per visit.

AIBU to suggest it is the system that could help the NHS? prepares for a flaming!

I'd pay £20 a visit if the system was like France!

HashtagShitShop · 12/01/2023 12:10

With the doctor that is at our practice most of the week, no. That man is a sadist and shrugs his shoulders and refuses to help (disabling back pain for a carer because "they won't change their life" (ie stop being a carer) or prescribe medication for a discharging ear infection that caused the hospital consultant to ring the surgery up and give him an ear bashing (pun not intended) as the frequency and the fact it wasn't clearing up (in part because the rare times he DID prescribe it wasnt a strong enough or long enough course) as it was a meningitis risk.

For the doctor who is there once a week, absolutely. He's booked out with people who wait to see him because of how useless the other is. He's the exact opposite and a lovely bloke. He and the other staff including nurses, hca and admin staff etc are the reason we stay because they are absolute stars.

babsanderson · 12/01/2023 12:10

And forget about any check ups. No way am I paying £20 for a smear test or my blood tests I have because of the medication I take. I will take my chances.

BluIsTheColour · 12/01/2023 12:09

No I don't want to pay £20 to see the gp. I cld afford to but I'd more likely not bother unless I was really worried about something or very ill. I'm sure lots of folk wld think the same. Plus I think I already pay enough in tax without having to fund a gp appointment.

I can only imagine folk on low incomes wld end up very unwell or worse!

Bestcatmum · 12/01/2023 12:09

I recently had a four month bout of severe illness with chronic condition I have. I managed to stagger into work in horrific pain, taking huge amounts of pain killers and disnt manage to see a GP in all that time. The flare up eventually subsided and went away on its own. I dont have the kind of job where you can just take time off. We see seriously ill patients and we dont have any staff. Im terrified of that happening again. Even if you do manage to see a GP they don't bother looking at your notes or history and just fob you off to physio which is useless. My condition needs to be properly managed. At one point I was taking 8 neurofen plus just to be able to get out of bed (ibuprofen and codeine). Thank God I'm just a few years off retirement.

babsanderson · 12/01/2023 12:08

And what happens if someone turns up at a GP surgery and says they can't pay but do need to be seen? Does the GP just send them to A and E?

JennyForeigner · 12/01/2023 12:07

I tried to yesterday. Our 3 year old son has an infected finger which had become urgent. Despite us actually being in the GP surgery for a vaccination on Tuesday and the nurse asking reception to arrange an antibiotic, they refused. And then went MIA for all appts.

I tried for hours to find a private GP service yesterday at up to £60. None would see a child and we had to go to minor injuries.

They were great in end but with GP surgeries apparently no longer willing to make exceptions for tiny children, we basically feel we now have no choice but to sign up for private healthcare at work at an annual cost of £1500.

So well done Rishi Sunak, I guess. You got what you wanted.

justanotherhappyflunkie · 12/01/2023 12:06

YukoandHiro · 12/01/2023 12:03

If you're not even registered how do you know how long it takes to get an appt?

Mine always gives same day for something urgent or for my kids, within 10 days for non urgent.

If you're not registered, do you already go private?

My partner is registered there. I would go private if I had to.

I don't know where I stand on the idea, hate to think of the NHS being privatised but can also see peoples frustrations with current services.

OP posts:
babsanderson · 12/01/2023 12:06

I can get seen on the day by my GP. If charging came in I would just go to A and E. I do not go to the GP for minor things though.

MilkyYay · 12/01/2023 12:06

I would because i can afford it, but what about the people who can't?

My grandparents worked their lives on low pay, in an era when they hadnt had access to the education to do better. They retired with savings and were terrific budgeters but lived extremely carefully on a very low income. If they had had to pay a charge for GP visits it would have left them without enough money for food or heating. They would have simply not gone, and my grandmother would have lived in horrendous pain from her rheumatoid arthritis.

inappropriateraspberry · 12/01/2023 12:05

I think it's a good idea for one offs like a chest infection, earache etc - would discourage a lot of time wasters and unnecessary appointments.
For longer term illnesses and conditions, pregnancy etc then it should be free after initial consultation.

Danikm151 · 12/01/2023 12:05

I think this would work if it was the cost of a prescription- if you don’t pay for prescriptions you don’t pay for the dr.
so essentially you’d prepay for your prescription and see the dr to get it. Would wittle out the no shows

Badbadbunny · 12/01/2023 12:04

How does having exemptions for the low paid, elderly, disabled etc (which would be essential), help avoid the no shows etc?

I'd want to see statistics showing exactly what groups of people are those who are more likely to miss/waste appointments. I suspect it will generally be the same people who'd be exempt under the charging proposals. So, it'd end up yet another tax on the "squeezed middle" and workers who probably aren't the ones using GP services that much anyway!

YukoandHiro · 12/01/2023 12:03

If you're not even registered how do you know how long it takes to get an appt?

Mine always gives same day for something urgent or for my kids, within 10 days for non urgent.

If you're not registered, do you already go private?

levellingleveller · 12/01/2023 12:03

justanotherhappyflunkie · 12/01/2023 11:51

I believe under the comparision I did all low income families would be free and always children are free.

No because it literally never works that way. Low income is always defined by benefit entitlement, unless you are saying people are asked to bring in three months worth of payslips for all earners in the family?

There already are private GP services. Off you go and pay for them if you want them.

Because what you are proposing now means you still get access GPS on what is ‘on the cheap’ for you, but is made prohibitively expensive for others.

pjani · 12/01/2023 12:03

This is why the health service has been chronically unfunded since 2010. When it stops working the whole principle comes into question.

When I had to pay for GP appointments (in another country) I would save up all my ailments or wait till something was really bad. (I’ve got a weird lump, can I also have a Pap smear and a new prescription for the pill?). The money does matter!

The NHS is one of the greatest things in this country - let’s just find it properly!