Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask if you would pay for GP visits

665 replies

justanotherhappyflunkie · 12/01/2023 11:36

Been talking with various friends who all agree they would rather pay a nominal sum to see a GP rather than the current system.

I have lived in a country that does this (free for children, disabled people, discounts for beneficiaries and long term sickness) and it was great. Same day appointments, good range of doctors, quick referrals.

The UK equivalent of this would be around £20 per visit.

AIBU to suggest it is the system that could help the NHS? prepares for a flaming!

OP posts:
RedRiverShore3 · 12/01/2023 12:55

I would pay, I would also pay for an ambulance service

People that have to visit the GP a lot for certain conditions should get a cut price yearly pass so they were not really out of pocket.

babsanderson · 12/01/2023 12:55

@Girasoli students do not get prescriptions free unless on a very low income.

justanotherhappyflunkie · 12/01/2023 12:55

CarlaH · 12/01/2023 12:48

This works perfectly well in other countries. What makes us different.

I have to agree. Its not perfect anywhere.

The NHS is a laughing stock amongst most people where I used to live. Not the staff or their dedication but the idea that we've never payed for healthcare and its never going to change. Despite the world changing almost unrecognisably since it was first created.

OP posts:
Girasoli · 12/01/2023 12:54

And pregnant women/post partum women, forgot them!

SnackSizeRaisin · 12/01/2023 12:54

roarfeckingroarr · 12/01/2023 12:33

If part of the deal was paying less in tax.

I'm firmly in the squeezed middle. I earn enough to be in the 40% bracket and not get a penny in terms of child benefit or government support, but live in London and have a toddler in childcare that costs me £1600 per month for 4 days pw. I can't bloody afford more outgoings.

If you're earning £50,000 you're hardly in the middle. You're in the top 10% of earners. It's your outgoings that are the problem

£1600 a month for childcare is ridiculous. For a start there should be subsidised childcare for all. Housing cost inflation is another huge problem creating inequality and social problems

babsanderson · 12/01/2023 12:54

Flossflower · 12/01/2023 12:47

There is a major problem with charging. People who can easily afford it would be more inclined to visit. We have a shortage of GPs. We can’t magic any more.

I agree that people paying would go more.
Someone has already commented saying they would like as they currently use a private GP as the appointment gives lots of time and she is not quickly rushed out as she is by an NHS GP.
NHS GP appointments are usually very short. They are not there to provide endless reassurance, just treat you and get you out. Those paying would demand more so GPs would be as busy as ever, and poor people with health issues would not get GP care.

Girasoli · 12/01/2023 12:53

I think if it remained free for children/students/people on benefits/the elderly (like prescription charges) I'd be happy to pay £20 per GP visits.

onetwobucklemyshoes · 12/01/2023 12:53

CarlaH · 12/01/2023 12:48

This works perfectly well in other countries. What makes us different.

Because that is how their system has been set up and funded. It's not how our system works. Our healthcare service is underfunded and demand outstrips supply. If tomorrow a select group (likely excluding those over 65s, chronic illness, those with certain disabilities, pregnant women, those under 18s, full-time students, those in receipt of certain benefits etc.) started paying a small fee to see their GP the money raised would be an absolute drop in the ocean and likely wiped out by means-testing admin fees anyway (and then wiped out again by the increasing costs of delayed presentations). A lot of appointments would be needed to fund more GPs.

Pottyaboutplants · 12/01/2023 12:52

I forgot also to mention that some GP’s have a policy of not accepting non fee paying patients during their busy times. Eg Early morning appts are reserved for people who pay. The thought process is that people have to commute to work while non fee paying/public patients don’t work and can attend during the day.

Buses do the same eg pensioners cannot use the bus for free until after 9am etc

babsanderson · 12/01/2023 12:51

@CarlaH Someone in another country has posted about how it does not work in their country and lots of poor people do not get anything except emergency medical care.

Bluekerfuffle · 12/01/2023 12:50

SnackSizeRaisin · 12/01/2023 12:41

GP appointments cost about £80. Half hour home visit 3x80 plus transport plus possibly an assistant depending on the area and safety.

Think how much a private vet costs. Then consider that GP pay is at least 3x that of a vet. Plus there is much less chance to cut corners in human medicine so overheads are higher.

Yes, but private vets here charge outlandish prices compared with some other countries.

CarlaH · 12/01/2023 12:48

This works perfectly well in other countries. What makes us different.

ellyo · 12/01/2023 12:47

This is such a bad idea.

It would force people to make their own decisions about symptoms - are they worried enough for it to be 'worth' potentially wasting £20, or however much it would be? Therefore the more £20s you have to potentially waste or lose, the more likely you are to have good health outcomes. And the fewer £20s you have, and the greater the needs you have to spread that money around (heating, eating, kids school shoes etc) the less likely you are to access healthcare, therefore the more likely you are to experience long-term poor health or death.

This is such an obvious outcome

Flossflower · 12/01/2023 12:47

There is a major problem with charging. People who can easily afford it would be more inclined to visit. We have a shortage of GPs. We can’t magic any more.

babsanderson · 12/01/2023 12:46

Herja · 12/01/2023 12:44

I'd not pay. I only go to the dentist when I have a fee exemption; I'd treat this the same.

Actually, my mental health issues and background cause me great difficulties with self care. I see the GP once every 5 years or so anyway. This would be the permanent perfect excuse! 'Ah, better not ... Might need that £20 for the kids this weekend...'. It would just mean even when I am really ill (last time was a 4 month chest infection I have not fully recovered from 2 months later), I'd definitely still not go.

I would go as I have a health issue, but I would go to A and E instead and wait to be seen.

Pottyaboutplants · 12/01/2023 12:45

I should add that creating a two tier health system does not equate to better public healthcare.

People are waiting on trollies in corridors for days in hospitals here. Considering I don’t know one person who doesn’t have private health insurance, what would it be like if everybody went public?

The issue is there aren’t enough staff.

ReedRite · 12/01/2023 12:45

babsanderson · 12/01/2023 12:42

I agree totally.
The most cost effective way to provide healthcare is to make first line care free and easy to access. You want to treat that chest infection before it gets bad, detect that cancer while it is easily treatable, diagnose that type 2 diabetes before it causes damage to the eyes and organs, etc.
Effectively encouraging people to delay seeking medical treatment until their condition is far worse makes zero sense on any level.

Absolutely this.

But it seems nobody in government or the NHS is ever capable of taking an overview of all costs and looking to save money overall by investing a little more at the front end.

They’d rather, it seems, pay a fiver down the line than a pound upfront now.

Madness.

babsanderson · 12/01/2023 12:45

I get seen the same day by my GP and get antibiotics that day.
It is not paying that makes the difference.

There is a shortage of GPs in many areas of the country. The reason introducing paying might make it easier for you to see a GP is because all those poor people can't afford to see a GP. It is basic rationing through cost and not medical need.

ThreeFeetTall · 12/01/2023 12:44

Hmmm. I think there should be some sort of penalty for a missed appointment, although why the GP can't see the next person in line I am not sure.

When I give things away on free cycle you get a lot of time wasters/no shows. Sell it for 99p on eBay and nearly always the person turns up, why?

Herja · 12/01/2023 12:44

I'd not pay. I only go to the dentist when I have a fee exemption; I'd treat this the same.

Actually, my mental health issues and background cause me great difficulties with self care. I see the GP once every 5 years or so anyway. This would be the permanent perfect excuse! 'Ah, better not ... Might need that £20 for the kids this weekend...'. It would just mean even when I am really ill (last time was a 4 month chest infection I have not fully recovered from 2 months later), I'd definitely still not go.

KTheGrey · 12/01/2023 12:44

@babsanderson yes, and paying direct - preferably with a real National Insurance scheme, run by insurers - would mean the money would go to the NHS. I don't think it would sort the NHS out today. But I think I pay a couple of hundred a year on doctor's appointments and I can live with that because the service is good.

Bluekerfuffle · 12/01/2023 12:42

I would be ok with that if they were a bit more attentive and helpful when you saw them. Right now, I find them such a pain in the arse to get an appointment in the first place and then pretty useless a lot of the time, so when it’s something for my son or that I think is more urgent I fork out for private, which is very expensive and we are not that well off, but at least they show more interest and do a better job as they don’t have so many people to squeeze in.

SnackSizeRaisin · 12/01/2023 12:42

Whynowwhynow · 12/01/2023 12:39

It’s already happening in the UK.

My GP surgery have sent letters out saying you will now have to pay £25 for a GP appointment.

Really? Can you post a picture of the letter? I don't believe you

MrsR87 · 12/01/2023 12:42

Yes. I have also lived in a country where you pay around €20 for an appointment and then get much of that pack in your next pay packet. People with disabilities/children etc were different. It worked very well. I remember even then (2009) feeling so unwell and dreading calling the docs as I expected to be fobbed off but instead I called, got straight through and had an appointment within 2 hours. I had the tests I needed the same afternoon and antibiotics by the evening! AMAZING!

Many people won’t like the idea but we have to be honest and frank that the current system is beyond broken and anything other than a complete rethink is not going to do anything other than delay the absolute collapse of the system.

babsanderson · 12/01/2023 12:42

onetwobucklemyshoes · 12/01/2023 12:38

Also, if people delay a GP appointment and hence present more unwell to secondary care that will quickly wipe out the (minimal) money put into the system. How many £20 GP appointments cover admission for IV antibiotics for pneumonia or a crisis mental health admission for deteriorating depression? What about conditions that could have been easily treated but have now deteriorated and involve more expensive, more complex treatments or cancers that are discovered much later? We should absolutely champion and demand properly funded primary care for all. A £20 sticking plaster is no solution.

I agree totally.
The most cost effective way to provide healthcare is to make first line care free and easy to access. You want to treat that chest infection before it gets bad, detect that cancer while it is easily treatable, diagnose that type 2 diabetes before it causes damage to the eyes and organs, etc.
Effectively encouraging people to delay seeking medical treatment until their condition is far worse makes zero sense on any level.

Swipe left for the next trending thread