Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask if you would pay for GP visits

665 replies

justanotherhappyflunkie · 12/01/2023 11:36

Been talking with various friends who all agree they would rather pay a nominal sum to see a GP rather than the current system.

I have lived in a country that does this (free for children, disabled people, discounts for beneficiaries and long term sickness) and it was great. Same day appointments, good range of doctors, quick referrals.

The UK equivalent of this would be around £20 per visit.

AIBU to suggest it is the system that could help the NHS? prepares for a flaming!

OP posts:
LastOfTheChristmasWine · 25/01/2023 08:40

justanotherhappyflunkie · 12/01/2023 11:44

Under the scheme in the country I lived in, all low income, beneficiaries and long term ill/ disabled people were either seen free of charge or heavily discounted. It's not my proposal! Just an experience I have had which some people I spoke to agreed they would be keen to see it implemented here.

I think the idea (however flawed) would be to make it easier for those who really need the system rather than it being blocked by missed appointments or those who could wait to see if their cold/flu passes without the need for a GP.

If we did it on the same basis as free prescription eligibility then the vast majority of appointments would be free anyway, because those categories of people (including children and the elderly) are the most likely to need an appointment/prescription

I believe 90% of prescriptions in England are free.

Don't underestimate the administrative cost of means testing either.

WigglyGlowWorm · 25/01/2023 08:36

You can tell the people who aren’t reading the OP as she’s already said low income people would be exempt from the £20 🙄

TizerorFizz · 25/01/2023 08:32

Only if you are very young. But you still have a much better pension than many others paid for partially by the state. And early retirement that many take. And lots of opportunities for part time working. And a top salary of £90,000 to aim for. Lots to look forward to!

RumandSpinach · 25/01/2023 08:14

gogohmm · 24/01/2023 14:38

I don't see why i should pay yet my wealthy parents be exempt! It already annoys me they (on 3x my income) get free prescriptions, winter fuel allowance etc whereas my student DD's have to pay! (I'm not on regular medication thankfully)

Quite, especially with the retirement age inching up.

I'm going to be a nurse until 68 now, apparently. Wish me luck.

RumandSpinach · 25/01/2023 08:11

Why and how would this improve the service?

I can't help but feel its main function is to:

A) Dissuade people from presenting to primary care. This will not save the NHS as a whole money, it will lead to more hospital admissions which is the most expensive intervention

B) Start eroding the NHS being free at the point of use

Please, if you're happy to pay for convenience you can already pay £40 for an online consultation or £90 face to face. Don't push for widespread change that is going to make swathes of people poorer and sicker.

Believeitornot · 25/01/2023 07:58

knitnerd90 · 25/01/2023 01:54

Because that's not how the system works. There is a finite supply of doctors, and the UK does not have enough; it has fewer doctors per capita than other European countries. The private sector exists in part by siphoning off resources (primarily doctors) from the NHS sector. For example many consultants work 2-3 days NHS and the rest private. If the private sector did not exist they would have to work 5 days NHS in order to maintain a full time job. (Of course, things are a bit more complicated than this: the NHS is able to pay less because the top consultants can make money privately, lack of private work would discourage some doctors, etc.)

Private care is lower volume: the doctors typically see fewer patients per day. So when doctors switch to working privately, the total number of patients seen will drop. If we incentivise further private healthcare, the number of patients seen may drop, not rise, unless (big if) offering private opportunities encourages GPs who have left medicine to return to work.

Changing the payer does not mean more care is available to provide. This is also partly why investment in the NHS takes years to show fruit: you can fix physical plant relatively simply, but increasing the number of people who actually do the work takes a long time. It takes over a decade to train a doctor, and the number that can be trained at any time is limited by existing hospital training capacity.

This.

Whenever people suggest private healthcare they don’t employ logic. More often than not it’s just cover for them to justify wanting better healthcare for themselves and their family. Screw everyone else.

Rummikub · 25/01/2023 02:22

Well said

knitnerd90 · 25/01/2023 01:54

TizerorFizz · 24/01/2023 12:04

It’s already there! There would be care for NHS patients. Why not remove richer people from the clogged system?

Because that's not how the system works. There is a finite supply of doctors, and the UK does not have enough; it has fewer doctors per capita than other European countries. The private sector exists in part by siphoning off resources (primarily doctors) from the NHS sector. For example many consultants work 2-3 days NHS and the rest private. If the private sector did not exist they would have to work 5 days NHS in order to maintain a full time job. (Of course, things are a bit more complicated than this: the NHS is able to pay less because the top consultants can make money privately, lack of private work would discourage some doctors, etc.)

Private care is lower volume: the doctors typically see fewer patients per day. So when doctors switch to working privately, the total number of patients seen will drop. If we incentivise further private healthcare, the number of patients seen may drop, not rise, unless (big if) offering private opportunities encourages GPs who have left medicine to return to work.

Changing the payer does not mean more care is available to provide. This is also partly why investment in the NHS takes years to show fruit: you can fix physical plant relatively simply, but increasing the number of people who actually do the work takes a long time. It takes over a decade to train a doctor, and the number that can be trained at any time is limited by existing hospital training capacity.

TizerorFizz · 24/01/2023 17:33

No government has reversed the OAP benefit stream. I’m an OAP. I have rental and unearned income. I, and DH, should pay NI. Or at least at a reduced rate. We are very healthy right now but we should all pay. Votes are, in effect, bought by all governments by over generosity to the elderly. They (we!) need to understand we didn’t save via NI. It’s a tax. We are not entitled to anything when others worse off than us are paying. Having said that: higher rate tax payers pay more than all standard rate tax payers added together. So we need higher rate tax payers and it should not matter where they get their money from as long as it’s legal!

gogohmm · 24/01/2023 14:38

I don't see why i should pay yet my wealthy parents be exempt! It already annoys me they (on 3x my income) get free prescriptions, winter fuel allowance etc whereas my student DD's have to pay! (I'm not on regular medication thankfully)

Badbadbunny · 24/01/2023 14:27

Pleasepleasepleaseno · 24/01/2023 13:45

NI is a nonsense in my opinion. I don't understand why they don't just get rid and add it onto income tax.

No doubt they're scared of the potential loss of votes from those who'd be hit, i.e. pensioners and those living off investment income, such as landlords, etc.

But, you're right, NIC is an absolute nonsense and is just like other indirect taxes being raised to increase tax revenue whilst trying the maintain the illusion of us being a "low tax" country due to not rising the income tax rates.

It's an absolute travesty that it's just a tax on workers and that a worker earning say £30k pays more "tax" than a pensioner or landlord with an income of £30k.

If anything workers should pay less, nor more, as they're actually contributing to the economy and work needs to be incentivised not punished.

Showdogworkingdog · 24/01/2023 14:10

levellingleveller · 12/01/2023 11:41

No. This is an absolute disgrace. It’s a clear disincentive for low income people to seek medical help.
it also disadvantages those with chronic ill health / disabilities who need more GP appts and are also more likely to be on low incomes.

Honestly, when there is so much in the news about people needing to use food banks and the working poor, how anyone can propose this disgusts me.

it’s hard to imagine a proposal which will more clearly improve things for the wealthy at the cost of the poor and disadvantaged.

Absolutely this. Plus of course with this lot, even if £20 doesn’t sound too scary right now, it wouldn’t be long before that £20 became £30, £40 or more.

Services have been starved of funding for years; one major issue is that we’ve made it really expensive for nurses to qualify by removing training bursaries for what is already a poorly paid job with awful working conditions and made it harder for qualified medical professionals from Europe to live and work here so we’re all paying agencies ridiculous rates for temporary staff to cover the huge labour shortages. Charging to use the service wouldn’t help that but it would dissuade everyone on a low income to seek medical help. And don’t get me started on the administrative costs of running a pay for access scheme like that…

Pleasepleasepleaseno · 24/01/2023 13:45

NI is a nonsense in my opinion. I don't understand why they don't just get rid and add it onto income tax.

TizerorFizz · 24/01/2023 12:07

Also, as in education, the better off would pay twice. NI should be paid by all taxed individuals. Not just those in employment. NI does not solely pay for the NHS. We have a complex system of taxation and expenditure. We need to spend what we have wisely as so many people are not working at all snd this number is increasing. Too many not in the workforce at all but still using services.

TizerorFizz · 24/01/2023 12:04

It’s already there! There would be care for NHS patients. Why not remove richer people from the clogged system?

Rummikub · 24/01/2023 08:48

Id prefer to not see a two tier system enforced by the introduction of payment to see a GP.

There’s already too many inequalities access to health care shouldn’t be one.

TizerorFizz · 24/01/2023 08:13

There’s nothing wrong with two levels of care. What happens is that dentists cannot get enough money on NHS contracts so they walk away. Just like NHS staff working for private health companies . The consultants do it and so do the nurses. It’s already 2 tier but the vast majority on the lower tier get a raw deal for basic services.

However far too many people try and see a doctor and don’t manage their own health.

If people can pay they should not clog up waiting rooms for NHS GPS. The private health offered is far more efficient. So as long as GP services are good for the majority, what others do is irrelevant. If payments need to be made by the majority, so be it. this is needed to improve the service for others.

AttentionAll · 23/01/2023 22:29

Agreed. They destroyed NHS dentistry, so now want to destroy NHS healthcare.

clementinejuiceforxmas · 23/01/2023 22:08

Marvellous - two tier GP system to match the two tier dentist system. That worked well

SpringtimeCherries · 23/01/2023 22:01

In Ireland you pay around 50 pounds for a GP appointment, unless you are on lower incomes/disability and then it’s all free. My relatives can usually get same day appointments, but not in all places. Around 50% have private healthcare (and even then will still pay 50 usually to see a local GP but could then be referred privately if needed an operation).

A&E departments are very busy like in the UK, and you have to pay to attend A & E, doctors are overwhelmed in a lot of places like here. It hits the ‘lower / middle’ incomes in Ireland more as they do not have free services, but have to pay. There are also shortages and wait lists for some areas.

So on one level it works, in another it’s still overwhelmed, even with half the population basically paying for their operations. So whilst the NHS is breaking, I think there are many factors and all have to be addressed, not just a quick fix politically.

AttentionAll · 23/01/2023 21:52

@crookedhoosie Tough luck. The conservatives do not care about poor people.

Rummikub · 23/01/2023 21:45

Would not ^

Rummikub · 23/01/2023 21:44

I imagine a lot of people would t go to the GP. It could cost the NHS more if people delay treatment.

crookedhoosie · 23/01/2023 20:08

FarmGirl78 · 23/01/2023 16:37

Slight variation on your idea.

You pay £20 when booking your appt and if you turn up you get given the £20 back.

If its something you could have got sorted at the Pharmacist or by buying lemsips in B&M you only get £5 back.

That would cut down on so many wasted trivial appointments.

What if you don't have the £20 in the first place?

SweetPetrichor · 23/01/2023 20:02

Happily, as long as everyone has to pay - albeit a very nominal fee for those on low income. I think even a nominal fee would encourage people to consider whether they need the appointment or whether this is the correct service to use - for example, maybe they’d be just as well going to ask a pharmacist.