Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask if you would pay for GP visits

665 replies

justanotherhappyflunkie · 12/01/2023 11:36

Been talking with various friends who all agree they would rather pay a nominal sum to see a GP rather than the current system.

I have lived in a country that does this (free for children, disabled people, discounts for beneficiaries and long term sickness) and it was great. Same day appointments, good range of doctors, quick referrals.

The UK equivalent of this would be around £20 per visit.

AIBU to suggest it is the system that could help the NHS? prepares for a flaming!

OP posts:
GreenTomato67 · 12/01/2023 14:53

Havanananana · 12/01/2023 14:42

"To those saying NHS is underfunded. You are wrong."

Compared with many other countries, the NHS is grossly underfunded.

UK per capita spending on healthcare (2021) was $5,387
Germany $7,383 = 37% more
Austria $6,693 = 24% more
Sweden $6,262 = 16% more
France $6,115 = 13% more
Denmark $6,382 = 18% more

The Conservative's argument that taxes have to be kept low (the UK is already a low-tax country) otherwise the country will suffer from decline and poverty is nonsense. These are some of the countries with the highest standards of living and the highest quality of life - with wealth far more equally distributed than in the UK. One measure of quality of life is the reassurance that good, affordable healthcare is available as and when it is needed - surely something that the 5th/6th/7th wealthiest country on the planet should be able to offer its citizens.

The underfunding is not just a one-year snapshot - the NHS has been underfunded for the last 12 years or more, with the result that staff are leaving (or not joining in the first place), many facilities and buildings are not fit for 2023 and there is still much equipment in the NHS that should have been scrapped years ago but cannot be replaced as there are no funds available. If the government underfunds by, say, 10% a year, then at the end of 10 years, the NHS is missing a whole year's worth of budget.

I live in one of the countries above. I can see a GP at any time just by walking in. I can see a Consultant within 2-4 weeks. When I recently needed minor surgery, the time from seeing the GP to actually having the surgery was about a month. There are no backlogs (and were hardly any during the pandemic). Ambulances arrive within minutes. There are almost twice as many doctors per capita as in the UK, and more hospital beds, intensive care beds etc. per capita.

As for the inefficiency argument - much of the inefficiency in the NHS is due to outdated equipment and facilities, including IT, and a service that is so overwhelmed trying to keep the ship afloat that there is no time to actually look at how to improve. Instead of looking at new ways of working or improving, doctors, nurses and administrators are tied up explaining to patients that they cannot be seen for another 6 months, or that their vital operation has yet again been cancelled. Demoralising for the NHS staff - stressful, and sometimes fatal for the unfortunate patient.

Great Post, so we'll said. We could have a much better service but it's a political choice to underfund the service and to privatise it bit by bit.

People should look into the links between the Conservatives and US Health and disability insurance companies going right back to the early 90s. The current state of the NHS is a deliberate choice by them.

Fordian · 12/01/2023 14:53

Pleasepleasepleaseno · 12/01/2023 12:02

Also.i don't think.everyone over 60 should get their prescriptions free tbh. Loads of 60+ are still working. Obviously if you're on pension credit it should be free like it should be if you get universal credit but I think it would save quite a bit.

I agree. DH and are over 60 (just 😂) but we earn £100k pa (pre tax). We can afford £9.80 or whatever it is.

Sartre · 12/01/2023 14:49

May be surprising to some people but not everyone has £20 to spend on a GP appointment. I know people who don’t qualify for free dentistry but can’t afford the fees to go so just have broken, fucked teeth that cause them endless pain. It would be the same if we started charging for a GP consultation, people would avoid going and this would subsequently cost the NHS more because they’d either end up in A&E or serious illnesses would get worse and they’d clog up the hospital that way.

gogohmm · 12/01/2023 14:47

No because it means the lower income working age people have to subsidise everyone else as normal (the rich go private already) just paying for a prescription is hard. Dsd earns minimum wage, how is she supposed to find over £30 to see a doctor and pay for her prescription monthly? (Mental health, repeats not allowed but not part of the free prescription scheme, no mental health drugs are). Meanwhile rich pensioners with their triple locked pension, winter fuel allowance and free bus pass don't have to pay.

I would support all those on household incomes over £100k paying (that includes us) as long as richer pensioners and the children in those households also pay

Palomabalom · 12/01/2023 14:46

I have a fear we are going towards an opt out package. I think basic emergency care will be paid for all by NI . This will be reduced for those who opt out to go private for additional treatment. Leaving a rather underfunded shaky health service which is neither use nor ornament for those who have no choice

Kevinyoutwat · 12/01/2023 14:44

And the 24 hour wait was because I wanted to see a specific GP. I could have seen one of the others at the private practice that day.

DrinkFeckArseBrick · 12/01/2023 14:44

I'd pay. It obviously doesnt cover the entire cost of the appointment but would help go towards it and discourage people from missing appointments or time wasting. The caveats being that being free for low income, elderly etc people and follow up / regular appointments would have to be properly thought through and implemented with a buffer (eg it shouldn't just be people on universal credit but should include a decent buffer so for example people linked to tax bands.)

This is not equivalent to private GPs or health insurance as the whole cost needs to be paid.

Either way we are all going to have to pay more in some way and at some point and it makes sense that if you use a service more then you pay a bit more if you can comfortably afford it

If other countries successfully run such a system then I dont see why we can't

Kevinyoutwat · 12/01/2023 14:42

@JennyForeigner sorry that was me. I name changed to earholes the other day and my old and new names keep randomly swapping when I quote people. It’s very annoying!

wonkylegs · 12/01/2023 14:42

caringcarer · 12/01/2023 13:35

OP clearly said free for children, disabled, those on benefits and discounts for long term chronic sickness. Why are people saying it disadvantages those on benefits and disabled? Generally a good idea I would pay and I am disabled.

As I asked in a previous post when does that free kick in?
When you go for that first appointment or months or years down the line when you are finally diagnosed?
I was really lucky my chronic condition was diagnosed within 6mths many other people with it take years for diagnosis.
I'm not on benefits mainly because the amazing meds I'm on have kept my disease relatively controlled so I can live a fairly productive life - but in order to be on those drugs I have to have regular drs appointments as they are extremely dangerous meds. I already have to pay for a prepayment cert for my prescription which is fine but was tricky in that first year when I didn't know what was going on.
I'm not elderly - I was diagnosed at 19

Getting regular treatment has 'saved' lots of money as I have avoided expensive surgery by slowing disease progress. It's cheaper for the nhs to manage this through my GP than the hospital system however paying for GP appointments would mean many people would bypass the GP for stuff like this.

Paying nominal amounts for gp appointments doesn't solve the fundamental issue of not enough GPs in the system.

Perhaps the government should concentrate on retaining & recruitment rather than making the healthcare jobs so unappealing that staff leave in droves. www.bma.org.uk/advice-and-support/nhs-delivery-and-workforce/pressures/pressures-in-general-practice-data-analysis

amp.theguardian.com/society/2022/apr/11/gp-numbers-in-england-down-every-year-since-2015-pledge-to-raise-them

Havanananana · 12/01/2023 14:42

"To those saying NHS is underfunded. You are wrong."

Compared with many other countries, the NHS is grossly underfunded.

UK per capita spending on healthcare (2021) was $5,387
Germany $7,383 = 37% more
Austria $6,693 = 24% more
Sweden $6,262 = 16% more
France $6,115 = 13% more
Denmark $6,382 = 18% more

The Conservative's argument that taxes have to be kept low (the UK is already a low-tax country) otherwise the country will suffer from decline and poverty is nonsense. These are some of the countries with the highest standards of living and the highest quality of life - with wealth far more equally distributed than in the UK. One measure of quality of life is the reassurance that good, affordable healthcare is available as and when it is needed - surely something that the 5th/6th/7th wealthiest country on the planet should be able to offer its citizens.

The underfunding is not just a one-year snapshot - the NHS has been underfunded for the last 12 years or more, with the result that staff are leaving (or not joining in the first place), many facilities and buildings are not fit for 2023 and there is still much equipment in the NHS that should have been scrapped years ago but cannot be replaced as there are no funds available. If the government underfunds by, say, 10% a year, then at the end of 10 years, the NHS is missing a whole year's worth of budget.

I live in one of the countries above. I can see a GP at any time just by walking in. I can see a Consultant within 2-4 weeks. When I recently needed minor surgery, the time from seeing the GP to actually having the surgery was about a month. There are no backlogs (and were hardly any during the pandemic). Ambulances arrive within minutes. There are almost twice as many doctors per capita as in the UK, and more hospital beds, intensive care beds etc. per capita.

As for the inefficiency argument - much of the inefficiency in the NHS is due to outdated equipment and facilities, including IT, and a service that is so overwhelmed trying to keep the ship afloat that there is no time to actually look at how to improve. Instead of looking at new ways of working or improving, doctors, nurses and administrators are tied up explaining to patients that they cannot be seen for another 6 months, or that their vital operation has yet again been cancelled. Demoralising for the NHS staff - stressful, and sometimes fatal for the unfortunate patient.

Earholeseyeholesarsehes · 12/01/2023 14:41

JennyForeigner · 12/01/2023 14:36

Oh thanks. It might sound stupid, but I didn't realise private services organise locally as well as the remote services.

Yes, I think a lot of people just see the apps being advertised and think that’s it.

But there are always private practices around. There are none in my town, but there is in the closet city and the next towns over.

The one I use is a 30 min drive from me, but the longest I’ve had to wait for an appointment is 24 hours, so I really don’t mind. Especially as the phone is picked up right away and no one asks what you want the appointment for or argues!

JennyForeigner · 12/01/2023 14:36

Kevinyoutwat · 12/01/2023 14:29

I don’t use a particular service.

There is one private gp practice I prefer out of all of the ones in the area, but just google “private GP X town” and I’m sure you’ll find a lot come up. More and more are cropping up everywhere due to demand.

I don’t like the apps, I prefer to see someone face to face.

Oh thanks. It might sound stupid, but I didn't realise private services organise locally as well as the remote services.

Igglepiggleslittletoe · 12/01/2023 14:33

MarshaBradyo · 12/01/2023 13:48

It sounds expensive and makes me appreciate NHS more.

Does that include preventative appointments eg smears or general check ups? Wonder if it drives numbers down

Smear tests are free between ages of 25-60. Contraception free for ages 17-25. That is the sum total of it.

babsanderson · 12/01/2023 14:32

No private GP where I live.
But I can see my excellent NHS GP the same day.
Continuity of care is really important. If you see a private GP make sure it is a practice you can go to whenever you have an issue. And it has to be face-to-face.

Kevinyoutwat · 12/01/2023 14:29

JennyForeigner · 12/01/2023 14:20

Interesting, thanks. If you have a recommendation for a particular service it would be good to have a fall back.

We tried a couple of apps and the superdrug one. All had a box you had to tick to confirm it wasn't for a child.

I don’t use a particular service.

There is one private gp practice I prefer out of all of the ones in the area, but just google “private GP X town” and I’m sure you’ll find a lot come up. More and more are cropping up everywhere due to demand.

I don’t like the apps, I prefer to see someone face to face.

Earholeseyeholesarsehes · 12/01/2023 14:22

stbrandonsboat · 12/01/2023 14:19

I would gladly pay as long as I was treated with respect and listened to rather than patronised and fobbed off which can happen with GPs.

Which is why I see private GPs. I’m not well off. But I had years of being fobbed off. Got private healthcare in place, then paid to see a private GP and was referred immediately through insurance to a consultant and something very serious was actually sorted within a matter of weeks.

I’d been begging an nhs GP to see me and then actually listen to me for almost a year.

Aquarius1234 · 12/01/2023 14:21

No cos GP appointment are always quick and not much use.

QuestionableMouse · 12/01/2023 14:21

Does it mean that the GP would actually take me seriously? I had six appointments for the same symptoms and it took me sobbing in the room for them to take me seriously. I was so badly anemic I had a blood transfusion the same day and and iron infusion.

But it took six appointments over six weeks to get treatment. I'm sure five of those could have been better used by other patients but the GP just kept brushing me off.

JennyForeigner · 12/01/2023 14:20

Kevinyoutwat · 12/01/2023 14:17

I’ve always used private GPs for my children from birth, I’ve never had one say they wouldn’t see children. That’s so unusual, I’m sorry you couldn’t find someone to see him.

Interesting, thanks. If you have a recommendation for a particular service it would be good to have a fall back.

We tried a couple of apps and the superdrug one. All had a box you had to tick to confirm it wasn't for a child.

BlusyTusday · 12/01/2023 14:19

I would tentatively support this, as long as there is a proper safety net for the chronically sick, low income and vulnerable; much as you are suggesting OP. The amount of missed appointments whilst others are struggling to see a GP is heartbreaking. Sadly some people don't seem to value things that they don't pay up front for. I know it's not a perfect solution, but it seems to work in a lot of other European countries so I'd be interested to see how it played out here. My reservation is that the system goes the way of NHS dentistry, which uses a similar model but doesn't seem to be working well either; lots of people can't find an NHS dentist, and if they can they're not 'poor enough' to qualify for free or more heavily subsidised treatment.

I think charging would only help if part of a bigger plan to help the NHS, if we relied on this alone I don't think it would fix much sadly, and risks people avoiding seeing their GP because of the cost.

Earholeseyeholesarsehes · 12/01/2023 14:19

I’ve not read the whole thread, so sorry if this has already been asked.

But I thought the problem was too few GPs? So even of people had to pay, where would all the GPs and free appointments magically appear from?

Or are they hoping people wouldn’t bother and would just die quietly in a corner?

stbrandonsboat · 12/01/2023 14:19

I would gladly pay as long as I was treated with respect and listened to rather than patronised and fobbed off which can happen with GPs.

Redblanky · 12/01/2023 14:19

Pleasepleasepleaseno · 12/01/2023 14:16

I really dont understand all th panic over the idea that people qouldnt bother going to the GP and would just get more and more sick. Do we worry about the fact that some people (like me!) have to pay for prescriptions and so maybe they won't bother going to the GP and will just sit and home and get more and more sick. Whats the difference?
Obviously kids, people on UC or pension credit shouldn't be charged and would just have to sign a form or whatever like they do when they collect a prescription. I mean it might not make much money but I can't see it would be a disaster for the population like some posters are saying

My Dad is currently waiting on cancer treatment. He definitely left it too late to go to GP so he's that way inclined anyway, but if he'd had to pay he wouldn't have gone at all. His choice because he could easily afford it, he just wouldn't have. He'd pay prescription charges once a Dr told him he needed to, but he wouldn't have gone for the initial consultation.

I think there will be lots of people like that. Probably also some who currently go too frequently and might thing twice mind.

Kevinyoutwat · 12/01/2023 14:17

JennyForeigner · 12/01/2023 12:07

I tried to yesterday. Our 3 year old son has an infected finger which had become urgent. Despite us actually being in the GP surgery for a vaccination on Tuesday and the nurse asking reception to arrange an antibiotic, they refused. And then went MIA for all appts.

I tried for hours to find a private GP service yesterday at up to £60. None would see a child and we had to go to minor injuries.

They were great in end but with GP surgeries apparently no longer willing to make exceptions for tiny children, we basically feel we now have no choice but to sign up for private healthcare at work at an annual cost of £1500.

So well done Rishi Sunak, I guess. You got what you wanted.

I’ve always used private GPs for my children from birth, I’ve never had one say they wouldn’t see children. That’s so unusual, I’m sorry you couldn’t find someone to see him.

Pleasepleasepleaseno · 12/01/2023 14:16

I really dont understand all th panic over the idea that people qouldnt bother going to the GP and would just get more and more sick. Do we worry about the fact that some people (like me!) have to pay for prescriptions and so maybe they won't bother going to the GP and will just sit and home and get more and more sick. Whats the difference?
Obviously kids, people on UC or pension credit shouldn't be charged and would just have to sign a form or whatever like they do when they collect a prescription. I mean it might not make much money but I can't see it would be a disaster for the population like some posters are saying

Swipe left for the next trending thread