Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask if you would pay for GP visits

665 replies

justanotherhappyflunkie · 12/01/2023 11:36

Been talking with various friends who all agree they would rather pay a nominal sum to see a GP rather than the current system.

I have lived in a country that does this (free for children, disabled people, discounts for beneficiaries and long term sickness) and it was great. Same day appointments, good range of doctors, quick referrals.

The UK equivalent of this would be around £20 per visit.

AIBU to suggest it is the system that could help the NHS? prepares for a flaming!

OP posts:
SkankingWombat · 12/01/2023 16:03

No, I wouldn't support it and suspect it would cost the NHS more in the long run when people wait until things are critical before seeking help.
I would, however, support a rise in NI and keeping the NHS free at the point of access.

UseOfWeapons · 12/01/2023 15:57

Havanananana · 12/01/2023 15:22

"If other countries successfully run such a system then I dont see why we can't"

It is a question of priorities and competence. Jeremy Hunt, an ardent supporter of the free market and private healthcare, was Secretary of State for Health and Social Care from 2012 to 2018. The mismanagement and poor decision-making under his watch is now working its way through the system in the form of too few doctors (he pissed off the junior doctors by imposing pay and conditions on them, so many left the NHS), too few nurses (Hunt scrapped the bursary in 2015), too little investment in equipment and facilities - and of course, by ignoring the findings of the Cygnus simulation, the UK was in no state to deal with the predicted pandemic when Covid actually arrived.

That Hunt is now in charge of the purse strings and is adamant that there is no money available to rectify the terrible mistakes made is an insult to every hard-working person in the NHS and in social care, and to the thousands of patients waiting hours for an ambulance, days for a GP appointment and months for a hospital appointment.

Brilliant post! At last!

Twiglets1 · 12/01/2023 15:57

Havanananana · 12/01/2023 15:31

"Yup I would pay £20 or more for a doctors appointment."

What happens if your GP decides that all of the appointments available next week should be given to people who cannot afford £20? Will you demand to be prioritised? Will you up your bid to £30, or £40, or £75 ... thus making doctors' appointments a commodity that can be sold to the highest bidder?

Or are you saying that you'd happily pay £20 per appointment so that everyone can access healthcare whenever they need it (assuming that millions of GP appointments can be magically created overnight)?

If millions of people would happily pay £20 for an appointment, why do the media and Conservative cheerleaders scream every time an increase in taxes is proposed? Or are the many people on here saying that they would happily pay really saying that they would only do so if it meant that they got priority?

calm down dear, the system works fine now with private dentists doesn't it, where they charge a certain amount and their customers pay it. They don't suddenly decide to prioritise people who can't pay their set price. Or suddenly decide to double their price or ask people to bid what they are prepared to pay for a filling.

Brefugee · 12/01/2023 15:56

So when dentistry charges were first introduced in England they were very low. Eye tests used to be free as well.
But dentistry charges have risen, and what the government pays dentists have reduced. So hardly any dentists offer NHS treatment. Pushing most people into private dentists.
The conservatives want to do the same with GPs, so in ten years time anyone who can afford it has a private GP and everyone else just goes without.

the oldies among us can remember when the Dentist was just like the GP. Free at the point of use. Private dentistry for cosmetic ones (white fillings, braces etc) was available. Eye tests were free.

So how it now is with dentists? that is how GPs will be as this pp said.

Here in Germany, if the GP prescribes something that will be cheaper if you get it privately, they will give you a private prescription that you pay. Prescriptions are charged by the pack size of what you get (it's complicated for me, easy for the pharmacist) and i usually pay EUR 5 per item.

If everyone who could afford it went private what would happen? the number of GP or hospital appointments would go down because there isn't an infinite number of doctors or appointments, and those that are now on the NHS would just be reallocated as private.

some pp mentioned a GP charging for the early appointments because they go to people who need to go to work and evryone else doesn't? utter rot. In general people who work but have little spare cash for fripperies like GPs tend to have less autonomy over their working hours than those further up the greasy pole. So it should be the other way round. How are you going to police that? Or just give the slots to the highest bidder? or have surge pricing like Uber?

justanotherhappyflunkie · 12/01/2023 15:45

Sorry message cut off

By the amount of people already using private schemes they've already had enough of the NHS. it would be a lot worse if they didn't!

OP posts:
justanotherhappyflunkie · 12/01/2023 15:43

I think we can all agree with current system doesn't work.

I'm opposed to raising taxes to throw more money at it. There needs to be a fundamental review of all NHS spending before it's given any more of our money surely?

And yes any pay as you go scheme won't make more GPs appear. We all need to drastically reduce how many times we use a GP where possible. By the amount of people alrea do using private schemes

OP posts:
babsanderson · 12/01/2023 15:38

@Brefugee I agree with you. Totally sick of how employers treat people in this country.

Brefugee · 12/01/2023 15:31

I agree with all of that except the not going to work.

which is why i actually wrote "not going to work if they can avoid it"

but because of the shitty sick pay (etc etc) you all should join a union.

Havanananana · 12/01/2023 15:31

"Yup I would pay £20 or more for a doctors appointment."

What happens if your GP decides that all of the appointments available next week should be given to people who cannot afford £20? Will you demand to be prioritised? Will you up your bid to £30, or £40, or £75 ... thus making doctors' appointments a commodity that can be sold to the highest bidder?

Or are you saying that you'd happily pay £20 per appointment so that everyone can access healthcare whenever they need it (assuming that millions of GP appointments can be magically created overnight)?

If millions of people would happily pay £20 for an appointment, why do the media and Conservative cheerleaders scream every time an increase in taxes is proposed? Or are the many people on here saying that they would happily pay really saying that they would only do so if it meant that they got priority?

babsanderson · 12/01/2023 15:30

@Brefugee I agree with all of that except the not going to work. Loads of people in the UK get no proper sick pay and get penalised for being off sick. So people come in much more ill than just having a cold. I have worked with people who keep going to the toilets to vomit.

Brefugee · 12/01/2023 15:28

they introduced this in Germany (you had to pay once per quarter) and it resulted in too much admin, not enough money coming in to make it worthwhile, and people didn't go to the doctor when they needed to because they couldn't afford it.

So it was scrapped.

What i think the most urgent thing the NHS needs right now is:

  • people to be more self-sufficient in recognising the symptoms of colds, and administering their own treatments that they can buy in the drugstore/chemist
  • use the pharmacist as well as going to the GP for minor ailments
  • not rushing to A&E as soon as they have an out of hours cold
  • knowing how to use the NHS hotline (101? 111?)
  • as far as possible not carrying on as though everything is ok when they have coughs, colds and worse (maybe more handwashing, masking up, not going to work if they can avoid it etc)

At the same time the NHS needs to try to standardise the systems/processes, GPs same.

there are no easy, and certainly no cheap, answers. Going private will help the individual but bottom line? it takes resources from the NHS, since it is the same doctors.

Beezknees · 12/01/2023 15:24

Yeah, I would. Haven't needed to see a GP for years so it wouldn't cost me much.

Havanananana · 12/01/2023 15:22

"If other countries successfully run such a system then I dont see why we can't"

It is a question of priorities and competence. Jeremy Hunt, an ardent supporter of the free market and private healthcare, was Secretary of State for Health and Social Care from 2012 to 2018. The mismanagement and poor decision-making under his watch is now working its way through the system in the form of too few doctors (he pissed off the junior doctors by imposing pay and conditions on them, so many left the NHS), too few nurses (Hunt scrapped the bursary in 2015), too little investment in equipment and facilities - and of course, by ignoring the findings of the Cygnus simulation, the UK was in no state to deal with the predicted pandemic when Covid actually arrived.

That Hunt is now in charge of the purse strings and is adamant that there is no money available to rectify the terrible mistakes made is an insult to every hard-working person in the NHS and in social care, and to the thousands of patients waiting hours for an ambulance, days for a GP appointment and months for a hospital appointment.

Twiglets1 · 12/01/2023 15:18

justanotherhappyflunkie · 12/01/2023 11:36

Been talking with various friends who all agree they would rather pay a nominal sum to see a GP rather than the current system.

I have lived in a country that does this (free for children, disabled people, discounts for beneficiaries and long term sickness) and it was great. Same day appointments, good range of doctors, quick referrals.

The UK equivalent of this would be around £20 per visit.

AIBU to suggest it is the system that could help the NHS? prepares for a flaming!

Yup I would pay £20 or more for a doctors appointment. Pay a lot more already to have a dentist appointment.

Emanresu9 · 12/01/2023 15:18

Yep I live in Jersey and we pay for Gp. Not anyone on benefits or low income but the general population do.

same day appointments, low stressed GP and if you’re referred to the hospital it’s all free after that. But just having that fee makes time wasters maybe pause before just not showing up without cancelling. Or booking an appointment because they’re bored.

Sarahcoggles · 12/01/2023 15:16

Fushiadreams · 12/01/2023 11:58

Yes but only if I could get same day appts when necessary or next day and if rhe receptionists stopped rudely interrogating on why I wished an appt.

I already pay tax for rhe nhs. So am already paying for the visit.

@Fushiadreams if only people would understand why they're asked questions. It really isn't difficult. Receptionists need to ascertain if a GP is the best person to deal with the problem.

When we've had new receptionists in post who aren't good at asking questions, I've seen patients who wanted to order their repeat medication, people who wanted to ask about parking at the hospital outpatients, people who wanted vaccinations (nurses do these), people who wanted to complain about the noise in the waiting room - seriously, many many patients don't understand which issues require a doctor, and which don't. Hence the receptionists asking. Otherwise the person who's passing blood in their poo can't get an appointment because it was snapped up by someone who wanted the phone number of the local X-ray department.

GreenTomato67 · 12/01/2023 15:15

MarshaBradyo · 12/01/2023 14:58

It’s down to voters too. I know people post they want to pay more on here if they do, but generally people feel taxed enough and probably don’t want to vote for higher taxes.

The other issue is low users usually pay more, I don’t mind and actually wanted the NI increase to go ahead, but I also want personal responsibility to feature more.

This is perhaps true but the way it's spun in certain areas of the press I think puts people off. I think if most people felt the money would be well used they'd be happy to pay more tax.

I do think more personal care for one's own health and better preventive care would be helpful but I think that would also require massive government intervention and higher regulation of the food and drink industry, tobacco, vaping etc.

I've heard of people with health issues going to the gp to seek treatment for chronic low grade health issues and they get turned away and told help is only available once they become seriously ill. I understand why this is, that the seriously ill have to be prioritised and that we're not in a position to practice preventive or more holistic (by that I don't mean alternatve therapy just seeing the whole person) medicine. We are just storing up problems for the future though.

BooksAndHooks · 12/01/2023 15:10

So richer people pay for a service that will give them easier access to appointments by putting lower income people off booking an appointment?

You would have quicker access because people can’t afford to go, hence there being more appointments.

No I do not agree with this at all. It will lead to people delaying going to the Dr and treatment potentially costing far more in the long run due to not being treated earlier.

crosstalk · 12/01/2023 15:06

@Takingabreakagain It's not that easy any more to cancel appointments (any more than it is to book them). I had undiagnosed Covid and was feeling dreadful before a simple blood test. I could go online between 0600-0800 (the time my surgery says it reviews online requests) to cancel. I missed that slot and was not capable of going online. Or phone if I could get through which I did with DP for an hour and got through half an hour before the appointment. Meanwhile weeping into my cup of tea and necking paracetamol.

I cannot think nowadays there are too many people dodging appointments unneccessarily. Unless as a PP suggests they are suffering from memory problems and don't respond to phone/email reminders.

However my GP surgery does have a list (as does local hospital) of the cost to them of missed appointments and it is flabbergasting. Very hard to hunt down and make people pay for negligence if that's what it is - if there isn't a good way of proving negligence and not just too ill to come/no one to take me/can't afford parking/couldn't get childcare - and a better way to cancel appointments.

wonkylegs · 12/01/2023 15:05

@gogohmm
If she hasn't got one already please encourage dsd to have a look at a prepayment prescription certificate if she has monthly prescriptions. It will probably save money.

www.nhsbsa.nhs.uk/help-nhs-prescription-costs/nhs-prescription-prepayment-certificates-ppcs

I didn't know about them until a fab pharmacist strongly encouraged (wouldn't let me leave until I filled out the paperwork) and it's saved me thousands over the years.

Badbadbunny · 12/01/2023 15:03

@Opa

What I would like the government to propose is how they can cut back on their own salaries and expenditure first and reroute some of those costs to the NHS

Have you actually done the Maths? Did you get your "noughts" wrong? You could zeroise MPs pay and expenses and it would be just a drop in the ocean when the NHS spends £150 BILLION per year. The wages and expenses of MPs is probably less than a billion, so not even 1 per cent of the NHS running costs. It'd be a political gesture at most and make absolutely no difference to the NHS for the vast majority of the 60 million UK population!

Sarahcoggles · 12/01/2023 15:02

If all children, disabled, elderly, people on benefits, war veterans etc get free appointments, it's unlikely to be much easier for other people to book appointments anyway. Most people who attend the GP surgery will come into those categories, so everyone else wouldn't notice much difference.

CremeEggThief · 12/01/2023 14:58

If I earn enough, I would pay; no question at all. Maybe it's because I'm from Ireland originally where most people have to pay at least €50 per gp appointment so I don't see it as a big deal.

MarshaBradyo · 12/01/2023 14:58

GreenTomato67 · 12/01/2023 14:53

Great Post, so we'll said. We could have a much better service but it's a political choice to underfund the service and to privatise it bit by bit.

People should look into the links between the Conservatives and US Health and disability insurance companies going right back to the early 90s. The current state of the NHS is a deliberate choice by them.

It’s down to voters too. I know people post they want to pay more on here if they do, but generally people feel taxed enough and probably don’t want to vote for higher taxes.

The other issue is low users usually pay more, I don’t mind and actually wanted the NI increase to go ahead, but I also want personal responsibility to feature more.

britsabroad · 12/01/2023 14:57

Not sure about charging people to see a GP. But totally on board with fining people for missed appointments. I live overseas, and if you miss a GP appointment you pay a fine equivalent to £50!