Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask if you would pay for GP visits

665 replies

justanotherhappyflunkie · 12/01/2023 11:36

Been talking with various friends who all agree they would rather pay a nominal sum to see a GP rather than the current system.

I have lived in a country that does this (free for children, disabled people, discounts for beneficiaries and long term sickness) and it was great. Same day appointments, good range of doctors, quick referrals.

The UK equivalent of this would be around £20 per visit.

AIBU to suggest it is the system that could help the NHS? prepares for a flaming!

OP posts:
lieselotte · 12/01/2023 17:07

I'm not sure how they would find the extra capacity just because people were paying £20 per appointment. And if they did suddenly find capacity it would bring into question the fact that they probably did have appointments available all along

I think there would be more capacity. For one thing, people wouldn't waste their time if they were paying for it. But also, money talks.

That said, there is a problem with NHS dentists. But you can see an optician easily enough.

lieselotte · 12/01/2023 17:05

1hyuny · 12/01/2023 11:37

I agree, the amount of appointments missed are ridiculous!! If we were charged then I bet they wouldn't miss appointments.

It used to be ridiculous. I doubt people miss face to face appointments now as they are so hard to get.

However, I would pay for a GP visit if it meant I could get a same day appointment for urgent issues and a routine appointment within a week or so. Or indeed an appointment at all.

Twiglets1 · 12/01/2023 17:04

OopsAnotherOne · 12/01/2023 16:57

I would worry that the poorest in society would be most impacted by this as £20 is a lot for a family who are having to choose between heating and eating.

People who are down to their last few quid for the month will be less likely to get little but potentially serious things such as a small lump or a suspicious mole checked out as it might not seem important enough to spend £20 on, when so many other things are taking priority at that time.

Perhaps a scheme where you register your bank details with your GP and they take a fee of £20.00 which is then returned to you on attendance at your GP would mean that people are only charged if they don't attend their appointment. This would generate some extra income for the GP Surgery but would (hopefully) cut down people who just don't turn up to their appointments.

While it would make sense to exclude those such as children, those receiving UC, pensioners and people with pre-existing health conditions from this, there are still many people within the UK who don't fall into these categories but still simply couldn't afford £20 being taken from their account at certain times of the month.

The only way to fairly implement such a system would be to ensure it's means tested, meaning pensioners with larger assets, savings and pensions are expected to pay the deposit whereas the pensioners with a very small income would be exempt. At the end of the day, as long as the person in question attended their appointment, they would be refunded automatically so it would not be an "unfair" system unless you essentially treat the system "unfairly" by adding to the no-show statistics.

People who currently qualify for free prescriptions could also qualify for free appointments with their GP.
But those who can afford to pay maybe should start paying as God knows, the NHS is in a dire financial state and the electorate has proved over and over again that people don't like paying high taxes.

DoraSpenlow · 12/01/2023 17:02

Not sure how it would work at our surgery. They currently have 5 GPs but the AskmyGP service has been suspended since before Christmas and they are only taking urgent cases because they say they are overwhelmed. I'm not sure how they would find the extra capacity just because people were paying £20 per appointment. And if they did suddenly find capacity it would bring into question the fact that they probably did have apppointments available all along.

Twiglets1 · 12/01/2023 17:01

Blossomtoes · 12/01/2023 16:54

But the system is broken.

Then the answer is to elect a government that would mend it, not collude with the one that broke it.

I'm not getting the opportunity to vote to change it right now though am I? Probably won't get a chance to vote all year.

In the meantime (& even assuming Labour could fix it which I have my doubts about now things are so bad but sure, prepared to give them a try) and to answer OPs question on this thread, Yes I would be prepared to pay £20 for a GP appointment.

JusteanBiscuits · 12/01/2023 17:00

caringcarer · 12/01/2023 13:57

To those saying NHS is underfunded. You are wrong. It is funded to a good level but it is grossly mismanaged. Some GP's prescribe medication that can be bought over the counter very cheaply. Ibuprofen cost 34p on Aldi yet a prescription for it costs £8 to NHS. Some people who can't tolerate wheat get bread and even cakes on prescription. They can buy food without wheat at supermarket. Gay men who have a lot of casual sex with people they don't know can be prescribed PREP just in case a person they have sex with is HIV positive. They could be using a condom. PREP is very expensive. Hospitals as pend rediculous amounts on things like having a new light bulb which is done by contractor who charges 20/10 times more than having their own electrician/maintenance person would cost. They have over 450 health bosses on over £100k pa and dozens earning over £160k pa. Yet trusts are not meeting their performance targets, waiting list grow and Junior Doctors and Nurses are underpaid and have to work rediculous long shifts of 12 hours when likely to be tired and that is often when mistakes are made. The NHS needs a complete overhaul. People in hospital don't have to pay for their food. No reason why a person in hospital can't pay for their food. They would be paying for it if not in hospital. Too much money is spent on the pointless gender surgeries then four or five years down the line many of them want reversing. Other operations which are a choice rather than as medical requirement like circumcisions should be charged for and all UK citizens should have a national ID card. No card no healthcare unless paying up front. It is a NHS not an International HS. Rant over.

Do you wear an I <3 The Daily Mail badge??

Stop believing everything they write

OopsAnotherOne · 12/01/2023 16:57

I would worry that the poorest in society would be most impacted by this as £20 is a lot for a family who are having to choose between heating and eating.

People who are down to their last few quid for the month will be less likely to get little but potentially serious things such as a small lump or a suspicious mole checked out as it might not seem important enough to spend £20 on, when so many other things are taking priority at that time.

Perhaps a scheme where you register your bank details with your GP and they take a fee of £20.00 which is then returned to you on attendance at your GP would mean that people are only charged if they don't attend their appointment. This would generate some extra income for the GP Surgery but would (hopefully) cut down people who just don't turn up to their appointments.

While it would make sense to exclude those such as children, those receiving UC, pensioners and people with pre-existing health conditions from this, there are still many people within the UK who don't fall into these categories but still simply couldn't afford £20 being taken from their account at certain times of the month.

The only way to fairly implement such a system would be to ensure it's means tested, meaning pensioners with larger assets, savings and pensions are expected to pay the deposit whereas the pensioners with a very small income would be exempt. At the end of the day, as long as the person in question attended their appointment, they would be refunded automatically so it would not be an "unfair" system unless you essentially treat the system "unfairly" by adding to the no-show statistics.

Blossomtoes · 12/01/2023 16:54

But the system is broken.

Then the answer is to elect a government that would mend it, not collude with the one that broke it.

ToWhitToWhoo · 12/01/2023 16:54

Havanananana · 12/01/2023 16:45

@Twiglets1 "calm down dear, the system works fine now with private dentists doesn't it, where they charge a certain amount and their customers pay it."

No. It doesn't work. Hunt totally destroyed NHS dentistry. Those who can afford it get reasonable dental care. Those who cannot afford private dentistry or who cannot access a NHS dentist are left to fend for themselves, with millions facing poor dental health the result. God help the UK if he's allowed to get away with destroying what's left of NHS healthcare in the same fashion.

Private dentistry costs a lot more than £20 per visit, though. Even NHS dentists are usually not free.

Twiglets1 · 12/01/2023 16:52

babsanderson · 12/01/2023 16:15

@Twiglets1 Do you know the terrible state of many poor people's teeth?

yes, is that my fault in your opinion since you sound accusatory?

I wish more dentists could still be NHS but they can't because it became financially unsustainable. Sorry to say it but I think the health service is going the same way. It has been underfunded for so many years it is falling apart horribly. I'm seriously thinking about finding a local private practice where I just pay and go as I need treatment (like my dentist). I've supported the NHS all my life and still have the greatest respect for NHS workers. But the system is broken.

Havanananana · 12/01/2023 16:45

@Twiglets1 "calm down dear, the system works fine now with private dentists doesn't it, where they charge a certain amount and their customers pay it."

No. It doesn't work. Hunt totally destroyed NHS dentistry. Those who can afford it get reasonable dental care. Those who cannot afford private dentistry or who cannot access a NHS dentist are left to fend for themselves, with millions facing poor dental health the result. God help the UK if he's allowed to get away with destroying what's left of NHS healthcare in the same fashion.

Kevinyoutwat · 12/01/2023 16:42

wormshuffled · 12/01/2023 16:37

I wouldn't support this, I would however support people being charged for missed appointments. My gym charges for missed classes, it makes people cancel in time for the slot to be used by someone else.

As long as there was a system at all surgeries that worked to cancel appointments.

The amount of times I had to cancel GP appointments for my dad on the day or the day before because he’d either been taken to hospital or decided to refuse to do and I couldn’t actually get though to anyone to let them know, despite repeatedly calling.

I’ve heard the same thing from countless people. Sometimes it’s not a no show, people just give up trying to get through to someone.

ToWhitToWhoo · 12/01/2023 16:40

Yes, I would. There would, however. have to be exemptions for those on low incomes, and those with certain illnesses that require very frequent appointments.

babsanderson · 12/01/2023 16:39

dollymixtured · 12/01/2023 16:22

Well it’s obviously not unlimited but very few people would need to see a GP multiple times in a month. For the average family that might need a few visits a year this would be a great service. The fact that you immediately jump to ‘unlimited’ in your mind is indicative of the problem we have which is that some people massively overuse the health service unnecessarily and others are very light users.

So you pay £170 a month and get a few visits to a GP a year. Absolutely fine for basically healthy people. Not okay for those who actually need healthcare though.

wormshuffled · 12/01/2023 16:37

I wouldn't support this, I would however support people being charged for missed appointments. My gym charges for missed classes, it makes people cancel in time for the slot to be used by someone else.

MarshaBradyo · 12/01/2023 16:25

scoobelopey · 12/01/2023 16:19

If you say that people can be exempt if they are children, disabled, poor or have a chronic condition, you're looking at about 3% of people paying.

Not even worth the admin costs.

If so you’re right it’s not worth it. Plus those paying will more likely feel the burden.

Are we that much different to other countries who pay?

TheGoogleMum · 12/01/2023 16:25

I fear this would put people off making appointments especially if money is tight

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 12/01/2023 16:24

levellingleveller · 12/01/2023 11:41

No. This is an absolute disgrace. It’s a clear disincentive for low income people to seek medical help.
it also disadvantages those with chronic ill health / disabilities who need more GP appts and are also more likely to be on low incomes.

Honestly, when there is so much in the news about people needing to use food banks and the working poor, how anyone can propose this disgusts me.

it’s hard to imagine a proposal which will more clearly improve things for the wealthy at the cost of the poor and disadvantaged.

Entirely agree with this. I mean I could afford to pay- and in fact rarely go for myself - but many couldn’t, and it’s the thin end of the wedge. The point of the NHS is it’s free at the point of care for all - it’s available to all and doesn’t punish anyone for being ill.

Some people don’t even have £10 to spend on a GP appointment, even if they could claim it back.

dollymixtured · 12/01/2023 16:22

Rowthe · 12/01/2023 11:47

Are you able to tell me what service this is?
As unlimited home visits for a family for £170 a month seems very cheap.

Well it’s obviously not unlimited but very few people would need to see a GP multiple times in a month. For the average family that might need a few visits a year this would be a great service. The fact that you immediately jump to ‘unlimited’ in your mind is indicative of the problem we have which is that some people massively overuse the health service unnecessarily and others are very light users.

babsanderson · 12/01/2023 16:21

@scoobelopey I agree. I just hope we get a Labour government before this government do much more damage than they already have.

scoobelopey · 12/01/2023 16:19

If you say that people can be exempt if they are children, disabled, poor or have a chronic condition, you're looking at about 3% of people paying.

Not even worth the admin costs.

scoobelopey · 12/01/2023 16:18

Threads like this just show how utterly clueless the vast proportion of the population is on who uses healthcare and why. It makes me sick to my stomach after 20 years in the NHS what attitudes like this will do to about 75% of healthcare users I treat.

Tubbyinthehottub · 12/01/2023 16:17

No, I don't support the creation of a two tier system for access to NHS healthcare at all.

babsanderson · 12/01/2023 16:15

@Twiglets1 Do you know the terrible state of many poor people's teeth?

SpringsRightAroundTheCorner · 12/01/2023 16:14

The thing is you mention that people on benefits, disabled, children etc wouldn't have to pay, what about those low middle earners who are struggling at the moment? They aren't in receipt of any benefits, aren't disabled and are working, what if they don't have £20 to visit the doctor? The people who are doing those fairly low paid service type jobs we rely on and are paying in via ni already are charged again. So if they can't afford it, what do they do?

I am not one of these people, I can afford it, but this isn't how I want our healthcare system to run. If you want to go private that option already exists for you, go private, pay a premium, the thing is many working people right now just couldn't afford it, even if it is "only £20". So no.

Swipe left for the next trending thread