Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask if you would pay for GP visits

665 replies

justanotherhappyflunkie · 12/01/2023 11:36

Been talking with various friends who all agree they would rather pay a nominal sum to see a GP rather than the current system.

I have lived in a country that does this (free for children, disabled people, discounts for beneficiaries and long term sickness) and it was great. Same day appointments, good range of doctors, quick referrals.

The UK equivalent of this would be around £20 per visit.

AIBU to suggest it is the system that could help the NHS? prepares for a flaming!

OP posts:
amyboo · 12/01/2023 18:56

The government in the UK only ever presents the status quo and privatisation (US style) as the two options. As others, including myself, have pointed out, there are plenty of European countries where there is some element of payment at point of delivery, non of whom have privatised healthcare systems like the US. Instead we have 80% of the costs of basic treatments/appointments fully covered (or up to 100% depending on status and additional insurance - usually covered by an employer) and easy access to necessary services. In the EU country I live in, I could also easily get an appointment with a specialist without a referral, and I end up paying maybe €10 towards the cost of an appointment.... Well worth it if you ask me!

mogsrus · 12/01/2023 18:47

Definitely, always thought this would be a good move.

CeriB82 · 12/01/2023 18:39

Absolutely not. I have no issue in seeing my GP/nurse.
i can call at 8am to make an appointment. If its terribly urgent they will see me. But i can get an appointment within 2-3 days.

and for my regular appointment every 6 weeks i book in advance at each appointment

dollymixtured · 12/01/2023 18:37

babsanderson · 12/01/2023 18:36

@dollymixtured How much do you earn?
I did once get antibiotics I could not pay for. I just ticked I was entitled although I was not. I needed them.

Nothing like a touch of light fraud to show your support for the NHS.

cptartapp · 12/01/2023 18:36

Would you charge everyone? Or would those on benefits, children, the elderly (by far the biggest user group and some very wealthy) be exempt? Leaving just the poor sods in the middle yet again.
Most of my non attenders are older people. I suspect many would be quite happy to charge 21 year old student John for a no show, but for 81 year old George there would be an outcry.
Unfair.

babsanderson · 12/01/2023 18:36

@dollymixtured How much do you earn?
I did once get antibiotics I could not pay for. I just ticked I was entitled although I was not. I needed them.

Rummikub · 12/01/2023 18:28

I’d rather pay more tax or NI as long as it went into training, recruitment and retention.

Rummikub · 12/01/2023 18:26

No I wouldn’t want a pay to see GP system. I wouldn’t go unless things were serious. Eg a lump that turned out to be cancer- I only went to appease my mum.

dollymixtured · 12/01/2023 18:24

babsanderson · 12/01/2023 18:23

Agree it is a very low amount. As a family we have often struggled but have never met the requirement for free prescriptions on a low income. If you have a full time job on minimum wage, you do not qualify. If you have children you have to be getting free school meals to get free prescriptions for adults.

Of course anyone with multiple prescriptions can get a prepay certificate so it's not a prohibitive amount in reality.

babsanderson · 12/01/2023 18:23

Thesearmsofmine · 12/01/2023 18:19

I just looked up the income cut off for getting free prescriptions as a few people have suggested that they could use the same cut off for free appointments. If I’m reading it right you have to earn £15,276 or less. It’s such a low amount and you can see how many above that income simply couldn’t afford it(same reason they don’t access dental care).

Agree it is a very low amount. As a family we have often struggled but have never met the requirement for free prescriptions on a low income. If you have a full time job on minimum wage, you do not qualify. If you have children you have to be getting free school meals to get free prescriptions for adults.

purplefacemask · 12/01/2023 18:22

Yes, there should be a sliding scale based on income.

dollymixtured · 12/01/2023 18:20

weathervane1 · 12/01/2023 18:18

This may have been said already - it's a long thread - but paying for a GP visit in the UK would the tip of a very unpleasant iceberg. The government would be delighted as it is already trying to push privatisation by underfunding the NHS and not actively looking to address the current issues. As someone who has spent a fair bit of time in the US, private health care really doesn't work for the vast majority who can not afford either the monthly fees or the co-pay amounts. The result is a large nation where the poorer in society have to suffer and do not have affordable / easy access to the best care.

Paying for a GP appointment will progress to paying for hospital appointment or ambulance services, anaesthesia, bandages, crutches, stitches etc etc. The tipping point will come where medical professionals set their own prices, hospitals form lucrative and tied partnerships with insurance companies and the cost at every stage increases sharply - large medical bills would be funded through increased healthcare insurance premiums and co-pays and the gap between those that can pay and those that cannot will widen.

As someone of 58, I can recall when the NHS was the envy of the world and with the right approach and investment, it could be again. For those who are considerably younger, it may be that you have never experienced it at its absolute best, but it can be done.

The £20 or £150 proposed for a GP appointment will quickly turn into £3K for an x-ray, £400 for a pair of crutches, £50K to remove an appendix etc. The process of having to check itemised invoices as they have to in the US, to remove fictitious medical items, will be the least of our worries.

Or it could be just like many systems across Europe. You have no evidence at all for your assertions.

Thesearmsofmine · 12/01/2023 18:19

I just looked up the income cut off for getting free prescriptions as a few people have suggested that they could use the same cut off for free appointments. If I’m reading it right you have to earn £15,276 or less. It’s such a low amount and you can see how many above that income simply couldn’t afford it(same reason they don’t access dental care).

weathervane1 · 12/01/2023 18:18

This may have been said already - it's a long thread - but paying for a GP visit in the UK would the tip of a very unpleasant iceberg. The government would be delighted as it is already trying to push privatisation by underfunding the NHS and not actively looking to address the current issues. As someone who has spent a fair bit of time in the US, private health care really doesn't work for the vast majority who can not afford either the monthly fees or the co-pay amounts. The result is a large nation where the poorer in society have to suffer and do not have affordable / easy access to the best care.

Paying for a GP appointment will progress to paying for hospital appointment or ambulance services, anaesthesia, bandages, crutches, stitches etc etc. The tipping point will come where medical professionals set their own prices, hospitals form lucrative and tied partnerships with insurance companies and the cost at every stage increases sharply - large medical bills would be funded through increased healthcare insurance premiums and co-pays and the gap between those that can pay and those that cannot will widen.

As someone of 58, I can recall when the NHS was the envy of the world and with the right approach and investment, it could be again. For those who are considerably younger, it may be that you have never experienced it at its absolute best, but it can be done.

The £20 or £150 proposed for a GP appointment will quickly turn into £3K for an x-ray, £400 for a pair of crutches, £50K to remove an appendix etc. The process of having to check itemised invoices as they have to in the US, to remove fictitious medical items, will be the least of our worries.

babsanderson · 12/01/2023 18:16

@Twiglets1 You need a review of your asthma. Using your inhaler every day is a sign of poorly controlled asthma.

Twiglets1 · 12/01/2023 18:14

RedCarsGoFaster · 12/01/2023 17:53

So diabetics, asthmatics, anyone with a long term disability should just shut up and die, right?

My mate in the USA couldn't afford to pay for blue inhalers for her sons asthma - she had no health insurance. Instead the child was only treated when he had attacks requiring hospitalisation which was free at her local emergency centre. Fully preventable with inexpensive medicine and check ups. And far cheaper throughout his lifetime.

People on this thread are so dramatic.
I have asthma myself, I take an inhaler at least once a day every day. I pay for my own prescriptions & I would still be happy to pay for GP appointments. I don’t see my doctor very often, only the nurse for an asthma review (would be happy to pay to see the nurse too).

Flowersinthebasement · 12/01/2023 18:14

Seems to me that in countries where health care is free or for a small initial fee, the equivalent tax/social insurance/government investment per capita is MUCH higher than in UK.

That fact has not been acknowledged or fixed by Government, and is largely ignored by service users who want service levels to vastly improve without it costing them a penny more.

dollymixtured · 12/01/2023 18:14

babsanderson · 12/01/2023 18:12

Because most rich countries do still balk at letting children die because their parents do not have money. Adults? Who cares.

Some people paying a small amount for a GP appt should not be equated with 'letting people die' it is gross hyperbole and sounds absurd.

babsanderson · 12/01/2023 18:12

justanotherhappyflunkie · 12/01/2023 18:10

You wouldn't pay for children if the U.K. adopted similar systems used worldwide

Because most rich countries do still balk at letting children die because their parents do not have money. Adults? Who cares.

babsanderson · 12/01/2023 18:11

@Twiglets1 GPs are not allowed to give prescriptions for ordinary aspirin and paracetamol.
People read things and get confused. So aclovar for cold sore cream is bought over the counter. But I get some on prescription at times - it is a lower strength than over the counter but is for a recurring cold sore I get right by my eye. You can not buy it over the counter. But if you looked at a list of medicine given out on free prescriptions and saw cold sore cream no doubt you would be up in arms.

justanotherhappyflunkie · 12/01/2023 18:10

yentirb · 12/01/2023 17:43

No. I have two small nursery aged children, they're sick continuously and we visit the GP often over reoccurring issues. I wouldn't be able to fund this.

You wouldn't pay for children if the U.K. adopted similar systems used worldwide

OP posts:
dollymixtured · 12/01/2023 18:10

onetwobucklemyshoes · 12/01/2023 18:04

dollymixtured - GPs are experts at managing chronic conditions. These patients don't necessarily need to be seen in secondary care. It is cheaper (and probably easier for the patient) to be seen in primary care anyway. It may take a while to stabilise conditions or to monitor treatment efficacy, in which case a GP may need to see a patient with a chronic condition regularly for a period. I'm not sure how you can argue that something isn't being managed well if it needs regular appointments - how else can the management be escalated and improved?! Lots of treatments take time, trial and error. No GP is seeing someone with high blood pressure weekly for 6 months! But someone with a mental health crisis may need regular follow-up (medications take a while to work) or someone with newly diagnosed T2DM or someone who is cycling through a few medications to find something they can tolerate for their blood pressure etc etc

Absolutely but a PP posted that they had had 4 appts in the last month, suggesting that this would be unaffordable and therefore unreasonable if appts were charged. I am merely pointing out that weekly GP appts should not be the long term default position for anyone. Of course in the short term much more regular visits may be necessary but in the long term weekly GP visits are not IMO a good model. Because a small number of people appear to take a disproportionately large amount of GP time in some cases and this contributes to the lack of access for everyone else.

Twiglets1 · 12/01/2023 18:08

ToWhitToWhoo · 12/01/2023 17:36

With too many people abusing the system and taking doctors appointments/getting prescriptions rather than buy a packet of aspirin from the supermarket because why not? It's "free".

For most people, a prescription is not free. Unless you're over 60, obtaining a prescription for a child, or have some other exemption, it is considerably more expensive to pay the prescription charge than to buy most OTC medications.

I’m obviously talking about the people who do qualify for free prescriptions (which is actually loads of people) who then get prescriptions for things like aspirin & paracetamol etc.

babsanderson · 12/01/2023 18:07

@dollymixtured I agree chronic conditions should be well managed. But my point was that there can be good reasons for weekly appointments. Someone else I know with bipolar was managed during a crisis with twice daily visits from the crisis team and GP appointments every 2-3 days. It was short term but kept that person out of hospital which would have been far more costly.

Similarly when my dad came out of hospital after kidney issues I contacted the GP every single day for a week for advice. There were issues with medication which was changed about 5 times that week. It would have cost me £140 under this plan. The alternative was to keep him in hospital for another week.

I know GPs see a lot of colds and minor things, but they do see more serious things that need intensive short term monitoring. The alternative is consultants and longer stays in hospital instead.

Patapouf · 12/01/2023 18:06

I'd pay £20 but I'd want an end to sitting around for 45 minutes when they are running late, to be able to make an appointment without being on hold for an hour and an appointment slot within ten days.

Swipe left for the next trending thread