Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask if you would pay for GP visits

665 replies

justanotherhappyflunkie · 12/01/2023 11:36

Been talking with various friends who all agree they would rather pay a nominal sum to see a GP rather than the current system.

I have lived in a country that does this (free for children, disabled people, discounts for beneficiaries and long term sickness) and it was great. Same day appointments, good range of doctors, quick referrals.

The UK equivalent of this would be around £20 per visit.

AIBU to suggest it is the system that could help the NHS? prepares for a flaming!

OP posts:
dollymixtured · 12/01/2023 21:51

Happyvalleyfan · 12/01/2023 21:42

@dollymixtured
What I meant was that the government has really tough choices- we need to manage deficit and people may not be willing to pay more taxes.

Well yes, but that isn't what you originally said at all. Cost containment is across all govt departments if anything the NHS is more protected than most departments

Happyvalleyfan · 12/01/2023 21:42

@dollymixtured
What I meant was that the government has really tough choices- we need to manage deficit and people may not be willing to pay more taxes.

Lordofmyflies · 12/01/2023 21:42

I do pay. Our GP service is terrible and it often takes days to get through to the surgery. Instead, we use a private on-line GP service (£40 per consult). I can get an appointment that day. I'd rather see my NHS GP but its impossible.

Happyvalleyfan · 12/01/2023 21:36

Rummikub · 12/01/2023 20:24

This can’t be true...

The amount NHS gets isn’t being reduced but it looks like the NHS are having to making the money go further, despite inflation.

www.england.nhs.uk/wp-content/uploads/2022/10/item-4.2-public-board-meeting-financial-position-and-the-future-financial-outlook-.pdf

“The NHS will be asked to plan for significant efficiency requirements for local health systems of 2.9% (£3.6bn) and 2.2% (£2.8bn) in each of the next two years. These annual efficiency requirements – agreed by the NHS as part of the SR - are higher than the NHS has historically delivered (c1%/year) as we seek to recover the lost productivity experienced because of Covid-19. We are planning that we will have to absorb recurrently the £1.5bn of additional inflation costs from this year and around £1bn of other new pressures and transferred responsibilities.”

SR = spending review I think

Swg · 12/01/2023 20:41

babsanderson · 12/01/2023 18:11

@Twiglets1 GPs are not allowed to give prescriptions for ordinary aspirin and paracetamol.
People read things and get confused. So aclovar for cold sore cream is bought over the counter. But I get some on prescription at times - it is a lower strength than over the counter but is for a recurring cold sore I get right by my eye. You can not buy it over the counter. But if you looked at a list of medicine given out on free prescriptions and saw cold sore cream no doubt you would be up in arms.

Actually not quite true - or didn’t used to be. There is a situation where is is appropriate to have a paracetamol prescription and that is where you’re likely to need a lot of it over a long period. Because it’s not appropriate to have someone who might be seriously ill need to go to the shop twice a week to stock up and the restrictions on selling it can cause issues.

Swg · 12/01/2023 20:31

No. Not because I can’t afford it.

Anyone who has a chronic illness will tell you it takes a lot of GP visits to work out what is going on. Frequently you’ll have a lot of vague symptoms like exhaustion and you’ll start at the optimistically temporary “probably just a virus” work through it not going away “post viral fatigue” “are you depressed?” “maybe long covid” and endure endless blood tests before something either turns up on one of them or things suddenly get worse prompting a diagnosis.

Living through that already is horrible and makes you feel like a huge hypochondriac. Living through it whilst not being paid and on long term sick and needing to go regularly?

These things always seem a great idea to people who don’t need to visit the GP more than once a year and can’t picture that changing.

dollymixtured · 12/01/2023 20:28

Rummikub · 12/01/2023 20:24

This can’t be true...

It’s a completely meaningless statement. The NHS isn’t a piggybank.

Rummikub · 12/01/2023 20:24

Happyvalleyfan · 12/01/2023 20:17

From what I have heard, the government is taking money out of healthcare system -
probably to pay back deficit without raising taxes. This problem ain’t going away and may get worse…

This can’t be true...

EsmeSusanOgg · 12/01/2023 20:18

Or... Crazy idea... Increase income tax so that those who can afford pay slightly more ax and the service is properly funded?

An upfront cost means those with chronic illness or low income will avoid seeking medical help.

Happyvalleyfan · 12/01/2023 20:17

From what I have heard, the government is taking money out of healthcare system -
probably to pay back deficit without raising taxes. This problem ain’t going away and may get worse…

Happyvalleyfan · 12/01/2023 20:06

BluIsTheColour · 12/01/2023 12:09

No I don't want to pay £20 to see the gp. I cld afford to but I'd more likely not bother unless I was really worried about something or very ill. I'm sure lots of folk wld think the same. Plus I think I already pay enough in tax without having to fund a gp appointment.

I can only imagine folk on low incomes wld end up very unwell or worse!

Not read the whole thread but had to respond to this- we dont pay enough for a good service- estimated shortfall has been £200 billion since 2010

you pay for what you get- you’re clearly happy with current situation?

www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2023/jan/11/patient-a-and-e-tories-nhs-hospital-government-funding

May main concern is that this will lead to a two tier system, and those paying for private appointments are NOT going to make situation better as we only have a finite number of doctors including GPs.

what’s to stop them doing a dentist? Fancy having to search for an NHS GP?

soupey1 · 12/01/2023 19:54

So for low income do you mean individual or household, I have a very low income but DH would be just over the £25k limit suggested. Do I need to go to him cap in hand if I have women’s problems and hope he’ll pay for me. He already has to pay for my prescriptions as although my income would qualify for help the household income doesn’t. I would mention that I am disabled but not enough for PIP under the current assessment process and don’t have the mental strength to fight it!

dollymixtured · 12/01/2023 19:43

Blossomtoes · 12/01/2023 19:35

Out of interest when was this golden age you are referring to?

1997 to 2010. I remember it well.

amp.theguardian.com/politics/2001/oct/28/health.politicalnews

these golden times?

MarshaBradyo · 12/01/2023 19:38

Havanananana · 12/01/2023 19:11

"As someone of 58, I can recall when the NHS was the envy of the world and with the right approach and investment, it could be again."

This is something worth repeating. The NHS was once excellent, GPs were accessible, waiting lists far shorter than they are today and for their time, hospitals were at the cutting edge of medicine and technology.

Successive governments, but particularly Conservative governments, have failed to ensure that expenditure and investment have kept pace with the increased and changing demands on the NHS. Changes in technology, changes in the age and medical profile of the population, changes in the attitude of the public to healthcare - these major changes have hardly been addressed by the politicians, and where they have been addressed (e.g. by Lansley or Hunt) the politicians concerned have somehow managed to make spectacularly wrong decisions at the wrong time.

"there should be a sliding scale based on income"

There is - it is called taxation. Those who earn more pay more in tax and more in National Insurance. However in a universal healthcare system this does not give them priority over those who pay less tax or NI.

Tbf I doubt people want to pay again even if they pay higher NI

Low users pay more but you’re better off not double charging the same group

Blossomtoes · 12/01/2023 19:35

Out of interest when was this golden age you are referring to?

1997 to 2010. I remember it well.

Darhon · 12/01/2023 19:31

Not in the current system which structurally can’t manage to provide care and where there’s been privatisation of primary care in some areas. I’m happy to consider a new system and then have insurance and pay on the models used in some places in Europe, but not pay for this system.

I feel the same about social care. I’ll pay more tax for it but I don’t want to pay into the largely privatised, run for profit not people system we have in place at the moment.

Fordian · 12/01/2023 19:24

Takingabreakagain · 12/01/2023 12:20

I don't agree that there should be a fee to see a GP or any other medical professional but I do think non attendance should be charged (unless there is justification). It is easy enough to cancel if you can't attend and perhaps the service would become more efficient if all available appointments were actually used.

My idea: set up a service where every DNA gets a fine notice, with an opportunity to state a reason for the non-attendance, in mitigation.

You'd get Booker-prize winning fiction in response, but they'd be much more wary of DNA'ing next time, and word would get out. You'd only have to actively run this for a year or so.

The problem is ensuring patients actually receive the appointment time.

Mobile? No one under 40 answers a mobile unless they're 100% sure of who's on the other end. And tbh, many staff clerking arrivals (often older people themselves) get the number wrong. Too many/too few digits.

Text? As above.

Email? Possibly, but with a 'please respond in order to confirm your attendance'.

But we ran a system in Queensland 20 years ago for (hen's teeth) MRI appointments where pts had to confirm receipt of appointment. But the number we'd contact, 24 hrs prior, who actually weren't going to turn up at all, it transpires, was shocking.

Twiglets1 · 12/01/2023 19:22

babsanderson · 12/01/2023 18:36

@dollymixtured How much do you earn?
I did once get antibiotics I could not pay for. I just ticked I was entitled although I was not. I needed them.

I understand you felt you had no choice at the time as you needed the antibiotics but they do spot checks apparently and if they find someone ticked the box but wasn't entitled to free prescriptions they can fine you up to 5 times the cost of the prescription - so not advisable for other people to do

www.nhsbsa.nhs.uk/nhs-penalty-charges-and-enquiry-letters

shatteredmama · 12/01/2023 19:18

No. Thin end of the wedge. Tories are trying to dismantle the NHS bit by bit and privatise healthcare. Don’t give them a helping hand. It’s a terrible idea.

dollymixtured · 12/01/2023 19:15

Havanananana · 12/01/2023 19:11

"As someone of 58, I can recall when the NHS was the envy of the world and with the right approach and investment, it could be again."

This is something worth repeating. The NHS was once excellent, GPs were accessible, waiting lists far shorter than they are today and for their time, hospitals were at the cutting edge of medicine and technology.

Successive governments, but particularly Conservative governments, have failed to ensure that expenditure and investment have kept pace with the increased and changing demands on the NHS. Changes in technology, changes in the age and medical profile of the population, changes in the attitude of the public to healthcare - these major changes have hardly been addressed by the politicians, and where they have been addressed (e.g. by Lansley or Hunt) the politicians concerned have somehow managed to make spectacularly wrong decisions at the wrong time.

"there should be a sliding scale based on income"

There is - it is called taxation. Those who earn more pay more in tax and more in National Insurance. However in a universal healthcare system this does not give them priority over those who pay less tax or NI.

Out of interest when was this golden age you are referring to?

AncientQuercus · 12/01/2023 19:13

DizzyRascal · 12/01/2023 12:24

My concern is that if charges were introduced in the UK, primary care would go the same way as dental care.

That's exactly it. Currently if you are poor, you can't afford to maintain your teeth. We have gone backwards- full circle to the poor having rotten and missing teeth.
All healthcare will be the same and it won't be pretty.

Yes to this. They are already aware that there is a huge link between bad teeth and heart disease. There are no dentists in our area taking new NHS patients at all, and I put off seeing the Hygienist pre Covid due to the cost, only to find we then couldn't see anyone at all for over 2 years.

It took 7 visits to my GP before they grudgingly referred me to a specialist and found out I did actually have cancer. Would they have to refund the £140 in your scenario?

The people most often at the GP are young children and elderly people, both of whom would be exempt, so what exactly is the point?

Havanananana · 12/01/2023 19:11

"As someone of 58, I can recall when the NHS was the envy of the world and with the right approach and investment, it could be again."

This is something worth repeating. The NHS was once excellent, GPs were accessible, waiting lists far shorter than they are today and for their time, hospitals were at the cutting edge of medicine and technology.

Successive governments, but particularly Conservative governments, have failed to ensure that expenditure and investment have kept pace with the increased and changing demands on the NHS. Changes in technology, changes in the age and medical profile of the population, changes in the attitude of the public to healthcare - these major changes have hardly been addressed by the politicians, and where they have been addressed (e.g. by Lansley or Hunt) the politicians concerned have somehow managed to make spectacularly wrong decisions at the wrong time.

"there should be a sliding scale based on income"

There is - it is called taxation. Those who earn more pay more in tax and more in National Insurance. However in a universal healthcare system this does not give them priority over those who pay less tax or NI.

Twiglets1 · 12/01/2023 19:11

babsanderson · 12/01/2023 18:16

@Twiglets1 You need a review of your asthma. Using your inhaler every day is a sign of poorly controlled asthma.

I'm under the care of a specialist asthma nurse thank you for your concern. It is very well managed as I have a full life and work part time. I take a preventer inhaler every day to avoid asthma flare ups and it works very well. Also have a reliever inhaler for the odd occasions I feel breathless but don't need that one very often.

Hopefullyupwards · 12/01/2023 19:06

justanotherhappyflunkie · 12/01/2023 11:44

Under the scheme in the country I lived in, all low income, beneficiaries and long term ill/ disabled people were either seen free of charge or heavily discounted. It's not my proposal! Just an experience I have had which some people I spoke to agreed they would be keen to see it implemented here.

I think the idea (however flawed) would be to make it easier for those who really need the system rather than it being blocked by missed appointments or those who could wait to see if their cold/flu passes without the need for a GP.

I think it depends on where the threshold is. Someone on a low income or with low disposable income, but not on benefits, may struggle / someone unable to work due to recent illness that has caused secondary issues e.g. post covid may already be struggling financially. There's also the issue of not enough GPs anyway. If everyone that needed access could realistically get it, then maybe.