Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask if you would pay for GP visits

665 replies

justanotherhappyflunkie · 12/01/2023 11:36

Been talking with various friends who all agree they would rather pay a nominal sum to see a GP rather than the current system.

I have lived in a country that does this (free for children, disabled people, discounts for beneficiaries and long term sickness) and it was great. Same day appointments, good range of doctors, quick referrals.

The UK equivalent of this would be around £20 per visit.

AIBU to suggest it is the system that could help the NHS? prepares for a flaming!

OP posts:
monitor1 · 13/01/2023 14:40

babsanderson · 12/01/2023 12:10

And forget about any check ups. No way am I paying £20 for a smear test or my blood tests I have because of the medication I take. I will take my chances.

If patients won't have monitoring bloods that are needed then eventually we just refuse to prescribe as it isn't safe.

monitor1 · 13/01/2023 14:38

just realised you might be using the word visit as an appointment rather than a home visit

even so in the private sector this is charged at upwards of £100

monitor1 · 13/01/2023 14:37

A visit including travel can easily take half an hour or an hour. I wouldn't be doing that for £20! Private GP home visits run at upwards of £300 in London

gogodoc.com/pricing/
www.one5.health/doctor-home-visits-london

JustDanceAddict · 13/01/2023 14:31

Yes if I could see a GP face to face.

Havanananana · 13/01/2023 14:30

"There’s a ridiculous misunderstand of NI here. It doesn’t insure you! It doesn’t pay for the NHS. It used to be thought it paid for pensions. It’s not an insurance. It’s tax. If goes into the taxation income pot like every other tax. So how we fund the NHS is not ring fenced."

But the original intention was that National Insurance would be just that - an insurance that would cover the cost of healthcare and pensions. Amongst older people (i.e. aged 65+) there is no "misunderstanding". They paid NI and accepted increases in these contributions on the clear understanding that the government was promising a social contract and would ensure that the health service and pensions were protected. The parents of this generation had hardly had either - vilification of the poor continued right up until WW2 and workhouses were only abolished after the Labour Party introduced the National Assistance act of 1948, only 75 years ago.

FWIW, this is exactly how the central European systems work. Along with their employers, people pay a percentage of their salary into a Mutual healthcare fund which is ringfenced and another percentage into a pension fund, which is likewise ringfenced.

There has been much legislation in the UK to prevent private employers from running off with the Company Pension Fund (cf Maxwell and the Daily Mirror fund that left pensioners penniless) but governments of all persuasions seem happy to either raid the NI pot or at least not a) ringfence it and b) top it up to the required level. The Conservatives are back to their basic mantra, the one that began with the Elizabethan Poor Laws of 600 years ago (which were not totally abolished until 1948) that assumes that the poor are degenerate skivers and treats them accordingly.

lieselotte · 13/01/2023 14:14

Twiglets1 · 12/01/2023 17:10

Lots of people do currently still miss appointments. I get a message from my surgery every month reminding people not to miss appointments and stating how many have done so that month - it's always dozens.

I am not convinced. If people are missing "appointments", it's telephone appointments, which unless they are for a specific time, are not appointments.

Phoning someone at a random time, when they may be working, on the loo, or driving, is not an appointment. If a GP says they'll call you eg between 4 and 4.30 and you're not there, that's a missed appointment, but not a random call.

MarshaBradyo · 13/01/2023 10:52

Raspberry290 · 13/01/2023 10:25

I would but many couldn’t afford it so it’s just another thing I’d end up subsidising others for which I would resent

It’d probably massively annoy both ends - those who don’t want to subsidise others and those who think it’s a slippery slope to dismantling NHS

Hanschenklein · 13/01/2023 10:31

@FatEaredFuck exactly. Sadly the people of the UK are so bl**dy predictable. A relentless feed of negative articles about the NHS from the same old sources and already the gullible population is being nudged in the right direction to thinking it's time to get rid. You can see the similarities between the rhetoric about the 'EU fat cats in Brussels jumping on the gravy train' and 'the lazy inefficient NHS managers/ NHS is a black hole' stuff that's being spouted.
I commented on an innocent facebook post the other day about the NHS.
It was a photo of smiling nurses in starched uniforms from the 70s. Many of the posts were derogatory about nurses - fat, lazy, uncaring- but most were about NHS diversity managers earning £100k and absolutely clueless about the management structure. Now I might be paranoid but that very subject was a thread a few weeks ago on MN and then picked up by the DM. Funny that 🙄 and telling how the anti NHS rhetoric is slowly but surely finding its audience.

Raspberry290 · 13/01/2023 10:25

I would but many couldn’t afford it so it’s just another thing I’d end up subsidising others for which I would resent

Lindtcat · 13/01/2023 10:05

If I could afford it I would, I have a multitude of health issues so I see my GP a lot. Always have great service.

FatEaredFuck · 13/01/2023 10:03

YABU.

I absolutely fucking wouldnt. I will join the rioters.

They've Already fucked up dentistry - no more slippery slope for general health.

Hanschenklein · 13/01/2023 10:01

Asking people to pay more is always hard, some do already or twice and it’s usually for benefit of another group.
Well yes but in the case of the current government it's been for the benefit of the super rich rather than the vulnerable or even the just scraping bys.

Kinnorafron · 13/01/2023 09:33

Would gladly pay if it means I can actually see a GP.

Pleasepleasepleaseno · 13/01/2023 09:31

MarshaBradyo · Today 09:26

Asking people to pay more is always hard, some do already or twice and it’s usually for benefit of another group.

I feel a bit ‘government fund more’ re everything just means some taxpayers pay more.

Agreed. And in my opinion the biggest change is that over 60s should not get everything free automatically. Obviously if they're on pension credit they should but why otherwise? Many are still working or are on large pensions with more disposable income than younger people yet they don't pay NI on their pension and don't pay for prescriptions. But they are the biggest cost to the NHS.

MarshaBradyo · 13/01/2023 09:26

Asking people to pay more is always hard, some do already or twice and it’s usually for benefit of another group.

I feel a bit ‘government fund more’ re everything just means some taxpayers pay more.

Brefugee · 13/01/2023 09:25

There’s a ridiculous misunderstand of NI here. It doesn’t insure you! It doesn’t pay for the NHS. It used to be thought it paid for pensions. It’s not an insurance. It’s tax. If goes into the taxation income pot like every other tax. So how we fund the NHS is not ring fenced. Also retired people do not pay it. Hence their belief “they have paid in and now deserve the benefits”.

but the basic premise of paying tax and NI all your working life is that you get a pension and healthcare at the end of it. So yes, Tax and NI pays for the NOW, but that is the generational social contract. You can't suddenly now tell pensioners "sorry, mate, it all went in the general pot, now you have to fend for yourself"

TizerorFizz · 13/01/2023 09:21

I don’t believe any government here has tried to dismantle it. If they have, they have failed.

There’s a ridiculous misunderstand of NI here. It doesn’t insure you! It doesn’t pay for the NHS. It used to be thought it paid for pensions. It’s not an insurance. It’s tax. If goes into the taxation income pot like every other tax. So how we fund the NHS is not ring fenced. Also retired people do not pay it. Hence their belief “they have paid in and now deserve the benefits”. That’s simply wrong. It needs to be a tax paid by all if they pay income tax. Applied to 18 year olds and 98 year olds. Obviously retired people have no employer contribution, but health care isn’t linked to work is it?

The other alternative is to allow people not to pay NI upon retirement but to use that money for basic health insurance. I respect the posters above regarding other systems but they have more money in their health systems than we do. We also have a lowering tax take due to early retirement and self employed not paying income tax. So we need a bigger overhaul in the medium term. People are not paying what they could. I exclude young families from this by the way or anyone who is generally struggling.

Brefugee · 13/01/2023 09:14

For clarity, the "Bismark" system in place in Germany and much of central Europe is based on insurance Mutual Societies rather than commercial health insurance companies

thanks, i forgot to explain that part. A lot of my American colleagues are surprised by this side of it.

Havanananana · 13/01/2023 08:57

"It's a bit more complicated here in Germany. Everyone is entitled (required) to have health insurance via one of the official health insurance companies."

For clarity, the "Bismark" system in place in Germany and much of central Europe is based on insurance Mutual Societies rather than commercial health insurance companies. These Societies exist solely for the benefit of the members (i.e. the people paying in the insurance contributions) rather than being focussed on making a profit for their shareholders. This is a very different form of health insurance to the discriminatory American system.

As @Brefugee explains, insurance contributions are compulsory and are paid by both employees and employers, which is not unlike the UK National Insurance system. One major difference is that these contributions are ringfenced for healthcare. Contributions are a straight percentage of earnings. Those who are not earning (e.g. students, chronically ill, unemployed) have their contributions paid by the State. Pensioners also pay contributions. Just as for employees, pensioners pay a percentage of their "earnings" - so someone only receiving a State pension pays less than someone who has "earnings" from a State pension, a company or private pension, and investment income.

Private health insurance is available, but where I live in Europe, hardly anyone has it. Why would they when they can see a GP just by walking in, see a Consultant within a week or two, have minor surgery within a few weeks, and get a free "MOT" health check every year.

After WW2, when these countries were rebuilding and becoming prosperous again, the governments decided that the standard of healthcare should be the same as that previously only available to those who could afford it. In the UK, the post-war Labour government set up the NHS with similar intentions, and for the last 70 years, the Conservatives (who voted against creating the NHS) have tried their best to dismantle it.

Brefugee · 13/01/2023 08:25

Insurance schemes pay 23% of German health costs

It's a bit more complicated here in Germany. Everyone is entitled (required) to have health insurance via one of the official health insurance companies. Unemployed, students etc are automatically enrolled into the AOK which is the biggest. Once you are on a certain income level (I think around EUR 6,000 per month?) you can use a private health insurance company and are a private patient with the perks that gives (you pay upfront for everything and are reimbursed).

For everyone who doesn't use that system you pay a percentage of your income (around 13%) to the health insurance, which is matched by your employer. The market was deregulated a few (20?) years ago so there are more providers and you have more choice. But the old providers are still there, and certain trades often have/had their own. For healthcare workers, miners etc. They were good (still are) because they offer the benefits, say, that miners might need in particular.

In effect it works like the NHS. It has problems (we have a shortage of beds in many places for eg) and i can always get an appointment when i need one. You go to a specialist for some things, you have to be referred to a specialst by your GP for others. So if you have a baby, you register with a paediatrician. Women choose an OB/GYN and go for all their womanly related health needs directly there. Ditto dentists. When i had shoulder trouble, i found my own orthapedic practice - and there were some treatments not covered by health insurance that i could add on (steroid injections for EUR 35 which pretty much fixed me after one time).

Incientally: my children were covered by my health insurance until they left school at 18 and either earned their own money (apprenticeship) or went to uni. Every visit, everything from birth, through check-ups, vaccinations, accidents everything. And when they had braces? we paid upfront (ouch) and then got 90% for DC1 and 95% for DC2 after treatment was completed. That stops people breaking the treatment off for sure.

Happyvalleyfan · 13/01/2023 08:12

PFI is appalling - bleeding the NHS for private profit

Someone was telling me about a quote to put in a couple of hooks to hang up a picture in a PFI hospital (would be fined if did themselves) -£45!!

Draconis · 13/01/2023 08:11

I don't think it's a bad idea but not £20.
It should be £5.

MarshaBradyo · 13/01/2023 08:04

TizerorFizz · 12/01/2023 23:44

PFI payments and big payments to NHS staff under Labour have all caused issues in the years since. It hasn’t been great for decades. Labour brought in PFI to replace dire buildings. But look at the cost! That’s led to a reduction of beds. There was meant to be care in the community until it went missing.

We have an aging population. People need more healthcare. Those who can afford insurance should be incentivized to get it. I believe they do that in France. I heard you pay extra tax or take out insurance. Insurance schemes pay 23% of German health costs. We need a rethink. It’s not just about GP services. My health policy covers gp services. I rarely see a GP but DD has had to use the private one to get something seen to. I’m loath to pay more tax to this NHS behemoth. It’s past it’s sell by date and it needs reform. Every good idea needs to modernise eventuality.

I agree on PFI and I’m glad it’s being talked about more as we’re still paying now.

We have a system where low users generally pay more. People ask for change as they see better results elsewhere

I probably wouldn’t overhaul system but take elements from others eg some do tax rebate for private but as much as that’s fine in other countries I think it would be people up in arms here.

I’m ok with a bit more NI for social care but not just massive hikes for everything as it loads more on low users

Pillowjoy · 13/01/2023 08:02

I do pay. I live in Ireland, and it’s €60 per visit. I’m happy with it, after nearly 25 years in different parts of England under the NHS, it’s been an (unexpectedly) better experience, even throughout Covid — I can almost always get a same-day appointment at a time I can make, with my specific doctor, whereas at my last GP surgery in the Midlands a next appointment was often two or three weeks away, and the only alternative was to start queueing on the street before eight am for a surgery opening at 8.30, and you could still be waiting till 11 or later to see any doctor. At my surgery, that often meant sitting in a waiting room that contained people who were obviously ill or in pain alongside the regular lonely/time wasters. For whom I felt and feel, obviously, but it wasn’t a helpful situation, and meant I only went to the GP if desperate.

Paying, at least in my experience, has meant a better experience, and better care. Relatedly or unrelatedly, a longterm condition that had a big negative impact on my life and which the NHS was unhelpful about, has been solved here via several minor surgeries and some thinking outside the box — all on public (free) system, during Covid.

Spendonsend · 13/01/2023 08:01

I would, but being honest Id expect an improvement in service and i think it would increase demand as if I could pay I'd go more often, although that might be offset by those who'd go less often due to affordability which seems a bit immoral that i can now go for my minor issue but someone with something bigger might not.

I think the issue is there arent enough doctors and I dont know that paying nominal sums would rapidly increase the number of doctors around to make it function.