Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask if you would pay for GP visits

665 replies

justanotherhappyflunkie · 12/01/2023 11:36

Been talking with various friends who all agree they would rather pay a nominal sum to see a GP rather than the current system.

I have lived in a country that does this (free for children, disabled people, discounts for beneficiaries and long term sickness) and it was great. Same day appointments, good range of doctors, quick referrals.

The UK equivalent of this would be around £20 per visit.

AIBU to suggest it is the system that could help the NHS? prepares for a flaming!

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Dis626 · 26/01/2023 18:32

I'm not on a low income, but I'm a lone parent and my outgoings are high (childcare, mortgage etc). I would absolutely struggle to pay this. I've not had the funds to pay for prescriptions in the past. I hate this idea that only people on benefits are struggling.

cptartapp · 26/01/2023 18:28

Helen901 · 26/01/2023 12:44

I already via my NI contributions however i do feel that if you miss an appt there should be a charge

I had two DNA's today. One was an 88 year old lady, the other a 28 year old man.
Would you charge them both?

Helen901 · 26/01/2023 12:44

I already via my NI contributions however i do feel that if you miss an appt there should be a charge

OutForBreakfast · 26/01/2023 12:25

@elliejjtiny Those teams exist. They have suffered cuts.
There used to be other teams as well like fall prevention teams. If someone elderly was taken to hospital after a fall the falls prevention team would support them to prevent future falls. They also took referrals from GPS etc. Falls take up a lot of emergency resources and sometimes simple measures like physio or even installing better lighting in hallways or a hand rail can prevent any falls happening.
But psychiatric community nurses, crisis team, respiratory nurses, cancer nurses, cardiac nurses all exist. They are often just as hard to get hold of as GPs though.

GelPens1 · 26/01/2023 12:17

YABU!! I pay enough in National Insurance and tax every month! £700 a month goes straight from my employer to the government.

elliejjtiny · 26/01/2023 12:11

I'm wondering if it would help to have a team of specialist nurses, kind of like health visitors but for other groups of people like the elderly, people with mental health issues and other groups of people who tend to use the gp a lot. They could take the pressure off the g p's and maybe do self care, preventative advice and routine health checks. I know the practice nurses do some of this stuff but I'm thinking of a more specialist role. I was just thinking that if we had a kind of facility where you could get an appointment and have reassurance and advice when needed then there would be less people giving up on the gp surgery and going straight to a and e. Also maybe having the option to take "being an adult" as a GCSE subject instead of subjects that most adults will never need again. They could learn about healthy lifestyle, when it's appropriate to use a and e, budgeting skills etc.

elliejjtiny · 26/01/2023 11:54

I think part of the problem is we are used to our healthcare being free now. If you watch the earlier series of call the midwife, people were used to paying for their healthcare or not getting it if they couldn't afford it. So they were grateful for free healthcare, even if it wasn't that great or there was a long waiting list. Now, we are used to free healthcare. If someone suddenly introduced paying for GP appointments then people would expect a better service for their money. And let's face it, if the only people being charged are the people who pay for their prescriptions, the amount of money saved is going to be minimal. The people who use the gp the most are not paying for their prescriptions.

Badbadbunny · 26/01/2023 11:31

Ineedwinenow · 25/01/2023 14:30

I’m not sure what the answer is to be honest, I’d happily pay to see the doctor if the care was better but I do understand something needs to happen to the ones that don’t show up, maybe taking a small fee out of their wages/benefits at source would make people think!

If they miss appointments and can’t be arsed to turn up then they clearly aren’t sick enough and should be fined, how hard is it to cancel an appointment if you don’t need it 🙄

It can be surprisingly hard to cancel an appointment. If they don't have an online booking system (many still don't), you can't just click to cancel. You then need to phone up, and end up 57th in the queue or just cut off.

Even if you manage to get through, there's no certainty they'll actually cancel your appointment. I once had two appointments the same afternoon, one for our DS and then another for me around an hour later. A couple of days before, I phoned to cancel DS's appointment and re-arranged it for the following week, but when I turned up for my own, the doctor gave me an ear bashing for DS failing to attend an hour earlier - I pointed out that I'd cancelled it and told her to check next week's diary to see the new appointment, which she did, and it was there, but she never apologised for the practice error of not cancelling his original appointment!

As for cancelling or changing a hospital appointment, that's a whole new level of pain, as when you call the number on the appointment letter (if it's not a disconnected number that it), you just get an answering machine, and leave a message, but they never get back to you, so you have to keep trying at random times to try to find a time/day when there's someone working who may actually answer the phone. (Ignored answerphone messages has happened many times!)

AttentionAll · 25/01/2023 14:49

@Ineedwinenow Actually they are sometimes the sickest patients. If you are badly ill with a chronic issue you often have multiple appointments alongside tiredness and difficulty concentrating. It is very easy to get mixed up.

Ineedwinenow · 25/01/2023 14:30

I’m not sure what the answer is to be honest, I’d happily pay to see the doctor if the care was better but I do understand something needs to happen to the ones that don’t show up, maybe taking a small fee out of their wages/benefits at source would make people think!

If they miss appointments and can’t be arsed to turn up then they clearly aren’t sick enough and should be fined, how hard is it to cancel an appointment if you don’t need it 🙄

cosmiccosmos · 25/01/2023 14:30

I already pay for the NHS through my taxes.

I would prefer it to be as it us now, free but there is an option to go private if you want to.

Regardless of ability to pay there should be a fine for not attending for regular offenders. The NHS needs reform, individuals need to take more responsibility for themselves. Throwing money at it isn't a long term fix.

AttentionAll · 25/01/2023 14:26

@carmenitapink My family would not. My DH and I both work full time and just above minimum wage. We would move on from being the ones with poor teeth to the ones with untreated medical problems.

AttentionAll · 25/01/2023 14:24

@Badbadbunny The private sector are not more efficient if they have the same money as the NHS. I am amazed anyone still argues this after the various private sector debacles.

carmenitapink · 25/01/2023 14:23

RedCarsGoFaster · 12/01/2023 11:41

I can afford to pay that. My best friend with her chronic ill health, disability and extremely low income, surviving without heating this winter on PIP and UC would have to try not to eat for a week each month to furnish that payment.

No. The NHS can't afford to make people pay. It will also result in higher deaths with unidentified cancers, diseases etc because someone can't scrape £20 together for an appointment.

Need an emergency appointment? Not got £20 because it's not payday for a few days? Tough! Suck up that infection and pray you don't develop sepsis.

Terrible idea.

Your friend would likely be one of those who would qualify for a free appointment...

AttentionAll · 25/01/2023 14:22

@Badbadbunny Specsavers take shortcuts. There need to be appointments for adjustments. The initial appointment is to check if the person needs a hearing aid or some other medical intervention. My gran was rejected at this stage and referred for other treatment that worked. Specsavers would have just fitted a hearing aid.

Using an example of the private sector taking shortcuts as being more efficient really does not stack up. And my local specsavers does it in two appointments and three if you go back for adjustments. So locally all they are cutting out is the initial consultation to see if a hearing aid is appropriate or you need some other intervention. Specsavers do not have qualified enough staff available to offer this anyway.

Badbadbunny · 25/01/2023 14:20

AttentionAll · 25/01/2023 14:18

@Badbadbunny They get the easy cases. My DP needs a double appointment example for simple tests such as a scan as he is disabled and so everything takes longer. A cataract operation would mean him being sent to the NHS as it would take twice as long as an able bodied patient. The private sector want the easy cases.

Yes, but the NHS still do the "easy" things in a convoluted, difficult and inefficient manner. If private providers can do the easy stuff quicker and more efficient, why can't the NHS do it the same way? But, you're missing the point really, my point was in answer to someone who said fewer people would get treated in total if there was more private, but I pointed out that greater efficiency in the private sector could mean more people being treated.

AttentionAll · 25/01/2023 14:18

@Badbadbunny They get the easy cases. My DP needs a double appointment example for simple tests such as a scan as he is disabled and so everything takes longer. A cataract operation would mean him being sent to the NHS as it would take twice as long as an able bodied patient. The private sector want the easy cases.

Badbadbunny · 25/01/2023 14:15

AttentionAll · 25/01/2023 14:03

The private sector is more efficient as they see largely well patients with one medical issue. They do not see elderly patients with multiple medical issues that are more complex and take longer to treat. Because private medical treatment for these type of patients is out of reach except for the very wealthiest.

Where the private sector do NHS work, such as cataract operations or hearing aids, they are still more efficient.

I get my hearing tests and hearing aids from Specsavers now. In and out in one appointment with follow ups/adjustments as and when you request it.

That's SO different from when I used the NHS audiology dept- there was an initial consultation, then a few weeks later, the hearing test, then a few weeks later another appointment to be "fitted" with the hearing aids, and then another appointment a few weeks later for them to be "adjusted" to the right settings. So the NHS took 4 appointment over a couple of months to do what Specsavers do in a single visit.

It's also a lot easier to get batteries, replacement tubes/domes, etc from Specsavers and to get setting adjustments done!

JenniferBooth · 25/01/2023 14:14

And yet there will still be moaning and whining when there are no family members (read women)
to provide unpaid care so elderly relatives can be discharged from hospital. Because those family members will be working until 68

AttentionAll · 25/01/2023 14:03

The private sector is more efficient as they see largely well patients with one medical issue. They do not see elderly patients with multiple medical issues that are more complex and take longer to treat. Because private medical treatment for these type of patients is out of reach except for the very wealthiest.

RumandSpinach · 25/01/2023 13:56

TizerorFizz · 25/01/2023 08:32

Only if you are very young. But you still have a much better pension than many others paid for partially by the state. And early retirement that many take. And lots of opportunities for part time working. And a top salary of £90,000 to aim for. Lots to look forward to!

I'm on the 2015 scheme and I'm 33.

Very kind of the state to fund my pension which now has an NPA of 68 for a physically demanding and risky job. My colleagues doing a less demanding equilivent private job receive a generous pension plus 10k in their annual salary, but nevermind that.

90k is for a chief executive. How many per Trust do you reckon there are of those?

Badbadbunny · 25/01/2023 13:36

@knitnerd90

Private care is lower volume: the doctors typically see fewer patients per day. So when doctors switch to working privately, the total number of patients seen will drop.

That assumes efficiency is equal between private and NHS, which in my experience isn't the case at all. The NHS seems to waste a lot of time and appointments due to foul ups and other inefficiency. I.e. it can take 2,3 or 4 visits to a GP (of course, a different one each time) to get a proper diagnosis/treatment of a condition, yet a private GP appointment time is longer so they can be more thorough and more likely to get the right diagnosis/treatment in the first consultation, or if not, then the second, as you'd probably see the same GP so there'd be continuation of care etc.

Likewise with other services such as MRI scans. OH who has bone cancer needed 4 attempts to get an MRI scan as the referral instruction was wrong for the first 3 (or the radiographer just read it wrong or did it wrong). Anyway, he was called back 3 further times before the oncologist got the scan she wanted. The next time, OH went private as he really struggled with the tube and found a private firm who did the sit up/open scanner - they did the right scan first time.

If the private sector is more efficient, either by better admin/management or more time per appointment, then healthcare professionals are more likely to get it right first time, and thus treat more patients than the NHS, due to not having the same volume of "wasted" appointments due to inefficiency.

AttentionAll · 25/01/2023 10:38

@TizerorFizz There are lots of people off long term sick. Run down the NHS and this is what happens.

MichelleScarn · 25/01/2023 09:07

TizerorFizz · 24/01/2023 12:07

Also, as in education, the better off would pay twice. NI should be paid by all taxed individuals. Not just those in employment. NI does not solely pay for the NHS. We have a complex system of taxation and expenditure. We need to spend what we have wisely as so many people are not working at all snd this number is increasing. Too many not in the workforce at all but still using services.

Righto @TizerorFizz so you want those you see as 'better off' as they have an income from working (from your perspective as a retiree) as clogging the system should they use the nhs or state education?

So many of this view but the caveat always seems to be 'better off than MEEEE, of course'. And anyone who questions the fairness of this of course gets the emotive 'YOU WANT PEOPLE TO DIE DONT YOU!!'

Rummikub · 25/01/2023 08:50

I think it’s is a slippery slope. Like when tuition fees were first introduced it was £3k/ year now it’s over £9k/year.

Swipe left for the next trending thread