Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think GCSEs are ridiculously hard?

135 replies

donpanicme · 12/01/2023 11:17

DD did pretty mediocre in her mocks and has asked me to help her revise. We’ve been working through the sciences and geography and OMG it’s so hard. There’s so much to learn in each subject for a start and it’s actually pretty complicated stuff like ions, relative atomic mass, mitosis. Honestly, I don’t know how she’s going to get though it all and remember it in order to do well. How on earth do kids do it?

OP posts:
MilkyYay · 12/01/2023 12:27

The problem with GCSE's it's too many subjects and teens aren't actually interested in half of them. It's all about getting the grade rather than learning something simply because it's interesting or important to know.

Well no, its about them learning this material so that we have an educated workforce to supply the labour we need. We aren't making kids do GCSEs for the fun of it!

PinkFrogss · 12/01/2023 12:27

YANBU OP, I think what many are missing when they compare it to O levels is that not everyone was expected to complete O Levels, there were also CSEs. Everyone does GCSEs so it should be accessible to everyone.

Also the number of subjects, many teenagers at DDs school did 10 or 11 GCSEs.

I think people just look for an excuse to bash the younger generation, you see it a lot on MN unfortunately

TeenDivided · 12/01/2023 12:25

I did O levels. DD1 did unreformed GCSEs in '15 but just near the end when modular exams and most coursework were gone, but there were still significant controlled assessments. DD2 did (or didn't) reformed GCSEs in '21.

My view:

  1. You shouldn't compare O levels, which only the top 20-40% sat with GCSEs which are meant to be accessible for all.
  2. The reformed GCSEs have more content to learn than the unreformed ones, plus they have more exams - DD1 sat 13 exams, DD2 was due to sit 20, and most actually have more than that.
  3. In my opinion, the reformed science is as hard as the old O level, especially as most pupils do all 3 sciences either as the dual award or individually.
  4. Mainly they aren't 'easier' they are different. History requires very different skills than way back.
  5. GCSEs are very challenging for less able kids and imo aren't really fit for purpose as a block any more for them. Especially the amount of exams turns everything into an endurance test more than anything else.
  6. Schools should somehow be encouraged and funded to provide more BTECs or something for more pupils as in the past.
PauliString · 12/01/2023 12:22

Oakbeam · 12/01/2023 12:20

I found maths harder than my GCSE 30 years ago- DS definitely covered things in GCSE which I did for A level.

I found it to be the other way round. For example, I did calculus at 0 level whereas now it only seems to be covered at A.

...with log tables to look up, Oakbeam?

MilkyYay · 12/01/2023 12:22

Could you be given 25 hours of content a week for two years and then remember 65% of it at the end? That’s 1950hours over the two years of teaching time, so 1267hours worth of facts?

Well yes, given that i got A* in most of mine and As in A level followed by a degree and a 3 year post grad professional qualification. To be fair i also did my homework and revision but at gcse i definitely didn't go mad on either of those, i remember gcse revision featuring a lot of breaks!!

Needmorelego · 12/01/2023 12:21

@Rowthe the coursework could be worked on in school during lessons.
@MilkyYay people remember facts about things they are interested in. The problem with GCSE's it's too many subjects and teens aren't actually interested in half of them. It's all about getting the grade rather than learning something simply because it's interesting or important to know.

Oakbeam · 12/01/2023 12:20

I found maths harder than my GCSE 30 years ago- DS definitely covered things in GCSE which I did for A level.

I found it to be the other way round. For example, I did calculus at 0 level whereas now it only seems to be covered at A.

MilkyYay · 12/01/2023 12:20

www.gov.uk/government/publications/infographic-gcse-results-2022/infographics-for-gcse-results-2022-accessible

the students I teach have to remember all of the content for that along with around 9 other subjects ready to regurgitate it all onto an exam paper at the end of a two year course. Some information they may not have gone over for two years.

And yet 1 in 3 kids in london is getting grade 7 & above, nearly 3/4 are getting a 4 and above.

If it gets any easier they'll all pass and it won't really be much of an achievement.

Mapletreelane · 12/01/2023 12:18

YANBU

When i see my DC16's homework I really struggle to believe I achieved As and Bs 30 odd years ago in my GCSEs. It is like an alien language.

To be honest I was stumped at Y5 maths during the pandemic. Had to remind myself I do have a maths GCSE.

WeepingSomnambulist · 12/01/2023 12:18

GracieLouFreeebush · 12/01/2023 12:16

Could you be given 25 hours of content a week for two years and then remember 65% of it at the end? That’s 1950hours over the two years of teaching time, so 1267hours worth of facts?

Um, yes. That's how I got top grade in all my exams. It is also how a lot of people are able to so their jobs.

Dancingbea · 12/01/2023 12:16

I think they are tough. History and geography has far more content and requires for history at least proper historical analysis than when I did gcse in 1992. The thing with science is that if you weren’t very good at it then you could just opt for single - I did biology - whereas now they all need to know something about physics and chemistry which is completely unfamiliar to many of us. I really don’t believe it’s all about regurgitating facts - even the RE exams have questions which require proper analysis and comparison that you can’t do just by learning facts.

GracieLouFreeebush · 12/01/2023 12:16

MilkyYay · 12/01/2023 12:12

They are really not that bad. Remember kids are in school 25 hours a week, 39 weeks a year learning all this content. Often the % needed to get a 5 is only about 65%, so a pupil can be dropping a third of the marks and still getting a "good pass".

They do need to present some challenge. If everyone could pass them easily with high grades they would become a qualification with basically no value.

Could you be given 25 hours of content a week for two years and then remember 65% of it at the end? That’s 1950hours over the two years of teaching time, so 1267hours worth of facts?

Fenella123 · 12/01/2023 12:16

Blimey, I remember doing the pre prepared Q and A for my language O levels in the 80s! For years I could explain the "green wave" traffic light synchronization system in German but not English ;)
I suspect you've just been busy and forgotten what it's like OP ;)

MilkyYay · 12/01/2023 12:16

Which kind of jobs are you given information and told to learn it and then not allowed to ever refer to the source of that information under pressure and then judged on your competence for said job based on that?

Loads. I'm an expert in a technical field and i can't sit in a board meeting and get a load of source materials out!!

I am regularly in meetings where I'm put on rhe spot and asked an urgent question and I need to be able to refer to complex content without nipping off to look it up first.

Rowthe · 12/01/2023 12:15

Needmorelego · 12/01/2023 11:29

They need to bring back the coursework. Relying on just the final exam (which is usually 3 exams per subject) is crazy.
Just look at the threads on here about how much revision needs to be done.
It just seems to be poor teens going over and over the same things again because they need to know it for the final exam.
If you have the coursework then stuff learned and worked on in the first term of Year 10 can be given a grade to go towards the final overall grade. But then essentially they don't need to worry about that part of the curriculum in as much detail again.
Obviously if they find the subject really interesting and plan to use that knowledge in future qualifications/jobs then they will remember it.
If not it will get filed in the part of the brain used for pub quizzes and playing Trivial Pursuit. Because let's face it - that's what most of what you learn in school is only useful for. Unless you use in a job it's mostly trivia.

Coursework will increasingly be phased out.

There are so many online options to cheat now. And difficult to catch plagiarism.

maddy68 · 12/01/2023 12:14

Tell her to go through loads of past papers using the mark schemes to help her get the right answers that will focus her revision

GracieLouFreeebush · 12/01/2023 12:14

ButterflyOil · 12/01/2023 12:11

Plus the exam only system is ridiculous in my view because so much of it relies on them remembering a huge range of information to parrot across so many subjects at once. So much of it also seems to be about memorising facts vs interpreting and analysing, critical thinking and so on.

It’s no wonder so many higher achievers at GCSE struggle at A level because the content and the way it’s taught seems so different. In the A levels it’s much more focused on applying the information.

What’s the use of being crammed full of facts and things to recall for 10 subjects if you’re not really taught how to use those facts? How can we honestly tell our kids that 100% exams in this way is vital for their future when in the real world you hardly ever have to use information in this way? Which kind of jobs are you given information and told to learn it and then not allowed to ever refer to the source of that information under pressure and then judged on your competence for said job based on that?

GCSEs are basically pointless exercises in pressurising young minds.

I agree with this completely. I refer to information in textbooks or online to assist in planning to teach my lessons, but the students I teach have to remember all of the content for that along with around 9 other subjects ready to regurgitate it all onto an exam paper at the end of a two year course. Some information they may not have gone over for two years.

MilkyYay · 12/01/2023 12:13

Also i laugh a bit when teens say they can't remember all this but question them on their favourite computer game and suddenly they are an expert with a superb memory.

WeepingSomnambulist · 12/01/2023 12:13

Scottish Standard Grades were harder. In difficulty level, GCSE's were behind standard grades. But then scottish kid's would do Highers and English kid's would do A levels, and A levels were considered to be just slightly above highers. Then we went on to advanced highers which were a bit above A levels.

There is no consistency!!

I dont know about nowadays with Scottish kids doing national 5s.

maddy68 · 12/01/2023 12:12

BBC bitesize is good

MilkyYay · 12/01/2023 12:12

They are really not that bad. Remember kids are in school 25 hours a week, 39 weeks a year learning all this content. Often the % needed to get a 5 is only about 65%, so a pupil can be dropping a third of the marks and still getting a "good pass".

They do need to present some challenge. If everyone could pass them easily with high grades they would become a qualification with basically no value.

ButterflyOil · 12/01/2023 12:11

Plus the exam only system is ridiculous in my view because so much of it relies on them remembering a huge range of information to parrot across so many subjects at once. So much of it also seems to be about memorising facts vs interpreting and analysing, critical thinking and so on.

It’s no wonder so many higher achievers at GCSE struggle at A level because the content and the way it’s taught seems so different. In the A levels it’s much more focused on applying the information.

What’s the use of being crammed full of facts and things to recall for 10 subjects if you’re not really taught how to use those facts? How can we honestly tell our kids that 100% exams in this way is vital for their future when in the real world you hardly ever have to use information in this way? Which kind of jobs are you given information and told to learn it and then not allowed to ever refer to the source of that information under pressure and then judged on your competence for said job based on that?

GCSEs are basically pointless exercises in pressurising young minds.

EssexMan55 · 12/01/2023 12:08

Seeline · 12/01/2023 12:02

They aren’t easier. That’s just something old people say to knock the younger generations down. I am a teacher so have seen when all of the content changed for Goves reform and it was made much harder.

Depends what you are comparing current exams to. Yes, Gove did make them harder, but compared to O levels, the old GSCEs were easier. I compared what my 2 DCs did (exams in 2020 and 2018) to my O levels, and as I said above, on balance I think the O levels were generally harder taking all things into account.

Even in the nineties GCSE were far easier than o levels.

I have seen o level physics papers with similar content to first undergraduate physics…

babsanderson · 12/01/2023 12:03

GCEs got easier, Gove made them harder again. People in the past did not get 9 A stars unless they were a genius.

Seeline · 12/01/2023 12:02

They aren’t easier. That’s just something old people say to knock the younger generations down. I am a teacher so have seen when all of the content changed for Goves reform and it was made much harder.

Depends what you are comparing current exams to. Yes, Gove did make them harder, but compared to O levels, the old GSCEs were easier. I compared what my 2 DCs did (exams in 2020 and 2018) to my O levels, and as I said above, on balance I think the O levels were generally harder taking all things into account.

Swipe left for the next trending thread