Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think GCSEs are ridiculously hard?

135 replies

donpanicme · 12/01/2023 11:17

DD did pretty mediocre in her mocks and has asked me to help her revise. We’ve been working through the sciences and geography and OMG it’s so hard. There’s so much to learn in each subject for a start and it’s actually pretty complicated stuff like ions, relative atomic mass, mitosis. Honestly, I don’t know how she’s going to get though it all and remember it in order to do well. How on earth do kids do it?

OP posts:
Badbadbunny · 12/01/2023 13:22

Greatly · 12/01/2023 13:10

I don't know. Does it matter? Personally I don't think it does.

It doesn't matter so much when comparing people who took exams around the same time. But it really DOES matter when comparing today's 20 year old against a 40 year old, both applying for the same job. Today's grade A was probably something like a grade C, 20 years ago, so the older applicant looks a lot worse on paper and may not even get through the initial screening process.

It also matters because a decade or two ago, someone with a string of As was really something special. Now it's commonplace. Employers need a way of selecting those with genuine ability. How do they do that when they get large numbers of applicants, all with A grades? It devalues the achievements of those at the top. Hence why every few years, there's either a new higher grade announced or a change in grading structure. Before long there'll be a grade 10 at GCSE or a 9 or 9+ to break up all those currently getting a 9. Likewise at A level, there'll be an A to break up those with As.

Furthermore, it makes it harder for Unis to select the most suitable applicants for their courses. It was almost unheard of for Unis to "require" an A* at A level, but now it's seen more and more as they get too many applicants with As that they need a new way of differentiating.

On a slightly different tangent, I also find it unhelpful that exams are graded according to a normal distribution curve, which means one year may need 90% to get an A*, the next year it may only need 85%, etc - so there's no comparison between years nor applicants who've done exams in different years. Yes, I know it's claimed to be due to "smooth out" variations in difficulty between years, but surely it would be better to set the questions properly so that each year is the same in terms of difficulty! It's how professional exams work - my accountancy exams had fixed pass marks year after year - the percentage required didn't change between years and strenuous efforts were put in place to ensure consistency of difficulty between years. Why can't that be done for GCSE and A Levels?

PinkFrogss · 12/01/2023 13:22

Stackss · 12/01/2023 13:14

GCSEs should be hard. The problem is too many DC and parents have an aversion to hard work and think that 10 minutes of looking over notes will cut it.

DC should have a tough revision schedule in place for evenings and weekends from the start of year 11. Those who do this will get good results- it’s not rocket science.

Why should they be hard? Every student has to sit them and pretty much all jobs require a GCSE pass in maths and English. Who does it serve to make them difficult? Many students who struggle with GCSEs are perfectly capable of many careers, why create Barrie’s towards them finally being able to succeed?

UsuallySuze · 12/01/2023 13:17

bellswithwhistles · 12/01/2023 13:07

If GCSES are harder, why do so many children get top top grades?

I did mine in 1990 (think we were the second year to do them) I went to a very able private school. There were about 15 girls out of 120 who got top grades (so 9 A's)..the rest of us got a mixture of As and Bs mainly.

Fast forward to 2005 and every single young person who worked for me got 9 A*s. All 10 of them. Trust me - they were not brighter than any child I was at school with. Not at all!

Same with degrees. Getting a first was a rarity. Now they hand them out like sweets!

Can't speak about 2005 but in 2022 just over 2000 kids in the entire country got straight 9s, from around a million students who sat the exams, so around 0.2%. They are not "handing them out like sweets"!

Stackss · 12/01/2023 13:14

GCSEs should be hard. The problem is too many DC and parents have an aversion to hard work and think that 10 minutes of looking over notes will cut it.

DC should have a tough revision schedule in place for evenings and weekends from the start of year 11. Those who do this will get good results- it’s not rocket science.

Badbadbunny · 12/01/2023 13:13

I don't think they're particularly "hard" as such. The kids have been learning for several hours per day for 5 years at secondary by the time they sit their exams. That's a lot of hours of teaching!

Yes, there's a lot of content that can potentially crop up in the exam, and lots of what the kids are taught doesn't appear. Perhaps the scope/breadth could be reduced, but the difficulty remains or increases so that then the exams have questions on a narrower range of knowledge, especially in, say, humanities subjects and perhaps English Lit, where the current breadth is quite ridiculous.

It's no surprise that the OP, as a parent, takes a quick look at an exam paper and thinks it's hard - they've not had the lessons, practice tests, revision sessions, etc, that the kids have had. Even if they'd done the subjects themselves 20/30 years ago, they'd have forgotten most of it and the syllabus will have changed so some of what parents learned for their GCSEs may have been removed and replaced with new topics.

I do think that teaching practices could be improved to help pupils though. My DS's school were known for their excellent history results at GCSE and A level. We were very impressed by the history lessons from literally the first week in year 7. They started with teaching bias, sources, intepretation, etc right from the first lesson, treated more importantly that content and learning of dates/facts, etc. They followed that through the school - barely any emphasis at all on learning dates/facts and constant practice on sources, i.e. diaries, illustrations, inscriptions, comparing one commentary of an event against another, etc., and also on the other "themes" of history exams such as cause & consequence etc. It was only in years 10 and 11 when they started learning "facts" as required for the looming GCSE exam, but they'd all got the core "skills" by that time that reading and understanding about the events to be examined was basically all they were doing, as they didn't need to learn exam technique, answering questions, etc that had been done to death in earlier years. It was a completely different way of teaching compared with my school days where it was all facts for the earlier years and then exam technique etc crammed in to the last few weeks before the exam!

babsanderson · 12/01/2023 13:10

Except language lab. That was an hour exam.

Greatly · 12/01/2023 13:10

bellswithwhistles · 12/01/2023 13:07

If GCSES are harder, why do so many children get top top grades?

I did mine in 1990 (think we were the second year to do them) I went to a very able private school. There were about 15 girls out of 120 who got top grades (so 9 A's)..the rest of us got a mixture of As and Bs mainly.

Fast forward to 2005 and every single young person who worked for me got 9 A*s. All 10 of them. Trust me - they were not brighter than any child I was at school with. Not at all!

Same with degrees. Getting a first was a rarity. Now they hand them out like sweets!

I don't know. Does it matter? Personally I don't think it does.

babsanderson · 12/01/2023 13:10

Needmorelego · 12/01/2023 13:06

@babsanderson I don't remember exams being that long. An hour? Maybe?

An hour! I have no idea how old you are but when I did exams there were all at least 2 hours, some up to 3 hours long. Your hand would be aching by the end.

bellswithwhistles · 12/01/2023 13:07

If GCSES are harder, why do so many children get top top grades?

I did mine in 1990 (think we were the second year to do them) I went to a very able private school. There were about 15 girls out of 120 who got top grades (so 9 A's)..the rest of us got a mixture of As and Bs mainly.

Fast forward to 2005 and every single young person who worked for me got 9 A*s. All 10 of them. Trust me - they were not brighter than any child I was at school with. Not at all!

Same with degrees. Getting a first was a rarity. Now they hand them out like sweets!

Needmorelego · 12/01/2023 13:06

@babsanderson I don't remember exams being that long. An hour? Maybe?

babsanderson · 12/01/2023 13:04

I thought exams in the past were longer than they are now?

Needmorelego · 12/01/2023 13:04

@GreetingsToTheNewBrunette that's part of the problem - it's several exam papers per subject.
My friends son sat 27 exam papers.
I took 6 GCSEs back in the mists of time.
2 were 100% coursework, 2 were a mix of coursework, end of module tests (which counted towards the final grade) and a final exam, 2 were fully exam only.
I vaguely remember there being 2 maths papers and 2 RS papers. 1 science paper - because we had done tests at the end of each module. There may have been a second paper. I can't remember.
French was split into reading, writing, listening, speaking but I remember the final exams as being short. We possibly did them at the same time so pretty much 1 exam.
So probably in total I sat about 5 or 6 exam papers.
I technically should have been taking 7 GCSEs. I dropped out of art because I struggled with it. That was 100% coursework though so still wouldn't have been any extra exams.
I can't imagine having to do 27 exam papers.

EffortlessDesmond · 12/01/2023 13:00

@GreetingsToTheNewBrunette Eight O levels was pretty normal. English Lit, English Lang, Maths and a modern language were compulsory; then a choice of academic subjects for the rest... in my case, Latin, German, History and Biology.

Several involved more than one paper. French had two written papers and a 15 minute oral; Latin prose, poetry and a grammar paper each of which involved translation from/to Latin.

There were five or six papers for A level English.

GreetingsToTheNewBrunette · 12/01/2023 12:52

How many o levels did you take though? I did GCSEs in 2015 and took 12 - for triple science that was 9 papers for just 3 GCSEs!

JaninaDuszejko · 12/01/2023 12:51

I have Highers from the 80s and my DC are doing GCSEs now so I can't compare like with like. But I'm a scientist and was talking to DD1 (y10) about my work and mentioned plasmids, and then started to explain what that is and she rolled her eyes and said 'I know what a plasmid is Mum'. Obviously it's the difference in the importance of molecular biology in 30 years but I distinctly remember learning about plasmids as an undergraduate and being pissed off that even bacteria were having sex when I wasn't! Generally I've been impressed with how they are teaching the subjects, most of the complaints in the press don't reflect our experiences. But the DDs are top set in a good school and are very engaged so tell us in detail about what they are doing which helps.

JudgeJ · 12/01/2023 12:49

UsuallySuze · 12/01/2023 11:34

I found maths harder than my GCSE 30 years ago- DS definitely covered things in GCSE which I did for A level. Perhaps it varies by board.

The Maths content now has elements that were not in GCSE or were at a higher level than when I was teaching 17 years ago. It seems to have happened as a response to the dumbing down of Maths during the 70s and 80s, when teachers were not allowed to teach tables, addition etc of fractions. I once heard a Head berating a supply teacher who was secondary trained for teaching tables and that was his wife!

EffortlessDesmond · 12/01/2023 12:48

O levels were aimed at people who would go on to A level and university. Everyone else took CSEs, which equated to the lowest grade O level if you scored a grade 1.

Anecdata, but I sent my 1972 Latin O level paper in to the teacher at DC's selective independent (at her request) and the feedback was that it would stretch today's AS level candidates. But of course, not many schools routinely teach Latin now.

LolaSmiles · 12/01/2023 12:43

Current GCSEs aren't unreasonable hard, but they are more difficult than the old GCSEs.The old GCSE content was much easier than old O Level content.

Greatly · 12/01/2023 12:42

PinkFrogss · 12/01/2023 12:31

I’m sure DDs weak grasp of French which means she can more or less say she has a sister and went to the cinema on the weekend is of great value to her work Wink

Ha ha same with my dd. The best we can say about French gcse is that she can understand some of what Timothee Chalamet says when he speaks French

Greatly · 12/01/2023 12:41

They are really hard OP, I agree.

I haven't read the thread but as this is mumsnet you'll no doubt get plenty of posts telling you how actually they are much easier 🤷🏼‍♀️

Needmorelego · 12/01/2023 12:37

@MilkyYay it's important to learn things. But not everything needs to have an exam and a grade.
Every (non Sen)16 year old that leaves school should be able to read, write and do maths.
That's the important stuff. Everyone should have a GCSE in those.
Other subjects are very important too. History is important so people can learn from the past. That is important to know in life - just look at the disaster that is Brexit. Many people had little clue of the history behind the EU - what it actually meant etc.
But what I meant is not everything should be about only learning it to get a GCSE out of it. Sometimes just learning something because it's important or interesting is all that's needed.
It's too just many different subjects that teens are meant to do.
Just too much.

TellMeWhere · 12/01/2023 12:34

I don't think they're too hard, no. A lot of it I don't know as I've forgotten, but considering kids are at school all day, they get plenty of time to learn this stuff.

I certainly recognise the science topics my stepkids are doing. There's been a few things in maths I have no recollection of, but that doesn't surprise me.

History is broadly similar.

Geography has moved with the times a bit.

English - they're still doing An Inspector Calls, which I did 20 years ago.

I agree that learning how to structure a proper essay answer is the hardest bit to learn.

There's so many online resources now. I didn't have a computer when I was doing GCSEs, so all I had was school books and revision guides.

PinkFrogss · 12/01/2023 12:31

MilkyYay · 12/01/2023 12:27

The problem with GCSE's it's too many subjects and teens aren't actually interested in half of them. It's all about getting the grade rather than learning something simply because it's interesting or important to know.

Well no, its about them learning this material so that we have an educated workforce to supply the labour we need. We aren't making kids do GCSEs for the fun of it!

I’m sure DDs weak grasp of French which means she can more or less say she has a sister and went to the cinema on the weekend is of great value to her work Wink

Sorefootouch · 12/01/2023 12:30

Well the problem in Scotland - as highlighted in the paper today - is that there are so many people getting A’s at higher that there is no means of differentiating between outstanding, good and mediocre students, and the kids from a deprived background are the ONLY ones getting into some courses as they are given a ‘leg up’ with widening access positive discrimination.

Make the exams as hard as possible seems the best option. Take the outstanding kids from private schools, the very good kids from average state schools and the good from deprived backgrounds. Making the exams easier so everyone gets an A is a disaster for everyone.

www.scotsman.com/news/politics/students-from-less-deprived-background-have-door-closed-to-university-due-to-snp-funding-approach-3983059

pinkflop · 12/01/2023 12:28

I think the amount they have to remember for each subject is far too much. And it seems they are taught something once and then expected to remember it.