Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think GCSEs are ridiculously hard?

135 replies

donpanicme · 12/01/2023 11:17

DD did pretty mediocre in her mocks and has asked me to help her revise. We’ve been working through the sciences and geography and OMG it’s so hard. There’s so much to learn in each subject for a start and it’s actually pretty complicated stuff like ions, relative atomic mass, mitosis. Honestly, I don’t know how she’s going to get though it all and remember it in order to do well. How on earth do kids do it?

OP posts:
GreetingsToTheNewBrunette · 12/01/2023 14:48

Yep, there were multiple exams for all my subjects too and we didn’t have coursework. Memorising quotes in Medieval English wasn’t my idea of fun 🙄

I think the main difference there’s an expectation to take at least 10 - 11 GCSEs that probably cover more than o levels did. Although I didn’t sit o levels so I don’t know 🤪

Don’t get me started on A Levels either my year was the first they got rid of AS levels so it all relied on the exams we sat in the second year (as well as coursework to be fair)

Greatly · 12/01/2023 14:37

Badbadbunny · 12/01/2023 13:22

It doesn't matter so much when comparing people who took exams around the same time. But it really DOES matter when comparing today's 20 year old against a 40 year old, both applying for the same job. Today's grade A was probably something like a grade C, 20 years ago, so the older applicant looks a lot worse on paper and may not even get through the initial screening process.

It also matters because a decade or two ago, someone with a string of As was really something special. Now it's commonplace. Employers need a way of selecting those with genuine ability. How do they do that when they get large numbers of applicants, all with A grades? It devalues the achievements of those at the top. Hence why every few years, there's either a new higher grade announced or a change in grading structure. Before long there'll be a grade 10 at GCSE or a 9 or 9+ to break up all those currently getting a 9. Likewise at A level, there'll be an A to break up those with As.

Furthermore, it makes it harder for Unis to select the most suitable applicants for their courses. It was almost unheard of for Unis to "require" an A* at A level, but now it's seen more and more as they get too many applicants with As that they need a new way of differentiating.

On a slightly different tangent, I also find it unhelpful that exams are graded according to a normal distribution curve, which means one year may need 90% to get an A*, the next year it may only need 85%, etc - so there's no comparison between years nor applicants who've done exams in different years. Yes, I know it's claimed to be due to "smooth out" variations in difficulty between years, but surely it would be better to set the questions properly so that each year is the same in terms of difficulty! It's how professional exams work - my accountancy exams had fixed pass marks year after year - the percentage required didn't change between years and strenuous efforts were put in place to ensure consistency of difficulty between years. Why can't that be done for GCSE and A Levels?

Presumably employers interview/set entrance tests and if it matters so much they should be aware a C 20 years ago is the equivalent of an A today (not sure it is actually, but still)

flimsyclam · 12/01/2023 14:15

@TeenDivided but that's what's happening. There are higher grades than ever?

Badbadbunny · 12/01/2023 14:14

@TeenDivided

I really don't think they are doing GCSE syllabus from y7 except obviously maths & MFL which are cumulative, and in that context also Engl Lang to some extent. Ofsted has also come down 'against' even a 3 year KS4 as far as I am aware.

Schools can start GCSE preparation in earlier years without actually "teaching" the specific content. Like in DS's history lessons where they were being taught bias, source interpretations, cause & consequence etc from the first lesson in year 7, but not the actual exam content until the start of year 10. It was the same with sciences, they were doing GCSE "style" questions from year 7, i.e. being "coached" on how to answer science based questions, such as a 3 mark question requires 3 bullet points, how to do a sequence of events answer by bullet point to answer a "how does x happen" style of question. They were teaching exam technique in the earlier years, but based on the basics of the subject and different types of topic that weren't in the exam 5 years away. So, for the benefit of Ofsted, they were teaching topics at an appropriate level, so got their tick, but couched around exam style testing, so they weren't actually teaching GCSE content until the last two years.

TeenDivided · 12/01/2023 14:07

flimsyclam · 12/01/2023 14:02

I actually think things are easier now than when I sat my gcse. So much available to revise with. I'd have got better grades if whenever I was stuck I could just Google something then YouTube a how to video on any subject. Also some schools prepare their students for gcse syllabus a lot earlier so students will study a subject to a certain level in year 7/8 and then increase the study in year 9 and it's almost revision by year 10/11.

When I was at school all the schools I knew only covered the gcse syllabus in year 10/11

Everyone can now google for help so you would have done 'better' but so can everyone else.

I really don't think they are doing GCSE syllabus from y7 except obviously maths & MFL which are cumulative, and in that context also Engl Lang to some extent. Ofsted has also come down 'against' even a 3 year KS4 as far as I am aware.

I think those that did GCSEs under the modular system underestimate how much harder it is to sit terminal exams (much ore O level like).

flimsyclam · 12/01/2023 14:04

Top grades

flimsyclam · 12/01/2023 14:04

The exception to this I might add is the language exams. So many native speakers of many languages live here now so that must be more difficult to achieve too grades in those as a non native speaker if exams are marked on a curve.

flimsyclam · 12/01/2023 14:02

I actually think things are easier now than when I sat my gcse. So much available to revise with. I'd have got better grades if whenever I was stuck I could just Google something then YouTube a how to video on any subject. Also some schools prepare their students for gcse syllabus a lot earlier so students will study a subject to a certain level in year 7/8 and then increase the study in year 9 and it's almost revision by year 10/11.

When I was at school all the schools I knew only covered the gcse syllabus in year 10/11

TeenDivided · 12/01/2023 13:58

harder exams = harder to get a high % than 'before'
harder to get top grades = proportionately fewer top grades given than 'before'

They aren't synonymous.

TeenDivided · 12/01/2023 13:56

@bellswithwhistles Children now don't really have an excuse not to get a top grade

I think you don't understand how exams are graded (on a curve), nor how much some less able kids really struggle even by working hard.

My DD1 worked very hard for her GCSEs and ended up with fab results (for her) of 5Bs and 3Cs. She only managed that because I was able to work 1-1 with her on revision and explaining things in a way she could retain the knowledge, eventually.

Nimbostratus100 · 12/01/2023 13:50

BBC bitesize is helpful at breaking content down into manageable chunks

bellswithwhistles · 12/01/2023 13:50

UsuallySuze · 12/01/2023 13:17

Can't speak about 2005 but in 2022 just over 2000 kids in the entire country got straight 9s, from around a million students who sat the exams, so around 0.2%. They are not "handing them out like sweets"!

Source?

I do remember reading reports stating that back in late 80s/early 90's only about 10% of children would achieve a top grade. In some subjects now its up to a 25%. A quarter of the people sitting the exam! Madness.

Children now don't really have an excuse not to get a top grade - revision galore available 24/7 on Youtube. Back in my day, if you hadn't noted it down properly in the lesson, tough. You were never going to get given a revision book as they were so expensive and your notes were the only thing to revise from.

Sorry I'm just not buying that exams are harder and that children today are brighter!

The grade boundaries are far more generous now.

Southwig22 · 12/01/2023 13:49

This is a strange thread. The whole point of GCSEs is to mark students across a scale of knowledge and capability.

If they were too "hard" then students wouldn't get top grades. Obviously it just means your daughter will be on the lower end of the grade scale. It's also not surprising that you find it "hard" given you haven't gone through the specific education for that course so... YABU.

TeenDivided · 12/01/2023 13:47

Many posters are conflating difficulty of exam with how many get top grades.
As they are marked on a curve, the two aren't directly related.

Make exams too easy and you end up differentiating based on silly mistakes.
Make exams too hard and you freak out pupils who then can't show even what they do know.

DomPom47 · 12/01/2023 13:46

The issue is the sheer amount of content that teachers have to cover in two years particularly for example in the Humanities: Geography, History and Sociology. In addition to this I don’t think the kids have enough time in the actual exam. If you can get your child some revision books and get her to go through what is covered in a lesson that evening or over weekend it will help with understanding and retention long term.

TeenDivided · 12/01/2023 13:43

GCSEs need to differentiate enough to know who could go on to succeed at A levels and otherwise what level BTEC/Apprenticeship is needed.

However it matters not one jot whether someone gets 8s or 9s, except for boasting rights. Universities can differentiate based on A level results.

Marking on a curve for the all important grade 4 for maths & English Language means we are literally (and I use that term advisedly) setting DC up to fail. We would be better off having a certain standard at least for those subjects. Additionally we need to bring back tiered papers for English Language that do not include Victorian texts.

I think MFLs (at least pre-reform) are more 'use' now than at O level. My DB got an A for German&French O levels but could not really speak the language usefully, whereas my DD got Bs at GCSE and had much more speaking practice & skill.

O level papers were mainly 2hrs, some 2.5, some shorter. I didn't have any 3hr papers (I have copies so checked recently). I don't think 'extra time' as a concept existed then. I think shorter papers are better, but there are still too many.

closingloop · 12/01/2023 13:42

Smiles of happiness come after having tankards of ale!

closingloop · 12/01/2023 13:40

Not sure that they are too difficult to be honest - even more children would get top grades if they were easier - it's already impossible to see the outstanding students. In the olden days they would be a tiny minority achieving an A grade, now the top grades are meaningless (one at A level, one at GCSE this year before anyone accuses me of being out of touch).

I will admit that I found home schooling GCSE maths in lockdown tricky - we'd get the same (right) answers, but the method to achieve them differed beyond comprehension.

I was the first year to do GCSE, so my SPAG - well more the grammar bit to be honest - was more suited to primary school levels. I managed to get my degree, write scientific papers and journal articles, and edit/proof read others without ever needing to know what the three articles are called, but I usually know how to use them.

(a, an and the if you're wondering)

SleeplessInEngland · 12/01/2023 13:40

Dotjones · 12/01/2023 11:35

I think exams are easier now, it's just that people don't work as hard. People know more but are less intelligent at the same time. Watch an old episode of Bullseye on Challenge TV and you'll wonder if everyone who played darts in the 80s was a complete idiot. General knowledge was weaker then because if you wanted to find out something you had to find a book with the information. Plus it took longer for knowledge to be spread because there was no instant publishing. This meant people had their own areas of expertise - clever in one area and thick in another - whereas now it's a more even, but thinner spread, across more areas.

I’d like to see data on this because it sounds very speculative.

Goldenbear · 12/01/2023 13:39

I think they are harder now than in the 00s - I thought grade inflation was particularly bad then?
My DS is in year 11 and very capable but it is the quantity of revision that is a real contrast to my experience in mid 90s. That said, you had to be a very good musician, grade 8, to be allowed to study Music GCSE, DS is more like grade 3 on the guitar and he was allowed to study GCSE, the problem is he has to do a medieval composition and I think he is just finding it too hard. He wants to take maths A level and as far as I can see Maths GCSE is hard enough so probably good practice. I like a PP struggled with teaching my year 5 DD at the time for homeschooling! With year 7 maths my son helps her. My DH is pretty good at maths but I achieved a C in GCSE and I don't think it was as hard. History looks similar to me with the use of sources and English Literature appears easy enough but I studied it at university so I would say that!

Badbadbunny · 12/01/2023 13:37

LavenderHillMob · 12/01/2023 13:22

I took O levels in 1985 and I agree with this.

I also think us oldies forget what we once knew. DD often asks me about something that seems like complete gobbledygook only for me to read it slowly and remember that - yes I did once know about it.

Yep, I remember SOHCAHTOA (trigonometry) and what it stands for. When the time came, I confidently expected to be able to help my DS with his Maths homework, but when it came to it, whilst I knew that sine was opposite over hypoteneuse, I hadn't a clue how to actually do it in practice! I also knew the basic physics equation of V=I*R and how to rearrange the equation and thought I'd be able to help him with electrics in Physics, but realised that was a tiny fraction of what the Physics syllabus contained and was the most basic level - he was beyond such basics in his first electrics lesson and soon moved on far beyond it. I recognised everything else he was being taught, but had forgotten it completely! It's very surprising just how much we forget over time, despite thinking (or kidding ourselves) that we remember it!

Needmorelego · 12/01/2023 13:37

@babsanderson I might be wrong. They might have been an hour and a half.
I just don't remember them being really really long.
It was 1991 I did my GCSEs. It was much more coursework and module based subjects then. Obviously that would vary between schools depending on which exam board yours went for.

Badbadbunny · 12/01/2023 13:31

PinkFrogss · 12/01/2023 13:22

Why should they be hard? Every student has to sit them and pretty much all jobs require a GCSE pass in maths and English. Who does it serve to make them difficult? Many students who struggle with GCSEs are perfectly capable of many careers, why create Barrie’s towards them finally being able to succeed?

Because employers and further/higher education need a way to differentiate based on ability. An exam where nearly everyone passes because it's so easy is of no use to anyone!

But yes, it's very soul destroying for pupils who struggle to look at an exam paper and see that most of it is beyond them. It almost certainly means that they'll do more badly on the bits they can do, because they'll be demoralised. It also means that the weaker pupils may well have been causing low level disruption in classes because they were being taught topics way beyond their abilities.

I was an advocate of the old system of CSEs and O Levels where the weaker pupils sat the CSE and stronger pupils sat the O level. It meant that the weaker students had an "easier" paper where they had a fighting chance of answering most of it, which may have ended up with the same relative grade compared with their peers, but they'd have been in lessons learning subjects they were capable of and less likely to become disengaged. I believe that GCSE's had a similar "lower" and "higher" tier of exam at some time, but not sure whether that applied to all subjects or even whether it still exists at all.

I also like the "modular" and/or points based systems instead of final exams used by universities and secondary schools in some countries abroad. Where you pick up "points" or "module passes" throughout your teaching time there which count towards an end result. By letting pupils accumulate "passes" or "points" throughout several years in smaller chunks, there's less emphasis on mass-revision towards a few weeks of "final" exams and lets weaker pupils concentrate on the basics at first and moving up to harder topics once basics have been mastered. Much better for avoiding disengagement.

PinkFrogss · 12/01/2023 13:24

PinkFrogss · 12/01/2023 13:22

Why should they be hard? Every student has to sit them and pretty much all jobs require a GCSE pass in maths and English. Who does it serve to make them difficult? Many students who struggle with GCSEs are perfectly capable of many careers, why create Barrie’s towards them finally being able to succeed?

Not to mention many students home lives aren’t set up for them to just study in evenings and on the weekends

LavenderHillMob · 12/01/2023 13:22

TeenDivided · 12/01/2023 12:25

I did O levels. DD1 did unreformed GCSEs in '15 but just near the end when modular exams and most coursework were gone, but there were still significant controlled assessments. DD2 did (or didn't) reformed GCSEs in '21.

My view:

  1. You shouldn't compare O levels, which only the top 20-40% sat with GCSEs which are meant to be accessible for all.
  2. The reformed GCSEs have more content to learn than the unreformed ones, plus they have more exams - DD1 sat 13 exams, DD2 was due to sit 20, and most actually have more than that.
  3. In my opinion, the reformed science is as hard as the old O level, especially as most pupils do all 3 sciences either as the dual award or individually.
  4. Mainly they aren't 'easier' they are different. History requires very different skills than way back.
  5. GCSEs are very challenging for less able kids and imo aren't really fit for purpose as a block any more for them. Especially the amount of exams turns everything into an endurance test more than anything else.
  6. Schools should somehow be encouraged and funded to provide more BTECs or something for more pupils as in the past.

I took O levels in 1985 and I agree with this.

I also think us oldies forget what we once knew. DD often asks me about something that seems like complete gobbledygook only for me to read it slowly and remember that - yes I did once know about it.