Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Potential Nanny has history of drug use

138 replies

Snuggy75 · 12/01/2023 09:54

We are currently recruiting for a new wrap-around care nanny for my primary school age kids and I have been made aware that one of the candidates (who has great references, gets on great with the kids) has a history of using cocaine and has got at least one police caution for it approx 18 months ago. Her DBS has currently run out apparently so I do not have any evidence of this yet.

AIBU to still consider employing this person - I don't know if they are still using?

My heart says absolutely no to looking after my kids with any connection to drugs and if they were really young I wouldn't even be considering it, my head says we have all done stuff in the past we may not be proud of and is cocaine really that much worse than getting really really drunk (I genuinely don't know the answer to this)?

Definitely need to get updated DBS, but if that does come back showing the caution - what should I do?

YABU - do not let this person near your children
YANBU - don't rule her out until you know more

OP posts:
TheLostNights · 12/01/2023 14:19

No chance. Why take the risk? You have to be able to trust this person 100% and already there are doubts. Just don't do it.

parsniiips · 12/01/2023 14:18

If it was like 18 years ago and everything else felt right I'd be inclined to give her a chance.

18 months.

No way.

Dotjones · 12/01/2023 14:17

No I wouldn't employ someone who'd been using cocaine in the last 18 months. It's not just like getting drunk.

flimsyclam · 12/01/2023 14:14

No way not in a million years would I.

Ladybyrd · 12/01/2023 14:07

Give her a chance working in an office - yes. Give her a chance looking after my kids - not a chance.

We all have a past, but no. Just no.

StuckInTheUpsideDown · 12/01/2023 14:00

I interviewed a nanny candidate who flagged she had a conviction that would come up on a DBS. However she was up front, it was relatively old and she had a reasonable explanation of how the situation arose, how she had learnt and moved on etc. I would not have ruled her out because of that but would have done extra diligence.

However 18 months would be far too recent for my tastes.

SomethingOriginal2 · 12/01/2023 14:00

If someone got a police caution 18mo for being drunk and disorderly I wouldn't hire them to look after children. I wouldn't even consider her, you have no idea how bad her drug problem is but you know she has one.

Decafflatteplease · 12/01/2023 13:57

That would be a firm no from me.

Busybody2022 · 12/01/2023 13:56

18 months is too recent. My mum is 6 years sober and I still don't trust her 100% and I know her well enough to know immediately if she's drinking again.

BungleandGeorge · 12/01/2023 13:51

is the expectation that nannies have a DBS to show at interview? (Presumably they can use the update service?). Or is it common to employ them and then have to apply/ wait etc? Do you have other applicants with the correct paperwork? If you have other potential employees with everything in order I think it would be wise to choose one of them. Otherwise you’ll be in the position of losing the other applicants and having to advertise again. Personally no I wouldn’t take someone with a caution 18 months ago, it’s far too recent

shewolfsout · 12/01/2023 13:48

Ofsted require schools to enhanced DBS everyone who works there, so I imagine that they have similar processes for nannies and childminders as well. If you need her to be Ofsted registered and she wouldn't currently pass an enhanced DBS (even if she did previously, or will eventually once it's filtered) then that could mean that she CANT work for you and be a much easier reason, than leaving it to your discretion. Is she going through a nanny agency?

She can't get an enhanced DBS herself so don't trust any DBS she gives you, she needs a new one to work as a nanny for you.

oudie · 12/01/2023 13:48

Snuggy75 · 12/01/2023 13:46

To clarify - the potential nanny has been out of childcare for a while and this has happened whilst employed elsewhere.
The informant is not working in or looking for childcare. They were working with the potential nanny when the police got involved. I do not think jealousy is an issue here.
Next step is for me to speak to the potential nanny about getting her DBS and see if she raises anything. There is still a chance it could be hearsay but it will take several weeks if I need to wait for the DBS (which i believe can be done a part of the Ofsted registration process).

This is so bizarre. Why are you not just putting this one off the list? Find someone else. Mad.

Snuggy75 · 12/01/2023 13:46

To clarify - the potential nanny has been out of childcare for a while and this has happened whilst employed elsewhere.
The informant is not working in or looking for childcare. They were working with the potential nanny when the police got involved. I do not think jealousy is an issue here.
Next step is for me to speak to the potential nanny about getting her DBS and see if she raises anything. There is still a chance it could be hearsay but it will take several weeks if I need to wait for the DBS (which i believe can be done a part of the Ofsted registration process).

OP posts:
whynotwhatknot · 12/01/2023 13:29

just to risky unless this other person is just spreading lies-are they in the same line of work need a job?

longwayoff · 12/01/2023 13:22

No. Temptation is hard to resist. She can find other work with less responsibility. Dont let your children pay for her mistakes.

Alexandernevermind · 12/01/2023 13:09

I'm a no too, I'm afraid. I'm sensible enough to know lots of us have messed about in our youth, even during teacher, doctor or police training years, but to be involved with drugs to the extent of having a record suggests more than a bit of experimenting. Our country isn't exactly hard line on personal use.

TabithaTittlemouse · 12/01/2023 13:09

What else did the gossip say?

Wait for the dbs and decide but if she has a caution it’s for more than the occasional snort on a night out.

Snuggy75 · 12/01/2023 13:07

Tescoland · 12/01/2023 12:30

How did you find out this person had a history of drug abuse? There’s no way you would know such information about a would-be employer. I
Let’s analyse this:
There’s no way she would tell you about previous drug use.
I doubt her former employers would know about it otherwise she wouldn’t have glowing references.
I am sure you don’t know her friends and relatives as most nannies work for families previously completely unknown to them.
This whole story stinks…

As I said above "From a mutual acquaintance who worked with her at the time and thought I should know."

It will also show on a DBS but I haven't seen that yet.

OP posts:
Hopelessacademic · 12/01/2023 13:02

No Way!
When you said "in the past" I assumed a long time ago - if she was in her 30s/40s and had done it once in her teens/early 20s then maybe I would chalk it up to youthful indiscretion, but not 18 months ago!

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 12/01/2023 12:59

Snuggy75 · 12/01/2023 11:04

From what I can understand - the caution will appear on her DBS but does that automatically mean she is not authorised to look after children? Or can you not get a DBS at all if you have a caution? Sorry I am looking all over the internet but can't seem to find the answer.

Anyone can get a DBS certificate.

She can only be barred from working with children if the DBS have placed her on the Barred List. This is normally following a referral though certain crimes (relating to harming children) will mean people automatically go on the Barred List.

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 12/01/2023 12:58

Snuggy75 · 12/01/2023 10:16

Thanks all - the vibe I am getting here definitely backs up my gut reaction!

I only found out about it this morning through a mutual acquaintance so no I haven't spoken to the nanny about it yet.

Oh FGS stop Listening to tittle tattle and ask her to get her DBS certificate to you (yes they do run out and can take bloody ages to come again)

Mardyface · 12/01/2023 12:56

I would ask the nanny about her DBS. While a drugs caution 18 months ago wouldn't automatically rule her out for me (it might, but not automatically), the fact that you didn't hear about it from her first would.

If your singing acquaintance is also looking for a good wraparound nanny, be cautious!

Branster · 12/01/2023 12:46

Absolutely not.
I wouldn't allow my dogs to be looked after someone who has been involved with drugs in the last 5 years, let alone children.

It is not your problem how she gets clearance for other similar jobs, so don't feel in any way sorry for the nanny or try to find rules and regulations.

There is a big question mark here. True or not, it is not your responsibility to give her a chance even if references are brilliant.

BlingLoving · 12/01/2023 12:33

I would not be taking the word of a random acquaintance who is unlikely to know the details. I would be far more interested in whether she has the relevant DBS checks and what her most recent family has to say about her.

Cocaine use is not, in itself, a sign of something sinister. I don't take it, don't like it and don't generally hang out with people who do. But I don't think I'd write someone off entirely because they have.

altmember · 12/01/2023 12:33

As an individual you aren't entitled to request a DBS check on a (potential) nanny anyway. Can only be done through an agency, and then you wouldn't necessarily be told all the exact details, just whether or not they think anything on there should prevent her from getting the job. The nanny can't request a DBS check on herself, and you shouldn't rely on a copy of one that she's supplied to you anyway.

Also, most low level offences (like possession of cocaine) get filtered after 6 years, so old stuff wouldn't even show up on an enhanced DBS. And employer's aren't allowed to ask about or considered filtered history anyway. So really all you can go on is what sounds like hearsay or rumour anyway. Really it depends on how reliable your source is?

But I'm guessing you'd be taking her on on a self employed basis anyway, so you could ask her if she has any criminal history. If she's honest then she'll tell you about it when you ask her. Obviously if she says her record is all clear than you can't be sure if she's lying or your grass is wrong.

A caution for possession could suggest a whole range all sorts of things in reality - from someone who dabbles occasionally and just got unlucky, to someone the police suspect is dealing but didn't have enough evidence for a stronger charge.

I know of people who use coke very sporadically and in a social setting, and they lead perfectly normal, decent lives. And others who are chronically addicted, and rob from their own family to feed their habit. You've no idea where this person is on that range of use/addiction, and 18 months is eyebrow raisingly recent.

I'd say if you've got any other decent applicants then it's probably not worth the hassle/risk of taking on this one. Of course the others could have far worse issues or DBS records, just that you've not heard the gossip on them...

Maybe going through an agency is worth it?