Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Civil servants - will you be striking on 1st Feb?

192 replies

Iamnotausername · 12/01/2023 09:30

I know you probably can't say what dept you are in but will you be striking?

I will.

OP posts:
Iamthewombat · 13/01/2023 14:01

AreOttersJustWetCats · 13/01/2023 12:14

I didn't say anything at all about my husband. That was another poster.

My husband works in the private sector.

You’ve read my reply to Peachgreen and decided that it must be aimed at you. Do keep up!

Iamnotausername · 13/01/2023 12:59

Yes to when RJM was recently moaning about the people who are essential to him being able to do his job.

OP posts:
Iamnotausername · 13/01/2023 12:56

As for the pp who said we don't need unions because there are H&S rules and employment rights etc you are very nieve. If all employers followed them all the time we wouldn't have ACAS, employment lawyers etc. A minute on the jobs board on here shows why unions exist.

Good union employees are the front line defence so staff don' have to pay expensive lawyer fees and have personalised face to face support that ACAS can't offer. We are having a mini restructure in our dept and the union is providing an employee voice. They have already forced the employef to change certain things because it would be detrimental to staff.

It's a bit cheeky when people who don' pay for union membership get the benefits by default.

I know unions vary in quality though. Mine is very visible and thr office reps are noisy (in a good way! 😆).

OP posts:
Eleganz · 13/01/2023 12:55

I think what has exacerbated the pay issues further is the continual corrosive statements from senior Tories about how useless and allegedly duplicitous the civil service are. This has massively eroded the goodwill of people who should really have already been striking about pay and conditions well before now.

We've again had JRM spouting off about how 'no-one will notice" that civil servants go on strike (lapped up by the usual sections of the media and erstwhile commentators). Due to impartiality rules it has essentially been open season on the civil service for over a decade now and people's morale is through the floor.

Strikes are absolutely a response to the government's openly hostile position towards public sector workers, particular civil servants who don't enjoy the same public support as doctors and nurses (most of us would kill for the pay deal that the nurses have rejected). We know that the Tories despise us.

The reality is that in my area pay has risen by less than 10% since 2010 against a 42% inflation rate according to the Bank of England's calculator for that time. That is a huge erosion of wages. The 2% pay offer is actually the highest wage rise anyone in my area has seen for over a decade and there have been 4 years of pay freezes in that time (the much vaunted lifting of the cap on public sector pay in 2018 did nothing to improve our pay offers). It is no surprise that people are leaving in droves and going on industrial action.

Iamnotausername · 13/01/2023 12:49

There isn't job security though. So many depts are dependent on the economy. The government are literally saying they want to make staff redundant.

The redundancy package is pretty average right now but again, the government is trying to reduce that.

Pensions aren't what they were.

We are loosing young staff as fast as they are coming in because there are jobs in the private sector which are better paid, have better promotion opportunities etc.

OP posts:
IamSamantha · 13/01/2023 12:41

Umbrio · 13/01/2023 12:03

Civil Service pay at grades HEO and under is propped up by partners who are working in the private sector. Myself and many others can only afford to stay because our partners are earning a decent wage in the private sector. I personally stay because I'm a carer and I'm lucky that I get treated well by the CS and can carry on working. I probably wouldn't get that elsewhere, certainly not in my former industrial area. There aren't a lot of options where I live. Unemployment used to be over 60% a few years ago.

I don't stay because the wages are amazing or even the pension (I've got over 20 yrs Service and my pension is currently forecast to be 6k, much less than my husband's).
For those who don't have partners earning a decent wage, they are the ones having to leave as they can't survive anymore. They are having to travel to other cities for better paid work as it's difficult to run a house on 1800 a month when rent is increasing, energy is ridiculous.
We don't want to leave, we just want to have a reasonable standard of living.

This.... I couldn't afford to live alone on my wage. I do have a couple of single parents working in my team. I also have carers working a full time CS job, entry level. They get universal credit to top up their wage! So in essence the government recognise that they pay a low wage and top it up in benefits.

From a practical point of view how many staff hours are the government funding to administrate the universal credit top up for their own employees? How many employees access benefit systems? It's an incredibly inefficient use of public funds. It's madness! Just pay public sector staff a wage they can live off. I'm not expecting a 10% pay increase across the board and if that does happen then it has to come from somewhere so taxes somewhere will have to go up.

peachgreen · 13/01/2023 12:39

Iamthewombat · 13/01/2023 12:03

No, you complained that your husband was underpaid and thus in a disadvantageous position. Remember?

Are you talking about me? He’s not my husband, he’s my boyfriend of 6 months and we aren’t financially connected in any way so quite frankly, it doesn’t impact me. But again, I don’t have to be directly impacted by something to care about the effects on other people.

What exactly is your agenda in this thread? You’re against striking in general? Or just against civil servants?

AreOttersJustWetCats · 13/01/2023 12:23

fitzwilliamdarcy · 13/01/2023 12:22

@Eleganz @Umbrio Yes, definitely. I’m single but the only reason I can continue to work there is because I’ve got no dependants and I’m frugal. Everyone I know at work has either got a well-earning partner or is single but childfree. I don’t know any single parents at all.

Interesting point - there are no single parents in my area either.

fitzwilliamdarcy · 13/01/2023 12:22

@Eleganz @Umbrio Yes, definitely. I’m single but the only reason I can continue to work there is because I’ve got no dependants and I’m frugal. Everyone I know at work has either got a well-earning partner or is single but childfree. I don’t know any single parents at all.

AreOttersJustWetCats · 13/01/2023 12:14

Iamthewombat · 13/01/2023 12:03

No, you complained that your husband was underpaid and thus in a disadvantageous position. Remember?

I didn't say anything at all about my husband. That was another poster.

My husband works in the private sector.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 13/01/2023 12:09

I’m not in that Union so no

Eleganz · 13/01/2023 12:08

Umbrio · 13/01/2023 12:03

Civil Service pay at grades HEO and under is propped up by partners who are working in the private sector. Myself and many others can only afford to stay because our partners are earning a decent wage in the private sector. I personally stay because I'm a carer and I'm lucky that I get treated well by the CS and can carry on working. I probably wouldn't get that elsewhere, certainly not in my former industrial area. There aren't a lot of options where I live. Unemployment used to be over 60% a few years ago.

I don't stay because the wages are amazing or even the pension (I've got over 20 yrs Service and my pension is currently forecast to be 6k, much less than my husband's).
For those who don't have partners earning a decent wage, they are the ones having to leave as they can't survive anymore. They are having to travel to other cities for better paid work as it's difficult to run a house on 1800 a month when rent is increasing, energy is ridiculous.
We don't want to leave, we just want to have a reasonable standard of living.

Spot on, work at an ALB and exactly the same here for lower paying roles. Only people who are staying are those that are the "second income earners" in their families as far as I can see. Lost three experienced people from technical/specialist roles who all said the same thing - enjoy working for me and the organisation but just can't keep supporting their families how they would like whilst staying in the roles. All have left for significant pay rises that mean that even though their private sector pension conditions are worse they are still better off pension-wise due to their much higher salaries.

Umbrio · 13/01/2023 12:03

Civil Service pay at grades HEO and under is propped up by partners who are working in the private sector. Myself and many others can only afford to stay because our partners are earning a decent wage in the private sector. I personally stay because I'm a carer and I'm lucky that I get treated well by the CS and can carry on working. I probably wouldn't get that elsewhere, certainly not in my former industrial area. There aren't a lot of options where I live. Unemployment used to be over 60% a few years ago.

I don't stay because the wages are amazing or even the pension (I've got over 20 yrs Service and my pension is currently forecast to be 6k, much less than my husband's).
For those who don't have partners earning a decent wage, they are the ones having to leave as they can't survive anymore. They are having to travel to other cities for better paid work as it's difficult to run a house on 1800 a month when rent is increasing, energy is ridiculous.
We don't want to leave, we just want to have a reasonable standard of living.

Iamthewombat · 13/01/2023 12:03

No, you complained that your husband was underpaid and thus in a disadvantageous position. Remember?

MiddleParking · 13/01/2023 12:03

Great idea! Everyone who doesn’t get a 13% pay rise immediately should strike. Everyone. Care workers. Supermarket workers. The food industry. Farmers. Distribution workers. The emergency services.

This, but unironically.

Eleganz · 13/01/2023 12:01

No option to strike as we aren't unionised in my area. I suspect that will change this year.

I have lost over 25% of my team to the private sector in the last 6 months and I am far from alone in my area. I have had to recruit much less experienced people to cover roles and have to use a significant part od the capacity of the remain staff, including me, to trading and develop the new hires.

peachgreen · 13/01/2023 11:54

Iamthewombat · 13/01/2023 10:53

Great idea! Everyone who doesn’t get a 13% pay rise immediately should strike. Everyone. Care workers. Supermarket workers. The food industry. Farmers. Distribution workers. The emergency services. What nonsense.

Bonus points for ‘race to the bottom’. Only ever used seriously by people who are in a more advantageous position than they want to admit to, and don’t like having it pointed out.

I don't think I ever said I wasn't in an advantageous position? I'm very happy with my job, wage and working conditions. That doesn't stop me from caring about other people.

And yes, I do think strikes are a useful tool for wage negotiation and more workers should unionise and employ them where necessary. The money is there. It is just currently entirely unfairly distributed.

fitzwilliamdarcy · 13/01/2023 11:54

We weren’t balloted but I would strike, yes. It won’t do any good though as the public couldn’t give a fuck and think none of us do anything anyway.

AreOttersJustWetCats · 13/01/2023 11:52

Iamthewombat · 13/01/2023 11:41

No, you argued that it is ‘a workers’ market like you’ve never known’ and claimed that the private sector can’t fill its roles in your area that you say pay 30% to 40% more. In which case, as @TheKeatingFive asked, why aren’t all the civil servants in your field jumping ship?

The logical answer is that the differential in pay and conditions, including the pension, can’t be as big as you suggest and hence the civil servants can’t be too badly done by compared to the private sector. If they were, they’d have moved already. The employment market is not a perfect market but people aren’t daft.

I though I made clear - those who stay do so for the pension, security, and because they enjoy the job. The labour market is more complex than people swapping jobs just because the headline salary is higher, but the overall trend is that we are losing people to the private sector.

You wouldn't argue that nursing conditions must be fine if 'only' 50% of them left. What about teachers - they may be leaving in their droves, but some are staying, so their conditions must be okay too?

The fact is, as a country, we need good quality, skilled people to work in (for example) the government regulators as well as in the regulated private industries. There are also some services that can only really be provided by the government, and we need people to do those jobs. Everyone complains when their passport doesn't come on time, don't they?

Not everyone is driven by money, but there does come a tipping point where you stop being able to recruit and the public service collapses. That is starting to be seen in many areas right now.

It may be that the recession and cost of living crisis shifts things, but recessions are not good for workers regardless of the sector they are in. The end result is usually a loss of pay and detriment to conditions across the board, as competition for jobs increase and it becomes an employers' market.

Personally, I oppose the increase in the gig economy and insecure shitty jobs - I don't want a race to the bottom, I want everyone to earn decent wages. The average working person in this country is significantly worse off than they were 15 or 20 years ago - we need to work out how to address that.

Greblegable · 13/01/2023 11:49

A really common scenario is specialist leaves civil service and starts working as a contractor. Because civil service can’t attract talent they employ contractors. So the same person ends up working on various projects for civil service but it costs the government much more than it would to employ them. There billion pound projects that can only function because of external contractors because we recognise we can’t get skills internally. That feels very broken in a workforce the size of civil service.

Iamthewombat · 13/01/2023 11:41

No, you argued that it is ‘a workers’ market like you’ve never known’ and claimed that the private sector can’t fill its roles in your area that you say pay 30% to 40% more. In which case, as @TheKeatingFive asked, why aren’t all the civil servants in your field jumping ship?

The logical answer is that the differential in pay and conditions, including the pension, can’t be as big as you suggest and hence the civil servants can’t be too badly done by compared to the private sector. If they were, they’d have moved already. The employment market is not a perfect market but people aren’t daft.

AreOttersJustWetCats · 13/01/2023 11:35

Iamthewombat · 13/01/2023 11:32

Lots of people are leaving the public sector because the private sector is bidding higher for their skills. But with the acute shortage, the private sector also can't fill all roles.

You can’t have it both ways. Either there are underpaid specialists languishing in the civil service, or there are not. If they have all left for the sunlit uplands of the private sector and still the private sector cannot fill the roles, there can’t be any of those underpaid disadvantaged people left in the CS to go on strike, can there?

You've completely distorted what I've said.😂

Lots of people are leaving. Others are staying.

I have made clear that there are other benefits (pensions, job security) which make the CS attractive. I enjoy my job, and am happy to stay.

Literally all I pointed out was that for my specific specialism, the private sector pays 30-40% more, and all sectors currently have significant vacancies for my skills. The fact that not everyone is jumping ship from CS to private sector does not invalidate this.

Iamthewombat · 13/01/2023 11:32

Lots of people are leaving the public sector because the private sector is bidding higher for their skills. But with the acute shortage, the private sector also can't fill all roles.

You can’t have it both ways. Either there are underpaid specialists languishing in the civil service, or there are not. If they have all left for the sunlit uplands of the private sector and still the private sector cannot fill the roles, there can’t be any of those underpaid disadvantaged people left in the CS to go on strike, can there?

TheKeatingFive · 13/01/2023 11:29

for final salary pensions.

I don't think many people are saying this. However your direct benefit pension is still excellent value compared to what else is out there.

Iamthewombat · 13/01/2023 11:29

Point to one post on this thread suggesting that civil servants ‘do eff all for final salary pensions’. You won’t win your argument by being a drama queen.