Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Civil servants - will you be striking on 1st Feb?

192 replies

Iamnotausername · 12/01/2023 09:30

I know you probably can't say what dept you are in but will you be striking?

I will.

OP posts:
Iamthewombat · 13/01/2023 21:22

*they wouldn’t be striking unless it affected the public.

Iamthewombat · 13/01/2023 21:22

Umbrio · 13/01/2023 16:24

Iamthewombat what an odd person you are. I'm not sure what you're getting out of this thread. You clearly have it in for Civil Servants for some reason 🤣

No, I don’t ‘have it in for civil servants’. Nor am I Jacob Rees Mogg, haha. I assume that is who ‘JRM’ is?

What I’m ‘getting out of the thread’ is debating civil servants’ decision to strike. Which affects the public, including me. They wouldn’t be striking unless it didn’t affect the public, right? This is a public forum.

Predictably, as soon as any difficult questions are asked, the thread veers off into a pity party or preaching.

Example: I asked precisely what the pension complaint underpinning the strike action was. Nobody knew, least of all the posters planning to strike over it. One poster linked to a pensions website that you had to subscribe to, after which I had to find out for myself what the McCloud remedy is and the context.

Example 2: somebody moans that her ‘DP’ doesn’t get paid enough. In her opinion, and his, his job is harder than hers (she’s known him for three months, it transpires, and has never done his job, but never mind). She earns much more, and thinks that this constitutes enough evidence to claim that strikes are justified and that civil servants would be paid much more if they worked in the private sector.

Example 3: somebody else chimes in to say that in her specialist field, salaries are 30% to 40% higher in the private sector. Hence the strikes are justified and civil servants are underpaid. Why haven’t they all moved to the private sector then, she is asked? She has no answer but launches into a preaching session about her opposition to ‘the gig economy and shitty menial jobs’. What’s that got to do with the civil service? It’s a distraction tactic.

I’m sure that there are all kinds of reasons for civil servants to be unhappy with their lot, but none of them have been well articulated on this thread.

Iamthewombat · 13/01/2023 19:26

AreOttersJustWetCats · 13/01/2023 15:38

I pretty obviously didn’t say that. 😂

You don't appear to be able to make any points without totally misrepresenting what people are saying. It's quite surreal, and makes for bizarre reading.

And yet you diverge from the subject of the thread to do heavy handed virtue signalling, to show what a good person you are. Is that because you know that you can’t answer the question about why civil servants haven’t flocked wholesale to the specialist roles in your field? That’s the surreal thing.

Iamthewombat · 13/01/2023 19:21

Eleganz · 13/01/2023 15:12

It is broken. In many areas of public sector we are talking about long term liabilities that often extend even beyond the standard long lifetime used in the private sector of 25 years. Maintaining in house expertise in these areas is much lower risk for managing these long term liabilities compared to relying on private sector contractors as the latter simply have no duty to maintain that expertise and supply it to the public sector as well as the public sector body then having no expertise to hold the output of private contractors to technical account and this can and does lead to poor quality delivery.

The people building the systems are very seldom the same people who maintain the systems when they are built. I’m not sure what point you are attempting to make. You think that the public sector should recruit and retain very expensive systems architects and software engineers who wouldn’t want to do the maintenance after the system has been built?

Big systems builds and implementations are done by third party businesses anyway, not by individual contractors.

Iamnotausername · 13/01/2023 17:05

Is Iamthewombat JRM in a rubbish disguise?

OP posts:
TuxedoCatBox · 13/01/2023 16:54

True, if we even look at our own/ a colleague’s UC claim it gets flagged. Massive no no.

PaniniHead · 13/01/2023 16:44

HazelBite · 12/01/2023 13:15

Retired Civil Servant here, wages, as in so many public services, have been static for many years now. It has gotten to the stage now that some in the DWP are processing their own claims for UC.
I don't think many of the general public realise how a strike of Civil Servants can massively impact their lives from benefits, the Court Service, borders, passports etc.
Unfortunately the Tories have only got themselves to blame, for years of staff cuts (usually experienced staff) and no realistic wage rises.

Sorry to be pedantic but DWP staff won’t be processing their own UC claims. If they are- then they’ll be sacked. It’s a major gross misconduct offence.

Umbrio · 13/01/2023 16:24

Iamthewombat what an odd person you are. I'm not sure what you're getting out of this thread. You clearly have it in for Civil Servants for some reason 🤣

AreOttersJustWetCats · 13/01/2023 16:24

I think people would be much happier with their salaries, and there wouldn't be such high turnover, if you were allowed to progress up your scale like you can in most other sectors. It should pay to build knowledge and experience in a role.

Agree with this.

nc8975 · 13/01/2023 16:21

My department is (although heard very little, my organisation striking wouldn't really hit the public much but could cause chaos within the CS but tbh it's already pretty chaotic....), you don't have to be in a union to strike by the way.

I won't be striking, on the whole I'm not too dissatisfied with the salary (and certainly not the pension) my biggest frustration with the CS which no one seems to give a shit about addressing is the lack of pay progression within a scale. I think people would be much happier with their salaries, and there wouldn't be such high turnover, if you were allowed to progress up your scale like you can in most other sectors. It should pay to build knowledge and experience in a role. I'm now seeking my 3rd promotion in 3 years, it is an absolute pain in the arse for my employers, I don't think it's as good for my personal development and ability in what I give back to the CS, but it's the only way I can get paid more which is important to me right now in this climate with a young family.

If they did a strike specifically on that, I'd be all over it!

Emdubz · 13/01/2023 16:10

My department didn’t reach the threshold 😞 but would definitely strike and hope we’ll get balloted again.

MiddleParking · 13/01/2023 16:09

peachgreen · 13/01/2023 16:06

Ill-founded and illogical you can have – I don’t agree, but that’s subjective – but I’m not being disingenuous or self-interested. Supporting striking workers doesn’t benefit me directly. I do it because a) I care about the well-being of others, b) the right to withdraw labour is essential and c) I believe a society in which wealth is distributed more fairly will be better for everyone.

(As an aside, I suppose in that sense it benefits me, but it’s a pretty long game to be playing…)

Most people are capable of caring about things even if they aren’t directly affected by them.

Same, to all of that.

AreOttersJustWetCats · 13/01/2023 16:07

I think you might be giving that poster too much credit @peachgreen. The repeated misrepresentation of what people are saying makes them look pretty goady imo....

That said, there have been some interesting posts on this thread by others, so it's been worth the reading.

peachgreen · 13/01/2023 16:06

Iamthewombat · 13/01/2023 14:02

I’ve never seen a disingenuous, ill-founded, illogical, self-interested argument that I haven’t wanted to demolish. That’s my ‘agenda’, if that makes you happy!

Ill-founded and illogical you can have – I don’t agree, but that’s subjective – but I’m not being disingenuous or self-interested. Supporting striking workers doesn’t benefit me directly. I do it because a) I care about the well-being of others, b) the right to withdraw labour is essential and c) I believe a society in which wealth is distributed more fairly will be better for everyone.

(As an aside, I suppose in that sense it benefits me, but it’s a pretty long game to be playing…)

Most people are capable of caring about things even if they aren’t directly affected by them.

AreOttersJustWetCats · 13/01/2023 16:04

Eleganz · 13/01/2023 12:55

I think what has exacerbated the pay issues further is the continual corrosive statements from senior Tories about how useless and allegedly duplicitous the civil service are. This has massively eroded the goodwill of people who should really have already been striking about pay and conditions well before now.

We've again had JRM spouting off about how 'no-one will notice" that civil servants go on strike (lapped up by the usual sections of the media and erstwhile commentators). Due to impartiality rules it has essentially been open season on the civil service for over a decade now and people's morale is through the floor.

Strikes are absolutely a response to the government's openly hostile position towards public sector workers, particular civil servants who don't enjoy the same public support as doctors and nurses (most of us would kill for the pay deal that the nurses have rejected). We know that the Tories despise us.

The reality is that in my area pay has risen by less than 10% since 2010 against a 42% inflation rate according to the Bank of England's calculator for that time. That is a huge erosion of wages. The 2% pay offer is actually the highest wage rise anyone in my area has seen for over a decade and there have been 4 years of pay freezes in that time (the much vaunted lifting of the cap on public sector pay in 2018 did nothing to improve our pay offers). It is no surprise that people are leaving in droves and going on industrial action.

Agree that the current government has been openly hostile and has effectively spent its time in office slagging off the CS. It's appalling behaviour, and civil servants are unable to comment to correct the lies being told.

JRM is odious beyond belief.

AreOttersJustWetCats · 13/01/2023 15:38

Iamthewombat · 13/01/2023 14:12

Yeah, that’s right. Everyone who doesn’t agree with you is in favour of low pay, the gig economy and a ‘race to the bottom’.

I pretty obviously didn’t say that. 😂

You don't appear to be able to make any points without totally misrepresenting what people are saying. It's quite surreal, and makes for bizarre reading.

MiddleParking · 13/01/2023 15:33

Iamthewombat · 13/01/2023 14:09

I assume that you’d be the first to call for the head of the CEO of Sainsbury’s when you couldn’t buy milk, right?

Oh dear. You know what they say about assuming.

Eleganz · 13/01/2023 15:12

Iamthewombat · 13/01/2023 14:07

It’s not ‘broken’ at all. It’s actually sensible resourcing. If you have a project of limited duration it makes sense to bring in external specialists. Then you get (in theory) expertise from the cutting edge of private sector tech projects without the long tail of costs. Nobody wants to take on pension liabilities and high salary/NI costs for someone who isn’t needed after three years.

It is broken. In many areas of public sector we are talking about long term liabilities that often extend even beyond the standard long lifetime used in the private sector of 25 years. Maintaining in house expertise in these areas is much lower risk for managing these long term liabilities compared to relying on private sector contractors as the latter simply have no duty to maintain that expertise and supply it to the public sector as well as the public sector body then having no expertise to hold the output of private contractors to technical account and this can and does lead to poor quality delivery.

hellswelshy · 13/01/2023 14:46

I would definitely be striking on the 1st February but...ironically my 20 years of service comes to an end on the 31st of January as I'm being made redundant due to 'relocation ' of work. This means around 5 local offices closing and a large hub opening in a location that's too far to get to for many staff. Hundreds of years of experience being lost due to this inane decision despite the union opposition. So yes, I support those striking as I've seen first hand how the pay has been chipped away at - the workloads have increased and become more and more complex for not much more than minimum wage. I'm sad to be leaving but it's probably the best for me.

Nat6999 · 13/01/2023 14:40

Ex Civil Servant, in the 11 years since I finished the pay scale I was on has barely increased, I can remember having to have a pay increase when NMW was introduced. I support the strikes.

Ted27 · 13/01/2023 14:17

@Eleganz

spot on, people think of civil servants as Whitehall. To be honest, no one will notice if I strike, Im not public facing, what I do can wait for a day. But when people are moaning about delays getting passports, driving licences, backlog in the courts, etc etc, they will notice. The wider public generally does not realise the scope of the civil service.
I did a talk to my son’s GSCE Citizenship class on careers in the civil service and they were gobsmacked at the range of services it encompasses.

with regard to pay, I am pretty much on the same FTE salary as I was 10 years ago. Interesting what are @IamSamantha and @fitzwilliamdarcy said about single parents. I’m a single parent, I haven’t gone for promotions in those 10 years because I adopted a child with significant additional needs. My part time salary was propped up by the benefits he received and tax credits. I have increased hours as he has improved, with a consequent drop in benefits - as they righfully should.
I am in the fortunate, though carefully planned, position of being mortgage free since May. If I was still paying a mortgage, things would be getting very tight now.
I only know a handful of other single parents, none in my division.
At 57 I am leaving in March, as much because of what @Eleganz said as the pay issue.
I will be very sorry to go in some respects. I will miss my colleagues who for the most part are dedicated public servants.

Iamthewombat · 13/01/2023 14:12

AreOttersJustWetCats · 13/01/2023 11:52

I though I made clear - those who stay do so for the pension, security, and because they enjoy the job. The labour market is more complex than people swapping jobs just because the headline salary is higher, but the overall trend is that we are losing people to the private sector.

You wouldn't argue that nursing conditions must be fine if 'only' 50% of them left. What about teachers - they may be leaving in their droves, but some are staying, so their conditions must be okay too?

The fact is, as a country, we need good quality, skilled people to work in (for example) the government regulators as well as in the regulated private industries. There are also some services that can only really be provided by the government, and we need people to do those jobs. Everyone complains when their passport doesn't come on time, don't they?

Not everyone is driven by money, but there does come a tipping point where you stop being able to recruit and the public service collapses. That is starting to be seen in many areas right now.

It may be that the recession and cost of living crisis shifts things, but recessions are not good for workers regardless of the sector they are in. The end result is usually a loss of pay and detriment to conditions across the board, as competition for jobs increase and it becomes an employers' market.

Personally, I oppose the increase in the gig economy and insecure shitty jobs - I don't want a race to the bottom, I want everyone to earn decent wages. The average working person in this country is significantly worse off than they were 15 or 20 years ago - we need to work out how to address that.

Yeah, that’s right. Everyone who doesn’t agree with you is in favour of low pay, the gig economy and a ‘race to the bottom’.

Iamthewombat · 13/01/2023 14:09

MiddleParking · 13/01/2023 12:03

Great idea! Everyone who doesn’t get a 13% pay rise immediately should strike. Everyone. Care workers. Supermarket workers. The food industry. Farmers. Distribution workers. The emergency services.

This, but unironically.

I assume that you’d be the first to call for the head of the CEO of Sainsbury’s when you couldn’t buy milk, right?

Iamthewombat · 13/01/2023 14:07

Greblegable · 13/01/2023 11:49

A really common scenario is specialist leaves civil service and starts working as a contractor. Because civil service can’t attract talent they employ contractors. So the same person ends up working on various projects for civil service but it costs the government much more than it would to employ them. There billion pound projects that can only function because of external contractors because we recognise we can’t get skills internally. That feels very broken in a workforce the size of civil service.

It’s not ‘broken’ at all. It’s actually sensible resourcing. If you have a project of limited duration it makes sense to bring in external specialists. Then you get (in theory) expertise from the cutting edge of private sector tech projects without the long tail of costs. Nobody wants to take on pension liabilities and high salary/NI costs for someone who isn’t needed after three years.

Iamthewombat · 13/01/2023 14:02

peachgreen · 13/01/2023 12:39

Are you talking about me? He’s not my husband, he’s my boyfriend of 6 months and we aren’t financially connected in any way so quite frankly, it doesn’t impact me. But again, I don’t have to be directly impacted by something to care about the effects on other people.

What exactly is your agenda in this thread? You’re against striking in general? Or just against civil servants?

I’ve never seen a disingenuous, ill-founded, illogical, self-interested argument that I haven’t wanted to demolish. That’s my ‘agenda’, if that makes you happy!