Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Civil servants - will you be striking on 1st Feb?

192 replies

Iamnotausername · 12/01/2023 09:30

I know you probably can't say what dept you are in but will you be striking?

I will.

OP posts:
AreOttersJustWetCats · 18/03/2023 09:10

Civil servants were not paid, either by their union or by their employer, for the strike days on 1st Feb and 15th March.

BessieSurtees · 18/03/2023 07:14

@Iamnotausername are you being paid when on strike?

RaininSummer · 16/01/2023 18:42

Three years off work? What planet are you on if you think that. I only joined 2 years ago but it's been fully face to face every day and I know colleagues were in office the first year too.

Iamthewombat · 16/01/2023 12:52

Iamnotausername · 16/01/2023 12:21

@Iamthewombat

Please explain why asking what pension scheme you were on is sour grapes? Exactly what was so sour grapes about my post? Oh yes, that's right you just read what you want to. You do that, don't you.

I was going to ask you something about the (new) pension scheme that you may have found useful and you would probably have wanted to look into. It has nothing to do with the strikes but seeing as you know everything anyway, I won't bother.

Anyway, you seem intent on making a fool of yourself and trying to upset people and start a fight so I'm going to just let you get on with it. I bet your colleagues were devastated when you left the CS.

Whoops. Tagged you. How very undignified.

Here’s your sour grapes. I see that you have included many more in your latest post! This is why you won’t be taken seriously.

Iamnotausername · 16/01/2023 12:47

Did we get 3yrs off? Nobody told me that. Why was I working on an antiquated lap top that they found in a cupboard that would crash at least twice a day if we got time off?! I feel ripped off.

My shift starts in an hour so I'd best go and get ready to do nothing for 8hrs.

OP posts:
hellswelshy · 16/01/2023 12:45

sst1234 · 16/01/2023 12:27

Probably not. People are used to the woeful state of the civil service from lockdown days. They’ve had three years off work now. What’s another few days.

Untrue. Myself and my colleagues worked all the way through lockdown, no change to service behind the scenes apart from increased workload due to thousands of new claims. Ridiculous comment.

nc8975 · 16/01/2023 12:30

Obviously I have time to search old threads because I don't work, just getting paid to sit at home Grin

nc8975 · 16/01/2023 12:29

@sst1234 I love the fact in January 2021 you called people idiots for falling for celebrity PR, and yet here you are regurgitating Tory bullshit like it's fact...

sst1234 · 16/01/2023 12:27

LeevMarie · 12/01/2023 11:38

OK, why are you striking? Will anybody notice?

Probably not. People are used to the woeful state of the civil service from lockdown days. They’ve had three years off work now. What’s another few days.

Iamnotausername · 16/01/2023 12:21

@Iamthewombat

Please explain why asking what pension scheme you were on is sour grapes? Exactly what was so sour grapes about my post? Oh yes, that's right you just read what you want to. You do that, don't you.

I was going to ask you something about the (new) pension scheme that you may have found useful and you would probably have wanted to look into. It has nothing to do with the strikes but seeing as you know everything anyway, I won't bother.

Anyway, you seem intent on making a fool of yourself and trying to upset people and start a fight so I'm going to just let you get on with it. I bet your colleagues were devastated when you left the CS.

OP posts:
Iamthewombat · 16/01/2023 10:55

More sour grapes! The new scheme. If I were in the old scheme I’d have had to have been a civil servant a long time ago. Which I noted that I was not.

Iamnotausername · 16/01/2023 10:06

@Iamthewombat

Whoops. Tagged you. How very undignified.

Which pension scheme are you talking about? You say you USED to be a CS. Are you on the old pension scheme or new one?

OP posts:
Iamthewombat · 16/01/2023 09:17

Nope, my civil service experience was not ‘many years ago’ and it covered two separate departments. Sorry to rain on your parade!

Can you see why your gripes are not being taken seriously at work? It’s because of the behaviour you have displayed in this thread. Petulant, over-emotional, petty and frankly illogical. Upthread you complain about having to work from home, because it’s unfair that you have to pay for heating and lighting during working hours. Simultaneously you complain that you couldn’t afford to commute to work if asked to do so. What do you expect your employer to do? Lay on a free taxi every day? I doubt that even that would satisfy you: you’d soon find something else to moan about. Perhaps your odd conviction that by paying for your excellent pension at bargain rates you are somehow ‘losing money’:

I appreciate you at least trying to find out the facts on the pension reason to strike which is based on us overpaying into our pensions based on the projected return we will receive during our retirement. It is unpalatable because we cannot affect what we pay into our pensions and therefore over the years we will be losing more money.

My views on the pay review and your workload are irrelevant, but you must see that all kinds of people, irrespective of the sector they work in, have had pay rises below what they had hoped for and that many people have high workloads? The things that give you the negotiating power to ask for a higher salary are having specialist and hard to source skills, having great experience and being a co-operative member of a team. And voting with your feet, by which I mean leaving for a better-paid role, not an inert one day strike.

IamSamantha · 15/01/2023 21:45

Iamthewombat · 15/01/2023 20:40

Yawn. Here you are upthread, complaining about pensions in response to a direct question from me, which was, what precisely is your complaint about pensions?

We cannot affect what we pay into our pensions and they aren't as good as people think. I had private sector pensions that are probably better. We had a pay review 5 years ago. It was recommended we were being paid 6k under what was justified. The review was acknowledged but we've seen nothing, no additional pay, no levelling up. The head of our directorate got a 5 figure bonus this year because we hit our SLA and productivity targets (by working all the hours god sends). They're on a 6 figure salary to begin with. We got nothing, no Christmas card, no thank you, no 15 minute time allowance for a Christmas coffee with our team (I'm being arsey but honestly nothing, not even an email saying thank you).

You don’t understand how pensions work, do you? Or the specific point the civil service unions are making. But, that’s not going to stop you complaining. You have no idea of how much somebody would have to pay into a private pension to even get close to the benefits offered by yours, and yet you claim that private sector pensions are better than the civil service scheme.

You also complain that the head of your directorate “is on a 6 figure salary”.

You complain about not being thanked for doing the job you are paid a salary for.

In your latest post, you confuse MPs with civil servants. As if paying MPs less would be more than a drop in the ocean compared to public sector pay costs. Do you know why MPs got a bigger pay rise than you? It’s because their pension scheme was made significantly less advantageous. Think about that, and whether you are as hard done by as you think you are.

😂 "I shall clarify for one last time!" Seems to have been utterly ignored by you (among other things). You are tedious Iamwombat. I see you've still not given us your view on our pay review not being adhered to, neither have you covered the areas of lack of staff increasing workloads etc.

Pensions are your obsession throughout this thread and despite my previous statements on my concern over pensions you're hanging on in there and now becoming disrespectful and patronising. Such a shame that you ruined a good adult debate.

You continue to select, edit and misrepresent the context of many posts to spin your own agenda and essentially pick fights with members because clearly you are correct based on your CS experience (many years ago and probably in one department). 100,000 of us, plus those who support us are apparently incorrect and only striking due to pensions, whinging and being "hard done by" 😂. If only you had told us this sooner we could have all stood corrected 😉.

I wish you well Iamwombat. Best of luck in your retirement. Please do be patient with the services you require from a government department as there may be delays in processing due to ongoing strike action.

Iamthewombat · 15/01/2023 20:40

IamSamantha · 15/01/2023 18:21

Thanks for the concern. I'm perfectly fit and well.

You're becoming very confused and seemingly mixing posts from people and misinterpreting/misrepresenting what's being written.

I shall clarify for one last time! I have never said i object to people being paid more depending on grade. This should reflect responsibility and position however, % increases in wages and bonuses should be equally attainable and fairly distributed among all staff. They should not be given to some for the work of others. I have never said pensions were a diabolic liberty or done a "reverse ferret". Indeed I said the pensions issue was not something that personally bothered me too much as I viewed it as a perk of the job not an employee right.

AA and AO levels are leaving due to better pay and conditions elsewhere. The reasons may have differed when you were a CS but this is now. You've still failed to address or acknowledge the current and increasing discrepancy in private pay vs public sector pay and at no time have you managed to rationally justify the discrepancy in pay rise % per grade/position. EG 17.5% pay rise parliamentary members awarded themselves, when the majority of CS have had pay freezes and now staff are accessing the benefit system due to low wages.

We do not strike and lose a days wage each time because we enjoy it. We do it as a last resort.

Yawn. Here you are upthread, complaining about pensions in response to a direct question from me, which was, what precisely is your complaint about pensions?

We cannot affect what we pay into our pensions and they aren't as good as people think. I had private sector pensions that are probably better. We had a pay review 5 years ago. It was recommended we were being paid 6k under what was justified. The review was acknowledged but we've seen nothing, no additional pay, no levelling up. The head of our directorate got a 5 figure bonus this year because we hit our SLA and productivity targets (by working all the hours god sends). They're on a 6 figure salary to begin with. We got nothing, no Christmas card, no thank you, no 15 minute time allowance for a Christmas coffee with our team (I'm being arsey but honestly nothing, not even an email saying thank you).

You don’t understand how pensions work, do you? Or the specific point the civil service unions are making. But, that’s not going to stop you complaining. You have no idea of how much somebody would have to pay into a private pension to even get close to the benefits offered by yours, and yet you claim that private sector pensions are better than the civil service scheme.

You also complain that the head of your directorate “is on a 6 figure salary”.

You complain about not being thanked for doing the job you are paid a salary for.

In your latest post, you confuse MPs with civil servants. As if paying MPs less would be more than a drop in the ocean compared to public sector pay costs. Do you know why MPs got a bigger pay rise than you? It’s because their pension scheme was made significantly less advantageous. Think about that, and whether you are as hard done by as you think you are.

peachgreen · 15/01/2023 19:00

@Iamthewombat Well that was a bizarre response…

  1. Tagging the person you’re replying to is not “trying to start a fight” – it’s a feature of this – and most other – forums. It prevents confusion. You’re holding several conversations at once – tagging or quoting makes that easier to follow. Calling it undignified is just silly. It’s perfectly normal and acceptable behaviour.
  2. Your argument that my belief that withholding labour is a fundamental human right means that I’ve “forgotten the subject of this thread” just… doesn’t make any sense? The two things can be true at once: I support striking as a fundamental human right AND I believe this specific strike is justified.
  3. I do have a pretty in-depth understanding of DP’s job, yes. I don’t think he’s mistreated. I do think he’s underpaid relative to his experience and responsibilities though, yes. In my experience — which is, of course, limited, but probably more than your average non-civil servant given I spent 6 years working directly with them — so are many civil servants, and I support the strike. I’m not “attempting to claim” that. I’m saying it outright. You clearly disagree. That’s fine.
IamSamantha · 15/01/2023 18:21

Iamthewombat · 15/01/2023 17:51

Are you quite well? Your posts are increasingly rambling. You’re the one who was complaining about people more senior than you being paid more than you, right? And who executed the reverse ferret on the pension question: one minute it was a diabolical liberty that made a strike inevitable, then the next, when you couldn’t explain what the problem with pensions was, you said that it wasn’t fundamental to your current dismay.

I’ve been a senior civil servant. I was well paid, and had great pension, which even at comparatively high contribution rates was a fantastic bargain. The holidays were great and the pressure was less than the private sector. I still moved back to the private sector. That’s because, despite having some excellent, motivated and clever colleagues, I got fed up of the endless moaning and inertia from the majority. As do many people who join the civil service. Any young people who join at AA or AO and leave are leaving for the same reason, not because the package is poor. They may also recognise that once you’ve been in the public sector for more than a few years, it’s incredibly hard to get out.

Thanks for the concern. I'm perfectly fit and well.

You're becoming very confused and seemingly mixing posts from people and misinterpreting/misrepresenting what's being written.

I shall clarify for one last time! I have never said i object to people being paid more depending on grade. This should reflect responsibility and position however, % increases in wages and bonuses should be equally attainable and fairly distributed among all staff. They should not be given to some for the work of others. I have never said pensions were a diabolic liberty or done a "reverse ferret". Indeed I said the pensions issue was not something that personally bothered me too much as I viewed it as a perk of the job not an employee right.

AA and AO levels are leaving due to better pay and conditions elsewhere. The reasons may have differed when you were a CS but this is now. You've still failed to address or acknowledge the current and increasing discrepancy in private pay vs public sector pay and at no time have you managed to rationally justify the discrepancy in pay rise % per grade/position. EG 17.5% pay rise parliamentary members awarded themselves, when the majority of CS have had pay freezes and now staff are accessing the benefit system due to low wages.

We do not strike and lose a days wage each time because we enjoy it. We do it as a last resort.

Iamthewombat · 15/01/2023 17:51

IamSamantha · 14/01/2023 07:04

You're manipulating responses.

Come and work with me for a while. You would need full security clearance, level 7 qualifications (MA or above) and at least 5 years experience working face to face, frontline. Then 6-9 months of training including exams. This is for my job.

You will be taking a pay cut to join but hey it's CS, it's going to be ok. You will have teams with a 40% rolling vacancy rate and you won't be able to keep hold of your AA or AO staff as they leave due to being overworked and can find better pay in the private sector. You have to train them up to do the job so resources are always removed to have a permanent training system in place.

Your IT system is overwhelming, based on a cheap 25year old platform that's not fit for purpose but it was the cheapest available so the government bought it. It will go offline continually for a few minutes at a time for at least 30mins every day, you will repeatedly lose your work and have to redo. It crash for over a day every month, you will have to make this lost time up. You fail to meet the increasing targets in place your placed on productivity disciplinary action therefore you continually work additional hours, which aren't recognised, and see targets increasing year on year. You will have staff off on long term sickness because of burn out. They will never come back but will remain on sickleave until they find another job. You cannot replace them until they've left.

You're take home wage is now lower than you started on and no you won't be getting paid anymore but yes you will be covering your ex colleagues job because they've left and another is on sick leave. You can ask for help again and again but replacements are virtually impossible to find and take a minimum of 6 months to train.

You will be looking for another job. You will be ideal for the CS Iamwombat because you'll think all the above is just your colleagues whinging. You will obviously decline any wage increase offered due to your colleagues strike action because it was perfectly acceptable before.

Are you quite well? Your posts are increasingly rambling. You’re the one who was complaining about people more senior than you being paid more than you, right? And who executed the reverse ferret on the pension question: one minute it was a diabolical liberty that made a strike inevitable, then the next, when you couldn’t explain what the problem with pensions was, you said that it wasn’t fundamental to your current dismay.

I’ve been a senior civil servant. I was well paid, and had great pension, which even at comparatively high contribution rates was a fantastic bargain. The holidays were great and the pressure was less than the private sector. I still moved back to the private sector. That’s because, despite having some excellent, motivated and clever colleagues, I got fed up of the endless moaning and inertia from the majority. As do many people who join the civil service. Any young people who join at AA or AO and leave are leaving for the same reason, not because the package is poor. They may also recognise that once you’ve been in the public sector for more than a few years, it’s incredibly hard to get out.

Iamthewombat · 15/01/2023 17:41

Oh well, that extra three months makes ALL the difference.

Can’t you see the flaws in your own argument? Clearly not. I’ll point out the most egregious. You say, above, that “…it’s important to support striking workers as a matter of principle because withdrawal of labour is a basic human right.”

In other words, you would support any strike because in your view, striking is a human right. You’ve forgotten that the subject of this thread is one particular strike: the proposed strike by civil servants. Which rather detracts from your attempts to claim that you have an in-depth understanding of your boyfriend’s job, and the jobs of many other civil servants and thus can claim without fear of contradiction that the civil service are mistreated enough to strike.

Incidentally, you should stop tagging me in your posts, like a teenager trying to start a fight. Have some dignity.

peachgreen · 15/01/2023 15:01

@Iamthewombat Your misrepresentation of other people’s posts (and complete fabrication of the facts in some places!) is really quite something.

a) DP and I have been together for 6 months, not 3. Actually it’s almost 8 months at this stage, to be entirely accurate. I’ve known him for quite a bit longer.
b) He’s also not the only civil servant in my life.
c) My previous private sector job was consulting, specifically for local and UK Government, so I worked closely with civil servants for 6 years. Long enough to see that in general, certainly at lower and mid-level, there was a lot more expected of them in terms of output and responsibility relative to their remuneration than in my experience of the private sector.
d) This experience leads me to conclude that striking is justified, as well as my belief that it’s important to support striking workers as a matter of principle because withdrawal of labour is a basic human right.

Testina · 14/01/2023 15:22

“You fail to meet the increasing targets in place your placed on productivity disciplinary action therefore you continually work additional hours, which aren't recognised, and see targets increasing year on year. You will have staff off on long term sickness because of burn out. They will never come back but will remain on sickleave until they find another job. You cannot replace them until they've left.”

And this is what a union should be for. To stop the target increase. To stop the productivity disciplinary action. To stop the extra hours. That’s bring down the burn out rate.

They should also be involved in a fair process for removing people on sick leave, so replacements can be made, but I doubt you’ll find a union willing to do that! Despite the knock on effect to their members in work.

All members work to rule, without even demanding a pay increase. No unpaid overtime. Let the services collapse. No pissing about with one day strikes that are just the same as you losing the system to a crash for a day - that is, just more pressure to make up the lost time.

This is a rare workers market ahead of recession. Now is the time to work contracted hours only - and the let the union be very clear its PR on why you can’t get a driving licence application through (or whatever service it is).

Zanatdy · 14/01/2023 07:56

No, I won’t be

IamSamantha · 14/01/2023 07:04

Iamthewombat · 13/01/2023 21:22

No, I don’t ‘have it in for civil servants’. Nor am I Jacob Rees Mogg, haha. I assume that is who ‘JRM’ is?

What I’m ‘getting out of the thread’ is debating civil servants’ decision to strike. Which affects the public, including me. They wouldn’t be striking unless it didn’t affect the public, right? This is a public forum.

Predictably, as soon as any difficult questions are asked, the thread veers off into a pity party or preaching.

Example: I asked precisely what the pension complaint underpinning the strike action was. Nobody knew, least of all the posters planning to strike over it. One poster linked to a pensions website that you had to subscribe to, after which I had to find out for myself what the McCloud remedy is and the context.

Example 2: somebody moans that her ‘DP’ doesn’t get paid enough. In her opinion, and his, his job is harder than hers (she’s known him for three months, it transpires, and has never done his job, but never mind). She earns much more, and thinks that this constitutes enough evidence to claim that strikes are justified and that civil servants would be paid much more if they worked in the private sector.

Example 3: somebody else chimes in to say that in her specialist field, salaries are 30% to 40% higher in the private sector. Hence the strikes are justified and civil servants are underpaid. Why haven’t they all moved to the private sector then, she is asked? She has no answer but launches into a preaching session about her opposition to ‘the gig economy and shitty menial jobs’. What’s that got to do with the civil service? It’s a distraction tactic.

I’m sure that there are all kinds of reasons for civil servants to be unhappy with their lot, but none of them have been well articulated on this thread.

You're manipulating responses.

Come and work with me for a while. You would need full security clearance, level 7 qualifications (MA or above) and at least 5 years experience working face to face, frontline. Then 6-9 months of training including exams. This is for my job.

You will be taking a pay cut to join but hey it's CS, it's going to be ok. You will have teams with a 40% rolling vacancy rate and you won't be able to keep hold of your AA or AO staff as they leave due to being overworked and can find better pay in the private sector. You have to train them up to do the job so resources are always removed to have a permanent training system in place.

Your IT system is overwhelming, based on a cheap 25year old platform that's not fit for purpose but it was the cheapest available so the government bought it. It will go offline continually for a few minutes at a time for at least 30mins every day, you will repeatedly lose your work and have to redo. It crash for over a day every month, you will have to make this lost time up. You fail to meet the increasing targets in place your placed on productivity disciplinary action therefore you continually work additional hours, which aren't recognised, and see targets increasing year on year. You will have staff off on long term sickness because of burn out. They will never come back but will remain on sickleave until they find another job. You cannot replace them until they've left.

You're take home wage is now lower than you started on and no you won't be getting paid anymore but yes you will be covering your ex colleagues job because they've left and another is on sick leave. You can ask for help again and again but replacements are virtually impossible to find and take a minimum of 6 months to train.

You will be looking for another job. You will be ideal for the CS Iamwombat because you'll think all the above is just your colleagues whinging. You will obviously decline any wage increase offered due to your colleagues strike action because it was perfectly acceptable before.

DdraigGoch · 14/01/2023 00:12

Testina · 13/01/2023 09:18

I don’t think a one day strike will be effective.

I think you’d gain more by working to rule, politely refusing to do unpaid overtime - and letting those services to the public grind to a halt.

I agree, all these complaints of being de facto below minimum wage due to unpaid overtime - just refuse en masse to do it. No loss of pay in the process.

Theopossumwasmeantforme · 13/01/2023 22:45

The pension overpayment issue is actually fairly important, last time I checked the calculator, which was months ago, it was a fairly decent chunk of my (low) salary. They're now saying that that money is needed to implement the mccloud judgement, but this was months and months after the valuation. The mccloud judgement was needed because the way that employees were moved to the new scheme was age discrimination, as it was handled differently depending on how close to pension age you were.

It's probably important to note that this judgement covers a HUGE number of public servants. Doctors, teachers, obviously fire fighters and judges. Does that make it more palitable?