Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think she shouldn’t bother buying Christmas presents?

35 replies

Gem123J · 12/01/2023 09:28

To be talking about Christmas now 😮I know! But I was just in the kitchen and one of my husband’s presents was on the shelf in front of me and I got wondering!

Every year my mum buys these awful presents for us and it just makes me think why even bother? For example this time I received an outdoor citronella candle and a solar panel bird feeder, all from b&m as the price tags were still on, and obviously bought from the summer sale! Aibu to think why even bother? These are things she’s obviously just picked up from the sale with no certain person in mind, I know she likes to buy loads from sales to keep in the house for when a time comes that she can use or gift it, so usually you would think with awful gifts that it’s the thought that counts, but obviously there’s no thought here right?! What use do I have for these in winter time anyway? The bird feeder, ok birds need food in winter, but the candle?! I also have a cat so a bird feeder isn’t something I’ll put up as last time we did this our cat would hang around to catch the birds so I don’t want poor dead birds in the garden again and the cat catching fleas from said dead birds (like before!).

And my husband was gifted this tiny wind up torch (which is kind of useful but is very small so only useful to look in the cupboard for something, if the lights are out!), and I think he did get some beer this time so not too bad! Oh and these socks that said ‘Merry Kissmass’ 😂so just shows she doesn’t pay attention to what she’s gifting, just simply picking bargains and then throwing them into gift bags.

I feel like just asking her not to bother at all to be honest, but I don’t want to sound ungrateful but there is absolutely zero thought in these gifts isn’t there? And I think I’m more annoyed because for her and her boyfriend I bought them a voucher each for the cinema because they like going to watch films, and scratch cards that were £10 each because they usually win when I buy some to put in a card for their birthday’s etc. so obviously I’m thinking of what they would like, and I’ve obviously spent quite a bit more on them to be honest, not that the value counts… if thought was put in the gift.

I also think to phone my brother sometimes to see what they had because I know for a fact he would not be happy, and would make it known, if him and his wife were to receive these things. My Mum mentioned before that she gives my brother’s wife a hamper on her birthday and she said this in front of my husband who doesn’t get anything for his birthday off her, and I do feel sorry because his family always give me a card and a bottle of something or chocolates for my birthday and he doesn’t get any recognition from my family!

Aibu and I should just let it go and get on with it and not cause any arguments or should I mention something because it’s better than receiving gifts that serve no use to us and just clutter the home if anything?!

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Anisina · 14/01/2023 00:03

TimeFlysWhenYoureHavingRum · 13/01/2023 23:09

Yanbu. I love xmas but it would be great if everyone stopped buying plastic tat for the sake of it.

'Plastic tat' might be my most hated MN phrase.

TimeFlysWhenYoureHavingRum · 13/01/2023 23:09

Yanbu. I love xmas but it would be great if everyone stopped buying plastic tat for the sake of it.

SillySausage81 · 13/01/2023 23:03

See, this is why I bloody hate gift giving.

Half the responses here are agreeing with you that they are shit gifts, half of them are saying they sound like great gifts.

My point is, some people are just really crap at buying gifts no matter how much thought they put into it, and on the other hand some people (not saying this is you OP) are really picky and make it impossible to buy for them.

I know I'm rubbish at gift giving. Every November and December are excruciating for me as I twist myself in knots trying to think of something the dozen or so people I have to buy for would like, but I just always find myself second-guessing every idea I have... It's just so easy to fall back on clichés, like "oh, Sally mentioned she likes bees last year... I'll get her a bee-themed tea towel". My mind just doesn't seem to work in the way that produces excellent gifts.

Hell, I can barely think of things I want for Christmas (I'm often stumped if anyone asks me, and end up falling back on clichés - "just get me some beers or some chocolates"), so I don't see how I can be expected to try and guess what anyone else wants.

I used to think my mum was like your mum, just buying any old tat without a thought, but now I have realised she actually buys it genuinely thinking we would like it... which makes me sad on so many levels. Sad that I don't appreciate her efforts and also sad at the amount of sheer waste. And sad that my instinctive reaction is irritation. I think gift-giving is her "love language" so we're bombarded with the stuff. When she explains why she bought us a particular gift I can now see that she has put thought into it, but the fact remains I just don't want it cluttering up my house. I just bloody wish Christmas gift giving could be restricted to children but no one else seems up for that, so on we go with the whole pointless, stupid, wasteful charade.

Sartre · 13/01/2023 22:03

Same issue with MIL. Her presents are just always awful. Completely inappropriate toys for DC (often dangerous tbh) and just things DH and I wouldn’t use at all. This year I got a fake Valentino belt and it’s bloody awful, it’s also a medium so it’s way too big for my waist. I wish she wouldn’t bother but we don’t have the heart to tell her. I think she thinks we will like them but we just never do, DC included.

User359472111111 · 13/01/2023 21:53

Nimbostratus100 · 12/01/2023 21:00

so made entirely 100% out of chemicals then, what else do you think they could possibly be made out of? Almond oil contains some particularly nasty allergenic chemicals too

I’m with you @Nimbostratus100 - I would much rather have a citronella candle and some silly socks than homemade bath stuff that’s probably going to give me an allergic reaction!

Twiglets1 · 12/01/2023 21:00

My MIL gives us a box of Cadburys Roses every year, we don't have the heart to tell her we don't like them. YANBU but I couldn't do it.

Nimbostratus100 · 12/01/2023 21:00

Gem123J · 12/01/2023 19:05

@Nimbostratus100 I said organic bath products, so no chemicals. Only organic cocoa butter and almond oil. And I never said I would have gifted them to her, when I was making them she told me not to ever gift them because she won’t use them, although she does use the bath. That’s just how she is. A bit like you it seems then!

Each to their own. I was simply trying to paint the picture how she tells me not to give her certain things because she finds them tat but fine for her to buy tat for others.

so made entirely 100% out of chemicals then, what else do you think they could possibly be made out of? Almond oil contains some particularly nasty allergenic chemicals too

Anisina · 12/01/2023 20:55

I think you would find fault with what ever she gave you. Those gifts don't sound bad to me. Well, the socks are a bit odd but we would just laugh and wear them any way.

baffledcoconut · 12/01/2023 20:47

Gem123J · 12/01/2023 19:05

@Nimbostratus100 I said organic bath products, so no chemicals. Only organic cocoa butter and almond oil. And I never said I would have gifted them to her, when I was making them she told me not to ever gift them because she won’t use them, although she does use the bath. That’s just how she is. A bit like you it seems then!

Each to their own. I was simply trying to paint the picture how she tells me not to give her certain things because she finds them tat but fine for her to buy tat for others.

I’d absolutely love to get a gift like this. But the inlaws wouldn’t. I guess it’s just down to being very different people who don’t get each other.

ps can I be your friend? I’d adore properly made organic bath stuff! (And not the freebie sample of hideous smelling stuff I got as my Christmas present…)

Gem123J · 12/01/2023 19:05

Nimbostratus100 · 12/01/2023 14:25

see, to me, bath products would be the ultimate in thoughtless pointless gifts, and I smile and say thank you politely, then they go straight in the bin as soon as the giver has gone.

I would never voluntarily apply unnecessary chemicals to my skin, and I hate the assumption that I would. I have recently had several surgeries, and the number of people who insist on sending me "pamper products" as get well presents is unreal, despite, when speaking to my sons in advance, being very specifically told I won't want them

So I wouldn't say your mums gifts are thoughtless, just that we like different things

@Nimbostratus100 I said organic bath products, so no chemicals. Only organic cocoa butter and almond oil. And I never said I would have gifted them to her, when I was making them she told me not to ever gift them because she won’t use them, although she does use the bath. That’s just how she is. A bit like you it seems then!

Each to their own. I was simply trying to paint the picture how she tells me not to give her certain things because she finds them tat but fine for her to buy tat for others.

OP posts:
Nimbostratus100 · 12/01/2023 14:25

see, to me, bath products would be the ultimate in thoughtless pointless gifts, and I smile and say thank you politely, then they go straight in the bin as soon as the giver has gone.

I would never voluntarily apply unnecessary chemicals to my skin, and I hate the assumption that I would. I have recently had several surgeries, and the number of people who insist on sending me "pamper products" as get well presents is unreal, despite, when speaking to my sons in advance, being very specifically told I won't want them

So I wouldn't say your mums gifts are thoughtless, just that we like different things

Gem123J · 12/01/2023 12:00

But she bought some Tropic stuff off her friend’s DIL to support her business but never once thought to support or promote her own daughter’s business!

Ok, I’ll stop now with the updates 😅

OP posts:
Gem123J · 12/01/2023 11:57

I think it’s worth me mentioning that this is a person who told me when I ran my own little side hustle making organic bath products a couple of years back not to gift her any of that s*@t for Christmas because she won’t use it! Whereas my MIL said to me very nicely that she never uses the bath just in case I gave her any of the products, and this is true, they’ve never once used their bath when they renovated their home!

And the products I made were nice too, made a lot of sales over a year until I stopped making them because I didn’t have time between work and being a parent, so not like I was just making some cheap horrible stuff.

OP posts:
Gem123J · 12/01/2023 11:44

thecatsthecats · 12/01/2023 11:37

I have a similar issue with my lovely and very generous MIL.

She always likes to buy things I definitely want, but also doesn't buy some things I ask for (she asks for links and lists, so I give them), because they're not "gifty" enough.

So as well as the thing I want, there'll be about twenty things I want with foofy, frilly, gifty things.

For example - a weights set - but also a lurid pink headband with a naff gym slogan on it. Baking materials, but also a few fluffy, cutesy baking implements that are totally (ugly) style over substance.

I love that she gets me gifts and wants to feel like she's treating me, but she's actually just treating me to a trip to the charity shop.

@thecatsthecats I know some people would happily accept, same as what we have received in the past such as the wind up radio, but to me
it’s just items that would rarely, if at all, get any use just taking up space. I’m in a much smaller house than she is, I hate clutter, and I just don’t have space for all this random bits that are useful in a crisis but not day to day. We never listen to the radio, she never listens to the radio, she likes similar music to me so knows I use my phone for music, as does she, so why the wind up radio?! We never go camping, neither has she ever, so it won’t get any use and she knows this.

OP posts:
thecatsthecats · 12/01/2023 11:37

I have a similar issue with my lovely and very generous MIL.

She always likes to buy things I definitely want, but also doesn't buy some things I ask for (she asks for links and lists, so I give them), because they're not "gifty" enough.

So as well as the thing I want, there'll be about twenty things I want with foofy, frilly, gifty things.

For example - a weights set - but also a lurid pink headband with a naff gym slogan on it. Baking materials, but also a few fluffy, cutesy baking implements that are totally (ugly) style over substance.

I love that she gets me gifts and wants to feel like she's treating me, but she's actually just treating me to a trip to the charity shop.

Gem123J · 12/01/2023 11:29

Ontopofthesunset · 12/01/2023 10:56

I'm with others here that they sound like perfectly reasonable gifts, not particularly thoughtless at all.

Does your mum know the citronella candle is useless to you? Have you had conversations about how you never sit outside in the summer? It sounds to me like a nice gift and we would use it. The same with the bird feeder, though I take your point about the cat. But have you specifically told her that you can't use bird feeders because the cat kills all the birds? If not, she might not realise. Also, the Merry Kissmas socks are just an affectionate joke, aren't they? It's just a silly Christmas thing for her son who I guess she's fond of, not a declaration of sexual interest.

The socks were gifted to my DH so not her son. Merry Kissmass with lots of kissing lips on it, my DH thought it was a bit weird but we know it’s just something she’s bought on sale and has thrown it in the bag for his gift. My brother would never accept novelty gifts and they would be in the bin, I know that for a fact!

She knew about our cat killing birds when we last had a bird feeder and we stopped putting anything out because we had a bad flea problem that in the last house because of this, out cat kept killing and eating birds and then even with regular flea treatment caught fleas and they were all in the house. Took weeks to get rid of them all! The candle will probably get use but I didn’t think it was a usual thing to buy summer accessories for Christmas presents? Our house is on the market and we’re hoping to sell soon so the candle won’t get any use in this house.

OP posts:
Ontopofthesunset · 12/01/2023 10:56

I'm with others here that they sound like perfectly reasonable gifts, not particularly thoughtless at all.

Does your mum know the citronella candle is useless to you? Have you had conversations about how you never sit outside in the summer? It sounds to me like a nice gift and we would use it. The same with the bird feeder, though I take your point about the cat. But have you specifically told her that you can't use bird feeders because the cat kills all the birds? If not, she might not realise. Also, the Merry Kissmas socks are just an affectionate joke, aren't they? It's just a silly Christmas thing for her son who I guess she's fond of, not a declaration of sexual interest.

Gem123J · 12/01/2023 10:16

Nicecow · 12/01/2023 10:11

Well you could just say it nicely, rather than not to bother. I've been telling my parents for years not to buy me anything as I don't need anything (which is true)

@Nicecow yes I’d definitely say it nicely, I think I might suggest no gifts this Christmas since we’ll have another child and I’ll have been on maternity for most part of the year so for us to cut down on our spending and that she can cut down on spending for us too.

OP posts:
Mabelface · 12/01/2023 10:15

My mum is terrible at gift buying! However, she does put thought behind the gifts, and my siblings and I compare each year.

She's 80 and lovely, so I go with the thought behind.

Gem123J · 12/01/2023 10:12

NoDairyNoProblem · 12/01/2023 10:04

Would it be fair to say it’s more the discrepancies between what your brothers family receive and what your family receive that is truly the issue? Thoughtless gifts aside.

@NoDairyNoProblem oh definitely. It could be that my brother kicked up a fuss because it’s definitely something he would do. Or that she doesn’t dare gift him things from the sale because she knows he would be disappointed. I don’t think it’s very fair, and I wouldn’t do that to my own children. It’s always been the case though, he’s always been treated better than I have, even though I’ve always done more to help with family, but that’s a whole different story! Some fairness would be nice, or nothing at all because it just adds salt to the wounds.

OP posts:
Nicecow · 12/01/2023 10:11

Well you could just say it nicely, rather than not to bother. I've been telling my parents for years not to buy me anything as I don't need anything (which is true)

Gem123J · 12/01/2023 10:08

Nimbostratus100 · 12/01/2023 10:01

what does the solar power of the bird feeder do?

NOthing you mention sounds like rubbish to me

You had a birdfeeder once, it didn't work out, she gave you a different one - cant you put it out of reach of the cat?

You obviously have an outdoors, and you have an outdoor candle, the sort of luxury item most people would enjoy, but not buy for themselves

You have a wind up radio stored under the stairs. WInd up radios are for peace of mind, for use in an emergency, such as getting snowed in, floods, or supply chain failure. They are not necesserily for using, just for having, for the peace of mind - although I always use ours when camping.

I dont see how this shows less thought than cinema vouchers and scratch cards.

@Nimbostratus100 It just has a little light on top of it.

Of course some would like these things. I’m not saying they’re completely rubbish I’m saying they’re useless for me. There is no thought. Whereas the voucher I bought because they go to the cinema often, they have use of this gift. Aren’t we told to put thought in gifts? If she bought them for you and you like these things and would get use out of them, great. But for me I have no use, I know they’re things she’s bought in the sale with no person in mind at the time.

Our fence is 6ft so I couldn’t really put the bird feeder any higher unless I went up on a ladder and stuck it on the house.

OP posts:
Q85 · 12/01/2023 10:04

I can relate some what. I have fear every Christmas opening gifts from my mum. I will encourage my partner that we open them Christmas Eve to almost get them out the way and away from the sight of others. As I can be so embarrassed by how little the gifts are suited to us.

I had a few years where it would really upset me. Sometimes cry asking my partner how does my mum know so little about me to be so far off the mark with the gifts. And his mum goes above and beyond to really consider what I might like (this heightens those feelings as she barely knows me and get it perfect even on a small budget)

I too had thought do I confront my mum, do I suggest we don't need gifts. And so glad I never did as this last year my dad died and she ended up speaking to me a little about when they'd go shopping and it opened my eyes that she really is doing the best she is able to.

I've made peace with the fact that my mum is unable to know me in a way I'd like and take comfort in knowing she tried. I will continue to open the gifts on Christmas Eve but with a different mindset from past years.

As for not acknowledging your partner it's hard to know what is going on there. Maybe one to consider how important it is to you and him to confront. And what outcomes could arise from the confrontation.

I did once have to talk to my mum about how upsetting it was that she would blank my partner when he was a guest in her home. I stopped taking him around and she does make more of an effort now to talk with him.

NoDairyNoProblem · 12/01/2023 10:04

Would it be fair to say it’s more the discrepancies between what your brothers family receive and what your family receive that is truly the issue? Thoughtless gifts aside.

Nimbostratus100 · 12/01/2023 10:01

what does the solar power of the bird feeder do?

NOthing you mention sounds like rubbish to me

You had a birdfeeder once, it didn't work out, she gave you a different one - cant you put it out of reach of the cat?

You obviously have an outdoors, and you have an outdoor candle, the sort of luxury item most people would enjoy, but not buy for themselves

You have a wind up radio stored under the stairs. WInd up radios are for peace of mind, for use in an emergency, such as getting snowed in, floods, or supply chain failure. They are not necesserily for using, just for having, for the peace of mind - although I always use ours when camping.

I dont see how this shows less thought than cinema vouchers and scratch cards.