Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To Pay for a Strangers Shopping?

191 replies

NameChangeAgainandAgainandAgain · 12/01/2023 03:03

I've name changed for this ...

There's a truly lovely thread on Chat called "What is the most memorable moment you shared with a stranger who you never saw again?".

There are many stories about the kindness of complete strangers and what a difference they have made to their life.

Some stories are incredibly moving and talk about how strangers have helped out when, for instance, a loved one has died.

Other stories talk about how a stranger has helped when things have been tough financially.

I know times are hard and reading all the posts has made me think that I'd like to, perhaps, pay for someone's basket of shopping in the supermarket, their petrol or buy someone a coffee etc.

Having read the impact this sort of thing has had on people, and how they remember it so many years on, I'd like to do this rather than donate as such.

How do you do this without being condescending or insulting? And how do you know who to do it to?

I wouldn't want any thanks as I'd probably run off quickly as I'd be embarrassed!

OP posts:
minmooch · 12/01/2023 08:26

@Getinajollymood nothing self congratulatory in being in a position to help someone. In my case the woman's shopping was about £25 so not a big deal to me, but was to her. I never told anyone else about it before as never felt the need.

I give to various charities if that makes any difference to you???

My son died aged 18 and during his illness many people, even strangers, helped me. I was happy to help someone.

LetsDoThis2023 · 12/01/2023 08:26

Buy a hot drink and some lunch for your local big issue seller.

LetsDoThis2023 · 12/01/2023 08:25

Buy a load of food for a food bank op.

Nogbreaks · 12/01/2023 08:24

On a plane that should be

Nogbreaks · 12/01/2023 08:24

I’ve paid for someone’s shopping when they didn’t have enough money but it was spontaneous not planned. I did it because someone once did it for me when I was a really poor student.
i’ e done similar things, you don’t need to plan it, if you look around you’ll see lots of opportunities to help people in small or big ways!
once took a woman’s baby in a place for a few hours - she was exhausted, baby crying, so I walked him so she could go to loo and have a minute.
little bugger fell asleep so I kept him, and told her to nap. They both ended up sleeping the rest of the flight, him on my lap and lady across the aisle. It was no bother to me, not really, and she was a different person once she’d had a bit of sleep!

GimmeSleep · 12/01/2023 08:23

Nothing big, but was queuing for food at a football match and the young boy in front asked how much a portion of chips was. He obviously didn't have enough so left the queue; added a portion on to our order and gave them to him.

alittlebitofspark · 12/01/2023 08:22

I wouldn't do it for fear of embarrassing the person but I do like to do a bit of anonymous gift giving if I can. I heard that someone in the community was struggling with an unexpected expense for their child so put some cash in a card through their letterbox. Didn't want to freak them out, so just said that I knew times were tough, wanted to help etc but didn't sign the card.

I've never had the opportunity to help a stranger (mostly of fear of embarrassing them) but I quite like the American idea of 'paying it forward' and when you go to a drive thru, paying for the order behind you. The person won't know until they get to the window and you can avoid any upset/embarrassment. In theory it then encourages them to pay it forward for someone else.

KatyN · 12/01/2023 08:15

I once paid for the morning after pill for a 17 year old who had been given spectacularly bad advice (not just about the choice of boy) about how she could access it for free.
The chemist didn't have the free ones or the ones that cost £20 so expected her to find £35.

We both cried. I was livid for her, she was just scared.

faffadoodledo · 12/01/2023 08:10

We managed to pay for a cafe meal for a lovely Ukrainian woman and her son. We were sharing a table with them. The little boy was playing with his plastic dinosaur figure and being absolutely lovely. He was delighted when my husband told him he was a geologist who'd seen real dinosaur bones. The woman's husband was fighting in Ukraine. We left before them, went to the til and paid for their lunch.
It was the nicest thing that happened to us all week.
But I wouldn't have done it less anonymously

FairyBatman · 12/01/2023 08:05

This can also go wrong. I took DS to the barbers and it was £6 I tried to pay with £10 our and she didn’t have change and didn’t take card. She was going to walk to the post office and get change so I offered to pop in and pay on the way back from the supermarket to save her going out.

Went to Lidl then called in and paid on the way home and then bumped into the old gent who had been waiting in the barbers who told me to treat DS as he’d paid the barber.

CF had taken money off both of us, never used her again.

InTheFourthAtMalloryTowers · 12/01/2023 08:00

A few years ago I was at a petrol station and a young soldier could not get the taxi fare, to get back to camp, out of his bank account. Was stood there with a large heavy box. I heard him calling various people or help and no one could
come and get him.

I approached him and explained my son was currently applying to the army and I wanted to help. Paid for his taxi back to camp. He was in tears. Asking for my name and number - I just told him when you are middle aged maybe you can help a young person own time and pay it forward.

I still think of him and hope he safe and happy.

DarkNecessities · 12/01/2023 07:48

Posters saying don’t buy for kids when parents say no and I agree.

I paid for a child on their own once though. He was trying to buy a Mother’s Day card and when he got to the till and counted his change he didn’t have enough and went off to put it back. Touched my heart

terriblyangryattimes · 12/01/2023 07:42

There is a cafe near me that also acts as a community hub and they have a sign at the counter that says that if you're struggling there are some meals already paid for by others and to just ask or point to the sign if it's busy.

I know the lady that runs the place and she says a few times a week people who are able to will add an extra fiver or tenner when they pay for this 'pot'. Perhaps see if you have anything like that locally, perhaps a place where the elderly might visit frequently to get out of the house for example? To get something warm inside them.

Getinajollymood · 12/01/2023 07:38

It’s nice to pay for someone’s bus fare or similar if they are short but just paying for a totally random persons shopping seems really a bit odd and very self congratulatory.

Does anyone else remember the woman in Australia who was given flowers and really wasn’t happy about it (understandably!)

I mean, if you have money to burn there are any number of worthy organisations!

minmooch · 12/01/2023 07:25

I paid for someone's shopping a couple of months back. They were obviously distressed, trying to put things back from her shopping to match what she had in her bank. She was trying to ring her mum to transfer money into her account. She had a young child with her.

She may have been trying to pull a fast one but her distress seemed real to me. I put all her things back in her basket and paid for her.

She wanted my details to pay me back but, like others, I said to her if she wanted to she could pay it forward some other time in her life if she were able.

I'd like to think I wasn't the only person who, if they could, would have stepped in and paid.

MrTumblesSpottyHag · 12/01/2023 07:21

I paid for a stranger's parking once (I've done this loads actually because I have aaalllll the apps on my phone!)
This particular time it was only £1 and she hadn't realised the carpark had gone cashless and couldn't get enough data to download the app.
I told her I was doing it, tapped it through and said enjoy your day.
She ran to her car and got a £5 note out and when I point blank refused to take it she tucked it into the top of my swimming costume and walked off 😮😂 (we were at a river and most people go there for the same hobby so people tend to be more friendly than other places but still it was a bit unexpected!)

I thought it was hilarious! I'm still not on profit though, I've lost count of how many £1 parking I've put through over the years 😆

sandgrown · 12/01/2023 07:17

I am always reminded of the young woman, a few years ago , who was 20p short of her bus fare and was turfed off the last bus. She walked home and was murdered. She had held the bus up while she searched her bag to find the extra money but nobody offered to help. I was at the next checkout to a woman who was trying to buy baby milk and I think her card was declined. She was in tears and went to walk away when the elderly man behind her insisted he pay for it .

LlynTegid · 12/01/2023 07:17

There is the possibility of hurting someone's pride, I think better to donate money and or/time to organisations that provide such help, such as food banks. Wish none of it was ever necessary, but that is not going to change soon.

Ahwelltoobad · 12/01/2023 07:12

WestBridgewater · 12/01/2023 06:41

Not exactly the same but in my weekly shop was a packet of Biscoff biscuits and the chap at the next till pointed them out to his wife, joking how she never got them. I told him that they were the last pack-which they were-and he seemed really disappointed and we had a bit of a chat about biscuits. They reminded me of my grandparents and when they were talking to the checkout person to pay I popped them in one of their shopping bags to find when they unpacked their shopping..

Brilliant!

FrenchandSaunders · 12/01/2023 07:09

I’ve paid someone’s train fare. There was a ticket inspector who made a beeline for this young mum with two small children. She asked if she could pay a bit with the cash she had and the rest on her card as there wasn’t much in her account.

She handed him the card while she counted out her change and he did the whole transaction on the card which was obv declined. Which he loudly announced so the whole carriage could hear.

He was an arsehole who seemed to enjoy her embarrassment and discomfort 😡

HereIfYouNeedMe · 12/01/2023 07:08

WestBridgewater · 12/01/2023 06:41

Not exactly the same but in my weekly shop was a packet of Biscoff biscuits and the chap at the next till pointed them out to his wife, joking how she never got them. I told him that they were the last pack-which they were-and he seemed really disappointed and we had a bit of a chat about biscuits. They reminded me of my grandparents and when they were talking to the checkout person to pay I popped them in one of their shopping bags to find when they unpacked their shopping..

I love this 😊

Oldfox · 12/01/2023 07:08

I paid for someone's parking once, not a big amount, but their phone wasn't being accepted, so I just paid it for them

tickychicky · 12/01/2023 07:07

Finallyfree23 · 12/01/2023 07:02

The smallest of gestures perhaps, but I was on a bus during the really bad weather recently when a young Mum got on with her 3 young kids. Her card was declined a couple of times for the £2 fare, and the driver tried to make then get off. She was distraught, they’d waited nearly an hour in the snow, trying to get to the walk in centre as one of the kids was sick.

I paid the fare, and gave the driver some choice words about decency. Maybe she was pulling a fast one, who knows, but it was £2 ffs! I didn’t really have £2 to spare, but how can anybody leave a young family shivering at the side of the road?

Perhaps the only sad thing was I think I made her cry more than she already was. 🙈

People have been there for me at some of my most difficult times and I know just how much I’d have appreciated that if I had been in that position. Sometimes life sucks, and sometimes random strangers really do make all the difference.

That could be down to the companies training and policies though or she could do the same thing every day. So you've made the drivers day a bit shitter. Still, that is a good idea - if you see someone about to be refused to get on the bus the offer to pay.

Finallyfree23 · 12/01/2023 07:02

The smallest of gestures perhaps, but I was on a bus during the really bad weather recently when a young Mum got on with her 3 young kids. Her card was declined a couple of times for the £2 fare, and the driver tried to make then get off. She was distraught, they’d waited nearly an hour in the snow, trying to get to the walk in centre as one of the kids was sick.

I paid the fare, and gave the driver some choice words about decency. Maybe she was pulling a fast one, who knows, but it was £2 ffs! I didn’t really have £2 to spare, but how can anybody leave a young family shivering at the side of the road?

Perhaps the only sad thing was I think I made her cry more than she already was. 🙈

People have been there for me at some of my most difficult times and I know just how much I’d have appreciated that if I had been in that position. Sometimes life sucks, and sometimes random strangers really do make all the difference.

Bagatella · 12/01/2023 07:00

I was once behind a middle aged woman at the till who tried to do a runner with a packet of sliced ham and a few tins of cat food. The cashier rung it up and she bagged it and shot out of the shop.

The security guards ran after her and pinned her to a car and they called the police. Whole shop came to a standstill to watch.

Her shopping came to less than a fiver. I offered to pay but was refused as 'a crime had been committed .'

Poor woman. She must have been desperate.