Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To Pay for a Strangers Shopping?

191 replies

NameChangeAgainandAgainandAgain · 12/01/2023 03:03

I've name changed for this ...

There's a truly lovely thread on Chat called "What is the most memorable moment you shared with a stranger who you never saw again?".

There are many stories about the kindness of complete strangers and what a difference they have made to their life.

Some stories are incredibly moving and talk about how strangers have helped out when, for instance, a loved one has died.

Other stories talk about how a stranger has helped when things have been tough financially.

I know times are hard and reading all the posts has made me think that I'd like to, perhaps, pay for someone's basket of shopping in the supermarket, their petrol or buy someone a coffee etc.

Having read the impact this sort of thing has had on people, and how they remember it so many years on, I'd like to do this rather than donate as such.

How do you do this without being condescending or insulting? And how do you know who to do it to?

I wouldn't want any thanks as I'd probably run off quickly as I'd be embarrassed!

OP posts:
SweetSenorita · 12/01/2023 09:34

Getinajollymood · 12/01/2023 08:38

It’s only an act of kindness if you are sure the recipient wants it, though.

I do think people should be aware that there is the potential to cause quite a lot of embarrassment and upset. Having kind intentions doesn’t mean we can or should completely overlook this.

Other people do not exist to give us a warm fuzzy glow.

Pfft. I'm happy if I can help give someone else a warm, fuzzy glow. I think the world would be a better place with more glow 🌟

I love this thread. And those of you with lovely stories ..... don't stop. You're not being self-congratulatory; you're making a kinder world. Go you 😘

Nogbreaks · 12/01/2023 09:25

'I am honestly not trying to be unnecessarily argumentative here, but can people really not see that in the midst of a restaurant or cafe or shop, potentially with people who know you or know of you, someone deciding you are worthy of a charitable act, could be both unwanted and embarrassing?'

only if you're a cynical person too self conscious to interact with other people.
I've never been embarrassed about being helped, or helping someone because you judge each situation at the time.
So sitting on a computer saying that's awful, you'll 'embarrass' people, really isn't relevant.

I also think this stuff if cultural, I'm from a country known for it's open, friendly people and strangers interact and chat much more than here in England nd without any notion of that being 'embarrassing'.

WatchingGreysAgain · 12/01/2023 09:23

I think this is an amazing thing to do, I’m definitely not in a position to do it currently and am using the local foodbank/community fridge due to a long month and being paid early before Christmas, however when I am in a better position I will definitely do this for someone, as I know how much I would appreciate it.

ThreeLocusts · 12/01/2023 09:05

Agree with pps that it's tricky to make sure you don't offent accidentally when chipping in with someone's shopping.

It's only happened to me a couple of times in decades of supermarket shopping that the person in front of me was a couple of quid/euro short and I could chip in. It's a real mood brightener to do that, lucky for me as much as the other person.

But it's got to happen unforced, otherwise better just give to a charity.

TheLette · 12/01/2023 09:02

ImustLearn2Cook · 12/01/2023 05:43

I think when it comes to other peoples children it is better to ask the parents quietly and respectfully. There are reasons that they say no. It could be because the children have already had enough sweets and the parents don’t want them to have any more. Or they say no to buying a toy because their children have too many toys, and sometimes it’s beneficial to children to not get everything that they want or ask for.

Undermining parents or other adults in authority in front of the children has negative consequences for children. Conversely respecting parents or other adults in authority in front of the children has positive consequences for children.

Also, when I was a child we were taught stranger danger and to never accept lollies, or toys etc from strangers. For obvious reasons. Predators will use these sorts of tactics to lure children.

Not all strangers are dangerous or predatory but children will not always be able to tell the difference between a Good Samaritan type or a dangerous person pretending to be a good person. So, I don’t think it’s wise to set a precedent of accepting food or toys or gifts from strangers.

A person I didn’t know tried to give my dd a brand new barbie doll in the shopping centre car park. She went to accept it but I said no. Then I said to the person that I appreciate that they were trying to be nice but no thanks. They looked a bit offended and shook their head as they walked away.

I explained to my dd that we don’t accept gifts from strangers because we don’t know if they are a good person or a bad person.

I agree with this. I would personally not be happy if someone bought my kids stuff. We can afford the stuff but can't be buying new toys and sweets every time we go to the shops for lots of reasons. In any chance we often take a small treat with us (like a chocolate coin) to avoid having to buy them something!

WandaWonder · 12/01/2023 09:01

I think there is nothing wrong with doing it quietly. Filming it and putting it on YouTube or tiktok is wrong

Not saying anyone one on here would

tickychicky · 12/01/2023 08:59

DonnaBanana · 12/01/2023 08:48

The woman unhappy at being given flowers was being filmed so quite different.

If you feel awkward say you’re paying it forward.

Even without being filmed I'd not be happy with a random stranger buying me flowers in public. What is their expectation? That I'd be grateful- how am I expected to "perform" in that moment.

Getinajollymood · 12/01/2023 08:56

I do get that @DonnaBanana and please don’t think I am having a go here but that’s the point: it’s about you, not them. (You meant generally not to you personally!)

tickychicky · 12/01/2023 08:56

Hoppinggreen · 12/01/2023 08:29

You need to pick your person/moment carefully.
I was using a self checkout at a small supermarket near DS school and there were a lot of people in there that knew me. A new card had arrived but I forgot to activate it so it was refused. I was fumbling around for a different card when a lady came over and offered to pay, I said it was ok I had another card but she loudly started going on about how I shouldn’t be embarrassed and it could happen to anyone as times were hard. I told her I was fine but she said I should just “pay it forward”.
I am sure her motives were good but it was bloody embarrassing and unnecessary

Yeah see that's bang out of order. You said no and she didn't respect that. It was all about herself.

DonnaBanana · 12/01/2023 08:55

I don’t really want recognition but it does feel very different giving a few quid to a charity versus putting something into someone’s hand. It feels more like you’re doing something as you can see it there and then, even if I were wearing a mask and totally anonymous.

DonnaBanana · 12/01/2023 08:53

@Getinajollymood No, you have a good point too. I think it has to be done with discretion. Otherwise it’s just grandstanding. That said I think doing it for social media clout is even less suitable.

tickychicky · 12/01/2023 08:53

LetsDoThis2023 · 12/01/2023 08:26

Buy a hot drink and some lunch for your local big issue seller.

Ask them first!

Theoscargoesto · 12/01/2023 08:51

Are you seeking recognition? I’m not criticising that aim, just asking. If you don’t necessarily want to be seen doing a nice thing but still want to do one, you can donate money to many many deserving charities…..if you want to specifically feed people, donate to your local food bank.

Getinajollymood · 12/01/2023 08:51

It’s still a public place, @DonnaBanana .

I am honestly not trying to be unnecessarily argumentative here, but can people really not see that in the midst of a restaurant or cafe or shop, potentially with people who know you or know of you, someone deciding you are worthy of a charitable act, could be both unwanted and embarrassing?

Someone gets on the bus and discovers they’ve left their purse at home, yes, randomly seeming someone the recipient of charity - especially if you refuse to take no for an answer - no!

Malificent1 · 12/01/2023 08:49

I was once in the local coop, picked some things we needed, let my daughter choose a couple of treats. Got to the till and realised I didn’t have my bank card - DH had it at home as I’d given it to him to pay for the previous night’s takeaway. No cash. My daughter was so disappointed when I said we had to leave everything and why. The man behind me offered to pay and I was so grateful. I paid him back there and then with online banking but I was so grateful to him for stepping in to help.

DonnaBanana · 12/01/2023 08:48

The woman unhappy at being given flowers was being filmed so quite different.

If you feel awkward say you’re paying it forward.

faffadoodledo · 12/01/2023 08:43

I like hearing these stories. @KatyN 's story was lovely, and she did a genuine good need, and shone a light on a problem

Hoppinggreen · 12/01/2023 08:39

Getinajollymood · 12/01/2023 08:38

It’s only an act of kindness if you are sure the recipient wants it, though.

I do think people should be aware that there is the potential to cause quite a lot of embarrassment and upset. Having kind intentions doesn’t mean we can or should completely overlook this.

Other people do not exist to give us a warm fuzzy glow.

Or to give you the opportunity to brag about it on Social Media

Getinajollymood · 12/01/2023 08:38

It’s only an act of kindness if you are sure the recipient wants it, though.

I do think people should be aware that there is the potential to cause quite a lot of embarrassment and upset. Having kind intentions doesn’t mean we can or should completely overlook this.

Other people do not exist to give us a warm fuzzy glow.

Nogbreaks · 12/01/2023 08:36

‘I think paying for someone else's things on random basis is self congratulatory too.’

is it? It’s between you and that person. No one else needs to know. The time I did it I just turned back and said, ‘please, let me get these bits for you’ while hitting the payment terminal with my card and when the woman was a bit oh you don’t have to I just said, someone did it for me once and left her to it.
and other than on here I’m not sure I’ve even mentioned it to anyone.

small acts of kindness can really help someone’s days. I’ve had strangers give me coins for parking, or to use a loo at a train station, I had a guy once give me the money i was short on a train fare ( probably cos he was in a hurry and I was hogging the machine, but still!), people help me with the kids buggy on steps, people helping me on planes when I travelled home with a baby and a toddler.
Nothing self congratulating about being open to helping someone else when you can, if you can.

alittlebitofspark · 12/01/2023 08:34

You can also help someone just by being aware of your surroundings as you shop too.

Last year I was in a big, busy supermarket and there was a man standing and staring at the food in the freezer section where I wanted to be. I just said 'excuse me' and leaned in to get what I wanted and he said to me, 'how did you know I didn't want that?'

I looked at him and could tell he was joking, so I said 'you can have it if you'd like it....' He just laughed but as I walked away I heard him say, 'it was just nice to talk to someone'.

I was so busy that I hardly clocked what he said until about 30 seconds later when I'd left the aisle. To this day I wish I'd gone back and asked him if he was ok. Sometimes you can do the biggest thing just by listening, engaging, smiling.

Getinajollymood · 12/01/2023 08:32

Yes, but that’s a bit different, @minmooch - you saw someone who appeared to be in need. It’s like the difference between giving someone homeless a couple of pounds and approaching someone random with £2 on the off chance they need it.

It’s your money and it is up to you what you do with it. I just can’t personally imagine being behind someone in the supermarket going about their day and deciding they need their shopping paid for! I wouldn’t be thrilled if someone decided to do that for me - I’d be thinking we looked awfully scruffy or something!

Roselilly36 · 12/01/2023 08:30

My DS1 does things like this, once paid a passenger’s bus fare, when the driver was going to chuck her off the bus because she didn’t have enough to cover the fare.

He was out for a walk one afternoon, I thought he was longer than usual, came in and said he had cut an elderly persons lawn, he saw them struggling and said, shall I finish that off for you, they agreed so he did.

Hoppinggreen · 12/01/2023 08:29

You need to pick your person/moment carefully.
I was using a self checkout at a small supermarket near DS school and there were a lot of people in there that knew me. A new card had arrived but I forgot to activate it so it was refused. I was fumbling around for a different card when a lady came over and offered to pay, I said it was ok I had another card but she loudly started going on about how I shouldn’t be embarrassed and it could happen to anyone as times were hard. I told her I was fine but she said I should just “pay it forward”.
I am sure her motives were good but it was bloody embarrassing and unnecessary

IntoTheDeepDark · 12/01/2023 08:28

I think paying for someone else's things on random basis is self congratulatory too. I think it's more about making a public gesture than being genuinely charitable.

I'd be pleased to offer to help someone if they needed it but I'd never randomly offer to pay for someone's shop I g for example.
People who post on Facebook etc telling people they have done this are really naff -

We had someone post a picture of themselves handing a 'homeless' man some food on our local Facebook page.

It's so smug and boastful. She was t raising awareness for the need to help people she was raising awareness for herself!