Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To Pay for a Strangers Shopping?

191 replies

NameChangeAgainandAgainandAgain · 12/01/2023 03:03

I've name changed for this ...

There's a truly lovely thread on Chat called "What is the most memorable moment you shared with a stranger who you never saw again?".

There are many stories about the kindness of complete strangers and what a difference they have made to their life.

Some stories are incredibly moving and talk about how strangers have helped out when, for instance, a loved one has died.

Other stories talk about how a stranger has helped when things have been tough financially.

I know times are hard and reading all the posts has made me think that I'd like to, perhaps, pay for someone's basket of shopping in the supermarket, their petrol or buy someone a coffee etc.

Having read the impact this sort of thing has had on people, and how they remember it so many years on, I'd like to do this rather than donate as such.

How do you do this without being condescending or insulting? And how do you know who to do it to?

I wouldn't want any thanks as I'd probably run off quickly as I'd be embarrassed!

OP posts:
ThinWomansBrain · 12/01/2023 20:07

@tickychicky
Right they might have just been having a bit. Anyway I think that's a bit cheeky of you tbh. The parents have said no, and you've swooped in there and got it for them.

Sorry, I'm not as presumptions as you appear to be.
After the children had stood in front of me in the queue choosing their flavours & then hear the parents say sorry, it was too expensive, I discreetly (so children not aware) asked the parents if they'd like me to buy cones for the children - they said 'yes, please, that would be lovely'.
I was sitting at a table outside the ice cream parlour, they were on the grass a few metres away - it takes even me quite a long time to eat £8 worth of ice cream, so I was able to observe the parents consuming the ice creams for quite a while.
And hear the kids screaming, presumably at still not any getting ice cream.

saltinesandcoffeecups · 12/01/2023 13:45

Was at a restaurant/bar that had an outside seating area along a river walk a mother with 3-ish kids sat down and was listening to the music. It wasn’t too late but probably 7pm or a little later. I overheard their conversation and they were killing time before their bus came. (In the US, in my area bus ridership isn’t the norm, so it’s usually those who are on the lower end of income use public transportation)

The kids were a bit whiny (but not obnoxious) It sounded like they were hungry … the mom looked at the menu and said they’d eat when they got home. The kids looked sad but didn’t argue.

We had already ordered dinner but I went in and ordered cheeseburgers and milk for the lot of them and asked the server to not point us out. They got the milk but left before the food came. Luckily by this time we had finished dinner and were also getting ready to leave when they brought out the food, we just grabbed it and caught up with the family. I said they had delivered the food right after they left. The mom said she hadn’t ordered anything. So I just said I wasn’t sure, the server was looking for you with this and we were leaving so we offered to catch you and then I shrugged.

It was probably the most unbelievable lie I’ve ever come up with.

After we got the car and we were driving away we saw them at the bus stop and the kids were eating with enthusiasm.

cstaff · 12/01/2023 13:21

My dad had dementia before he died a few years ago. One evening he went missing - walked out of the house, hopped on a bus and ended up the other side of the city. We reported him missing but in the meantime he hailed a taxi to pick him up and the driver realised almost immediately that he had alzheimers and brought him to the nearest police station where they had the report of him missing. My mam spoke to the driver later when he was returned and it turned out that one of his parents was similar and he recognised the signs almost immediately. My mam wanted to reward / pay his fare or do something but he wasn't having any of it - he was just glad to help. Absolutely lovely gent.

AwkwardPaws27 · 12/01/2023 12:36

sylv165 · 12/01/2023 10:27

I think anonymous is best. I don't like the idea of someone paying for my shopping etc as it feels very public and I wouldn't be quite sure what to do. But I have paid for things on behalf of someone anonymously - for example my daughter does a hobby and I knew from chatting to another mum that they had had a bad few months and she was feeling stressed about money. So I contacted the organisers and paid her monthly fees, making sure they wouldn't tell her who had done it. I think it was a good way to help her because she would never have accepted if I had offered her help. But at the same time she knew people were listening and cared about her and her child, without wanting to make it public or take any credit

This is really lovely.
I was in similar circumstances as a young teen - I'd part-paid for a summer camp with St John Ambulance, but lost my Saturday job (not my fault, the shop changed hands & used their own family to staff it) & couldnt pay the rest. My mum was struggling as a single parent to make ends meet & we'd narrowly escaped homelessness so i couldn't ask her for it. I'd done a lot of voluntary hours for the group, & my cadet leader kindly funded the remaining amount for me so I didn't miss out. I've never forgotten that kindness.

magicstar1 · 12/01/2023 12:18

I just do things like that without planning it, if you know what I mean.
I was in a Subway and an elderly woman couldn't understand the menu. She only really wanted tea and toast. I took her to a cafe around the corner and ordered her tea and toast. I then paid for it and left to go back to work.

I've paid for people on the bus who had no change, or their cards didn't work.

Last week I spotted a woman trying to lift a heavy shopping bag into her car and went over to help her. She was delighted. Two minutes later I tried to get a trolley but my token wouldn't work, and a stranger came over and handed me 50c to use. I find that doing little nice things, goes around.

Seaweedandsalt · 12/01/2023 12:13

Two instances of strangers being kind:

My mother who was 85 at the time and has a form of dementia forgot her purse one day when out shopping. All her purchases were on the conveyer belt at the till when she realised. She said she was sorry and would nip home and get some money, but some kind chap in the queue behind her insisted on paying for her shopping. It was around £20.00. I put a post up on FB about someone being really kind paying for her shopping and manged to trace the chap. He declined repayment when I offered and so I FB his wife who I managed to trace and said I'd drop him some money around but she declined as well (probably didn't want to give out her address) so I popped some money in a charity tin instead.

Years before this, when Mum had been diagnosed with cancer (which was caught early and successfully treated) I was working in Birmingham City Centre and stopped at the shop next to the train station and picked out some flowers and took them to the till. A chap behind me in the queue asked me if they were for a friends birthday, I replied they were for my Mum as she'd just been diagnosed with cancer and he picked up another bunch, paid for them and caught me as I was going out the door and said "these are for your Mum, I hope she feels better soon". I thought what a lovely kind caring person he was. I half expected to see him on the train on the way home but didn't.

GimmeSleep · 12/01/2023 12:06

Oh also was at a Designer Outlet once and Hotel Chocolat had reduced loads of boxes to a couple of quid. Was talking to the people working in another shop and they said something like "ooh hope there's some left when it's our break time"; so we went back to to HC grabbed some more boxes and took them back to them. It really made their day 😊

Labracadabra · 12/01/2023 12:00

I did this once. A teenage boy in front of me was trying to buy a sandwich and drink and had to leave it as he didn't have enough money (or maybe his card was declined, can't remember) and I bought the stuff and gave it to him as he was hanging around outside with his mates. I think I just said "here's your stuff" or something and he looked at me like I'd come from another planet 😆which I'd consider pretty mild given his age and the fact he was with his pals.
I just thought if it was my daughter (not a teenager yet!) I'd be sad if she couldn't buy something to eat and drink

JustForABitofFun · 12/01/2023 11:57

I'd like to do something like this too.

For those saying it's self congratulatory, the OP has said they would probably run off.

I think the point of doing it this way, rather than a food bank, is that it's much more personal and could make the receiver feel that there are people out there who care for them when their luck is down?

Cuckoochime · 12/01/2023 11:38

One of the summer season 'exam invigilator ' staff at school donates his entire earnings to the welfare team to use 'as they see fit' - a few hundred £ each year, over a number of years. He will never know what enormous benefit his kindness has given to students in the most awful circumstances (and they don't know who their helper is either).

I once went in to the petrol kiosk to pay to find a harrassed mum in tears as her card wouldn't work and her kids were screaming in the people carrier at the pump - the petrol station staff were so unsympathetic. I paid her petrol, aware her promise to repay may be empty, and a couple of hours later she was on my doorstep with the money and flowers.

A reminder most people are lovely...

cleanasawhistle · 12/01/2023 11:17

I have been behind kids at tills who were buying sweets and realised they didnt have enough money and I have payed.
Remember walking past some kids in a shop who were picking snacks up and saying we only need another 20p for this.....I gave them a £1.

But I feel sad about the time I didn't do anything.
Going back a lot of years me,DH and my sons were just finishing eating in Burger King ,Blackpool Pleasure Beach.
Four teenage lads came at sat at the next table.
Three unpacked their food and drinks while one sat with nothing.
I will never know if he just didnt want anything or that he had no spare money .

Nogbreaks · 12/01/2023 10:53

I've paid bus fares or made up the change, and that's happened to me too. It's not much money but can make an impact.
I also had a meal paid for once by a stranger, me and Dsis went out not long after we'd lost our DM and we were laughing. crying, the lot.
When we went to pay someone had left a note saying, Sorry for your loss, always cherish each other, and picked up the entire bill.
Still no idea who that was, and the server just said it was an older couple.

sylv165 · 12/01/2023 10:27

I think anonymous is best. I don't like the idea of someone paying for my shopping etc as it feels very public and I wouldn't be quite sure what to do. But I have paid for things on behalf of someone anonymously - for example my daughter does a hobby and I knew from chatting to another mum that they had had a bad few months and she was feeling stressed about money. So I contacted the organisers and paid her monthly fees, making sure they wouldn't tell her who had done it. I think it was a good way to help her because she would never have accepted if I had offered her help. But at the same time she knew people were listening and cared about her and her child, without wanting to make it public or take any credit

Headabovetheparakeet · 12/01/2023 10:14

The only time I've ever been behind someone who didn't have enough money, it was a very well known politician. I gave him the money and he promised to repay but never did!

AwkwardPaws27 · 12/01/2023 10:13

Some cafes allow you to pay for "suspended" coffees (or soup, sandwiches etc), which can then be requested by someone who needs them.

Intrepidescape · 12/01/2023 10:07

I did this during Christmas one year. An old woman put all of the things to the side that she couldn’t afford. I paid for them and said happy Christmas. It’s not how it is on YouTube - the whole “I want to pay for your shopping” and then filming the whole thing while everyone cries. You pay, hand them the bag and walk away. It’s not a big deal - don’t make it a big deal.

I once paid for a homeless woman’s accommodation and groceries. She was trying to save money for a backpackers. I gave her money so she didn’t have to keep begging and bought her a meal and some drinks and snacks. Again, don’t make it a big deal.

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 12/01/2023 09:54

Be warned though there are some Cf’s out there, my friend’s DH thought he would try and make an elderly person’s day in Tesco. He Looked at the belt in front, calculated that it was roughly £75 of shopping. Said to the checkout lady ‘I’d like to pay for this person’s shopping’ the elderly person looked surprised, didn’t really say thank you and then when asked ‘any cash back?’ Said ‘yes, £100 please’ 😂

I'm not convinced that she is necessarily a CF, though. Was there any indication that she was struggling for money or was it just the (potentially patronising) idea that old people are poor? Some pensioners are very wealthy ("Yes, there was this elderly man with a Scouse accent and the remnants of a mop top buying some vegan sausages - I paid for him, as I know how difficult it is for pensioners"); and even if she was just of average means, she quite possibly had budgeted and might have been offended by the insistence.

If she had been planning on getting cashback (although I thought the limit was £50 - has that changed?) - maybe she doesn't have a cash machine near her - why should she go without getting the cash she needed and planned to get, just because somebody decided she was a charity case and paid for her shopping? She might even have thought it was a scam, could have been fearful that this 'kind' man was going to accost her in the car park and demand her bank details or 'favours' as repayment or something.

I also agree with it being really undermining of parents to buy their kids treats. Maybe it's not the very best parenting, but a lot of parents will tell their kids that they don't have enough money to buy what they consider another excessive treat; if you just say "No, I'm not buying it for you - you've had enough", that can lead to endless pestering and pleading, but if you tell them "I CAN'T buy it for you", they might accept it and quit their relentless campaign.

As PP said, children will often demand something that they like the idea of, but the parents know they'll never actually eat it, so it will just be a huge waste of money, even if they have it available.

I think it's definitely important to react subtly to a need when it clearly arises and not just come over all Charlie Big Potatoes, regardless of whether your intervention will be needed/appreciated or not. It's usually obvious when somebody has fear in their eyes and is about to put their shopping back, and you can discreetly show them kindness - "Oh, these stupid card machines are so rubbish and temperamental, they just randomly refuse cards for no reason at all; here, let's see if it will deign to accept this one" - as opposed to just swooping in and seeking your charity target of the day to make you feel better or give you something to brag about on SM.

IntoTheDeepDark · 12/01/2023 09:53

Most supermarkets have somewhere to leave donations for food banks. Why would people choose a random person who may or may not be in need rather that just contribute to the food bank. I think it's because some people want the warm fuzzy feeling of interacting with the person they are giving the money to. That's a bit off to me.

It's different if you want to help someone who has forgotten their purse or who is genuinely in need but the 'random' things are questionable.

IntoTheDeepDark · 12/01/2023 09:53

Most supermarkets have somewhere to leave donations for food banks. Why would people choose a random person who may or may not be in need rather that just contribute to the food bank. I think it's because some people want the warm fuzzy feeling of interacting with the person they are giving the money to. That's a bit off to me.

It's different if you want to help someone who has forgotten their purse or who is genuinely in need but the 'random' things are questionable.

IntoTheDeepDark · 12/01/2023 09:53

Most supermarkets have somewhere to leave donations for food banks. Why would people choose a random person who may or may not be in need rather that just contribute to the food bank. I think it's because some people want the warm fuzzy feeling of interacting with the person they are giving the money to. That's a bit off to me.

It's different if you want to help someone who has forgotten their purse or who is genuinely in need but the 'random' things are questionable.

Redsquirrel5 · 12/01/2023 09:50

OP

You could donate some money to SVP St. Vincent de Paul at any Catholic Church and mark what it is for. I paid for a boy’s new shoes for school once when he was starting back in September. It was lovely to see him in a pair of shiny, new boots and I had a little smile to myself.

I gave a cashier in a Spar some money for ice cream on a very hot day in 2020 for some boys. Four had chosen an ice cream when a fifth arrived so they put them back and we’re going to buy sweets because the fifth boy had no money.
They were so pleased to find that they could have their ice creams and thank me before I got to the door. They were so surprised.

Ahwelltoobad · 12/01/2023 09:40

Roselilly36 · 12/01/2023 08:30

My DS1 does things like this, once paid a passenger’s bus fare, when the driver was going to chuck her off the bus because she didn’t have enough to cover the fare.

He was out for a walk one afternoon, I thought he was longer than usual, came in and said he had cut an elderly persons lawn, he saw them struggling and said, shall I finish that off for you, they agreed so he did.

❤️

queenrollo · 12/01/2023 09:38

I went for a cup of tea and slice of cake in a cafe one morning. Two older ladies came in separately, for the same. When I paid I asked the girl to add theirs to my bill and said if they asked to tell them it was just a gift from someone who wanted to spread a little happiness.

I once also gave a local florist payment for an arrangement and told her to choose someone in the community that she felt deserved the treat. She matched what I had donated and sent the flowers to someone who had been having a really difficult time. I saw on social media that it was very well received and to this day the only person who knows it was me is the florist.

Mabelface · 12/01/2023 09:36

I've had my shopping paid for by a stranger who heard me when I was looking at the reduced stuff and decided to leave some bits in case someone else needed them. I was brassic at the time. I paid it forward, paying for someone's prescription when their card was declined. Doing small things can make a huge difference to someone. It did to me.

pattihews · 12/01/2023 09:35

I wouldn't do it, OP. I once went to Sainsbury's in my gardening gear after a hard afternoon's work chopping back hedges: must have looked a right state. I queued behind a professional-looking woman, beautifully groomed, and she hung around at the end of the till while I bagged up my few bits and then leant in and offered her Sainsbury's card as I got out my purse to pay and said: 'Please, let me, I've got a ridiculous amount of points on my card, I'd like to pay for your shopping.' I was taken so much by surprise that it took me a few seconds to process what she was suggesting, and before I could say 'Thanks but no thanks' she'd paid for me, given me a big smile and was off.

I was at that time, in around 2005, earning around £50k and owned my own mortgage-free home. I ended up putting the £40 I should have paid for my shopping in a charity box. You can't tell just from looking at people who needs the money and who doesn't. My partner and I are comfortably off and yet you would never know from looking at us. We wear old clothes, we have home haircuts, we drive dull 7-year-old cars. We just don't do conspicuous consumption.