Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think this isn't fair to a two year old.

65 replies

dinkysino123 · 11/01/2023 21:21

My partner and I split up just as my daughter turned one. He moved out and left to live 40 minutes away.

He sees her regularly pretty much every weekend. He wants her in the week too, but he works difficult hours (sometimes he will be working late or really early) on the few occasions he has had her in the week, he's ended up having to call me to collect her and I've had to drive the 40 mins to her house at 5.30pm only for her to be dropped off at nursery at 7.30am in the morning.

I don't think this is fair to her, as she also goes to nursery full time. Also, at my house she has a bath and her own cosy bedroom. My ex has tiny one bedroom flat and hasn't put a bed/cot up for her as apparently 'she never settled' he also doesn't have a bath! He is constantly going on and on about having her in the week to stay over, but I genuinely think it's more about controlling me than what's best for our daughter. I've put my foot down time and time again and would say he could pop over to see her in the evenings. However, now she is a bit older when he pops round for a couple of hours it really unsettles her and then I spend hours in the evening trying to get her back down.

He also expects me to FaceTime with her every night. Today I had put my phone on silent as I was in the office and when I got home I didn't hear him call. I put her to bed and then saw more missed calls and messages asking me if everything was ok and that he'd tried to call me and I had my notifications turned off.

I responded saying I had put my phone on do jot disturb hence I missed the calls and added at the end 'not that I need to explain myself' and he wrote back 'unbelievable'. I find him wanting to know my every move and expecting me to FaceTime him all the time and making me feel guilty when I don't really controlling.

Do you think I'm being unreasonable to suggest going forward we each do every other weekend, rather than shared weekends and he can FaceTime 3 x in the week? I can't live the rest of my life constantly on edge that if I don't FaceTime or allow him round my house I'm going to be made to feel awful.

OP posts:
TimeToFlyNow · 11/01/2023 22:28

dinkysino123 · 11/01/2023 22:18

@TimeToFlyNow thank you! This is how I feel. At weekends he's always bringing her home a few hours early than arranged, which is why I feel it's about control. I'm not trying to stop contact I just want stability and routine for my little girl.

Yes, she needs a routine and a bed!

And a man who can't even have his child for a weekend or who brings her back whenever he feels like it isn't going to get 50 /50 he's just trying to control and scare you

And If he wants her in the week then it's not on you to facilitate it in your house

dinkysino123 · 11/01/2023 22:27

@SecretVictoria yes it is all he can afford. He has. Good job, but got himself into lots of debt

OP posts:
dinkysino123 · 11/01/2023 22:27

@Bbqchicken I did try to take her off him and he kept taking her to the car. He got very aggressive.

I am VERY accommodating to him. I'm not sure how he would have her 50:50, he can't afford child maintenance let alone childcare. The bath is nit picking and maybe expecting a bed for my daughter is too (I personally don't think it is but can see why others disagree but I'd want more for my daughter)! I totally get what you're saying and that's why I probably bend far too much to accommodate his needs

OP posts:
SecretVictoria · 11/01/2023 22:23

YANBU to want some sort of routine.

YABU to complain he only has a 1 bed flat. Maybe that’s all he can afford?

Bbqchicken · 11/01/2023 22:20

In a separation the Child should be put first by both parties. Children do need routine but they also benefit from the love and care of both parents and unfortunately you will have to put yourself out to do what is best for the child, its not ideal but thats the situation you are in. You need to put your personal feelings aside as hard as it is and focus on working with him not against him for him to see his child and he needs to do the same for you. Facetiming every night is unreasonable, but it does show he cares and misses her.

I don't understand the bringing her home at 8pm and putting her in and out the car 3 times. This makes no sense to me why wouldnt either of you have just taken her in to bed.

Nothing wrong with a 1 bed flat, He needs a travel cot or a bed for him in the living area when she is there all very workable. The lack of bath...sorry thats just nitpicking, silly things like that shouldn't even be a concern. I think in situations like this if it went to court and you got 50/50 then you would look back on this time and wish you had been more accomodating. I would as I'd want my children with me as much as possible, id rather be inconvenienced a few times driving about if it meant I had then 80% of the time.

dinkysino123 · 11/01/2023 22:18

@TimeToFlyNow thank you! This is how I feel. At weekends he's always bringing her home a few hours early than arranged, which is why I feel it's about control. I'm not trying to stop contact I just want stability and routine for my little girl.

OP posts:
dinkysino123 · 11/01/2023 22:17

@bumpytrumpy this is a really good idea. He doesn't work shift work. He has a full time job, which sends him travelling around the country. Mostly near to home but sometimes further afield.

OP posts:
Copperoliverbear · 11/01/2023 22:12

Refuse more than what you think is best for your child. X

TimeToFlyNow · 11/01/2023 22:11

Sod that, if he wants her in the week then he needs to sort out his hours .

I'd do every other weekend and a couple of face times in the week .

Doesn't sound like ge wants quality time with her though if he keeps bringing her home

bumpytrumpy · 11/01/2023 22:11

Can he come and collect her early from
Nursery when he has worked an early shift? So pick her up mid afternoon and return her in good time to settle before bed? That would seem best for midweek contact at the moment, then every other weekends like you suggest.

dinkysino123 · 11/01/2023 22:07

@1hyuny also it's not the FaceTiming it's when he pops round for an hour or two in the evening that means she takes ages to resettle

OP posts:
dinkysino123 · 11/01/2023 22:05

@Threeboysandadog yes! This is a great idea though I think it would need a professional mediator x

OP posts:
dinkysino123 · 11/01/2023 22:04

@1hyuny in answer to your question. I don't have loads of support or many people to reach out to. You can always read and choose to ignore.

Maybe she does need sleep training. Will look into it

OP posts:
Threeboysandadog · 11/01/2023 22:02

Can the two of you sit down and make a plan for the next 6 months/year re. how it’s going to work and what’s not going to happen. He can tell you what he would like and you can say what you would like and work out an arrangement that is agreeable to you both. You may need a friend each or someone to mediate if you think it may become heated.

1hyuny · 11/01/2023 22:00

You posted about this before with all the facetiming etc. I never understand why people post the same sort of thing again 🤔 either way just say no and keep saying no. But I cant see how him facetiming her for a bit means it takes you hours to resettle her? Maybe she needs a bit of sleep training.

dinkysino123 · 11/01/2023 21:59

@Suziesz yes, but leaving a mother still on maternity leave with a ten month old and basic mat pay to pay all rent and bills says a lot about someone's character. This was over a year ago. I do sound bitter, maybe I am... but I've had to do a lot on my own with no support.

I did bring it up months ago and he said no as he wants to see her every weekend. Again, I have to be prepared to work around if he's taking extra weekend shifts! Im just crap at boundaries I realise

OP posts:
Suziesz · 11/01/2023 21:56

dinkysino123 · 11/01/2023 21:51

@Suziesz when you say 'suddenly separated' this man left me and my daughter when she was 10 months old and choose to move nearly an hour away! I don't have that much sympathy for him to be honest, especially when I suggest having her for whole weekends and he says 'well I don't want her the whole weekend as I need some time to myself too.'

I mean as shit as it is, anyone is allowed to end a relationship. It’s not fair to imply someone should stay in a bad relationship in order to see their child or otherwise ‘you don’t have any sympathy’.

So you have already asked him to do the full weekend every other weekend and he has said no?
Your OP suggested you hadn’t raised this yet.
Do you think I'm being unreasonable to suggest going forward we each do every other weekend, rather than shared weekends and he can FaceTime 3 x in the week?

dinkysino123 · 11/01/2023 21:53

Thanks @parietal sound advice! As I said if he hadn't let me down the times he was meant to have her in the week then I'd be more inclined to agree to his demands but it's not fair on me or DD
To mess her around

OP posts:
parietal · 11/01/2023 21:51

fair to a toddler is getting to spend time with both parents, not sticking always to your routine.

and the more time she spends with her dad, the more likely he is to realise that actually, having a routine and a bedtime etc does make life easier and that Disney Dad mode can't last.

Offer a set times you can manage, e.g. every-other-weekend + every-other-wednesday night. He will have to do the pickups / dropoffs to nursery for his nights etc, and no swapping at short notice. Also no FT in between because that is often very unsettling for little ones. Then let him get on with it.

dinkysino123 · 11/01/2023 21:51

@Suziesz when you say 'suddenly separated' this man left me and my daughter when she was 10 months old and choose to move nearly an hour away! I don't have that much sympathy for him to be honest, especially when I suggest having her for whole weekends and he says 'well I don't want her the whole weekend as I need some time to myself too.'

OP posts:
Suziesz · 11/01/2023 21:49

It’s very easy in these situations to ‘other’ the father and claim it’s only ever control, that they aren’t putting the child first etc but that’s easy to say when you are the resident parent who gets to spend the majority of your time with the child.

Imagine if you were suddenly separated from your DD? You were only allowed to see for for short periods of time on the weekend, dictated by the other parent usually. Would you not be dying to see your DD? Even on face time?

It sounds like you aren’t that long separated and it’s still in the transition period of a adjusting away from him living with DD.

I’m not saying you have to be tired to face timing him every night but the ‘not that I need to tell you’ when you missed the call was really unnecessary and as PP said it was antagonist so you can’t then make him the bad guy for replying ‘typical’.

dinkysino123 · 11/01/2023 21:48

@vintagechristmas he is a Disney dad. dad loves him as he's fun and does all the fun stuff. Is he a good dad? He pays f all, he didn't come and meet me at hospital when I had to take her to a&e in the middle of the night, he always expects me to take time off work whenever she Ill, she was crying for me the other night at his and so he drove round and dropped her off at mine T 8pm (even though I told him on the phone she'd be fine) once he got to mine she didn't want to say goodbye to him so he put her in and out of her car three times until I said enough. Do I think they are signs of a responsible, stable father? No!

OP posts:
UsingChangeofName · 11/01/2023 21:48

YABU (not the facetiming - but the rest).

She has two parents and it is right that she spends as much times as she can with each of them.

dinkysino123 · 11/01/2023 21:45

@Hankunamatata personally I don't think it's fair on daughter.. she is young and needs stability. No she doesn't need a bath, but I do think she needs her own bed at least. He has never stuck to any routine with her and it has a massive impact on her.

OP posts:
vintagechristmas · 11/01/2023 21:43

Is he a good man? Does your child like spending time with him?

Another perspective to think of it from is- what if it was the other way around? I couldn't imagine my child being with their father and being unable to see and FaceTime them each day.

If/ when he has overnights do you expect to not contact them and completely leave them to it? No FaceTime or calls then either?