Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Body positivity and wanting to lose weight

120 replies

constituaint · 11/01/2023 20:44

I can’t square away my desire to lose some weight with my agreement that women’s bodies (especially fat ones) are weaponised by patriarchal media and that it’s quite hard to be a fat woman in society.

I do believe in health at any size, that women’s bodies are not there for the male gaze, that my whole generation (elder millennial…shudder) have got quite disordered ways of looking at our bodies but I still find myself wanting to lose some weight because, after all, I’m quite vain and I do think I would look better 15kg lighter.

BUT it does seem really to be an undercurrent now that my desire to lose weight implies that I hold other people to these standards, that I think there’s something wrong with fat bodies in general, that I think there’s a right and a wrong way to be a woman and take up space etc etc. I don’t! It’s an impossibly high bar I set for myself.

I understand that on top of women’s health not being treated as seriously as men’s there’s an extra layer for fat women who are told that losing weight will solve all their problems - or to come back to GP when they’ve lost a certain amt of weight which is just awful. And I do get that health at every size is possible, but I am left wondering how true this is? Is someone like me with prob 15kg to lose at a much higher risk of various serious conditions or is this ‘systemic fatphobia’ I’ve been reading about? I know BMI is rubbish on an individual level but good for populations.

I suppose my question is, AIBH(ypocritical) to want to personally lose weight (because I’m vain and maybe there are real health reasons) but to support the body positivity movement? Or is the BP movement making excuses for obesity which is a really serious thing and health at every size is balonz?

OP posts:
Lentilweaver · 12/01/2023 08:00

Fatshaming is awful. Fat people are not lesser. But clearly HAES has gone too far when people think being a healthy weight is pandering to the patriarchy.

As @5128gap said upthread, comparing a fat, active person who doesn't smoke or drink to a thin, inactive person who smokes or drinks is simply disingenuous. All things being equal, being a healthy weight when you hit mid 40s is a good goal. Because after that losing weight becomes incredibly tough.

MaireadMcSweeney · 12/01/2023 07:40

UsuallySuze · 12/01/2023 07:34

I've always understood "health at any size" to mean "whatever size you are, you can do things to improve your health" ie it's better to be fat and active, eating your greens, going to the doctors when necessary etc, than fat, inactive, eating crap and avoiding the doctor- it doesn't have to be a negative spiral.

That's not what activists have turned it into though. The fact that the OP is questioning whether it's ethical for her to try to lose weight is exactly the problem with HAES now.

UsuallySuze · 12/01/2023 07:34

I've always understood "health at any size" to mean "whatever size you are, you can do things to improve your health" ie it's better to be fat and active, eating your greens, going to the doctors when necessary etc, than fat, inactive, eating crap and avoiding the doctor- it doesn't have to be a negative spiral.

malificent7 · 12/01/2023 07:04

But i do agree that fat shaming is awful...people put on weight for a myriad of issues. In my setting there is chocolate everywhere in the office...gets eaten by the staff very quickly.

I do intermittent fasting....weight has dropped off. Healthy food is delicious.

malificent7 · 12/01/2023 07:01

I work in healthcare. Absolute nonsense that there is health at any size. Working in my field motivated me to stay slim. You do not want illnesses such as heart disease, diabetes, arthritis etc that are more commonly associated with obesity. Fuck the male gaze.

Wintercurrentbun · 12/01/2023 07:00

hidethenips · 11/01/2023 21:36

The original Health At Every Size® philosophy has been twisted by the Body Positivity movement to suggest that 'fat can be is healthy' when what it actually promotes is "safe and equitable access to healthcare for people regardless of size, health status, and health goals first and foremost." I don't agree with all of the HAES principles but it was designed to take away the focus on losing weight and redirect it towards eating healthily and exercising for other health reasons, which is better than nothing.

Your dilemma is something I've been struggling with too - last year I decided that I was going to stop dieting for a whole year and follow the intuitive eating principles instead and that if I was still unhappy at the start of this year, I would start dieting again. Ironically, I lost weight! And I want to lose some more, and that's fine by me, because now I've developed healthier habits, I exercise for fun and I don't obsess over calories anymore.

We've spent our entire lives being told fat is bad, it's not surprising none of us really want to be fat - I don't think that makes you (or me) a hypocrite.

Thank you for this😊

Absolutely hit the nail on the head with this post.

The many posters who’re shrieking ‘it’s all bollocks’ need to check themselves on the ignorance meter.

Fat shaming and systemic fatphobia is real and negatively affects so many people’s lives. So many people are too ashamed to get help, join a gym, go for a swim or run etc. Many people grew up surrounded by toxic thinness.

The majority (if not all) diets don’t work long term and study after study shows that most people bounce back weight wise, because it’s unsustainable.

Years of yo-yo dieting is terrible for health. Creates an environment ripe for eating disorders and disordered eating in general where foods are demonised and calories are obsessed over.

Intuitive eating is very interesting and has helped a lot of people to reframe their approach.

Quinoawoman · 12/01/2023 06:49

Anyone thinking of going 'on a diet' (seems like a lot in this thread), please read this:
laurathomas.substack.com/p/heres-what-happens-when-you-go-an

MaireadMcSweeney · 12/01/2023 06:36

GracieLouFreeebush · 11/01/2023 22:04

If I went by bmi I would be considered overweight, possibly obese. I exercise everyday with a variety of activities across the week (play sport, weights at the gym and run). I think you can be healthy at any size because I am healthy, I eat a balanced diet and have a resting heartbeat of 52. My sister is significantly slimmer than me, she has a couple of takeaways every week and I don’t think she has exercised since school PE 15 years ago, just because she is smaller doesn’t mean she is healthier.

If you're obese then you have higher risks of various health issues than you would if you weren't. It doesn't mean you aren't in good health now
Im obese and exercise regularly, rarely get ill etc but I need to lose 4 stone to protect my future health. It's as simple as that.

MMMarmite · 11/01/2023 22:32

I think the health at every size movement has some good points. Drs shaming people and blaming everything on their weight is not going to lead to good health outcomes. Not is it helpful to larger people's health if they feel uncomfortable to be seen at the gym or swimming pool, or if they are bullied and develop stress or depression.

I also think that it goes too far in claiming every body shape is equally healthy. The truth probably lies between the two camps.

5128gap · 11/01/2023 22:14

The appropriate comparator for an overweight person who eats well and excercises is a slim person who eats well and excercises, not a slim person who eats junk food and never moves off the sofa.
When assessing the health benefits of losing weight, the only pertinent comparison is your current self versus yourself at a healthy weight.
As long as you don't inexplicably drop your healthy lifestyle along with the extra kilos, you'll be even healthier slim.

Concernedrethis · 11/01/2023 22:04

You can be thin but have organs surrounded by fat. You can be larger but all muscle and fit and healthy. Size doesn’t necessarily indicate health.

Eating lots of fresh, whole foods and fibre is good for you all round. So is exercising regularly. That’s what keeps us well, healthy and to have a greater sense of well-being. Focus on that rather than the number on the scales or the dress size you wear.

We need to move away from certain body shapes and sizes being deemed attractive (this has changed over time and is different in different cultures so isn’t a ‘truth’) and learn to love ourselves and value and respect each other whatever we look like.

That’s different to the pursuit of health and building and maintaining a healthy lifestyle. That’s what we should encourage and strive for.

GracieLouFreeebush · 11/01/2023 22:04

If I went by bmi I would be considered overweight, possibly obese. I exercise everyday with a variety of activities across the week (play sport, weights at the gym and run). I think you can be healthy at any size because I am healthy, I eat a balanced diet and have a resting heartbeat of 52. My sister is significantly slimmer than me, she has a couple of takeaways every week and I don’t think she has exercised since school PE 15 years ago, just because she is smaller doesn’t mean she is healthier.

stepstepstep · 11/01/2023 21:55

Body positivity for me is about mental health - not listening to the voices (internal or external) that tell you that fat equals lazy, stupid, greedy and ugly.

HAAS for me is about physical health (as PP said) particularly that fat bodies deserve care & healthcare and that being fat shouldn’t stop you from exercising or being active (the fact that you couldn’t buy activewear over a size 16 until a few years ago tells you all you need to know about that)

Neither of those necessarily contradict wanting to lose weight for health reasons.

important to remember that the causes of obesity are as much social as individual (the composition of food has changed hugely in the last 30 years)

also important to remember that being healthy doesn’t make you a better person and being unhealthy doesn’t make you a bad person.

Craghopper1 · 11/01/2023 21:53

Your knocking on the door of obesity with those stats OP. Healthy at every size is bollocks. You've got kids; lose the weight and be a healthy mum and good role model for them.

Quinoawoman · 11/01/2023 21:49

georgiesmash · 11/01/2023 20:58

I do also believe that society is fatphobic,

No one's scared of fat people.

Yes but people are terrified of BEING fat. And fat people are treated appalingly.

We would do much better as a society to understand that 80% of our weight is down to our genetics and that people just have different body types. Once someone who is a tiny bit overweight - or perhaps just average but wants to be skinny - starts dieting, they raise their weight set point and actually gain weight in the long term. For anyone interested in the science, I suggest reading 'Why We Eat (Too Much). Not sure I agree with the 'non diet' (it totally is a diet) suggested at the end but the science is pretty solid written by a bariatric surgeon.

Coffeellama · 11/01/2023 21:45

It’d be daft to not loose weight because of what ideals you support and what people might think. You want to loose weight, so get started. Health at any size is a lie, and even though people can maintain health up to a certain point, it doesn’t mean loosing weight won’t make you healthier and feel better still. Do what’s right for you, don’t overthink the reasons not to loose weight.

5128gap · 11/01/2023 21:43

I lost 2 stone. I'm now mid point healthy BMI. I went from tired, sluggish, achey, always fighting headaches, stomach problems, out of breath at any exertion, making that grunting noise when I stood up or bent down...to fit, healthy, pain free, loads of energy, zero digestive issues, few headaches.. there is no way any BP movement is going to convince me there's no link between weight and health. Particularly as my mum died from an obesity related illness when she was not much older than me. I'm 53.
People who are healthy and OW are mainly those too young for it to have caught up with them.

Echobelly · 11/01/2023 21:42

I think people are entitled to be comfortable in their own bodies, whether by losing weight, or not wanting to lose weight!

I've always been OK with my body but last year did actually diet to lose weight for the first time (1.5 stone) - I figured better to keep on top of it now than getting to a stage when it would be harder to lose. I have been fairly slim my whole life and have a leg joint issue that would be worsened by being oveweight, so I try to stay under what would be considered overweight - not by much and I'm not aiming for a perfect body, just a weight that minimises stress on my joints. Also aesthetically for me all my weight goes to my stomach and I find it difficult to find clothes that fit well when I put too much weight on.

But there doesn't have to be a qualifying reason - if you just want to lose weight for health/aesthetic reasons, it's fine.

Foldinthecheese · 11/01/2023 21:38

I cannot stress enough how valuable exercise is in dealing with this stuff. I do fairly intense exercise classes about five times per week, and it’s just completely changed how I feel about my body. It has made me want to eat more healthily so I have the fuel that I need, but it has also taken me focus off of the desperate desire to be thin that I felt for so long. Instead, I like feeling strong and seeing how I’m able to improve my performance in my classes. I’m also able to ski and paddle board because I have good core strength, and I absolutely know I couldn’t have done those things before.

I know that exercise might not make a big difference to the scale, but I really think it’s the key to changing how you feel about your body. That means that dieting isn’t about punishing yourself for not looking good, but about fueling yourself appropriately so you can achieve your goals.

hidethenips · 11/01/2023 21:36

The original Health At Every Size® philosophy has been twisted by the Body Positivity movement to suggest that 'fat can be is healthy' when what it actually promotes is "safe and equitable access to healthcare for people regardless of size, health status, and health goals first and foremost." I don't agree with all of the HAES principles but it was designed to take away the focus on losing weight and redirect it towards eating healthily and exercising for other health reasons, which is better than nothing.

Your dilemma is something I've been struggling with too - last year I decided that I was going to stop dieting for a whole year and follow the intuitive eating principles instead and that if I was still unhappy at the start of this year, I would start dieting again. Ironically, I lost weight! And I want to lose some more, and that's fine by me, because now I've developed healthier habits, I exercise for fun and I don't obsess over calories anymore.

We've spent our entire lives being told fat is bad, it's not surprising none of us really want to be fat - I don't think that makes you (or me) a hypocrite.

UsuallySuze · 11/01/2023 21:34

I’m all for body positivity, taking that to be the idea that the worth of a human is not measured by how closely their body matches some physical ideal. I don’t see any hypocrisy or inconsistency in supporting that position while also wanting to be healthy and thinking it’s a good idea for other people to want to be healthy too 🤷‍♀️

Bemyclementine · 11/01/2023 21:32

I don't like the body positivity movement. I am happier, healthier, more able, when I'm slimmer. I'm a similar size to you OP and want to lose weight for many reasons, health and looks are the top 2 it has to be said. I'm not healthy at this size, I'm unfit and feel big and awkward. I hate the way I look abd feel.

Claudia84 · 11/01/2023 21:31

Not saying you specifically are ignorant OP - just people that use word salad to ignore experts.

Claudia84 · 11/01/2023 21:29

Or is the BP movement making excuses for obesity which is a really serious thing and health at every size is balonz?

Yes it is.
Being comfortable with the changes in your body post children = body positivity
Body positive movement that celebrates obesity and uses the patriarchy as an excuse to ignore the real health issues associated with being overweight = ignorant

TheLeadbetterLife · 11/01/2023 21:28

constituaint · 11/01/2023 21:00

I weigh 90kg at 1.75m tall. I had 3 children in 3 years which has taken its toll I suppose. But I don’t know how much the number on the scales matters really - my body shape is fundamentally different to pre-30/pre-children.

I am the same height as you and weighed 90kg a couple of years ago (and I don't even have the excuse of children). I am 15kg lighter now and a healthy BMI and I feel much better. Obviously I look better too, but that's really beside the point. Shit doesn't ache anymore, I'm fit and healthy, and have hugely decreased the risk of all manner of horrible conditions.

You simply can't be healthy at any size. Not really.