Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Body positivity and wanting to lose weight

120 replies

constituaint · 11/01/2023 20:44

I can’t square away my desire to lose some weight with my agreement that women’s bodies (especially fat ones) are weaponised by patriarchal media and that it’s quite hard to be a fat woman in society.

I do believe in health at any size, that women’s bodies are not there for the male gaze, that my whole generation (elder millennial…shudder) have got quite disordered ways of looking at our bodies but I still find myself wanting to lose some weight because, after all, I’m quite vain and I do think I would look better 15kg lighter.

BUT it does seem really to be an undercurrent now that my desire to lose weight implies that I hold other people to these standards, that I think there’s something wrong with fat bodies in general, that I think there’s a right and a wrong way to be a woman and take up space etc etc. I don’t! It’s an impossibly high bar I set for myself.

I understand that on top of women’s health not being treated as seriously as men’s there’s an extra layer for fat women who are told that losing weight will solve all their problems - or to come back to GP when they’ve lost a certain amt of weight which is just awful. And I do get that health at every size is possible, but I am left wondering how true this is? Is someone like me with prob 15kg to lose at a much higher risk of various serious conditions or is this ‘systemic fatphobia’ I’ve been reading about? I know BMI is rubbish on an individual level but good for populations.

I suppose my question is, AIBH(ypocritical) to want to personally lose weight (because I’m vain and maybe there are real health reasons) but to support the body positivity movement? Or is the BP movement making excuses for obesity which is a really serious thing and health at every size is balonz?

OP posts:
Movinghouseatlast · 12/01/2023 16:05

I think its all got a bit mixed up. Originally it was about shaming people who were not 'perfect' sized. I was adequate to feel 'fat' as a young adult when I really wasn't fat at all- I was a size 12-14 and lovely looking back. But my mum called me fat, men wanted me to be a size 8-10 and when I became tbat weight I suddenly had lots of interest. That type of judgement should stop.

But honestly, being body positive about being a size 22 obese person seems crazy to me. There are huge health implications there and whilst I don't think there should be discrimination I do think someone that size can't be as healthy due to the pressure on organs.

I'm overweight now- I'm 13 stone and a size 14. On my height that is overweight and I can really feel it. I get very out of breath walking uphill for example. I need to lose weight for health reasons and because I look awful. However, when I was 10 stone and a size 12 I should not have beenade to feel as bad asI was. Which is probably why I can't lose weight now.

Climbles · 12/01/2023 16:00

Kanaloa · 12/01/2023 15:46

Which studies? I would presume many of the health difficulties come not from being ignored by doctors (I mean surely the health issue already exists if the doctor is ignoring them) but from excess fat around organs, lack of movement, lack of proper nutrition etc. If the issues are caused by doctors ignoring fat people’s pain then where is the pain coming from?

This is exactly the issue. People assuming every health issue a fat person has is due to weight. Anyone can get ill regardless of weight. I’m not saying being fat isn’t bad for you just that if we had a non fat-phobic health care system there would be better outcomes for fat people.
I have become interested in the issues faced in the fat community through Sophie Hagen a stand up comedian and fat rights activist. I can’t remember the details of the studies she has referenced but if you Google fat-phobia in the health system a bunch come up.

Ursuala · 12/01/2023 15:52

Kanaloa · 12/01/2023 15:44

You don’t have to stay overweight to prove you don’t have fat people. It just sounds in your op like you basically feel guilty for wanting a healthy body.

Or looking for an excuse to carry on munching on the ginger nuts

Kanaloa · 12/01/2023 15:46

Climbles · 12/01/2023 11:37

Studies have found a lot of the additional health risks of being over weight come down to the health system not taking fat peoples pain seriously and not offering the same level of care. Black people have the same difficulties being believed.

Which studies? I would presume many of the health difficulties come not from being ignored by doctors (I mean surely the health issue already exists if the doctor is ignoring them) but from excess fat around organs, lack of movement, lack of proper nutrition etc. If the issues are caused by doctors ignoring fat people’s pain then where is the pain coming from?

Quinoawoman · 12/01/2023 15:45

constituaint · 12/01/2023 08:48

Thanks everyone some really interesting perspectives.

Can anyone recommend some good reading on intuitive eating?

Just Eat It by Laura Thomas

Kanaloa · 12/01/2023 15:44

*don’t hate fat people!

Kanaloa · 12/01/2023 15:44

You don’t have to stay overweight to prove you don’t have fat people. It just sounds in your op like you basically feel guilty for wanting a healthy body.

SilliusSoddus · 12/01/2023 15:43

How old are you? Since turning 40 my focus for losing weight has largely moved away from how I look and has become much more about being healthy. I'm hoping to get another 40 years out of this body

Totally agree with this. I care less and less about how I look or how others view me. I care more and more about ongoing health and independence - and the freedoms they bring - as I move through my 40s and look further ahead to my old age.

MaireadMcSweeney · 12/01/2023 15:42

GracieLouFreeebush · 12/01/2023 12:00

You have assumed my weight is pure excess fat I think. I have a lot of muscle and probably the same amount of fat as my sister who is slim, I just have it on top of muscle. If I lost the muscle I wouldn’t be overweight.

I haven't assumed anything of the sort!
i also have a lot of muscle (I can feel it under my fat!) and if I lost my muscle I'd be a lot lighter but less healthy. But that's another false equivalence. A skinny lightly muscled woman is still at lower risk of many diseases than a fat, heavily muscled woman. You should be comparing yourself with your own self with less body fat.

Ursuala · 12/01/2023 15:42

I do believe in health at any size

Oh good Lord. Seriously Op?

MaireadMcSweeney · 12/01/2023 15:40

ehb102 · 12/01/2023 11:33

Ooh, look! Fat phobia out in force here.

Health at every size is about being as healthy as you can at every size. Sure. I'd be a lot healthier if the 50kg of fibrotic fat was off me, but lipoedema makes it so that won't happen with diet and exercise.

I still exercise and look to control my normal fat though. I do it looking like the before picture even at my lightest possible weight. Post surgeries I'm starting the work to get back to full health.

Look after your body as best you can and ignore anyone who says you aren't okay until you achieve thinness. It's not true.

Where is the fat phobia?

MaireadMcSweeney · 12/01/2023 15:40

constituaint · 12/01/2023 08:48

Thanks everyone some really interesting perspectives.

Can anyone recommend some good reading on intuitive eating?

Intuitive eating for someone with unhealthy eating habits (which those of us who have reached obese DO have) isn't a good idea at all.

GracieLouFreeebush · 12/01/2023 12:00

MaireadMcSweeney · 12/01/2023 06:36

If you're obese then you have higher risks of various health issues than you would if you weren't. It doesn't mean you aren't in good health now
Im obese and exercise regularly, rarely get ill etc but I need to lose 4 stone to protect my future health. It's as simple as that.

You have assumed my weight is pure excess fat I think. I have a lot of muscle and probably the same amount of fat as my sister who is slim, I just have it on top of muscle. If I lost the muscle I wouldn’t be overweight.

Laurdo · 12/01/2023 11:55

The whole body positively thing has gotten out of hand and is potentially dangerous.

It's funny how there was an outcry about the fashion industry using underweight models yet the opposite is happening now with people applauding the use of overweight models. Whilst I think it makes sense to show how clothes look on different bodies, I don't think we should lose sight that being overweight or underweight can have health implications. I don't judge anyone elses weight. That's up to them. If someone's happy being overweight good for them, but let's not kid ourselves that it's healthy.

60% of the population in the UK is overweight and it's only going to get worse. When you look around and see most overweight people you think "oh I'm fine, I'm normal, I'm not as fat as that person bla bla bla."

I've always been health conscious, I've never been overweight but I have been unhappy with my body, wanted to be more toned etc. I eat well and go to the gym regularly and I'm pretty happy with how my body looks now. I've had comments like," if you think you need to tone up what must you think of me". That's their issue. I'm not going to stop striving to look my best because someone else has insecurities about their body.

I think you're overthinking it. If you want to lose weight do it. What's more body positive than eating better, doing more exercise and being healthier. If anyone thinks that's a dig at them that's their own shit that they need to deal with.

Lentilweaver · 12/01/2023 11:46

Studies have also shown that PoC are more susceptible to diabetes/ heart disease/ Covid and therefore can be ill even at a relatively healthy weight.

I am Asian, 50, 5"7 and 11 stone, so at the top end of a healthy BMI but not technically overweight. I have been told to lose weight though because I have diabetes in my family. And of course Asians are genetically prone to diabetes.

I don't see this as fat phobic or discriminatory. It's the same as if my GP told me I had eczema. It's not a moral judgement of me as a person, it's just health advice.

Climbles · 12/01/2023 11:37

Studies have found a lot of the additional health risks of being over weight come down to the health system not taking fat peoples pain seriously and not offering the same level of care. Black people have the same difficulties being believed.

ehb102 · 12/01/2023 11:33

Ooh, look! Fat phobia out in force here.

Health at every size is about being as healthy as you can at every size. Sure. I'd be a lot healthier if the 50kg of fibrotic fat was off me, but lipoedema makes it so that won't happen with diet and exercise.

I still exercise and look to control my normal fat though. I do it looking like the before picture even at my lightest possible weight. Post surgeries I'm starting the work to get back to full health.

Look after your body as best you can and ignore anyone who says you aren't okay until you achieve thinness. It's not true.

Mamoun · 12/01/2023 09:57

Lannielou · 11/01/2023 20:57

I'm 50 this year and obese. Finally last year I deafened my mums voice in my head and started going to the gym. I don't go to lose weight, I go for strength and flexibility. I don't weigh myself again ignoring my mums voice in my head. I love the body positivity to a point, hence why I wear funky gym leggings. I want to be 50 and fabulous

You sound fabulous!

BlandSoup · 12/01/2023 09:33

This is a good podcast about ultra process food and how it is so unhealthy and makes you want to eat more. Don’t know what your day to day foods are but it’s certainly made me think about what I eat.

www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/m0017tcz/episodes/downloads

BlandSoup · 12/01/2023 09:28

Yes, you can have both those thoughts in your head. You wanting to lose weight doesn’t mean that you don’t support body positivity. You can want to lose weight without it meaning you judge other women. And without having to aim for the heroin chic look.

Healthy at any weight isn’t true. Obesity is one of the biggest risk factors for cancer.

hidethenips · 12/01/2023 08:57

constituaint · 12/01/2023 08:48

Thanks everyone some really interesting perspectives.

Can anyone recommend some good reading on intuitive eating?

Intuitive Eating - Evelyn Tribole & Elyse Resch (4th Edition). It really did change my life!

Menora · 12/01/2023 08:55

As a fat person myself, the body pos movement has not helped me. It has made it more tormenting and confusing as to what I should accept.

I have had to square this away by working out that it means being fat doesn’t stop me being good at my job, or a good parent or not being worthy of being loved or respected, but in terms of health it is negative. I am unhealthy and I need to lose weight.

I don’t want to accept health at all sizes if in reality I am going to die earlier than I might otherwise. I really worry about this movement giving out an absolutely false sense of security. Being fat is within my control, although it’s clearly emotional problems as I know it’s not good for me yet I am still doing things that make me fat. I don’t think I should be treated badly as I am fat, or even judged for it but it’s on me to change it. I refuse to be pressured by unpleasantness or cruelty but I need a healthy dose of reality - fat is probably bad for you and I would help myself by losing weight

constituaint · 12/01/2023 08:48

Thanks everyone some really interesting perspectives.

Can anyone recommend some good reading on intuitive eating?

OP posts:
BogRollBOGOF · 12/01/2023 08:22

The best way to be "body positive" is to nourish your body with good food and maintain it with exercise/ activity levels. Love what your body does for you, and look after it.

You wouldn't proclaim that you love your car, then load it so the suspension barely copes, put the wrong fuel type in, take it out once every 3 weeks, scrape it into bushes/trees and wonder why it performs poorly.

Significant excess weight has a health cost. You may have plenty of nutrients, but it costs more effort to move. Yes, obese people can and do run marathons, but at any running event the top 10% will be pretty lean and the average BMI will go up towards the back of the event. Very, very few are fast and fat; fit enough to participate, but not fast.

The health toll is cumulative. You can get away with it when you're in your 20s-30s, but it does catch up in middle age. The younger you were obese, the harder it is to change your habits/ lifestyle/ view of yourself and the physical toll. My motivation comes from my dad dying as a result of his lifestyle in his early 50s. If it's about genetics, then looking at my family, I have "fat genes", they're all overweight past 35... except my lifestyle is different and that is far more influential. I'm realistic about my body shape- my priority is to treat my body well.

It's worth eating and moving in a balanced way as an act of self love. It's not about morality, vanity or politics; you have one body to carry you through life, care for it.

thecatsthecats · 12/01/2023 08:07

For what it's worth, I'm with you, OP, in how you feel about diet culture.

I have never and would never fit into the heroin chic, braless in strappy dresses, nothing tastes as good as skinny feels mode.

I'm one of the people for whom BMI is quite a poor measure. Muscly, and broad framed (my fingers can't meet around my wrist at any size and my shoulders are 2" wider than the top of the average range for women). A nurse laughed at my BMI coming out at 27, when I had a 28" waist at 5'9". Resting heart rate in the athlete range, high aerobic capacity, perfect blood pressure - I can have a BMI of 27, and be perfectly healthy.

But having this attitude didn't help me when I later gained weight. I was so busy with resisting unhealthy mindsets that I lost sight of what was healthy for ME too.

I had to work HARD to lose that weight, then long covid stacked a few more pounds on.