Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

...to propose some really radical changes to council tax?

167 replies

allswellthatends · 11/01/2023 17:39

Following up on yesterday’s thread about encouraging downsizing (thank you, PoinsettiaPosturing) I’d like to propose a few radical changes to council tax, which we all seem to agree needs reform.

I’d base council tax on the total floor area of the house, ie all the rooms not just the footprint on the land. It would include garages, sheds, and even (perhaps at a different rate) private gardens. It would not be based on number of rooms but on absolute size, so there would be no cliff-edges, just a straight charge per square metre. (With, obviously, variation for land actively under farm cultivation or grazing.)

This would effectively make council tax a milder form of wealth tax or property tax such as they have in North America, but ensure the money stays local instead of ending in central government hands.

It would encourage anyone living in a home larger than needed to downsize (why pick on the elderly?) Living close together not only costs less in services but is better for the environment. It would help meet the government goal or reducing car travel in a fairer way than Oxford's plan to charge for driving out of your 15-minute neighbourhood. It would eliminate the need to target council house tenants with the extra-bedroom charge.

Taxing by living space instead of cost would be a great deal fairer to all regions: people who live in London already pay a disproportionate price for less space, why should they have to pay higher council tax on top of that? After all, more room is a luxury no matter where in the country you live. City residents would still be paying slightly more tax on living space, because city houses involve more corridors and staircases and I'm afraid I'm still taxing that when I become Queen of the World.

Please don’t all start screaming about how much richer Londoners are: they’re not all rich, and this is one reason teachers, nurses, and other essential workers are being priced out – cost-of-living adjustments don’t reflect true costs and could more efficiently rolled into a council tax system. London salaries are not as much higher than in the rest of the country as rents and property prices are; Londoners just pay more of their already-taxed income on housing, and subsidise services for the rest of the country in the process, so why should they be penalised yet again with higher council taxes as well? Like all of us, they already pay more income tax if they earn more and more VAT and stamp duty if they buy more.

But rural and suburban residents too might benefit from more council tax being collected locally to fund the services they use. In Britain people choose to move out because they want bigger houses, and then wail that there are (say) no buses, when the simple fact is that rural residents can't and don’t want to pay the true cost of running buses (and roads, plumbing pipes, and electric wires, and rubbish collection, and wifi signals, etc etc) over areas that are more spread out.

Then (here’s where I’d get really evil): I’d base the council tax on planning permission for the site, even before the building is built. That would give developers a real push to build houses. Westminster has been saying for years they need to stop developers from land-banking to keep housing prices high.

I’ve donned my aluminium-foil helmet. Grin

OP posts:
WoofWoofWoofMudToys · 11/01/2023 19:31

LeggyLinda · 11/01/2023 18:16

Like most people (I think), I cannot see a fair solution to gain taxation at the local level. Most fair solutions involve taxing for local services on a per-head basis - which sounds too much like the hated poll tax.

all I know is that council tax is currently one of our biggest outgoings and we seem to get nothing in return for it.

@LeggyLinda

no police?

no rubbish/recycling services?

no road lighting?

no road maintenance?

ne verge cutting?

etc etc etc

mist unusual??

pieceofpasta · 11/01/2023 19:24

How would work for people with leasehold (rather than freehold) if it was based on land owned? Where I live is mostly leasehold.

America12 · 11/01/2023 19:24

I lived in a 2 bedroom council house with a huge garden.
Single parent (always worked).
That would have made me pay more because I was allocated a house with a big garden. Not fair.
Maybe it should go on people ? It's to pay for services.

OhFFS! · 11/01/2023 19:17

No thanks to the idea. We already pay over £300 for sod all services. We live in a small village so do have space and a decent size garden. No one could develop the garden for housing due to access so we couldn't reduce the space if we wanted to. Our friends who live in Greater London pay far less and get so much more. Under your plans we would need to spend even more and still get hardly anything for it. That's not fair either

MrsDanversGlidesAgain · 11/01/2023 19:16

Orders76 · 11/01/2023 19:01

Sounds like forcing older people who don't have large amounts of cash out of their homes.

And we have a winner.

DahliaMacNamara · 11/01/2023 19:14

ErrolTheDragon · 11/01/2023 19:00

Sheds? What about greenhouses? Polytunnels?

Guy across the road has a large pigeon loft and a treehouse. He's going to get totally hammered. Bloody birds won't pay a penny, either, the feckless sods.

Grumpybutfunny · 11/01/2023 19:14

Itsokay2020 · 11/01/2023 18:45

On face value I agree with basing council tax on size, but then I live in a house which is band E despite being a smaller size to band D houses within my village. It’s based purely on value, but our house was only built 5.5 years ago. The whole system is very unfair and unfairly penalises those in the south in my opinion (we currently pay £2,372.04 pa) as it’s based on property value.

I pay more than that in an old mining town in the north east! 2.3k for a village is cheap.

OP why does it need to be based on house size? Not number of people accessing the services? We don't use even half of the services our council provides (road isn't even adopted) yet pay the same as someone with three kids in the local school, using the leisure centre and library. We also live in an area where we don't need to downsize as we aren't packed in like sardines. You chose to live in London with its benefits like easy access to promotion and shopping but that does come at a cost. We live semi rurally, have to drive to the local shops etc but have the advantage of more space.

midgetastic · 11/01/2023 19:03

Orders76 · 11/01/2023 19:01

Sounds like forcing older people who don't have large amounts of cash out of their homes.

Well the op of the referenced post was exactly trying to achieve that

lieselotte · 11/01/2023 19:01

Then (here’s where I’d get really evil): I’d base the council tax on planning permission for the site, even before the building is built. That would give developers a real push to build houses. Westminster has been saying for years they need to stop developers from land-banking to keep housing prices high

I'm not sure about that because I don't want green field development. But maybe we need to be stricter about council tax on empty properties which need to be brought into use. And obviously charge second/third/tenth home owners a massive premium. But with my grant from central government idea you wouldn't be able to do that, unless councils levied an extra charge on those people.

Orders76 · 11/01/2023 19:01

Sounds like forcing older people who don't have large amounts of cash out of their homes.

MintJulia · 11/01/2023 19:01

We've just been through a pandemic that spread rapidly because people were packed close together, and now you want to impose a tax that encourages people to be packed closer together. That's bright !

I have a half acre veggie patch & greenhouse. I live rurally. I grow 50% of our veg, fruit & salad - all environmentally sound, no food miles etc but you think that should be taxed now. I assume you live in a town !

confusedcentral5 · 11/01/2023 19:01

Abolish CT & SD & just have the one property tax.

allswellthatends · 11/01/2023 19:01

Kinnorafron · 11/01/2023 18:37

You seem to be forgetting that a house is where we live for most ordinary mortals - we can't just up sticks and fuck off somewhere we like more easily. Apart from the costs of moving - if we own the place we'll likely have to pay stamp duty too.

I live in a cheap place with space because I can't afford to live in London and probably never will be able to. Under your plan I'm going to be penalised - and probably forced to move to cramped accommodation in a city - is that your aim?

Another good point, Kinnorafron, but actually, it was your choice. You wanted more space, so you moved further out. Definitely your right to choose. Sounds like, though, you could have chosen to live in a smaller place and didn't... your choice.

Am sort of surprised no one has yet pointed out, more specifically, that many people live where they do because family is near or they grew up there. I am so rootless this is a lost cause with me but I do get that it matters, especially for money-poor or time-poor people. With enough political pressure arguably each region will get a mix of more "Tory-style" (low-tax, low-service) and "Labour" (less-tax, less-service) councils but that too will take at least a lifetime, so this is a problem.

You are all raising very interesting points. Honestly, I want you all to join my Star Chamber. Shall we form a political party?

OP posts:
confusedcentral5 · 11/01/2023 19:01

I think that's a good idea, bit similar to property tax in France & other places I believe.

Honper · 11/01/2023 19:00

Yabu. If you're a Londoner you already pay less than the rest of us for an asset that is worth significantly more than a comparable asset elsewhere. We're already subsidising you!

It should be based on a combination of income and asset value and the single person discount should be 50%. There should also be a discount for tenants. They get taxed based on the 1991/notional value of an asset they don't even own! Instead add a tax on landlords and also freeholders. Which also might discourage developers from building leasehold bloody houses.

hoppityscotch · 11/01/2023 19:00

Rubbish idea unless you're going to make sure everyone has access to live in a tiny shoebox house with no garden. The size of the property does not equal its value.

lieselotte · 11/01/2023 19:00

By the way I live in a true blue Tory constituency in the south and pay considerably more council tax than people in London do, I'm not sure how we compare with eg Scotland or cities in the north of England. I paid buttons when I lived in Wandsworth in a tiny flat which was band A.

ErrolTheDragon · 11/01/2023 19:00

Sheds? What about greenhouses? Polytunnels?

lieselotte · 11/01/2023 18:56

Coming at this from a completely different direction - a suggestion to do away with council tax altogether, increase income tax and other general taxation and give every council a grant from central government based on the number of residents. Then everyone has the same money and there's no postcode lottery which says some people get better services than others. To do that I'd get rid of some layers of local government to save admin costs (eg have unitary authorities instead of county and district councils).

I know Labour want to do the opposite and have more devolvement though.

Screwcorona · 11/01/2023 18:54

I'd prefer if everyone was taxed on income purely instead of all the different taxes that end up adding up to a huge percentage of low and middle earners incomes, and small percentage of rich people

Brahumbug · 11/01/2023 18:51

FuckabethFuckor · 11/01/2023 18:06

I actually wonder if this would add bureaucracy, not remove it. You'd have to have some kind of central government oversight to ensure councils operate their taxation schemes fairly, proportionately to local services and within certain boundaries, which would end up with each council having to pitch or propose rates to government on a periodical basis. The administration of that would be enormous.

There already is a government agency overseeing council tax, the Valuation Office Agency.

MrsDanversGlidesAgain · 11/01/2023 18:51

MrsDanvers, I said "happen to know" because we didn't know when we moved in. (Is it normal for property agents to mention this? Maybe it should be?

I have a Rightmove habit (pondering where to retire) and council tax bands are usually on the properties. It's one of the questions I'd ask. Perhaps that's just me.

trythisforsize · 11/01/2023 18:51

I've had a brainwave - maybe theres a flaw in this but . . . .
Instead of changing council tax, why can't income tax be altered so that those who work for NHS, caring, social, teachers and not-for-profit professions are in a lower rate scheme of tax bands, those who work in profit orientated jobs are in a higher rate scheme of tax bands. After all, aren't our taxes paying the caring/teaching professions? It seems daft that they then give the same proportion of tax back again as tax.
This system would result in higher take home wages for those currently striking, without a change to their actual salary AND it would encourage people into those types of professions which we desperately . The people making profits would pay higher tax and so they should because they make money out of the infrastructure that tax puts in place (nhs, transport etc).
Who wants to vote for me?

DahliaMacNamara · 11/01/2023 18:47

You lost me at sheds, tbh. I fork out for a shed to accommodate the belongings of a DC who can no longer afford to rent their own place, and you think that should make me liable for higher council tax? There'd be shed disguisers on the market in a heartbeat, Like those patterned wotsits you can buy to prettify your bin. Incognito sheds disguised as a hedge or a fence, and agreement with the neighbours not to grass each other up.

CastleTower · 11/01/2023 18:47

FYI, council tax is not higher in London. Westminster has one of the lowest rates in the country. The NE has some of the highest, despite much lower average salaries. It always surprises people who move up here from the South.

Factor this into your reform, perhaps!