Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

...to propose some really radical changes to council tax?

167 replies

allswellthatends · 11/01/2023 17:39

Following up on yesterday’s thread about encouraging downsizing (thank you, PoinsettiaPosturing) I’d like to propose a few radical changes to council tax, which we all seem to agree needs reform.

I’d base council tax on the total floor area of the house, ie all the rooms not just the footprint on the land. It would include garages, sheds, and even (perhaps at a different rate) private gardens. It would not be based on number of rooms but on absolute size, so there would be no cliff-edges, just a straight charge per square metre. (With, obviously, variation for land actively under farm cultivation or grazing.)

This would effectively make council tax a milder form of wealth tax or property tax such as they have in North America, but ensure the money stays local instead of ending in central government hands.

It would encourage anyone living in a home larger than needed to downsize (why pick on the elderly?) Living close together not only costs less in services but is better for the environment. It would help meet the government goal or reducing car travel in a fairer way than Oxford's plan to charge for driving out of your 15-minute neighbourhood. It would eliminate the need to target council house tenants with the extra-bedroom charge.

Taxing by living space instead of cost would be a great deal fairer to all regions: people who live in London already pay a disproportionate price for less space, why should they have to pay higher council tax on top of that? After all, more room is a luxury no matter where in the country you live. City residents would still be paying slightly more tax on living space, because city houses involve more corridors and staircases and I'm afraid I'm still taxing that when I become Queen of the World.

Please don’t all start screaming about how much richer Londoners are: they’re not all rich, and this is one reason teachers, nurses, and other essential workers are being priced out – cost-of-living adjustments don’t reflect true costs and could more efficiently rolled into a council tax system. London salaries are not as much higher than in the rest of the country as rents and property prices are; Londoners just pay more of their already-taxed income on housing, and subsidise services for the rest of the country in the process, so why should they be penalised yet again with higher council taxes as well? Like all of us, they already pay more income tax if they earn more and more VAT and stamp duty if they buy more.

But rural and suburban residents too might benefit from more council tax being collected locally to fund the services they use. In Britain people choose to move out because they want bigger houses, and then wail that there are (say) no buses, when the simple fact is that rural residents can't and don’t want to pay the true cost of running buses (and roads, plumbing pipes, and electric wires, and rubbish collection, and wifi signals, etc etc) over areas that are more spread out.

Then (here’s where I’d get really evil): I’d base the council tax on planning permission for the site, even before the building is built. That would give developers a real push to build houses. Westminster has been saying for years they need to stop developers from land-banking to keep housing prices high.

I’ve donned my aluminium-foil helmet. Grin

OP posts:
CitronVert22 · 11/01/2023 22:59

All the stuff about keeping the money local doesn't make sense. Currently council tax only pays for about a quarter of local services anyway. The rest of the cash comes from central government.

Local tax for local people sounds good, but all it means is that central government doesn't redistribute wealth from rich areas to poor ones. This means poor areas end up with worse public services.

Penguinsaregreat · 11/01/2023 22:57

Sorry about the typos.

Penguinsaregreat · 11/01/2023 22:56

You will never please everyone.
Perhaps councils should offer far fewer free services. Perhaps people should pay for what they need/use.
Then you will have the parents of children who get free services jumping up and down crying “That’s not fair!”
The families of all those whose parents receive care which for by the tax payer crying too.
You can’t one the one hand say people should pay for services such as transport, oh but I don’t want to pay for the transport the council provides to take my child to and from school.
I would be quite happy to see a reduction in my council tax and services reduced. I doubt after much consideration everyone would though. You will never get around the fact that some people take far more from the system than they put into it.
Id be happy not to have my bins emptied in return for a reduction in council tax. I would quite happily take all my rubbish to a collection point. However I can guarantee that those who don’t pay as much tax as I do would be jumping up and down complaining, dating his the council should be paying to empty their bins and why should they have to physically take it somewhere.

Nevermind31 · 11/01/2023 22:52

Seems to be an excuse for developers to build even smaller houses… English houses are already tiny…

CrocodilesCry · 11/01/2023 22:50

Four of the ten UK councils with the lowest council tax bills (for a Band D property so comparable) are in London (Westminster, City of London, Wandsworth and Hammersmith & Fulham). Not a single area of London is included in the ten areas with the highest council tax rates. Sorry, but your idea is based on a false assumption about the cost of council tax so it's pretty moot.

fUNNYfACE36 · 11/01/2023 22:49

Jeez what an administrative nightmare that would be to set up! Where would all the staff and money to measure the square metreage of every property in the land come from?

AreOttersJustWetCats · 11/01/2023 22:44

Also, worth pointing out that council tax is not currently about taxing wealth (as some on here have suggested). If it were, renters would be exempt because the house isn't their asset.

AreOttersJustWetCats · 11/01/2023 22:43

Also, worth pointing out that council tax is not currently about taxing wealth (as some on here have suggested). If it were, renters would be exempt because the house isn't their asset.

AreOttersJustWetCats · 11/01/2023 22:36

Why do you assume that Londoners pay more in council tax? They don't.

www.thetimes.co.uk/article/council-tax-london-pays-20-per-cent-more-north-england-c8ktg8q8x

"the owner of a £28 million Belgravia townhouse, with its own gym, swimming pool, cinema and lift, pays less council tax than the owner of a £240,000 three-bedroom terrace in Oakham, a small town near Leicester"

Believeitornot · 11/01/2023 22:29

I think bin a property based council tax for local services (as councils do more than that).

Just have higher general taxation on individuals and businesses and allocate the funds to local areas based on various factors.

Reduce the size of central government and put more money locally. Have strong local accountability- bring back the Audit Commission to properly monitor councils. I think our local politicians should be improved as they are the ones with the greatest impact on our lives (think of the services we use: schools, NHS, bin collection etc, that should all be run locally).

Our government is too centralised. Central government are too far away from people to make sensible decisions and needs slimming down.

Any property based taxes should be on gains from price changes, not annual nonsense charges.

jcyclops · 11/01/2023 22:21

Chimna · 11/01/2023 20:18

Some London boroughs already have the cheapest Council Tax rates in the country.

Not strictly true.

You can't compare band D tax in Wandsworth (£1227) or Kensington and Chelsea (£1364) with somewhere like Hull (£1541) and say London is cheaper.
The median house in Hull is band A (£1027), in Wandsworth it is band D (£1227) and in Kensington & Chelsea it is band F (£1970).

Kinnorafron · 11/01/2023 21:31

@allswellthatends
Another good point, Kinnorafron, but actually, it was your choice. You wanted more space, so you moved further out. Definitely your right to choose. Sounds like, though, you could have chosen to live in a smaller place and didn't... your choice.
Up to a point. There is no point at my life when I'd have been able to buy a house or even a flat in London.

EmmaEmerald · 11/01/2023 20:33

*how

EmmaEmerald · 11/01/2023 20:33

Allergic "I've seen this many times over the years, in Central government, Local government, and in private businesses. Someone comes up with a bright idea, feasibility studies prove that it's actually NOT feasible. Then 10 years later some other person comes up with the SAME bright idea, and you go through it all again. Or even worse the in depth study doesn't take place, the idea is implemented, and it's a complete failure costing time, effort & sometimes worse."

and woe betide anyone who points out it's been done before.

one of the best ideas for council tax reform would be to look at councils waste money.

Itsokay2020 · 11/01/2023 20:26

@Grumpybutfunny we don’t live in London, instead we are approximately 50 miles always from the centre of London. A small village (circa 2,000 homes), no doctors, dentist and limited public transport. Our road hasn’t been adopted either. I still believe that given there is a national minimum wage, living wage and consistent apprenticeship wages across England, council tax should be ‘levelled up’ so that it is based on size, not value, providing more consistency and provide more funds to help cover the growing cost of social care, for example.

Chimna · 11/01/2023 20:18

Some London boroughs already have the cheapest Council Tax rates in the country.

Refreshmentsanyone · 11/01/2023 20:12

The riots because poll tax taxed people taxed regardless of their ability to pay.

The old rates system it replaced was based on what a house could be rented out for. Maybe it’s time to revert back to that?

hothands · 11/01/2023 20:09

We already pay over £300 for sod all services

Is that per month, per year or a typo?

JaninaDuszejko · 11/01/2023 19:58

There are two aspects here. Council tax is a property tax with the aim of taxing people at least partly on their wealth rather than just income. In addition it is a local tax and, as has been repeatedly pointed out, people with very valuable properties in rich areas pay less council tax than people in bigger houses in poor areas.

My brother lives in a 2 bed flat with 1 reception room in London, I live with my husband and children in a 4 bed house with 3 reception rooms in the NE. We have similar household incomes, his flat is worth twice what our house is. Which house should be in the higher band? Who should pay the most council tax? Who is paying the most?

A local income tax would be one kind of fair but wouldn't reflect household wealth. And all politicians are reluctant to change the system because when the poll tax was introduced councils took the opportunity to increase the amount they collected (hence the riots). You can pretty much guarantee the same would happen again if the system was changed again.

jgw1 · 11/01/2023 19:38

Mark19735 · 11/01/2023 18:42

Nope, I think that putting all property into seven arbitrary bands based on an estimated value on 1 Apr 1991 and using that system would be best.

It's what I grew up with, and I CAN'T BE EXPECTED TO IMAGINE ANYTHING ELSE.

And let me just hijack this thread to say I HATE TAXATION. That should shut down any debate

And also add some whataboutery - such as WHAT ABOUT ALL THE WASTE IN THE MINISTRY OF [INSERT HOBBY HORSE HERE]. Don't we spend too much on funding something I read about in the Mail that makes me REALLY ANGRY? I'm sure that made up figure that sounds a lot would easily pay for all the services provided by local authorities across the country as a whole, because it's bigger than my current council tax bill and I CAN'T DO MATHS!

Phew - that felt good. Hopefully that will cauterize anyone who was intending to post along those lines.

And, having got that out of my system - well done OP, great thread. Good suggestion. Who do I vote for to make it happen?

May I applaud your excellent post.
Well played.

Allergictoironing · 11/01/2023 19:37

I guess I could say that every council has to tax not only on the same basis but at the same percentage, but, as you know, different areas do have different priorities and surely we think the choice is good too?

It's not just different priorities, but different needs e.g. an area with a higher percentage of low/no income people usually needs to pay more to support them. An area with a higher proportion of the elderly is likely to need to spend more on social services, whereas one with a young family demographic will need more spent on education. You then add in factors like the higher the population density in general, the more these and many other outgoings increase e.g. healthcare, infrastructure support (as being used more), facilities.

Then factor in areas where there just aren't many jobs, e.g. very rural areas or those where a traditional industry like mining or manufacturing have stopped. Feed in the additional costs of cities & towns where much of the wear & tear on infrastructure is caused by commuters or shoppers coming in to the area

And then add in the salaries of the people carrying out these functions; you tend to have to pay more for certain professions in built up areas due to a variety of reasons including availability of these people and their own cost of living, but in more rural areas you need to allow for longer distances to travel between jobs and possibly again fewer skilled workers in a particular field.

I'm afraid that like many good ideas, once you start to look at exceptions and differences you realise that what seemed simple is actually much more complex than first thought, and that there tend to be more exceptions than the "typical" example the theory was based on.

I've seen this many times over the years, in Central government, Local government, and in private businesses. Someone comes up with a bright idea, feasibility studies prove that it's actually NOT feasible. Then 10 years later some other person comes up with the SAME bright idea, and you go through it all again. Or even worse the in depth study doesn't take place, the idea is implemented, and it's a complete failure costing time, effort & sometimes worse.

Kabalagala · 11/01/2023 19:33

I think it's a great idea. We are, as some people like to point out, a small island. Anything that encourages efficient use of housing and space should be encouraged.

America12 · 11/01/2023 19:33

@allswellthatends @Kinnorafron it's not always a choice where you live though ?
People on MN are always getting told to move to cheaper areas.
There are people who would love to live in London but will never be able to afford to.

TemporaryNaming · 11/01/2023 19:33

Erm no thank you. I am a private tenant & have a HUGE garden shared between 2 flats- but 'my section' is the biggest according to the title deeds. I only live here because no other landlord would take me as I'm a single mother relying on UC to help pay rent. I know they say they can't discriminate but they absolutely do. Why should I pay more council tax than my neighbour who owns her house outright? Ridiculous idea.

orangegato · 11/01/2023 19:32

Fuck this I own a bungalow