Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

...to propose some really radical changes to council tax?

167 replies

allswellthatends · 11/01/2023 17:39

Following up on yesterday’s thread about encouraging downsizing (thank you, PoinsettiaPosturing) I’d like to propose a few radical changes to council tax, which we all seem to agree needs reform.

I’d base council tax on the total floor area of the house, ie all the rooms not just the footprint on the land. It would include garages, sheds, and even (perhaps at a different rate) private gardens. It would not be based on number of rooms but on absolute size, so there would be no cliff-edges, just a straight charge per square metre. (With, obviously, variation for land actively under farm cultivation or grazing.)

This would effectively make council tax a milder form of wealth tax or property tax such as they have in North America, but ensure the money stays local instead of ending in central government hands.

It would encourage anyone living in a home larger than needed to downsize (why pick on the elderly?) Living close together not only costs less in services but is better for the environment. It would help meet the government goal or reducing car travel in a fairer way than Oxford's plan to charge for driving out of your 15-minute neighbourhood. It would eliminate the need to target council house tenants with the extra-bedroom charge.

Taxing by living space instead of cost would be a great deal fairer to all regions: people who live in London already pay a disproportionate price for less space, why should they have to pay higher council tax on top of that? After all, more room is a luxury no matter where in the country you live. City residents would still be paying slightly more tax on living space, because city houses involve more corridors and staircases and I'm afraid I'm still taxing that when I become Queen of the World.

Please don’t all start screaming about how much richer Londoners are: they’re not all rich, and this is one reason teachers, nurses, and other essential workers are being priced out – cost-of-living adjustments don’t reflect true costs and could more efficiently rolled into a council tax system. London salaries are not as much higher than in the rest of the country as rents and property prices are; Londoners just pay more of their already-taxed income on housing, and subsidise services for the rest of the country in the process, so why should they be penalised yet again with higher council taxes as well? Like all of us, they already pay more income tax if they earn more and more VAT and stamp duty if they buy more.

But rural and suburban residents too might benefit from more council tax being collected locally to fund the services they use. In Britain people choose to move out because they want bigger houses, and then wail that there are (say) no buses, when the simple fact is that rural residents can't and don’t want to pay the true cost of running buses (and roads, plumbing pipes, and electric wires, and rubbish collection, and wifi signals, etc etc) over areas that are more spread out.

Then (here’s where I’d get really evil): I’d base the council tax on planning permission for the site, even before the building is built. That would give developers a real push to build houses. Westminster has been saying for years they need to stop developers from land-banking to keep housing prices high.

I’ve donned my aluminium-foil helmet. Grin

OP posts:
PuzzleMonster · 12/01/2023 00:28

Penguinsaregreat · 11/01/2023 23:09

There is a huge problem. Poor areas get poorer. Social care costs are unfair. Why should I pay more because I can’t afford to live in a posh area, with better facilities, better transport, better green areas, more pleasant, better schools the list is endless.
Some people have been unfairly priced out of naice areas. So they have to live in crappier parts of the country subsidising those who don’t pay their fair share. Paying more and more.

So should everyone be subsidising those who don't pay their fair share, or shouldn't they? You seem to be arguing that everyone else should subsidise them, but not you!

PuzzleMonster · 12/01/2023 00:18

CrocodilesCry · 11/01/2023 22:50

Four of the ten UK councils with the lowest council tax bills (for a Band D property so comparable) are in London (Westminster, City of London, Wandsworth and Hammersmith & Fulham). Not a single area of London is included in the ten areas with the highest council tax rates. Sorry, but your idea is based on a false assumption about the cost of council tax so it's pretty moot.

Band D properties in different areas are not remotely comparable: in one place it is a small flat, in another a large house, so you are comparing apples and pears.

altmember · 12/01/2023 00:11

Chimna · 11/01/2023 23:48

But at the same time, why should the poorest people in the country be paying the same as billionaires? Surely a fairer system would be to rebamd all properties based on today's values and review every 10 years, pool all money back to the government then share out fairly to councils.

Because they get exactly the same service from the local authority regardless of their wealth or the size/value of their home. Council Tax is supposed to be about paying towards the local services and amenities, not a wealth tax. I'm not even sure why it's called a tax at all really? Other taxes (income tax etc) are supposed to raise more money on a wealth/income basis.

The whole tax system needs overhauling. But then so does public spending.

NewYearNewCareer · 12/01/2023 00:07

What about people who commute? They use the city benefits without paying for them surely? And vise versa obviously!

Id love to pick a house based on exact need - but that isn’t obtainable.

A large town house is now cheaper that a 2 bed flat because people can’t afford to Mai rain or heat them. They would go to ruin!

EmmaEmerald · 12/01/2023 00:02

PuzzleMonster · 11/01/2023 23:58

That is exactly what happened in France. And not just to old people, either.

Oh dear.
there do seem to be protests in France, not that it gets reported.

I must go to bed but I will look up the situation in France, as we will probably get lumbered with something weird soon.

Mark19735 · 12/01/2023 00:00

Its about cost efficiencies. The miles of road per resident in Wandsworth is much lower than in South Wales. Makes it cheaper to sweep them for each person chipping in. And one bin lorry can collect a thousand residents' waste in a day, tip at the transfer station, and return to do another thousand before that crew go off shift. In Shropshire that same crew might collect the bins from a hundred homes in the entire shift. One big library can serve 100,000 residents in Westminster, in a rural area you'd need 10 smaller libraries each serving 10,000. That's more librarians, more heating, and ten copies of each book, whereas the bigger library might only need 5. The list is endless. Bottom line is, cramming people into cities is cheaper, rural areas are nicer, that attracts better off people, but it also means country-dwellers have to pay more per head for their services. It's not just public services though - you seen the petrol prices in Cornwall? Or tried to get a parcel delivered anywhere in Northern Ireland or the Outer Hebrides?

PuzzleMonster · 11/01/2023 23:58

Orders76 · 11/01/2023 19:01

Sounds like forcing older people who don't have large amounts of cash out of their homes.

That is exactly what happened in France. And not just to old people, either.

PuzzleMonster · 11/01/2023 23:57

confusedcentral5 · 11/01/2023 19:01

I think that's a good idea, bit similar to property tax in France & other places I believe.

The land tax in France was a complete disaster.

Onnabugeisha · 11/01/2023 23:56

I don’t understand a radius based on time..as in a “15 min radius”
A radius is usually as the crow flies….as in a straight line..but we don’t journey in straight lines?
And what method of transport is this measured by?
Some days it takes 30mins to go 1/2mile, other days can get 20 miles in 15mins and that’s by car.
If it’s a bus, you can literally have not moved and inch in 15mins or more standing and waiting at the bus stop.
Walking..is that the speed of an angry teenager or a shuffling pensioner?

and so on. Seems pretty arbitrary to me.

GFP · 11/01/2023 23:50

*talk

GFP · 11/01/2023 23:49

Shocking on MN I know but there’s always cycling when people take about a 15 minute radius. Electric scooters. Just use your imagination really, we don’t all have to live cheek by jowl in apartment blocks.

Chimna · 11/01/2023 23:48

jcyclops · 11/01/2023 22:21

Not strictly true.

You can't compare band D tax in Wandsworth (£1227) or Kensington and Chelsea (£1364) with somewhere like Hull (£1541) and say London is cheaper.
The median house in Hull is band A (£1027), in Wandsworth it is band D (£1227) and in Kensington & Chelsea it is band F (£1970).

But at the same time, why should the poorest people in the country be paying the same as billionaires? Surely a fairer system would be to rebamd all properties based on today's values and review every 10 years, pool all money back to the government then share out fairly to councils.

PuzzleMonster · 11/01/2023 23:44

Kinnorafron · 11/01/2023 18:29

We ourselves upsized from a three-bedroom flat for 5 of us, one of the bedrooms too small even for a bed, to a five-bedroom house around the corner, partly because of my disabled son and how he affected the other children. We are in the same council tax band under the same council, and even though we benefit from this stupidity it's still stupidity!
Does your new house demand significantly more from Local Authority services?

Exactly. Confused

PuzzleMonster · 11/01/2023 23:43

MrsDanversGlidesAgain · 11/01/2023 18:29

If you prefer to pay more council tax rather than hire a hotel room when family visit, that's your choice

I have a one bedroom flat, I have to do that anyway. As far as I can see this comes down to - you have lots of money, great. You can pay for the rooms and have the family round and parties and a garden and a swimming pool or whatever. You don't have the money - tough shit. Studio with shared bath along the corridor for you and forget the family get togethers. And that's not going to be just the elderly, although at bottom this is probably just another 'pensioners in houses too big for them, how dare they take up space' argument.

I've seen some daft ideas on here but that's a doozy.

And also, what on Earth have family get togethers got to do with funding the appropriate share of your use of local services?

PuzzleMonster · 11/01/2023 23:41

OP you are basing your changes on a misunderstanding of council tax. In London many people with very valuable houses pay way less than people with cheaper houses elsewhere - so your argument that your new system will be "fairer" doesn't stack up.

Council Tax is meant to pay for local services. It makes no logical sense for it to be linked to house value at all. The poll tax actually made the most sense. I was a small child then so not too clear on what people's objections to it were. There will never be a perfect system but surely the closest crude approximation you'll get to the amount of services used would be the number of occupants, not the property value or size or garden size!

JudgeRudy · 11/01/2023 23:41

This sounds like it could be incredibly unfare to single households. Would there be a kind of standing charge where each household got Xm square for £Y then were charged £Z/square meter?
Let's assume I live alone in a 1 bed property but the neighbours are a couple. I would then pay twice as much tax but be using less amenities. I cannot downsize. I can't have half a bathroom or half a kitchen.
So does a garden have a different rate to a kitchen.
I just think it would be so hard to bring in. Maybe if you bought your home before 2025 you could choose to stay on the current system but newbuilds and exchanges would be on new system.

BungleandGeorge · 11/01/2023 23:27

jcyclops · 11/01/2023 22:21

Not strictly true.

You can't compare band D tax in Wandsworth (£1227) or Kensington and Chelsea (£1364) with somewhere like Hull (£1541) and say London is cheaper.
The median house in Hull is band A (£1027), in Wandsworth it is band D (£1227) and in Kensington & Chelsea it is band F (£1970).

Yes but why are all these properties in such a low band compared to elsewhere? A band d property would be about 300-350k round here. I presume it’s because Londoners have seen their property prices skyrocket and are vastly underpaying

Crinkled · 11/01/2023 23:23

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

BungleandGeorge · 11/01/2023 23:19

No it needs to be based on how many services you receive and ability to pay. Council tax is grossly unfair and your method is no improvement! A single person living in a village in a property worth 400k shouldn’t have to pay more than a family of 4 working adults in a 3 bedroom flat in a city worth 3 million. No, that isn’t fair. London has some of the lowest council tax rates yet some of the best facilities and highest earnings and capital.

JenniferBooth · 11/01/2023 23:19

Tenants pay council tax based on the value of a property they dont own

Penguinsaregreat · 11/01/2023 23:09

There is a huge problem. Poor areas get poorer. Social care costs are unfair. Why should I pay more because I can’t afford to live in a posh area, with better facilities, better transport, better green areas, more pleasant, better schools the list is endless.
Some people have been unfairly priced out of naice areas. So they have to live in crappier parts of the country subsidising those who don’t pay their fair share. Paying more and more.

EmmaEmerald · 11/01/2023 23:05

Penguins "I would be quite happy to see a reduction in my council tax and services reduced"

same. All the money they are spending doesn't get stuff like road mending done. You take your life in your hands if you're on a double decker bus going in and out of potholes.

I stayed in a hotel for work - very nice - they were hosting a council's "town twinning" event, complete with banquet.

my council spent a fortune on a consultation to prove there were grounds for getting rid of the local library.

they somehow spent £1million tarting up a small area with benches near the high street, then appear amazed that it's a hangout for daytime drunks.

I will say they have been great about sorting flytipping, and problems from a nearby building site.

BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz · 11/01/2023 23:01

Given that most of my council tax goes on social care in my region, I'd say it should be less linked to house size.

Alternatively, govts could find a way to separate the tax we pay that is earmarked for social care, make a National pot for that, reduce CTax overall before better linking it to house size.

1990s · 11/01/2023 23:01

greenbackers · 11/01/2023 17:56

I think there should a land value tax - i.e the amount of land owned.

Under your scheme, what happens if people extend or demolish parts of their house. How is that checked and added to the bill, especially if done as permitted development?

Haven’t RTFT so someone’s probably already said this but there used to be a land tax, got taken away by Thatcher I think?

The planning system was based on the twin approach of land tax and planning permission, so when they removed one half with land tax it meant all these developers can hold onto land with no penalty…

Fleur405 · 11/01/2023 23:01

New builds in the uk are already the smallest in Europe. I see lots of 5 bed new builds that have a smaller square footage than my 3 bed 1930s house.

anyway, council tax bandings are already based on a market value calculation - so surely that takes into account the size of the property/garden/amenities etc?