Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

...to propose some really radical changes to council tax?

167 replies

allswellthatends · 11/01/2023 17:39

Following up on yesterday’s thread about encouraging downsizing (thank you, PoinsettiaPosturing) I’d like to propose a few radical changes to council tax, which we all seem to agree needs reform.

I’d base council tax on the total floor area of the house, ie all the rooms not just the footprint on the land. It would include garages, sheds, and even (perhaps at a different rate) private gardens. It would not be based on number of rooms but on absolute size, so there would be no cliff-edges, just a straight charge per square metre. (With, obviously, variation for land actively under farm cultivation or grazing.)

This would effectively make council tax a milder form of wealth tax or property tax such as they have in North America, but ensure the money stays local instead of ending in central government hands.

It would encourage anyone living in a home larger than needed to downsize (why pick on the elderly?) Living close together not only costs less in services but is better for the environment. It would help meet the government goal or reducing car travel in a fairer way than Oxford's plan to charge for driving out of your 15-minute neighbourhood. It would eliminate the need to target council house tenants with the extra-bedroom charge.

Taxing by living space instead of cost would be a great deal fairer to all regions: people who live in London already pay a disproportionate price for less space, why should they have to pay higher council tax on top of that? After all, more room is a luxury no matter where in the country you live. City residents would still be paying slightly more tax on living space, because city houses involve more corridors and staircases and I'm afraid I'm still taxing that when I become Queen of the World.

Please don’t all start screaming about how much richer Londoners are: they’re not all rich, and this is one reason teachers, nurses, and other essential workers are being priced out – cost-of-living adjustments don’t reflect true costs and could more efficiently rolled into a council tax system. London salaries are not as much higher than in the rest of the country as rents and property prices are; Londoners just pay more of their already-taxed income on housing, and subsidise services for the rest of the country in the process, so why should they be penalised yet again with higher council taxes as well? Like all of us, they already pay more income tax if they earn more and more VAT and stamp duty if they buy more.

But rural and suburban residents too might benefit from more council tax being collected locally to fund the services they use. In Britain people choose to move out because they want bigger houses, and then wail that there are (say) no buses, when the simple fact is that rural residents can't and don’t want to pay the true cost of running buses (and roads, plumbing pipes, and electric wires, and rubbish collection, and wifi signals, etc etc) over areas that are more spread out.

Then (here’s where I’d get really evil): I’d base the council tax on planning permission for the site, even before the building is built. That would give developers a real push to build houses. Westminster has been saying for years they need to stop developers from land-banking to keep housing prices high.

I’ve donned my aluminium-foil helmet. Grin

OP posts:
Crinkled · 12/01/2023 18:00

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Fushiadreams · 12/01/2023 13:35

Chinnn · 12/01/2023 08:20

0.5% of the zoopla value of the house every year. No system is perfect but this is better than any other I have heard of.

Cmon you must be able to see how that is the worst idea. How councils in London would make way more money than those say in the north of England. How Zoopla is completely inaccurate for many properties?

no one could think council tax should be based on Zoopla surely?

Penguinsaregreat · 12/01/2023 13:32

Like I said you can never have a fair system. Or rather there will never be a fair system.
BRinging back the poll tax would be political suicide. I’m old enough to vaguely remember the rioting it caused up and down the country. The poll tax was unfair to all but an elite few. It resulted in everyone paying it regardless of ability to pay. This included pensioners on state pension and young adults who still lived at home with their parents. Everyone paid the same regardless of where you lived. I imagine stay at home parents paid the same too and I doubt the disabled got a free pass. Again, it caused mass rioting which I imagine cost millions of pounds. Riot police had to be paid plus the firefighters were having to deal with the burning cities.

Fushiadreams · 12/01/2023 13:27

Who are you proposing it to? You understand this is a chat forum and we aren’t in a position to change it. So if you want to propose a change it’s to parliament or your mp?

Mark19735 · 12/01/2023 13:21

The easiest way would be to let home owners value their own property. Then have two taxes - one council tax based on value of property, and another capital gains tax that applies to any proceeds in excess of the owner-assessed value. If you make the CGT liability slightly higher than the council tax one, no-one would have any incentive to under-value their home, although if they really wanted to/needed to they could.

EilonwyWithRedGoldHair · 12/01/2023 13:16

Chinnn · 12/01/2023 08:20

0.5% of the zoopla value of the house every year. No system is perfect but this is better than any other I have heard of.

Zoopla is horrendously unreliable - they had valued our old house at £90,000, which was hugely overpriced. No idea how they work out their prices, but I wouldn't trust them.

EilonwyWithRedGoldHair · 12/01/2023 13:07

Its the sheer randomness of the current system that annoys me. I live in a 3 bed semi detached house in an ok area, my mum lives in a huge 5 bedroom farm house in rural area and is in the same band as me. Obviously the land included in the property skews the value, but if the land weren’t included her property is still easily worth double mine.

Yes, the randomness is annoying. I never understood why our first house was in band B and my parents house in band A. We couldn't afford to buy where I grew up, houses there were over £150,000. Their house is double fronted with a (small) front garden, three bedrooms, has a separate dining room. The house we bought was technically three bedroom, but only had one reception room downstairs and a downstairs bathroom, and no front garden, in an area that was generally cheaper.

Believeitornot · 12/01/2023 12:38

That’s why you have bodies like the Audit Commission to keep a check on things.

Not giving them money means you have less services.

MyMilkshakeScaresAllTheBoys · 12/01/2023 11:03

@PuzzleMonster

It varies a lot by state but as much as Americans like to think they pay less, once you factor in all the extras levied on top it isn't any less really, sometimes it's more for often terrible services and schools.

My point was property taxes weren't comparable, are very expensive, unequal and not something most people would realistically want to see over here.

PuzzleMonster · 12/01/2023 10:04

Chinnn · 12/01/2023 08:20

0.5% of the zoopla value of the house every year. No system is perfect but this is better than any other I have heard of.

No offence but that's a really bad idea and betrays a huge lack of understanding of economics and demographics.

PuzzleMonster · 12/01/2023 10:02

MyMilkshakeScaresAllTheBoys · 12/01/2023 05:02

US/UK property and council tax payer here. My UK council tax just went up this year as my partner finished his course. Kind of them to give those discounts.

For my pokey house in the US in a northern (midwestern) city on 1/16 of an acre, the property tax was $5400 this year! My parents were over 6k before they went to the country side. And what people pay in the east like NJ would make your eyes water- think 8k. Snow plowing doesn't help those in the northern states either!

The US system also funds the schools which makes for massive systemic inequality.

So like most things, I wouldn't be recommending the US version, OP!

Is it really comparable though? No expert but I thought in the US income taxes and national taxes were much lower and state/ local taxes are higher because much more is devolved, with it being a federation?

Newtrick · 12/01/2023 09:54

Surely it also depends on what the local housing stock looks like? There's only so much you can control of how big your property is.

I currently live in an area that is full of older big properties so they are mostly converted into flats which would work for single people in your scheme.

However I used to live somewhere where flats were rare, and the available housing in the area was predominately 50s semis which werent big enough to create maisonettes out but would be expensive if taxed per sq ft. There simply weren't smaller housing alternatives available eg you wouldn't be finding many properties that only had one single bedroom, most properties will have a double bedroom if you need it or not

I also hate the idea that it consigns single people to the ideas of things like studios.
There is a certain amount of basic sq ft that in order to have a basic quality of life.
For example if my partner moved out, I'd still need the same size kitchen and bathroom, same size living area, preferably with some space for a table to eat at. The storage needed for food, spare bedding, hoovers, gardening supplies wouldn't change.

Having been someone that's lived in studio flats and new build "starter housing", I don't think encouraging creating lots of small housing is right. I can't explain to you how shit it is to have small amounts of space. I've lived in places which have one cupboard to store all your food in (meaning you spend more as you can't buy anything in quantity), limited food prep space then limited space to cook it let alone then have a table to eat it at. It made getting proper nutrition really hard because it was geared's towards people maybe cooking a microwave meal or a pot noodle.

The starter home I lived in was 2 bedroom but had been built in a tiny foot print. As a two bed house you would assume it was a family home, and without dimensions or scale it really looked like it. However the house was designed with zero storage. No loft, and not a single cupboard, nook or cranny. A really good example of this was our hoover. The space design meant there was nowhere in the halls to leave them (too narrow), no cupboard, no under the stairs space (formed the key part of the living room) and had to live in our spare room. Our bedroom had an ensuite but wasn't wide enough to fit a double bed and any form of wardrobe in so we had one chest of drawers. The loft space was very limited height so more eves. The kitchen had 3 single cupboards total and an under sink cupboard. It was 100% designed for you to have to use the 2nd room as storage.

People who haven't lived in the basic new build layout really struggle to grasp just how unsuitable that layout is, how few straight walls you have for furniture etc. If you live in an older property then there's often so much more potential built in. I remember my parents laughing at the fact our spare room had so much in, until we pointed out that it contained everything they had in a loft, garage, airing cupboard, multiple kitchen cupboards, wardrobes, under stairs cupboards and any other cupboard they had

We need to be creating appropriate new housing that's both affordable but also practical and works longer term for people. For the love of God it needs to include cupboard space!

Dotjones · 12/01/2023 09:21

There should only be two taxes that apply to all individuals, income tax and wealth tax. Scrap VAT, council tax, death tax and NI. Instead levy an income tax that scales up aggressively as people pass the average earnings point and a wealth tax that targets savings, pensions (especially defined benefit schemes) and investments.

One of the most unfair things about the current system is that my income gets taxed, then I am charged VAT on things that are not luxuries, my taxed income has to pay my council tax and when I die anything I own will be taxed once again.

Mark19735 · 12/01/2023 09:14

I've no objection to that. But I've also not seen too many people arguing this kind of logic actually sweeping the streets, picking litter, caring for the elderly, educating kids ...

JonahAndTheSnail · 12/01/2023 09:05

Local councils are just as likely as Government to be corrupt and have proven themselves to be more than capable of spaffing tax monies up the wall, so I'd prefer to hand as little money over to them as possible.

Chinnn · 12/01/2023 08:20

0.5% of the zoopla value of the house every year. No system is perfect but this is better than any other I have heard of.

Penguinsaregreat · 12/01/2023 08:13

It works where my family live. I don’t see rubbish strewn along the streets and they don’t have door to door waste collections.
Fly tipping exists now in the UK.
Its about pride and respect. Sone people have it others don’t. Sone people are scruffy even with all the help in the world.

AreOttersJustWetCats · 12/01/2023 06:56

Penguinsaregreat · 11/01/2023 22:56

You will never please everyone.
Perhaps councils should offer far fewer free services. Perhaps people should pay for what they need/use.
Then you will have the parents of children who get free services jumping up and down crying “That’s not fair!”
The families of all those whose parents receive care which for by the tax payer crying too.
You can’t one the one hand say people should pay for services such as transport, oh but I don’t want to pay for the transport the council provides to take my child to and from school.
I would be quite happy to see a reduction in my council tax and services reduced. I doubt after much consideration everyone would though. You will never get around the fact that some people take far more from the system than they put into it.
Id be happy not to have my bins emptied in return for a reduction in council tax. I would quite happily take all my rubbish to a collection point. However I can guarantee that those who don’t pay as much tax as I do would be jumping up and down complaining, dating his the council should be paying to empty their bins and why should they have to physically take it somewhere.

Id be happy not to have my bins emptied in return for a reduction in council tax. I would quite happily take all my rubbish to a collection point.

You haven't thought that through. Firstly, it wouldn't save much if anything. The council would still need to do daily collections and process the waste. Not everyone has a car, so there would need to be lots and lots of collection points, within walking distance of people's homes.

Also, it would make it significantly harder for the elderly or non able bodied to have their rubbish collected at all.

And it would lead to a totally predictable increase in fly tipping because some people couldn't be bothered.

It's a classic example of someone only thinking about what works for them. Councils aren't about providing the optimum level of service that you require, they are there to provide the services the whole community requires. And bin collection is high on the list.

MyMilkshakeScaresAllTheBoys · 12/01/2023 05:02

US/UK property and council tax payer here. My UK council tax just went up this year as my partner finished his course. Kind of them to give those discounts.

For my pokey house in the US in a northern (midwestern) city on 1/16 of an acre, the property tax was $5400 this year! My parents were over 6k before they went to the country side. And what people pay in the east like NJ would make your eyes water- think 8k. Snow plowing doesn't help those in the northern states either!

The US system also funds the schools which makes for massive systemic inequality.

So like most things, I wouldn't be recommending the US version, OP!

Itsnotalternateuniverses · 12/01/2023 02:23

Not sure if your ides would work but council tax does need to be changed. We used to live in a flat above a shop. We moved in to a far larger semi detached property with cellars: both are band A.

PuzzleMonster · 12/01/2023 00:33

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Yep.

PuzzleMonster · 12/01/2023 00:33

BungleandGeorge · 11/01/2023 23:19

No it needs to be based on how many services you receive and ability to pay. Council tax is grossly unfair and your method is no improvement! A single person living in a village in a property worth 400k shouldn’t have to pay more than a family of 4 working adults in a 3 bedroom flat in a city worth 3 million. No, that isn’t fair. London has some of the lowest council tax rates yet some of the best facilities and highest earnings and capital.

Again, no it doesn't when you look at the type of property being taxed, not its resale value (which is irrelevant in terms of proportion of Council services used). But yes a better approximation for services used is number of occupants, not property size. But property size would make far more sense than property value. A Band D property in London (tiny flat) is not comparable to a Band D property in a rural area (huge house). The latter may have many occupants therefore use many services. The former can only house one or two people. Far easier administratively though and fairer to simply divide up the budget needed for local services by the number of local residents and charge that.

PuzzleMonster · 12/01/2023 00:29

JenniferBooth · 11/01/2023 23:19

Tenants pay council tax based on the value of a property they dont own

Because it's a tax for local services that they use. This is why it's ridiculous that it's linked to the type of property. It should be a tax per resident of each local authority area.

Mark19735 · 12/01/2023 00:29

The whole point is that people aren't expected to pay the same for the services a government or local authority provides because people don't have the same capacity to pay.

If you base the calculation for an individual's liability for taxation on X, then people with a lot of X will pay more tax than people with less of X. It doesn't matter what X is. Income, Transactions, Land Value ... there will always be people who have more of it that others, who will be required to contribute more than others owing to that imbalance. No method for choosing X is inherently fair or just - they each disadvantage different groups, that's all.

So the real challenge is ... what criterion for X is the most efficient and effective way of collecting tax? Not the fairest ... the one with the lowest costs of collection. That is why income and transactions have historically been prioritised ... because there is a cash transaction occurring at the point of taxation. That's why employers deduct PAYE and NI ... because they already have their wallets open each time they run the payroll. It's harder to avoid.

Taxing wealth, or land, is fraught with problems - the main one being that there is not necessarily any cash on hand to settle the tax bill when it falls due. But, there is a bigger social problem - becoming ever more acute in an increasingly unequal society - which is that all the wealth is concentrated in the hands of a much smaller segment, and those people are not using their wealth to generate anything productive for the economy (think of all those old folk in their empty-nest five bed houses that their kids moved out of 20 years ago ... and are now trying to raise their own families in 2-bed rentals ... )

Whether we like it or not, there aren't enough workers earning high enough wages to support government expenditure through income taxes, and there aren't enough high value transactions to support it through VAT, so a greater share is going to have to come from taxes on assets. More council tax, more inheritance tax, new wealth taxes and so on. Or the government stops spending quite so much ... but those cuts will have to be borne by the unproductive parts of society. It would make sense to start with the old - we could cut NHS waiting times by 80% if we enabled one-way visits like we do at the veterinarians.

CrocodilesCry · 12/01/2023 00:28

PuzzleMonster · 12/01/2023 00:18

Band D properties in different areas are not remotely comparable: in one place it is a small flat, in another a large house, so you are comparing apples and pears.

They're based on valuations made in 1991. Some of the London boroughs are less than half the cost of other areas regardless of band. It's really not apples and pears at all.