Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think DC will be safer at nursery than with a nanny?

117 replies

VegMam · 11/01/2023 14:38

We're currently debating whether to send our 12 month old DC to nursery, or to hire a nanny. I can see some benefits of a nanny over nursery, however, I worry that DC will be less safe with a nanny. For example if the nanny takes DC to the park, what if the nanny doesn't watch DC closely and DC runs off, same with crossing the road etc. Or what if the nanny is distracted and DC picks up choking hazards. I think this worry is exacerbated by MIL telling me she can always tell which ones are parents and which are nannies at the park as the nannies are the ones playing on their phones / chatting rather than interacting with / watching the kids.

In some ways nursery feels like a more controlled and therefore safer environment.

YABU - the nanny is a professional and will take good care of the child.
YANBU - a nanny is an unknown quantity looking after DC in 'the wild' where anything can happen

OP posts:
ohyouknowwhatshername · 11/01/2023 17:42

Crispyturtle · 11/01/2023 16:50

Meh I’m a parent and I play on my phone and ignore my kids plenty

😄

Willyoujustbequiet · 11/01/2023 17:37

Deaths at nurseries seem to have made the papers in recent years so on balance you I'd say safer with a nanny.

purpledalmation · 11/01/2023 17:15

Surely 1to1 is a safer option

CakeCrumbs44 · 11/01/2023 17:00

A nanny usually looks after kids from one family, so one to one if you have an only child. Compared to ratios of 1:4 for 2 year olds in a nursery setting, I would say it's less likely to be an accident.

However if you mean a childminder, who follows the same ratios as a nursery and looks after kids from multiple households, then yes I would agree with your concern. I've had contact with lots of childminders at toddlers groups etc. Some are fantastic but some are a bit lax.

MajorCarolDanvers · 11/01/2023 16:56

BeatriceBatchelor · 11/01/2023 15:09

I wouldn't put a child under 2 in a nursery.

There's always one 🤦‍♀️

MajorCarolDanvers · 11/01/2023 16:56

Visit 3 nurseries, 3 child minders and speak to 3 nannies.

You will know what you want and like after doing this.

It's really a personal preference

justasking111 · 11/01/2023 16:51

Soft play I've seen mothers switch off and let children get on with it because they're chatting I've had to rescue a few as a grandparent.

Crispyturtle · 11/01/2023 16:50

Meh I’m a parent and I play on my phone and ignore my kids plenty

Whitewolf2 · 11/01/2023 16:33

I chose nursery over nanny/childminder for the reasons you mention. I was once at a soft play with my children and the nannies couldn’t have cared less about the children they were looking after! They were just out for a chat together.

Nurseries are not immune to hiring uncaring staff, but at least staff are visible to others much of the time and stay in the same environment with the ethos and facilities you can see when you do visits. I used to do pick ups at various times due to work and so did other parents so it felt like you got a brief view of the care given during the day etc.

PlanBea · 11/01/2023 16:25

When are you looking to start the childcare? I had to have my DS' name down on the waiting list for his nursery before he was even born to guarantee him a place. My friend had to have grandparents step in for a few months as they left it too late (at 3 months old for a space at 11 months)!

XelaM · 11/01/2023 16:23

Nanny is always safer than nursey because of the 1:1 care.

Caldecot · 11/01/2023 16:21

BeatriceBatchelor · 11/01/2023 15:09

I wouldn't put a child under 2 in a nursery.

🙄

EndlessRain1 · 11/01/2023 16:09

ChildminderMum · 11/01/2023 15:57

The big benefit of a nanny over nursery is that you are choosing and supervising the person actually caring for your child - you will have met them, can spend some time with them before you hand over, will have personally looked at their qualifications, criminal record check, spoken to their references. And can observe what they are like with your child.

With a nursery, it's kind of luck if you get carers who are sensible and experienced or total idiots you wouldn't leave a goldfish with - you don't have any control over who is actually with your child, how often staff change and so on. You might not even ever meet or know the names of the people caring for your child.

The other thing someone else touched on is emotional security vs physical security. Yes, in a nursery your child might stay in the same safe room every day with multiple adults and be physically safer than they would be with one person who they love but who takes them to parks, soft plays and libraries full of risks. But it terms of development and attachment, one reliable carer is preferable from the baby's point of view.

Good nurseries will have key workers dedicated to children. Our DD initially had a key worker entirely to herself which was amazing, and later one she shared with a couple of other children. She definitely had "her" person.

Similar for DS, although he didn't have the one to one. And they even changed his first his key worker to a lady he preferred/ seem to bond with better when he didn't seem happy with the original one. He consistently was the one who I handed him to on drop off, that gave him back at the end of the day, and who appeared in most of his photos/ jounral entries.

So of course it's not the same as only one person looking after the baby/ child, but good nurseries are of course aware of child development and wellbeing and take account of this sort of thing.

mynameiscalypso · 11/01/2023 16:00

I think there are many reasons for choosing either depending on your options and circumstances but I don't think physical safety is a benefit of a nanny to me; I would say it's the reverse. My DS' nurse go to the park/playground 3 or 4 times a week. I'm much more wary of a a couple of members of staff supervising a group of overexcited toddlers than I would be if I knew DS was there with a nanny.

ChildminderMum · 11/01/2023 15:57

The big benefit of a nanny over nursery is that you are choosing and supervising the person actually caring for your child - you will have met them, can spend some time with them before you hand over, will have personally looked at their qualifications, criminal record check, spoken to their references. And can observe what they are like with your child.

With a nursery, it's kind of luck if you get carers who are sensible and experienced or total idiots you wouldn't leave a goldfish with - you don't have any control over who is actually with your child, how often staff change and so on. You might not even ever meet or know the names of the people caring for your child.

The other thing someone else touched on is emotional security vs physical security. Yes, in a nursery your child might stay in the same safe room every day with multiple adults and be physically safer than they would be with one person who they love but who takes them to parks, soft plays and libraries full of risks. But it terms of development and attachment, one reliable carer is preferable from the baby's point of view.

Susanthehappytrottingelf · 11/01/2023 15:43

A lot of this is really variable depending on your area - the nursery we used had 7 staff members who had all been there for several years and most had or had had children in the nursery themselves, they also had one apprentice. I didn't visit any that had only very young staff but I am sure that's the case in some areas

NotRainingToday · 11/01/2023 15:40

MrsTerryPratchett · 11/01/2023 15:33

she can always tell which ones are parents and which are nannies at the park as the nannies are the ones playing on their phones / chatting rather than interacting with / watching the kids.

This is pure bollocks.

Yes, and confirmation bias! Guardian playing on phone = nanny! I bet she didn't ask anyone if they were the parent or the nanny.

Flittingaboutagain · 11/01/2023 15:40

Private day Nurseries where i live are staffed predominantly with very young staff, often teenagers. They run at absolute max ratios all the time.

I would take an experienced nanny over a nursery every single day of the week.

^ same. Went to look round two and both had 18-20 year olds looking after the little ones with a more experienced worker in the office doing paperwork.

BertieBotts · 11/01/2023 15:37

MilkyYay · 11/01/2023 15:03

. I didn’t want my baby out and about on the school run etc

This is such a common view, i always find it interesting as i actively wanted my child out and about doing normal things including school runs

Me too.

Thepeopleversuswork · 11/01/2023 15:37

Well for starters I would stop listening to your MIL. She is just parroting a load of hoary old bigotry about childcare.

I agree with a PP I don’t think it’s helpful to think of it in binary terms: nursery v nannies. There are brilliant nurseries and crap nannies and vice versa. It depends on the individual/setting. Obviously there are strengths and weaknesses of both, not to mention budget concerns. I would look at as many options as you can and then take a view.

Stompythedinosaur · 11/01/2023 15:36

The uncomfortable truth is that you cannot absolutely guarantee a child's safety in any setting. But both a nursery and nanny will take good care of your dc.

You seem very focused on physical safety over the benefit in terms of emotional development of having a single dedicated caregiver. I couldn't have afforded a nanny, but I absolutely would have chosen one for this reason if I could.

MrsTerryPratchett · 11/01/2023 15:33

she can always tell which ones are parents and which are nannies at the park as the nannies are the ones playing on their phones / chatting rather than interacting with / watching the kids.

This is pure bollocks.

MogTheForgetableCat · 11/01/2023 15:32

I don't think it's helpful to talk about the options in abstract. As above, a good nanny is better than a bad nursery and vice versa. I was a bit more inclined to use a child minder when I first started looking but the ones I properly checked out weren't good options and I loved a couple of the nurseries I saw so it's good to be open minded.

For me, I want my DCs to have as much fun as possible and their time being focused on them doing activities they like. This happens for the whole day in nursery, but I wouldn't count doing school runs etc (especially in a car) as fulfilling that with a childminder.

EndlessRain1 · 11/01/2023 15:31

tonystarksrighthand · 11/01/2023 15:11

I felt exactly the same.

What's wrong with normal life activities!?

Our Nanny used to take DC everywhere with her!

Depends. A walk to school, stop at the park, maybe go to the shop, all good life experiences. Being sat in a buggy for hours while the CM/ nanny has coffee with her friends, or in a car seat while she runs errands, not so great.

Stopandlook · 11/01/2023 15:30

tonystarksrighthand · 11/01/2023 15:11

I felt exactly the same.

What's wrong with normal life activities!?

Our Nanny used to take DC everywhere with her!

Nothing is wrong with it - I did say it was PFB syndrome.

my third newborn had to do the school run 3X a day with me from a month old as I had one in preschool and one in reception. He survived.