Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think DC will be safer at nursery than with a nanny?

117 replies

VegMam · 11/01/2023 14:38

We're currently debating whether to send our 12 month old DC to nursery, or to hire a nanny. I can see some benefits of a nanny over nursery, however, I worry that DC will be less safe with a nanny. For example if the nanny takes DC to the park, what if the nanny doesn't watch DC closely and DC runs off, same with crossing the road etc. Or what if the nanny is distracted and DC picks up choking hazards. I think this worry is exacerbated by MIL telling me she can always tell which ones are parents and which are nannies at the park as the nannies are the ones playing on their phones / chatting rather than interacting with / watching the kids.

In some ways nursery feels like a more controlled and therefore safer environment.

YABU - the nanny is a professional and will take good care of the child.
YANBU - a nanny is an unknown quantity looking after DC in 'the wild' where anything can happen

OP posts:
jannier · 11/01/2023 20:55

Go by recommendations of all setting types then make a shortlist and visit or interview a few judge how things seem for the children how warm and welcoming the staff/individual is look at how confident the children are to speak and approach the adults are any being left out or overlooked? Do individuals show interest in your child and your parenting look at references and training ( nannies and childminders have these) Ofsted reports will show any complaints even those found to be malicious. Talk to existing parents and go by what you feel is the best fit.

SnackyOnassis · 11/01/2023 20:46

Your MIL's logic is fundamentally flawed unless she's going around the playground asking every guardian on their phone or not about their relationship to the child they're with - there's no evidence to back up what she's concluded from what she's seeing.
And if she is going around the playground interviewing people, I would be even less inclined to take a steer from her, because that would be batshit.

You won't get anywhere comparing averages and anecdotes, OP, what you need to be assessing is specifics - the nursery you would be most likely to use and the nanny you would use. Compare both against a neutral set of your requirements like cost, sickness policy, staff holidays, communication and updates, your expectations of the stimulus and learning you want for your child, etc etc. Only then will you be able to make an informed decision.

Surgarblossom · 11/01/2023 20:38

BeatriceBatchelor · 11/01/2023 15:09

I wouldn't put a child under 2 in a nursery.

Tut!!

cansu · 11/01/2023 20:27

Like others have said, you can get poor nannies and poor nurseries. If I had the choice I would absolutely go for a nanny. Your child will get more attention 1 :1 and your life will be so much easier. No rushing around to drop off or pick up. You will have much more input into the daily routine and get loads of feedback.

jannier · 11/01/2023 20:26

Somethingsnappy · 11/01/2023 20:23

@jannier I haven't seen anything in the news about a nursery this week. What's happened?

1 year old Child died whilst napping 6 staff members and managers arrested.

mathanxiety · 11/01/2023 20:26

There's more to baby care than just safety. Personal relationships are extremely important. Having someone talk and sing to your baby and respond quickly to cues is the way human babies are designed. Care from just one person fulfills those needs.

You can focus a nanny on safety if you provide an incident log for him or her to fill out, as well as a nappy and sleep log.

Somethingsnappy · 11/01/2023 20:23

@jannier I haven't seen anything in the news about a nursery this week. What's happened?

jannier · 11/01/2023 20:23

CakeCrumbs44 · 11/01/2023 17:00

A nanny usually looks after kids from one family, so one to one if you have an only child. Compared to ratios of 1:4 for 2 year olds in a nursery setting, I would say it's less likely to be an accident.

However if you mean a childminder, who follows the same ratios as a nursery and looks after kids from multiple households, then yes I would agree with your concern. I've had contact with lots of childminders at toddlers groups etc. Some are fantastic but some are a bit lax.

Childminder ratios are not 1 to 4 it's normally 1 to 3 and unlike a nursery which includes office staff the ratio is actually working with not available on the premises. You also get childminders working with others but the ratio is still 1 to 3.

OCDmama · 11/01/2023 20:20

We have a childminder who is excellent. I wouldn't want my daughter at a nursery before she's 3. The childminder's home is spotless and it's been the greatest environment for our girl.

jannier · 11/01/2023 20:17

Newusername3kidss · 11/01/2023 15:06

Personally I would consider a nanny if they were only looking after your child, but not a childminder. There’s a lot who go to a play centre I go to weekly and honestly half the time they haven’t the vaguest idea where the kids are and babies are generally left in the prams whilst they have coffee and chat with other child minders. This is an extreme example I know but basically they are at liberty to do / go where they like with the baby. Also if they are unwell you are screwed as you will have to take time off work. With nurseries they have to follow such strict guidelines and follow early years programmes with the activities they do and obviously it doesn’t matter if your key worker is ever ill or on holiday as they are always appropriately staffed.

Childminders have to follow the same guidelines as nurseries. Have you seen the news this week I think that is one of many cases proving they are not safe just because there is more staff.
How do you know these childminders are registered childminders or unaware where the children are? You don't have to be following 3 year olds around to know exactly where they are. How do you know it's not a nap time?

Hangupsrus · 11/01/2023 20:09

I work in a nursery. I'd choose the nanny. I had child minder for dc3 and regret putting my first dc in a nursery.

Getinajollymood · 11/01/2023 20:03

It’s all young girls at DS’s nursery, but I’m fine with that. They are lovely, gentle and caring and that’s what is important. I am sure most Nannies and CMs are too. I’m sure it makes a nice change for DS to be around younger adults, I was 40 when I had him!

Ginsloth · 11/01/2023 19:56

We tried a nursery and changed to a childminder and I’m so glad we did.
The nursery, on our pre-admission visits seemed great, but once our son started I saw lots of things I didn’t like. The baby room was ran by mostly late teens, who I’m sure were doing their best but really seemed to lack common sense. There were issues that would have been easily resolved with a bit of thought or communication but weren’t. The children all had a “key worker” but were looked after by anyone in their room. Often this meant they were greeted into nursery by someone they weren’t familiar with, making drop offs any settling in more upsetting than it needed to be. All round I just found it a bit chaotic and didn’t feel like there was anyone taking personal responsibility for the care of my child.
Our childminder on the other hand is absolutely fantastic. She describes her role as providing a home-from-home and that’s exactly what it is. She’s very honest and I trust her more than I ever did the nursery workers. Our son has a really lovely relationship with her. She’s a mum herself and also an early years teacher which is great.
From my experience and friends’, I think that a nursery is ok once they get to 3, any younger than that and I think they benefit from having a single care giver (besides their family obviously).

Bunnycat101 · 11/01/2023 19:40

So much is individual dependent. A few years ago our nursery was struggling as the manager was on sick leave and things were falling through the cracks. A new manager and room leaders were brought in and it was amazing. The nursery manager is probably critical in what the experience will be like. Similarly, with nannies there will be brilliant ones and less good ones but it is harder to get a feel for what is going on during the day. I’ve been put off childminders by some of the ones I saw at activities but also well aware there will be some amazing childminders too.

GreenManalishi · 11/01/2023 19:11

Scenes in*

GreenManalishi · 11/01/2023 19:11

Having seen some absolute senes on nurseries I would say nanny but bad nanny is going to be as bad as a bad nursery and vice versa.

As with life general there are no guarantees and moreover, no perfect option, only compromise that you're willing to make.

NuffSaidSam · 11/01/2023 19:03

ChildminderMum · 11/01/2023 15:57

The big benefit of a nanny over nursery is that you are choosing and supervising the person actually caring for your child - you will have met them, can spend some time with them before you hand over, will have personally looked at their qualifications, criminal record check, spoken to their references. And can observe what they are like with your child.

With a nursery, it's kind of luck if you get carers who are sensible and experienced or total idiots you wouldn't leave a goldfish with - you don't have any control over who is actually with your child, how often staff change and so on. You might not even ever meet or know the names of the people caring for your child.

The other thing someone else touched on is emotional security vs physical security. Yes, in a nursery your child might stay in the same safe room every day with multiple adults and be physically safer than they would be with one person who they love but who takes them to parks, soft plays and libraries full of risks. But it terms of development and attachment, one reliable carer is preferable from the baby's point of view.

This is the crux of the issue.

There are good and bad nannies, good and bad nurseries. The key thing though is that it's easier to sort the good/bad nannies because you're personally interviewing them, spending time with them, checking their qualifications and references, asking the specific questions that are important to you. With a nursery you're trusting management to do that. Bear in mind that the nursery industry is suffering a staffing and funding crisis, can you guarantee they're not cutting corners when it comes to staff? I don't think so.

tenbob · 11/01/2023 18:50

justasking111 · 11/01/2023 15:03

Well they won't catch every bug going with a nanny so you won't be off work or called back because of illness.

This was the deciding factor for me…

Nannies still work if your children are ill. Nannies don’t knock off if they have a bad nappy.

For me, the risk of being phoned during the working day to collect DC and then having to keep them at home for 2 days was too much.

In 5+ years of having a nanny, we’ve never had to leave work to come home, and on the rare occasions they’ve been ill, we have a reciprocal arrangement with another family for their nanny to take our DC, and then our nanny covers if theirs is sick

NurseryNurse10 · 11/01/2023 18:43

As someone who does supply nursery nursing I would say a nanny everytime.

beefybasso · 11/01/2023 18:41

I hired a nanny but checked that she had first aid, I paid for her to go on an annual first aid update too, I paid any subscriptions she thought benefitted my dc.

Many many people came up to me over the years to tell me what a wonderful caring nanny I had, sometimes I didn't even know them but our nanny had made friends with them and their babies.

When my dc was sick my nanny cared for them really well. My dc didn't have to wait for me to come and collect them etc. I didn't have to take a day off, whereas at a nursery I'd be expected to. She took them to any baby clubs going, this also helped me keep a link with friends I'd made on maternity leave. My dc loved their nanny so much.

My friends dc went to nursery and caught every bug going over and over and was constantly off sick which was hard for my friends job. Then when their dc came home with bite marks friend was told there was only so much nursery could do to stop it happening. That was at an outstanding nursery. My baby offered stability no nursery could imo.

One to one care vs a ratio? No way. Unless you've got the wrong person I doubt a one to one nanny would be worse than a nursery.

I still send our old nanny a present 6 years since she last worked for us! Nursery can be amazing btw but I truly believe one to one is better.

NuffSaidSam · 11/01/2023 18:34

Thereisnolight · 11/01/2023 17:52

Nursery all the way for me.
No one to let you know if the nanny is rubbish or even abusive.

Your child will let you know. It's easy enough to see a baby delighted.
to see their loving nanny and a child who is scared/wary/unhappy to be left with their nanny.

Also, nannies are out in the world a lot of the time so plenty of people to keep an eye. Not like nurseries where it's all behind closed doors.

CremeEggsForBreakfast · 11/01/2023 18:04

As a nanny I'm mildly offended by the "the nannies are the ones on their phones" stereotype. Plenty of parents are on their phones or ignoring the children and chatting to their friends. Sure there are nannies who do the same but the majority of nannies and childminders I've met have genuinely loved their jobs and the company of the children and given them their full attention.

I've read far more horror stories about nurseries than I have nannies but I'd still send my child to all the nurseries that I've had interactions with.

It's entirely about the style of care you'd like than which is "safer".

Thereisnolight · 11/01/2023 17:52

Nursery all the way for me.
No one to let you know if the nanny is rubbish or even abusive.

VincaBlue · 11/01/2023 17:49

Not sure how to vote because it all depends on the quality of the nanny or nursery. A friend used a great nanny and there are great nurseries or you sometimes read about ones like this

www-theoldhamtimes-co-uk.cdn.ampproject.org/v/s/www.theoldhamtimes.co.uk/news/23236020.amp/?amp_gsa=1&amp_js_v=a9&usqp=mq331AQIKAGwASCAAgM%3D#amp_tf=From%20%251%24s&aoh=16733760583834&csi=0&referrer=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.google.com&ampshare=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.theoldhamtimes.co.uk%2Fnews%2F23236020.chaotic-middleton-nursery-rated-inadequate-ofsted%2F

The secret is to do thorough research, although it's not always easy to know what's going on when you're not there. Another friend used a nursery with cctv you could log into in the US! My preference would be a nanny for more of a home from home experience and being able to go out and about every day

simonthedog · 11/01/2023 17:46

My concern was always that there is no one to whistle-blow a nanny if there are any safety issues.