Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think DC will be safer at nursery than with a nanny?

117 replies

VegMam · 11/01/2023 14:38

We're currently debating whether to send our 12 month old DC to nursery, or to hire a nanny. I can see some benefits of a nanny over nursery, however, I worry that DC will be less safe with a nanny. For example if the nanny takes DC to the park, what if the nanny doesn't watch DC closely and DC runs off, same with crossing the road etc. Or what if the nanny is distracted and DC picks up choking hazards. I think this worry is exacerbated by MIL telling me she can always tell which ones are parents and which are nannies at the park as the nannies are the ones playing on their phones / chatting rather than interacting with / watching the kids.

In some ways nursery feels like a more controlled and therefore safer environment.

YABU - the nanny is a professional and will take good care of the child.
YANBU - a nanny is an unknown quantity looking after DC in 'the wild' where anything can happen

OP posts:
SherbetDips · 12/01/2023 06:29

I’m a nanny and I’m very safety conscious. I’ve had over 25 years experience keeping babies and toddlers safe.

we’re human of course and accidents happens as they do with parents.

Sux2buthen · 12/01/2023 06:25

justasking111 · 11/01/2023 15:03

Well they won't catch every bug going with a nanny so you won't be off work or called back because of illness.

Yes it will wait until school starts instead. This is not preventable 🤣

RP2211 · 12/01/2023 06:12

Sillyheadoooooo · 11/01/2023 21:57

The child will be so much safer and better looked after with a trusted nanny or childminder.
Nurseries cannot get staff, they are desperate so generally will hire and old person who has completed an online level 2 qualification weather they want to work with kids or not. Staff turnover is high, child never gets to develop a bond with their key workers yada yada.
Workers not really aware and tested on the EYFS like a childminder/ nanny working for ofsted is… There are exceptions obviously but most nurseries are practically at crisis point, sending kids home any hint of illness to keep to legal ratios.

Expert knowledge here? Horrific advice.

Fabfam · 12/01/2023 01:08

I personally would send to nursery. More sociable ,and more flexible if one person off sick and even subconsciously every worker is auditing the other workers so child is safer .

B1rds · 12/01/2023 01:02

It depends. You get good and bad versions of each

bellamountain · 12/01/2023 00:11

I had the same worries so put my first child in a nursery (aka daycare which is what they really are). However, sometimes I'd turn up and there was some random person I'd never met handing my child over to me. There were too many staff members coming and going and it didn't sit right with me.

The nappy rashes were horrendous. Switching to a childminder was the best thing. Your child will actually experience real life with a Nanny more akin to the life they have with you.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 11/01/2023 23:59

autumnnightsaredrawingin · 11/01/2023 15:24

Hmmm. I have been a nanny, had a nanny, worked in a nursery and sent one of my children to a day care nursery.

it TOTALLY depends on the nanny and nursery. Many day nurseries really aren’t that great. Having lots of people might make it seem ‘safer’ but it’s not always the case. Good nannies are great. Good nurseries are great. Bad nurseries are awful, bad nannies are awful.

No easy solution. On balance, for a child under 2 I’d go for a nanny and for children over 2 and a half/3 ish, IF money were no object (haha!) and I was working I’d go for a nanny plus a part time nursery school (IMO these are totally different to day nursery and much better). Appreciate that’s a very expensive way of doing things although obviously 15 hour funding does kick in after 3.

This is basically what I wanted to say!

We couldn’t afford a nanny when mine were little but I would would have preferred it. Id have preferred really good nanny to a nursery that is!

A good nursery is a great option too though. Just be really careful with the one you choose - in the same way you’re careful with recruiting a nanny - or anyone to do an important job. Don’t be worried about moving your child if they don’t seem happy or if you have concerns though. I moved my Dd when she was nearly 3 to a nursery that was much more of a pain to get to as I was worried the first nursery didn’t give them enough outdoor time or interesting activities- and it was the best decision. She loved the second nursery having never really settled at the first.

evemillbank · 11/01/2023 23:54

I feel there is safety in numbers which is why I chose nursery over nanny

Cherryblossoms85 · 11/01/2023 23:53

Just pick the right nanny. I never doubted the choice at all and I felt very confident that she would look after my child well. They still really miss her and talk about her. When I was working overseas a lot, they would get a bit mixed up and call her mummy. You'll never get that with a nursery.

jannier · 11/01/2023 23:51

All studies show a baby is best with a secure consistent carer hence the key worker was put forward to try to fill the gap between a small setting and a big one. Unfortunately many nurseries do not use a key worker in the way it is intended. They should be the main person working with a child ...play, nappy, feeding, greeting and handing to parent but in most nurseries this is not how they are used and it's just paperwork. This makes it harder to settle and a less secure child. Unfortunately too some parents don't want their child to bond with others (understandably it's tough handing baby to someone else).

jannier · 11/01/2023 23:45

Wishawisha · 11/01/2023 21:03

My first really hated (HATED!) both the car seat and the pram, so this was honestly the main reason for me to avoid a childminder because at least at a nursery that wasn’t a problem.
Second child wasn’t as bad in the pram but still didn’t enjoy it at all, which I’m assuming is pretty common and maybe a reason a lot of parents don’t really want their children on the school run?

So what did you do, never go out? Lots of babies hate being put down if they are used to being held so pushchair, car seat, playmat or floor are all a no but they still need fresh air. Did the nursery have staff carrying them around a yard all day?
People object to school runs because they think the child gets nothing from it and is just being dragged out when actually they are learning .....colours, numbers, birds, shapes, road safety games, the school environment it can be a very positive experience

smilingthroughgrittedteeth · 11/01/2023 22:09

Your MIL is wrong
I was a nanny before i had my children and i can hand on heart say i was a great nanny, I was never on my phone at the park i was always attentive and playing with the children in my care. Now as a mum of 3 if we go to the park (which is rare as i hate it) I can be found sat on a bench looking at my phone or reading a book whilst they amuse themselves.

Suedomin · 11/01/2023 22:05

This is such a common view, i always find it interesting as i actively wanted my child out and about doing normal things including school runs
Me too personally I think it's much better for them than being in a nursery all day.

Sillyheadoooooo · 11/01/2023 21:57

The child will be so much safer and better looked after with a trusted nanny or childminder.
Nurseries cannot get staff, they are desperate so generally will hire and old person who has completed an online level 2 qualification weather they want to work with kids or not. Staff turnover is high, child never gets to develop a bond with their key workers yada yada.
Workers not really aware and tested on the EYFS like a childminder/ nanny working for ofsted is… There are exceptions obviously but most nurseries are practically at crisis point, sending kids home any hint of illness to keep to legal ratios.

thirdtimeluckyorwhat · 11/01/2023 21:52

If you use a qualified nanny with excellent previous references from parent you can speak to I would use a nanny over a nursery. They get individual care and attention taken out to lots of different places and have the comfort of their home environment too I think for a 12 month old that is far nicer than a nursery setting.

SouthLondonMum22 · 11/01/2023 21:51

I feel more comfortable with nursery over childminder (we didn't consider a nanny) for reasons several have already stated, mine will start at 12 weeks so we'll see how it goes.

SnackyOnassis · 11/01/2023 21:46

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Not much happening under your bridge tonight, then?

tenbob · 11/01/2023 21:45

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Oh fuck off

OP is looking at childcare, not listing her DC on eBay

VegMam · 11/01/2023 21:42

Lots of great advice thank you. We’ve got a nursery spot but the nursery recently extended and we feel it’s too big and just doesn’t give us a good feeling. Hence considering a nanny.

OP posts:
SpanishSalsaing · 11/01/2023 21:36

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

SpanishSalsaing · 11/01/2023 21:34

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

RP2211 · 11/01/2023 21:29

So many judgemental people on here about nurseries and they've never even had their child in one. Well aren't you lucky as some of us do not have an option other than a nursery. We had no childminders or nannies who had space for my child by where we live or by where we worked. It had to be a nursery and from 9 months old. Yes she gets colds but my god she'll have a good immune system by the time they start school. And my god they do their best by the kids. They follow the national curriculum and we get an in-depth analysis of what they've done throughout the day including meals, activities and photos. Go with what you feel most comfortable with, from my own experience, nursery is good and my child is flourishing.

RP2211 · 11/01/2023 21:22

Caldecot · 11/01/2023 16:21

🙄

Some people have no choice.

stepmad · 11/01/2023 21:09

I am a nanny my charges have all ended up in Ae due to accidents at nursery and school none with me.
My phone hardly makes an appearance all day long
Yes I do see other nannies we do chat but each nanny is another set of eyes.
Have rescued more than a few children who have got into trouble while a mum has been trying to work using the phone
The nearest park to work the nursery children are strayed to this plastic thing let loose for pictures then back in again.

Wishawisha · 11/01/2023 21:03

MilkyYay · 11/01/2023 15:03

. I didn’t want my baby out and about on the school run etc

This is such a common view, i always find it interesting as i actively wanted my child out and about doing normal things including school runs

My first really hated (HATED!) both the car seat and the pram, so this was honestly the main reason for me to avoid a childminder because at least at a nursery that wasn’t a problem.
Second child wasn’t as bad in the pram but still didn’t enjoy it at all, which I’m assuming is pretty common and maybe a reason a lot of parents don’t really want their children on the school run?

Swipe left for the next trending thread