Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

How disruptive does a child have to be to be removed from Primary School?!

262 replies

Juggletits · 11/01/2023 10:43

Ongoing saga at our primary school. One child has been hugely disruptive since day one - attacking other children (stabbing with pencils, stamping on chests, stomach punches, facial damage with nails or sports equipment amongst many others), attacking teachers, throwing chairs, upending tables and regularly trying to escape.

Last term they brought a pocket knife in to school and showed it to other children, cut his own trousers and threatened other children that he "could stab them"

There is an ever growing list of assaults and incidents against many children and the parent community is absolutely baffled as to why the child has not been removed. They clearly need serious and ongoing support and our school is not set up for a child with such a level of additional needs.

The reason from the HT is that "certain thresholds haven't been met"

Does anyone know what these thresholds are from a legal/professional point of view?

It has reached the point that parents are keeping their children out of school because they are not safe in the classroom.

Multiple emails have been sent to the school, Academy Trust, Ofsted and MARU

What more can be done? An entire school is being disrupted by one child - this cannot be right?!

OP posts:
RedToothBrush · 11/01/2023 16:32

Unfortunately parents striking/collectively not sending children just further alienates an already struggling parent/child. I agree that writing/complaining about the system, rather than the actual child, each time is the way to go and if all parents can consistently do this something will eventually be done. From experience though, it might not end well for that parent/child, but it seems to be the only way to safeguard every child

I think we've had a better response by framing it as the child being failed and at risk as well as our own rather than 'bad'.

^^
^^
^^

OhmygodDont · 11/01/2023 16:28

You need to go for the safety and safeguarding of your child from harm during the school day. Their duty of care to keep your child safe. Also the mention the fear your child has. Do all this is writing/email. Keep a paper trail. Every time an incident happens with your child another email.

Moxysright · 11/01/2023 16:27

RedToothBrush · 11/01/2023 16:23

They need specialist support though.

I am aware of the kid in my son's class and what he does. If he starts to kick off even when he's being given one to one he starts screaming and attacking staff and other children. It's a fight or flight response but he has enough emotional intelligence to also manipulate the situation.

When they were doing a test he started to kick off and was saying 'im not going to do this. I'm going to deliberately get everything wrong'. Before running around the classroom jumping on tables and then properly kicking off. Can you imagine if he did this when the others were supposed to be doing SATS?

As it is it's so disruptive there are days when I wonder how the class learn anything.

And that's before I start talking about how he's bullied other children and hurt other children

Being inclusive in this situation isn't actually including everyone. It's putting the behaviour of this child about the needs of all the other kids in the class

As I say DS being flagged for SEN too has helped because we can make an argument that they are failing to provide both a safe environment and for his learning needs.

If he was getting the support he needs then, it wouldn't be a problem but he's not. He's being failed too. But genuinely having seen on occasion three members of staff be required to deal with this one child, how can you include them in a normal school environment?

They need a quiet environment which is calm and quite not with 101 distractions and having to compete with others for attention. It's not the right environment for their needs - that's the point. The fact they end up being kicked out is a sign of the failure of the system to intervene much sooner to stop it reaching crisis point where the child and their classmates end up injured or traumatised.

The child needs to learn the coping methods for society before being thrown into society not the other way around where they fail to cope and then implode with damaged mental health as a side effect, told they are naughty / evil etc etc and have this massive social rejection in a negative way. If you make the specialist facilities a positive step rather than a last resort it's a completely different position for all concerned.

Delays in SEN diagnosis and a lack of spaces are the issue here. The kids who need this level of support aren't getting it early enough and too few are.

My son likes this kid, but he's come home with bruises and in tears too. My son should be taught healthy boundaries and it's ok to say no , rather than feel he should have to put up with it 'to be kind'. That's not being kind to him - that's setting up kids to be vulnerable to abusive relationships in future. And actually if the kid is SEN and the kids around have negative experiences that in the long term doesn't bode well for inclusion - they will eventually steer clear of anyone with SEN because of a negative experience.

The point here is that ALL kids have a right to a safe and appropriate environment. If they can be included great but if 'inclusion' actually means at their expense that's a failure. The needs of the entire class have to be fairly balanced and them all be equals rather than some 'more equal' than others.

This👏🏼 Inclusion shouldn’t shouldn’t come at the cost of worrying whether your child will be shanked in school.

RedToothBrush · 11/01/2023 16:23

whateveryouwantmetosay · 11/01/2023 14:57

Wow. The blame the child attitude here is disgusting. I am horrified that parents (and even school governors!) are advocating for a child with ND and additional needs be segregated instead of providing them with additional supports that they clearly need. Educational segregation needs to stop in the UK. It's discriminatory at best and teaching our children that people with ND need to be locked up/put away rather than included in society.

They need specialist support though.

I am aware of the kid in my son's class and what he does. If he starts to kick off even when he's being given one to one he starts screaming and attacking staff and other children. It's a fight or flight response but he has enough emotional intelligence to also manipulate the situation.

When they were doing a test he started to kick off and was saying 'im not going to do this. I'm going to deliberately get everything wrong'. Before running around the classroom jumping on tables and then properly kicking off. Can you imagine if he did this when the others were supposed to be doing SATS?

As it is it's so disruptive there are days when I wonder how the class learn anything.

And that's before I start talking about how he's bullied other children and hurt other children

Being inclusive in this situation isn't actually including everyone. It's putting the behaviour of this child about the needs of all the other kids in the class

As I say DS being flagged for SEN too has helped because we can make an argument that they are failing to provide both a safe environment and for his learning needs.

If he was getting the support he needs then, it wouldn't be a problem but he's not. He's being failed too. But genuinely having seen on occasion three members of staff be required to deal with this one child, how can you include them in a normal school environment?

They need a quiet environment which is calm and quite not with 101 distractions and having to compete with others for attention. It's not the right environment for their needs - that's the point. The fact they end up being kicked out is a sign of the failure of the system to intervene much sooner to stop it reaching crisis point where the child and their classmates end up injured or traumatised.

The child needs to learn the coping methods for society before being thrown into society not the other way around where they fail to cope and then implode with damaged mental health as a side effect, told they are naughty / evil etc etc and have this massive social rejection in a negative way. If you make the specialist facilities a positive step rather than a last resort it's a completely different position for all concerned.

Delays in SEN diagnosis and a lack of spaces are the issue here. The kids who need this level of support aren't getting it early enough and too few are.

My son likes this kid, but he's come home with bruises and in tears too. My son should be taught healthy boundaries and it's ok to say no , rather than feel he should have to put up with it 'to be kind'. That's not being kind to him - that's setting up kids to be vulnerable to abusive relationships in future. And actually if the kid is SEN and the kids around have negative experiences that in the long term doesn't bode well for inclusion - they will eventually steer clear of anyone with SEN because of a negative experience.

The point here is that ALL kids have a right to a safe and appropriate environment. If they can be included great but if 'inclusion' actually means at their expense that's a failure. The needs of the entire class have to be fairly balanced and them all be equals rather than some 'more equal' than others.

JustKeepBuilding · 11/01/2023 16:06

His formal diagnosis is stuck in the system so he's not getting the right support and the school are stuck until that happens too.

No they aren’t. Support in schools is based on needs, not diagnosis. An EHCP and provision within it doesn’t require a diagnosis.

RedToothBrush · 11/01/2023 15:59

We have a not dissimilar situation going on in my son's class.

We have spelt it out in formal letters that we fear a massive safeguarding incident if not dealt with.

Everything incident you have has to be documented - and can't purely go on heresy - it's take photos of injuries and say kids mental health damaged etc etc. Focus on the impact on your child and how they are being harmed in specific incidents rather than more generalised behavioural issues.

Say that the needs of other children are not being met and balanced and keep at it.

The school have to go through a process of demonstrating that they have taken every possible step and have exhausted all avenues. Writing letters will help the school build a case. The school won't want the child anymore than you do. My friend works in another class with another child who is currently hurting her on a daily basis - she doesn't want that and the other staff don't want it

I know lots of schools are having similar issues at the moment and kids can't get diagnosis or spaces in special schools so there is pushback in the system

Remind of legal responsibilities and consequences if this continues and nothing is done.

In our case the parents are determined to keep the kid in the school despite the head saying they can't meet the child's needs. My suspicion is he will eventually go boom and there will be a major incident and he won't come back at some point before yr 6. He is special needs but his needs are extreme and even though the parents do care for him they are clueless, feeding the situation and aren't coping. His formal diagnosis is stuck in the system so he's not getting the right support and the school are stuck until that happens too. They will need to demonstrate that even with support the situation still isn't under control.

We've actually been fortunate in that DS and one other boy in the friendship group have also been flagged with SEN needs so that's adding pressure to the mix about the school needing to address that too.

But yes all the other agencies - council and ousted are places to get onto as well. Keep writing letters and stress that if something does happen with the paper trail you've got, heads will roll in terms of liability...

It will take time but the system is utterly fucked. Remember you and the school are probably on the same page here not at odds with each other so phrase things to aid their case for funding or sending the child to a more appropriate setting.

Jellycats4life · 11/01/2023 15:46

cantkeepawayforever · 11/01/2023 15:09

The thing is, the additional support that this child is likely to need are most likely to be found in a good special school that has extremely high ratios of specifically trained and expert staff, and an adapted curriculum and environment that meets their needs.

It is not necessarily to be found in a busy, low staff ratio mainstream school, with a highly academic and ‘content rich’ curriculum, even if a 1:1 staff member is assigned to them.

‘Physical inclusion at all costs’ is , for very high needs children, often ‘isolation and failure’, as they cannot adapt their behaviour and needs to succeed in that classroom environment - through no failure of their own or the school’s. It’s expecting a fish to climb a tree - even with an individual helper to lift the fish up into the branches, it’s not going to succeed.

Unfortunately, in today’s political and funding environment, the only way for a child to reach the additional support they need in a specialist setting is to fail so dramatically in a mainstream setting that they and others are harmed. Which is obviously a dramatic government failure.

This is exactly the problem. Thousands of children are being babysat in mainstream Infant schools up and down the country. I say Infant schools because, in my experience at least, by Year 2 the schools are saying that transition to a mainstream Junior school is untenable and that’s when they’re forced to look at SEN schools from year 3. That’s a very well-trodden path for families I know.

Inclusion is a thorny issue. I think some parents are, for numerous reasons, so very against the idea of sending their child to a SEN school, even if their needs are incredibly high. The stigma of “special school” is a big deal. For some I think it’s a kind of denial?

Of course there are other families who want SEN schools from Reception age, only to be told that there aren’t any local SEN schools that take children so young. The only option is to be babysat at mainstream until they reach the right age.

The problem with “inclusion” as a concept, as noble as it is, is it makes parents believe that mainstream schools are equipped to deal with all manner of complex needs and disabilities. And they’re not. I had no idea that kids who can’t access the classroom or the curriculum sit with their TAs watching cartoons, or wander around the corridors for large portions of the day. But they do.

cantkeepawayforever · 11/01/2023 15:09

The thing is, the additional support that this child is likely to need are most likely to be found in a good special school that has extremely high ratios of specifically trained and expert staff, and an adapted curriculum and environment that meets their needs.

It is not necessarily to be found in a busy, low staff ratio mainstream school, with a highly academic and ‘content rich’ curriculum, even if a 1:1 staff member is assigned to them.

‘Physical inclusion at all costs’ is , for very high needs children, often ‘isolation and failure’, as they cannot adapt their behaviour and needs to succeed in that classroom environment - through no failure of their own or the school’s. It’s expecting a fish to climb a tree - even with an individual helper to lift the fish up into the branches, it’s not going to succeed.

Unfortunately, in today’s political and funding environment, the only way for a child to reach the additional support they need in a specialist setting is to fail so dramatically in a mainstream setting that they and others are harmed. Which is obviously a dramatic government failure.

x2boys · 11/01/2023 15:07

whateveryouwantmetosay · 11/01/2023 14:57

Wow. The blame the child attitude here is disgusting. I am horrified that parents (and even school governors!) are advocating for a child with ND and additional needs be segregated instead of providing them with additional supports that they clearly need. Educational segregation needs to stop in the UK. It's discriminatory at best and teaching our children that people with ND need to be locked up/put away rather than included in society.

But that really does depend on the needs of the child ,not all children are suited to mainstream education mine certainly isn't ,I can ,t comment on the child in question here ,but I am say it would be massively unfair to my child if he had been shoe horned into a mainstream school with just a 1:1,as from my experience he wouldn't have been included ,he would have been a class novelty at best
he's always gone to a special school( he's 12) and is very much included in his school and this is the best place for him ,inclusion shouldn't be about mainstream at all costs but finding the best place to meet the individual child's needs .

whateveryouwantmetosay · 11/01/2023 14:57

Wow. The blame the child attitude here is disgusting. I am horrified that parents (and even school governors!) are advocating for a child with ND and additional needs be segregated instead of providing them with additional supports that they clearly need. Educational segregation needs to stop in the UK. It's discriminatory at best and teaching our children that people with ND need to be locked up/put away rather than included in society.

WhereIsMyGlasses · 11/01/2023 14:49

Brotherlove · 11/01/2023 11:38

If parents are asking for help and think their child is ND....the school is failing that child, and all the others.
Where is the 1:1 when they are hurting other children? That is the question....

This! And I say this as a parent of a similar child/difficulty when in mainstream (minus the knife) I was screaming (still am) for help, the school was putting up barriers, ultimately I and my child was to blame in the eyes of school and other parents but my child was unsupported and in the wrong environment. I discipline my child, I put on place strong boundaries but these may be different from the kinds of discipline and boundaries that work for neurotypical children and often could look like I'm lax in that area from the outside judgemental eye.

I can understand the other side though, and your need to protect your child. Something school should be doing and it sounds like they aren't. Unfortunately parents striking/collectively not sending children just further alienates an already struggling parent/child. I agree that writing/complaining about the system, rather than the actual child, each time is the way to go and if all parents can consistently do this something will eventually be done. From experience though, it might not end well for that parent/child, but it seems to be the only way to safeguard every child.

JustKeepBuilding · 11/01/2023 14:48

LetsAllGoOnStrike · 11/01/2023 14:41

@user1496262496 is your last sentence correct? What is the rationale for that?

There aren’t enough SS places, and unless the pupil has an excellent EHCP it is often cheaper, so LAs continue to persevere with MS even when it isn’t in the pupil’s best interest and parents want SS.

LetsAllGoOnStrike · 11/01/2023 14:41

@user1496262496 is your last sentence correct? What is the rationale for that?

JustKeepBuilding · 11/01/2023 14:38

good luck trying to get 1:1 staff when you pay peanuts

If the 1:1 is specified and quantified if section F of the EHCP the provision must be provided. Ultimately it is the LA who is responsible for ensuring the provision is provided, even if that means they have to fund the 1:1 at a substantially higher rate. They won’t do so unless forced to though.

MiniHouse · 11/01/2023 14:37

Juggletits · 11/01/2023 10:43

Ongoing saga at our primary school. One child has been hugely disruptive since day one - attacking other children (stabbing with pencils, stamping on chests, stomach punches, facial damage with nails or sports equipment amongst many others), attacking teachers, throwing chairs, upending tables and regularly trying to escape.

Last term they brought a pocket knife in to school and showed it to other children, cut his own trousers and threatened other children that he "could stab them"

There is an ever growing list of assaults and incidents against many children and the parent community is absolutely baffled as to why the child has not been removed. They clearly need serious and ongoing support and our school is not set up for a child with such a level of additional needs.

The reason from the HT is that "certain thresholds haven't been met"

Does anyone know what these thresholds are from a legal/professional point of view?

It has reached the point that parents are keeping their children out of school because they are not safe in the classroom.

Multiple emails have been sent to the school, Academy Trust, Ofsted and MARU

What more can be done? An entire school is being disrupted by one child - this cannot be right?!

I think they should be excluded. The challenge is some LAs lack alternative provision. This sounds awful for the child and others. Push this to the highest level. Try head teacher, head governor, academy chain, local council, MP, Ofsted, threaten to go to local newspaper in the way of not naming names but this is what happens at this school

DazzlePaintedBattlePants · 11/01/2023 14:34

It's incredibly unlikely the school will or can do anything.

And for all those posters saying the child just needs better support, even when children have an EHCP that miraculously covers the right support, good luck trying to get 1:1 staff when you pay peanuts and the poor staff member is faced with violence, bodily fluids and swearing. They don't exist any more.

The only guaranteed course of action is to move your child, but you can't guarantee that any school you move to will not have similar problems.

To some extent primary is about holding in there until the buck is passed to secondary.

cantkeepawayforever · 11/01/2023 14:34

The worst thing is that each child who leaves as a result of the behaviour decreases the school’s funding, thus decreasing the dwindling pot of money they have to staff the child’s support (until funding is secured , and even then it is usual for the school to have to find the initial few thousand pounds unless the parent fights the LA very hard for absolutely full funding).

user1496262496 · 11/01/2023 14:31

The trouble with removing your child to a different school is that the disruptive child might be removed to that school too. When I ran the PRU it wasn’t unusual for children to have attended 10 plus different educational establishments by the time they joined age 11. History would repeat itself at each place. The aim is to try and keep disruptive students in mainstream education

cantkeepawayforever · 11/01/2023 14:28

It is probably worth emphasising the financial position the school is likely to be in here.

Unless and until the child has an agreed EHCP with the hours of 1:1 funding written into it, the school has no money to pay the salary of a 1:1 member of staff. Already, due to real terms budget cuts, staff numbers in many schools are being cut - often by removing class TAs so classes with a single adult (the teacher) are more and more the norm. Funding issues are particularly acute in small village-type schools that do not always have full classes of 30, and where small overall numbers mean that the costs of eg Head, part time SENCo, cook etc have to be met out if a smaller overall budget.

Calls for ‘full time 1:1 supervision’ by whom? Funded how? What are you willing to be cut in the school to pay for it?

Daisybuttercup12345 · 11/01/2023 14:26

I would remove my child. And send emails and letters of complaint to every source available from the governors to social services to ofsted. Consider calling the police every time.
Parents strike sounds good.

DontSpeakLatinInFrontOfTheBooks · 11/01/2023 14:24

They’re not going to share anything about this child with you because it’s frankly none of your business. I understand your concerns (I’d be beside myself too if my child had been hurt/their education was suffering like this), but rather than demanding the child is excluded, demand to know what is being put in place to keep your child safe. And get angry at the system that is failing everyone here including the disruptive child. I don’t envy anyone who works in education at all- there’s not enough of them, there’s not enough funding to meet basic needs and it’s a shit show basically.

NestingSparrow · 11/01/2023 14:21

LlynTegid · 11/01/2023 14:20

I would suggest with a number of parents you visit the Head Teacher. And refuse to leave the premises unless there are proper processes in place to ensure safety. Be prepared to be on site well beyond school finishing time.

I really hope you are joking here.

NestingSparrow · 11/01/2023 14:20

The poor teachers. It must be impossible for them.
Move your child to a different school OP.

LlynTegid · 11/01/2023 14:20

I would suggest with a number of parents you visit the Head Teacher. And refuse to leave the premises unless there are proper processes in place to ensure safety. Be prepared to be on site well beyond school finishing time.

Isthisexpected · 11/01/2023 14:18

The only additional thing you can do is also contact the police if children are being physically attacked because there may be negligence charges the school's safeguarding team could be picked up on and not keeping kids safe from bullying and violence.