Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

How disruptive does a child have to be to be removed from Primary School?!

262 replies

Juggletits · 11/01/2023 10:43

Ongoing saga at our primary school. One child has been hugely disruptive since day one - attacking other children (stabbing with pencils, stamping on chests, stomach punches, facial damage with nails or sports equipment amongst many others), attacking teachers, throwing chairs, upending tables and regularly trying to escape.

Last term they brought a pocket knife in to school and showed it to other children, cut his own trousers and threatened other children that he "could stab them"

There is an ever growing list of assaults and incidents against many children and the parent community is absolutely baffled as to why the child has not been removed. They clearly need serious and ongoing support and our school is not set up for a child with such a level of additional needs.

The reason from the HT is that "certain thresholds haven't been met"

Does anyone know what these thresholds are from a legal/professional point of view?

It has reached the point that parents are keeping their children out of school because they are not safe in the classroom.

Multiple emails have been sent to the school, Academy Trust, Ofsted and MARU

What more can be done? An entire school is being disrupted by one child - this cannot be right?!

OP posts:
JustKeepBuilding · 12/01/2023 14:36

LetsAllGoOnStrike · 12/01/2023 14:18

@JustKeepBuilding I don't disagree with what you are saying, but do you advocate that all the teachers and other children should have to put up with the situation in the meantime, with the level of disruption to their education and fear (that may impact them long-term) that seems to be occurring, as obviously that doesn't appear to be the best outcome for anyone.

Like it or not without a diagnosis (and did that request get put in before or after the trouble at the school started) this has been going on for 3 years according to OP which is wholely unacceptable for the rest of the teachers and other pupils to have to put up with. It should not be on the other parents to try and move this forward or make their child leave the school.

Not once have I posted anyone has “to put up with the situation”, especially not for 3 years. From the school’s actions what should happen is the school should a) not pedal myths, b) provide appropriate support, c) push the LA for additional funding, d) support the parents to appeal to SENDIST and e) follow due process in order to resolve the situation - that could include following the proper process to lawfully exclude (not illegally excluding as so many do) the pupil which would provide evidence of unmet needs.

JustKeepBuilding · 12/01/2023 14:34

No, I haven’t!


By your own admission this situation has been going on years, there has been time to force the LA to provide additional funding. Yes it takes time, but not this long.

RedToothBrush · 12/01/2023 14:26

JustKeepBuilding · 12/01/2023 14:10

No, I haven’t missed the point. I’m well aware there are many parents who want to remain in MS, for numerous reasons, and schools, parents and LAs not agreeing, but the school could be providing more support. You yourself say there isn’t even 1:1 at break and lunchtime and seem to incorrectly be of the belief you need a diagnosis for the school to give more support - presumably that’s come from the school. If they don’t have the funding they need to approach the LA, pushing the LA for more funding doesn’t require anyone else’s involvement.

You have missed the point!

I'm saying thats the point the school are at. But in the interim there isn't support and incident have happened because they've not got the funds to do this yet!!!!

Kids have been hurt because there is no slack in the system.

The school has one of the tightest budgets in the country because they get so little from government due to the funding formula. Its deemed a good school in an affluent area but the demographics weirdly work against it for exactly the same reasons because these factors have created a higher than average need for SENCO support due to a highest natural prevelance (older parents / more parents liable to be in employment where neurodiversity is more common to begin and the genetic consequences of this).

Its crappy for all concerned that you have to understand the system, and appeal to the school understanding this, and they then have to appeal to the authorities armed with this. It all takes time - time in which the kids involved are all at risk.

The parents might be shitty with us, but actually we are ultimately on their side and we don't want a vigilante response. Other parents have been a lot harsher in what they've said privately to us and we've had to calm them down and encourage them to play the game.

From what this kid has done, him bringing in a knife to school in a year or two definitely is something thats on my radar and in my concerns.

But even if we move our son I don't know that we protect him because two years of covid seems to have made cases like this all over the country be more acute and common. It would be easy to move only to find the same set of problems at another school. The system is broken to that degree and the threshold for schools to be able to force the issue of extra support is that high in cases where there is a dispute over the problem between parties.

The entire point is the cracks in the system that are glossed over and dismissed as 'minor' when they really aren't. Those cracks allow harms in the interrim before you reach the point of full exclusion or further down in the system with earlier appropriate intervention.

Third party parents SHOULD NEVER be in the position where they feel they have to step up and force the issue. It should be brought to a head and dealt with, long before it reaches that stage.

Speaking to friends who teach elsewhere the issue is widespread and they see it coming a mile off but they can't do anything until crisis point is reached in these type of cases. They get to year 5 or 6 and go boom. And its either dealt with them or festers before getting to yr 7 and it goes horribly wrong at high school very quickly indeed. The teachers aren't having their concerns taken seriously and every child is a uphill battle to get even the most basis level of appropriate support.

Its wrong. So so wrong. It has such life long consequences for all the kids.

LetsAllGoOnStrike · 12/01/2023 14:18

@JustKeepBuilding I don't disagree with what you are saying, but do you advocate that all the teachers and other children should have to put up with the situation in the meantime, with the level of disruption to their education and fear (that may impact them long-term) that seems to be occurring, as obviously that doesn't appear to be the best outcome for anyone.

Like it or not without a diagnosis (and did that request get put in before or after the trouble at the school started) this has been going on for 3 years according to OP which is wholely unacceptable for the rest of the teachers and other pupils to have to put up with. It should not be on the other parents to try and move this forward or make their child leave the school.

JustKeepBuilding · 12/01/2023 14:17

The school don’t need other parents’ back up to push the LA for additional funding and not pedal the myth that a diagnosis is necessary.

RedToothBrush · 12/01/2023 14:11

JustKeepBuilding · 12/01/2023 10:40

From reading Red’s other posts I think it probably is parents v school v LA. I thought it sounded like the parents do want support, but want to remain in MS where school don’t believe they can meet his needs - although the school don’t seem to be providing all the support that could be provided in MS. So even if the school and parents aren’t fully on the same page the school could support the parents to secure more support.

This.

School ultimately need back up to strengthen their case with the parents / authority to get this kid higher on the priority list and the parents to take the situation as seriously as they should.

We've tried to be positive in saying that we understand but there is a gap in provision thats not being properly addressed without being critical of the school.

I think the parents will eventually come round because they aren't so belligerent as others might be (and I can see why uncaring parents would be a real issue). The point is, its not entirely straightforward.

Its not like I don't have sympathy for them or their son either. I just get that in the process you have a bunch of kids who are totally innocent parties who get caught and harmed in the crossfire of it because there is this massive unnecessary stigma and reluctance to intervene firmly sooner due to lack of midway facilities which are essentially 'normal' type schools but with much lower child/adult ratios and more specialist staff rather than the more full on 'special schools'. Theres this halfway house area which got completely abolished.

JustKeepBuilding · 12/01/2023 14:10

No, I haven’t missed the point. I’m well aware there are many parents who want to remain in MS, for numerous reasons, and schools, parents and LAs not agreeing, but the school could be providing more support. You yourself say there isn’t even 1:1 at break and lunchtime and seem to incorrectly be of the belief you need a diagnosis for the school to give more support - presumably that’s come from the school. If they don’t have the funding they need to approach the LA, pushing the LA for more funding doesn’t require anyone else’s involvement.

RedToothBrush · 12/01/2023 14:02

JustKeepBuilding · 12/01/2023 09:59

A formal diagnosis is not necessary and support is based on needs. If the LA won’t include the support needed the parents need to be supported to appeal.

If 1:1 is specified and quantified in the EHCP funding isn’t the parents concern. The provision must be provided and if it isn’t the parent can enforce the provision. If the school need more funding they should take it up with the LA. If 1:1 isn’t in the EHCP the parents need to appeal.

You miss the point. The parents don't think there is a problem and aren't pushing it....

The best friend of the parent is in agreement with me over their complete denial of the seriousness of the situation and she doesn't know how to deal with it (her son is also getting hurt and also has SEN needs. She has been trying to gently stress how she needs to be proactive and recognise and accept the level the issue has reached and how much its affecting others.

The whole issue here is the dispute between the parents, the school and the local authority and there not being a resolution. And this is why he's falling through the cracks in the system.

In complaining it seems to have strengthened the school's hand and forced the issue because they can make a stronger case about how other children are being harmed in various ways and they have a safeguarding duty.

The parents think their child is within normal parameters just driving them insane. None of the other parents have been willing to confront them as they are particularly pushy and Mum is very very defensive. Everyone is being overly polite and 'being kind' and its helping precisely no one because the issue has effectively been swept under the carpet for much longer than it should have been.

The irony is our concerns completely mirror the suspected diagnosis (which we didn't know when we put in the complaint and Mum has since told me). Mum was in shock when school called her in over it and they said that other agencies will need to be involved because its got to this point.

Its all really sad. The school get it, but are trying to manage the situation around privacy issues and safeguarding all parties whilst having their hands tied. We get its a case of playing the system and ensuring everything is documented to protect our child and others in the class and to get the right support for this kid BEFORE we get to the point where there is a major inicident and he's kicked out. Cos thats not in the interests of this kid nor the other kids / staff that will be affected if it does get to that stage.

Management rather than going until you reach crisis point is what should be happening. The school can't manage the situation without other parties working WITH them. And I suspect this is similar to a lot of other situation - parents, school and authorities not being aligned with a common goal / agenda which leads to kids falling through the cracks in the system.

sleepissooverrated · 12/01/2023 13:12

Write a formal complaint to school about the knife incident using their formal complaint procedure and demand that they come up with a written plan on how they are going to ensure that other children in the school are kept safe. If they don't, report it as a safeguarding incident to ofsted. This might trigger an urgent safeguarding inspection.

JustKeepBuilding · 12/01/2023 10:40

From reading Red’s other posts I think it probably is parents v school v LA. I thought it sounded like the parents do want support, but want to remain in MS where school don’t believe they can meet his needs - although the school don’t seem to be providing all the support that could be provided in MS. So even if the school and parents aren’t fully on the same page the school could support the parents to secure more support.

cantkeepawayforever · 12/01/2023 10:31

I was responding to I believe in the case of this child there has been dispute over the support the parents believe is needed, what the school believe is needed and what the LA are prepared to provide.

I can see this could be read in a number of ways - school & parents vs LA (best case scenario in terms of working to get things resolved); parents vs school and LA; parents vs school vs LA (probably the worst case). I am not sure which is most likely from reading the post - reference to eg watching inappropriate material and acting it out does imply that home & school may not be quite on the sane page. (I am reminded of an occasion with a slightly similar child where a dad stood up, red in the face and balling his fists threateningly in my direction ‘what do you mean? There’s no problem with X. I was just the same at his age and I turned out ok!’)

JustKeepBuilding · 12/01/2023 10:22

cantkeepawayforever · 12/01/2023 10:18

A formal diagnosis is not necessary and support is based on needs. If the LA won’t include the support needed the parents need to be supported to appeal.

If 1:1 is specified and quantified in the EHCP funding isn’t the parents concern. The provision must be provided and if it isn’t the parent can enforce the provision. If the school need more funding they should take it up with the LA. If 1:1 isn’t in the EHCP the parents need to appeal.

The most difficult situations arise where the parents either do not support the school’s account of the child’s difficulties there, or lack capacity to ‘understand and fight the system’.

Some parents may say ‘But they’re fine at home’ - especially if the trigger is larger groups, that can be true, or if the home environment has gradually adapted to the child’s needs and avoid difficulties (whether this be by maintaining a silent and very orderly home, or by very significant screen use , or simply by never requiring the child to do anything they would prefer not to). Other parents are in more active denial. Others simply do not picture what the school curriculum expects and demands (‘can’t he just sit and colour with Miss X in the corner or in the office? He won’t be any bother there’ for a child on the cusp of transfer to secondary and working at the level of a 4 year old).

Yes, schools and parents working very hard together CAN overcome many of the obstacles put up by LAs (though they cannot magic up SS places). But if parents cannot or will not work with the school, or actively work to frustrate and oppose them (or conversely, if a school opposes the parents, which can happen too), then what SHOULD happen in terms of quantifying EHCPs and appealing to the LA may not do so.

That doesn’t sound to be the case in the situation I was commenting on though. The posts state the parents want more support. If the parents can’t navigate the system alone the school should be supporting them to appeal and signposting them to services that can support them through an appeal.

cantkeepawayforever · 12/01/2023 10:18

A formal diagnosis is not necessary and support is based on needs. If the LA won’t include the support needed the parents need to be supported to appeal.

If 1:1 is specified and quantified in the EHCP funding isn’t the parents concern. The provision must be provided and if it isn’t the parent can enforce the provision. If the school need more funding they should take it up with the LA. If 1:1 isn’t in the EHCP the parents need to appeal.

The most difficult situations arise where the parents either do not support the school’s account of the child’s difficulties there, or lack capacity to ‘understand and fight the system’.

Some parents may say ‘But they’re fine at home’ - especially if the trigger is larger groups, that can be true, or if the home environment has gradually adapted to the child’s needs and avoid difficulties (whether this be by maintaining a silent and very orderly home, or by very significant screen use , or simply by never requiring the child to do anything they would prefer not to). Other parents are in more active denial. Others simply do not picture what the school curriculum expects and demands (‘can’t he just sit and colour with Miss X in the corner or in the office? He won’t be any bother there’ for a child on the cusp of transfer to secondary and working at the level of a 4 year old).

Yes, schools and parents working very hard together CAN overcome many of the obstacles put up by LAs (though they cannot magic up SS places). But if parents cannot or will not work with the school, or actively work to frustrate and oppose them (or conversely, if a school opposes the parents, which can happen too), then what SHOULD happen in terms of quantifying EHCPs and appealing to the LA may not do so.

YetAnotherSpartacus · 12/01/2023 10:04

It's not inclusive just to shove as many kids as possible down a sausage factory mentality. It ends up centring everything on a disruptive child whilst not actually meeting their needs anyway and not balancing their needs with those of other children in the class who also lose out.

Of course it isn't and if it was an adult being forced (in most normal situations) to go to work where the threat of violence, intimidation, injury and pain was constant we'd be kicking up a massive fuss.

Why, when it comes to children, is it OK?

JustKeepBuilding · 12/01/2023 09:59

RedToothBrush · 11/01/2023 23:42

Quite.

The child in my son's class is looking like he has complex needs (I am aware of the suspected diagnosis as the mum has told me)

He's fixated on killing or hurting things, using language which is concerning and inappropriate for his age. He's unable to try the difference between reality and fantasy and seems to be getting access to age inappropriate media / games and this is coming out in how he interacts with the other kids. He likes to constantly have a 'tool or weapon' when he plays, which seems to be encouraged as a soft item but has often been a stick during playtimes. He's excessively controlling - staff struggle with him but imagine this in group of young kids - the kids are encouraged to be inclusive but this means they are not being taught its ok to say 'no' if they are unhappy or uncomfortable. He has obsessive behaviour that focusses on certain kids. Overall its been an utterly toxic situation which had clear elements of coercive control and emotional abuse as well as actual physical harm.

I believe in the case of this child there has been dispute over the support the parents believe is needed, what the school believe is needed and what the LA are prepared to provide. There is no formal diagnosis yet and this kid hasn't been considered a priority by the LA. He's falling through all the cracks for numerous reasons.

The whole thing is a mess.

The other child needs one to one support but there's no funding available for it as it stands. He needs to be in a more appropriate environment with less children - one of his triggers is large groups. He just can't cope with it. There isn't the space on site for him to be taught in this way away from others. He needs his friendships actively managed. He needs constant supervision more on a par with a toddler during lessons and breaktimes which isn't possible for his age group. None of this is healthy for other kids to be exposed to.

I don't want to move DS as he has such a good relationship with his best friend and the pair of them have been through enough in the last year with this and other things. Spliting them would do them both a lot of harm. I'm not prepared to hurt either of them. I will fight all the way to defend them both from this kid. I firmly believe its in his best interests too. If we don't keep pushing back he won't get the support he needs. Its not about 'pushing him out'. Its about pushing for him to get appropriate support and for the needs of others in the class to be met.

Its not inclusive just to shove as many kids as possible down a sausage factory mentality. It ends up centring everything on a disruptive child whilst not actually meeting their needs anyway and not balancing their needs with those of other children in the class who also lose out.

There's one little girl from a difficult background and massive anxiety issues who is terrified of the kid in my son's class fgs. Her dad is no longer in the picture...

A formal diagnosis is not necessary and support is based on needs. If the LA won’t include the support needed the parents need to be supported to appeal.

If 1:1 is specified and quantified in the EHCP funding isn’t the parents concern. The provision must be provided and if it isn’t the parent can enforce the provision. If the school need more funding they should take it up with the LA. If 1:1 isn’t in the EHCP the parents need to appeal.

jellybeans · 12/01/2023 00:36

There were a 3 kids like this in my DC school. It was awful. Parents did nothing. School did little. All 3 of them got expelled soon after they started high school but were allowed to get away with it at primary.

x2boys · 12/01/2023 00:29

oakleaffy · 11/01/2023 19:24

If your child was blinded in one eye, I’m sure you’d feel differently.
The rights of violent children ought never trump those of children who are mon violent and just want to learn.
Segregation keeps everyone safer.
Why should the rights of one affect the safety and well being of the majority?

I agree that children should be taught in the best setting that suiits them but please don't talk about them being segregated or whose rights trumps etc
ALL children deserve a good education that suite their needs .

x2boys · 12/01/2023 00:18

JudgeJ · 11/01/2023 19:01

They protected their children, not bullying at all, sometimes it need direct action.

I'm not sure vigilantism,is ever a good course of action ??

RedToothBrush · 11/01/2023 23:42

oakleaffy · 11/01/2023 19:24

If your child was blinded in one eye, I’m sure you’d feel differently.
The rights of violent children ought never trump those of children who are mon violent and just want to learn.
Segregation keeps everyone safer.
Why should the rights of one affect the safety and well being of the majority?

Quite.

The child in my son's class is looking like he has complex needs (I am aware of the suspected diagnosis as the mum has told me)

He's fixated on killing or hurting things, using language which is concerning and inappropriate for his age. He's unable to try the difference between reality and fantasy and seems to be getting access to age inappropriate media / games and this is coming out in how he interacts with the other kids. He likes to constantly have a 'tool or weapon' when he plays, which seems to be encouraged as a soft item but has often been a stick during playtimes. He's excessively controlling - staff struggle with him but imagine this in group of young kids - the kids are encouraged to be inclusive but this means they are not being taught its ok to say 'no' if they are unhappy or uncomfortable. He has obsessive behaviour that focusses on certain kids. Overall its been an utterly toxic situation which had clear elements of coercive control and emotional abuse as well as actual physical harm.

I believe in the case of this child there has been dispute over the support the parents believe is needed, what the school believe is needed and what the LA are prepared to provide. There is no formal diagnosis yet and this kid hasn't been considered a priority by the LA. He's falling through all the cracks for numerous reasons.

The whole thing is a mess.

The other child needs one to one support but there's no funding available for it as it stands. He needs to be in a more appropriate environment with less children - one of his triggers is large groups. He just can't cope with it. There isn't the space on site for him to be taught in this way away from others. He needs his friendships actively managed. He needs constant supervision more on a par with a toddler during lessons and breaktimes which isn't possible for his age group. None of this is healthy for other kids to be exposed to.

I don't want to move DS as he has such a good relationship with his best friend and the pair of them have been through enough in the last year with this and other things. Spliting them would do them both a lot of harm. I'm not prepared to hurt either of them. I will fight all the way to defend them both from this kid. I firmly believe its in his best interests too. If we don't keep pushing back he won't get the support he needs. Its not about 'pushing him out'. Its about pushing for him to get appropriate support and for the needs of others in the class to be met.

Its not inclusive just to shove as many kids as possible down a sausage factory mentality. It ends up centring everything on a disruptive child whilst not actually meeting their needs anyway and not balancing their needs with those of other children in the class who also lose out.

There's one little girl from a difficult background and massive anxiety issues who is terrified of the kid in my son's class fgs. Her dad is no longer in the picture...

IDontCareMatthew · 11/01/2023 19:54

Raspberry290 · 11/01/2023 13:17

You could also advise the school that you’ll be approaching local media. That’ll be unpopular with some but if it was my child being impacted I wouldn’t hesitate

Another good idea..

IDontCareMatthew · 11/01/2023 19:53

Raspberry290 · 11/01/2023 13:15

Write to the governors and report the knife incident to the police

Good idea!

oakleaffy · 11/01/2023 19:24

whateveryouwantmetosay · 11/01/2023 14:57

Wow. The blame the child attitude here is disgusting. I am horrified that parents (and even school governors!) are advocating for a child with ND and additional needs be segregated instead of providing them with additional supports that they clearly need. Educational segregation needs to stop in the UK. It's discriminatory at best and teaching our children that people with ND need to be locked up/put away rather than included in society.

If your child was blinded in one eye, I’m sure you’d feel differently.
The rights of violent children ought never trump those of children who are mon violent and just want to learn.
Segregation keeps everyone safer.
Why should the rights of one affect the safety and well being of the majority?

fitzwilliamdarcy · 11/01/2023 19:15

Move your child. Speaking from experience, nothing will happen unless there’s a serious incident and even then nothing is guaranteed as his parents will fight all the way. The only way that the children being assaulted will be prioritised in any way over the violent child is if their parents remove them.

And hope to God there isn’t another one in the next school.

Jules912 · 11/01/2023 19:06

I have a SEN child prone to violent meltdowns, and know how hard it is to get support. Saying that the knife incident suggests a level of planning/ deliberate cruelty my DD wouldn't be capable of. It also took the best part of a term to ( mostly) find the right interventions for my DD after she stopped being able to mask at school, interestingly this wasn't 1-2-1 support.
She was suspended twice in that term, which actually turned out to be a good thing as it got her on the radar of the usually useless LA who were willing to provide support ( mostly counselling) at that point, although I suspect only because it was cheaper than waiting until she ended up at the PRU.

JudgeJ · 11/01/2023 19:01

x2boys · 11/01/2023 12:41

Nice 🙄they basically bullied a family out of the village

They protected their children, not bullying at all, sometimes it need direct action.