Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

How disruptive does a child have to be to be removed from Primary School?!

262 replies

Juggletits · 11/01/2023 10:43

Ongoing saga at our primary school. One child has been hugely disruptive since day one - attacking other children (stabbing with pencils, stamping on chests, stomach punches, facial damage with nails or sports equipment amongst many others), attacking teachers, throwing chairs, upending tables and regularly trying to escape.

Last term they brought a pocket knife in to school and showed it to other children, cut his own trousers and threatened other children that he "could stab them"

There is an ever growing list of assaults and incidents against many children and the parent community is absolutely baffled as to why the child has not been removed. They clearly need serious and ongoing support and our school is not set up for a child with such a level of additional needs.

The reason from the HT is that "certain thresholds haven't been met"

Does anyone know what these thresholds are from a legal/professional point of view?

It has reached the point that parents are keeping their children out of school because they are not safe in the classroom.

Multiple emails have been sent to the school, Academy Trust, Ofsted and MARU

What more can be done? An entire school is being disrupted by one child - this cannot be right?!

OP posts:
Percypiglover · 13/01/2023 09:14

Whilst often it because of additional need or home situation most schools would have an automatic exclusion for a child bringing in a knife though my experience is secondary so maybe primary operate differently. I wouldn't be happy with my child being stuck in that position and it's clear the child bears more support than they are getting.

JustKeepBuilding · 13/01/2023 08:24

And it’s the LA’s duty to provide education and SEN support, not the parents. If DC are unable to attend due to illness, SEN, exclusion or otherwise parents still shouldn’t deregister and EHE, the LA must provide alternative provision to ensure DC receive a full time education.

You don’t see parents on here deregistering their DC because of colds.m or anyone advocating it.

Stressfordays · 13/01/2023 07:04

JustKeepBuilding · 12/01/2023 21:39

Deregistering and EHE often results in less and slower support. By EHE it is easier for professionals to sweep DC’s needs under the carpet and LAs say parents are making suitable alternative arrangements thereby relieving them of their duty. You wouldn’t deregister if that meant your child was less likely to receive the support they need, and the support they did get took longer and a bigger fight to get. Far better to push for more support, and an alternative placement if necessary, while remaining on the school’s roll.

Yes they may get slower support, but its your duty as a parent to ensure your child doesn't hurt others. Plenty of threads on here accusing parents of being neglectful for sending their children into school with a cold, but send your child in who struggles to the point of regularly attacking others and its suddenly ok?

Diverseopinions · 13/01/2023 02:53

Spendonsend · 12/01/2023 21:34

Lots of parents do pull their children out if they are distressed to the point of injuring other. There are thousands and thousands of children with no school place for years on end.

Many parents of disruptive children - and I'm thinking about a special school context, and my (now) adult son who has asd - will keep them off school, if they have had a meltdown or seem more unsettled and challenging than usual, they will keep them off, until they seem more settled. It is often the case that physical illness precedes very challenging behaviour. You can't work out what has caused agitation, and then they fall asleep at 5pm on the sofa and start to get a temperature. However, most parents I know would keep children with ASD off school, if they were going through a challenging bout of behaviour.

What sounds unusual about the child about whom OP is speaking, is that there is very little analysis which has been done, or so it appears, into the antecedents for the behaviours. It is unbelievable that he is being left unsupervised to go through the school day with a knife and attacking children in the stomach and risking serious injury. It's unbelievable to think about being the headteacher and not being worried about a serious incident occurring. How could you get up in the morning and go to work, knowing that your laissez-faire attitude to health and safety might put you in court, cause you life-long regret and guilt, and damage children? Most people would want to remove the risk of serious injury as immediately as possible. Senior managers in school would be expected to have an enhanced appreciation of risk assessment, not one which is wholly unrealistic.

My son left school a few years ago, so what I observed was different, and I'm now continually reading that funding for schools is so inadequate that the children are not learning and they are dangerous places to be. Maybe all the tried and tested recourses no longer exist. Maybe there are no experts to come in and design strategies. But as a school leader, you'd think the senior managers would want to exclude and keep the environment safe, and answer questions about their action later. Better to be critisized for excluding, than to do very little and risk a serious incident.

It just sounds nasty to speculate on the child's family and their sense of responsibility. For whatever reason, the parents can't manage or improve the boy's behaviour. Schools are expected to be places where teams work collectively and enhanced knowledge and training can be bought in. By contrast, two adults on their own don't have the same back up. It must be hard for them to keep their other children safe. Unless you are parenting a child who shows very aggressive tendencies as described by OP, you don't know how easy or hard is their workload, in managing him.

Child-rearing is logical and instinctive for the majority of normal presentations of typical children. It is impossible for us to say on Mumsnet what is the range of this child's behaviour, whether effective parenting is possible, and his is a young age for any professional to be making clear diagnosis. It may or may not be achievable for the parents to help this child reduce his aggressive behaviour on their own.

If provision is so woeful that school's no longer see the point in making referrals to other agencies, because these no longer exist or function, then this is another thread for extrapolating that readers should vote Labour at the next election.

WhereIsMyRollingPin · 12/01/2023 22:30

My DCs school, many years ago, did very little in similar circumstances until eight children left the school en masse. Each parent wrote to the Head explaining why, copied to HoG and the LEA. Once that happened they sort of said "Oh, right, it's a problem, we need to do something."

The offending child is now in prison.

hiredandsqueak · 12/01/2023 22:21

Ds had challenging behaviour besides the autism. I had managde to ensure he had a statement giving 1 to 1 support before he started nursery. He did manage to hurt other children in nursery and reception. I felt terrible but I wasn't there and I had done everything in my power to keep everyone else safe.
It changed when ds had an incredible TA who wasn't afraid to refuse the teacher's requests to support others, do photocopying, displays etc as each time ds had hurt previously was because the TA who was assigned to him was elsewhere "running errands"
Long story short but because of the incredible support he received by her and subsequent TAs when he moved to an outstanding secondary, in year ten he got the HT award at prizegiving for having "behaviour and attitude to learning second to none."

Kamia · 12/01/2023 22:17

The school are being neglectful. There should be a policy for when that child is violent and he should be removed straight away. Even if he does have special needs there should be plans put in place to prevent that sort of behaviour. That seems like a disaster waiting to happen.

cantkeepawayforever · 12/01/2023 22:10

I think, in terms of close supervision, you also have to bear in mind the constraints of space in many classrooms. Typically, any child in my old classroom was necessarily no more than a few cm from their direct neighbour, and 6 other children would be within the teach if an outstretched arm or leg.

For one thing, an attentive adult (or two, allowing for breaks) would always have to be seated or standing within an arm’s length of the child because otherwise they would be unable to get to them quickly (almost no circulation space) and for another, for the child not to be able to reach anything that could be used to hold or throw as a weapon (other than a table or chair) would deprive several other children of necessary equipment as it could otherwise not be far enough away.

There would be no space to seat a child with an adult with a large enough ‘exclusion zone’ except outside the classroom.

JustKeepBuilding · 12/01/2023 21:39

Deregistering and EHE often results in less and slower support. By EHE it is easier for professionals to sweep DC’s needs under the carpet and LAs say parents are making suitable alternative arrangements thereby relieving them of their duty. You wouldn’t deregister if that meant your child was less likely to receive the support they need, and the support they did get took longer and a bigger fight to get. Far better to push for more support, and an alternative placement if necessary, while remaining on the school’s roll.

Spendonsend · 12/01/2023 21:34

Stressfordays · 12/01/2023 21:24

At what point as a parent of a SEN child you know attacks others do you take some responsibility and pull them out yourself? I would be mortified if my child was injuring others, even if I knew they could not help their reactions. There is no way would I allow my child in an environment that would allow them to get like that and do that to other children. I'm sorry, but I just wouldn't.

SEN support is shocking in schools and I really feel for parents and children dealing with all of this. Something needs to change and fast. But other children should not be being hurt in the process of this.

Lots of parents do pull their children out if they are distressed to the point of injuring other. There are thousands and thousands of children with no school place for years on end.

Stressfordays · 12/01/2023 21:24

At what point as a parent of a SEN child you know attacks others do you take some responsibility and pull them out yourself? I would be mortified if my child was injuring others, even if I knew they could not help their reactions. There is no way would I allow my child in an environment that would allow them to get like that and do that to other children. I'm sorry, but I just wouldn't.

SEN support is shocking in schools and I really feel for parents and children dealing with all of this. Something needs to change and fast. But other children should not be being hurt in the process of this.

Diverseopinions · 12/01/2023 21:10

gravyriceandchips · 12/01/2023 20:51

@Diverseopinions I agree and therefore she cant. So when it kicks off it kicks off.

"If the child doesn't have a support worker because of funding issues, they can't be in school. The LA must surely accept this."

In the meantime with insufficient funding it just goes on until something serious happens. Nothing changes.

Things do change, but it's about going about things in a certain way. I think that that is the problem it's knowing how to approach the issue. Lawyers are good at that sort of thing, which is why parents, who go to SEN tribunals, not infrequently get their wishes met.

In this instance, the school response sounds not at all good.

You can Google challenging behaviour and find manuals and videos in ABC charts and ways of identifying a child's triggers. There are management techniques which work. Many children improve in their behaviour, with the correct interventions, if started at that relatively young age

The school should give the child an individual behaviour plan. I don't know the rules, but I would have thought another parent had the right to ask what the school is doing to keep their own child safe, and to ask questions about what has been put in place, including in the behaviour plan.

I never agree that size and strength and fitness don't matter in a member of staff tasked with managing the immediate presentations of challenging behaviour. I think if a child were to be attacking another peer, and angry, or even fighting with another angry child, then some physical strength would be needed to break it up. But it shouldn't get to the level at which an argument has become a fight. The volatile child ought to be helped to engage at play time in structured activity. All the obvious and usual strategies, which used to be used in schools.

Staff need to be active and able to move swiftly, with the child. Supporting challenging behaviour is a specialised area of work. You need the right people to do the job and then the management of the behaviour works well.

JustKeepBuilding · 12/01/2023 20:56

If the child doesn't have a support worker because of funding issues, they can't be in school. The LA must surely accept this.

Unless the school are going to follow due process and formally exclude they can’t just say a pupil can’t attend otherwise it would be an illegal exclusion.

gravyriceandchips · 12/01/2023 20:51

@Diverseopinions I agree and therefore she cant. So when it kicks off it kicks off.

"If the child doesn't have a support worker because of funding issues, they can't be in school. The LA must surely accept this."

In the meantime with insufficient funding it just goes on until something serious happens. Nothing changes.

Spendonsend · 12/01/2023 20:45

To be fair the idea isnt to have someone who can restrain a child so they dont need to be big, its to have someone who prevents the situation happening using all sorts of techniques. But obviously this isnt always possible. Restraint is very much a last resort.

Diverseopinions · 12/01/2023 20:41

gravyriceandchips · 12/01/2023 20:35

@Diverseopinions
There is a child in my dd class who is bigger physically than the male teacher assigned to support. The actual teacher is about 5ft

She is tiny.

She would be unable to restrain him. He has meltdowns. Not his fault he becomes overwhelmed. He's not the violent child but is prone to throwing chairs etc. not at his classmates and he's not violent to people but he loses control and chairs have been thrown. It's so dangerous and so awful for them all. Him included.

The other child is violent towards his classmates. He's tiny. Teacher can't restrain him either because she's about the same size as him.

The support teacher is split between classes. He can't be everywhere at once.

There does t see. To be enough funding for any support.

If the child doesn't have a support worker because of funding issues, they can't be in school. The LA must surely accept this. Funding can be secured at a national level. In any case, how could the teacher teach the class and manage the behaviour of a child with challenging conduct? She can't be looking at the board, teaching 30 children and sitting next to that child. You can only manage challenging behaviour by being near to the child in question.

Sherrystrull · 12/01/2023 20:37

The child I worked with would yank pencils from other children's hands. Have you worked with a similar child?

gravyriceandchips · 12/01/2023 20:35

@Diverseopinions
There is a child in my dd class who is bigger physically than the male teacher assigned to support. The actual teacher is about 5ft

She is tiny.

She would be unable to restrain him. He has meltdowns. Not his fault he becomes overwhelmed. He's not the violent child but is prone to throwing chairs etc. not at his classmates and he's not violent to people but he loses control and chairs have been thrown. It's so dangerous and so awful for them all. Him included.

The other child is violent towards his classmates. He's tiny. Teacher can't restrain him either because she's about the same size as him.

The support teacher is split between classes. He can't be everywhere at once.

There does t see. To be enough funding for any support.

Diverseopinions · 12/01/2023 20:34

Sherrystrull · 12/01/2023 20:21

Are you suggesting pencils aren't placed on tables?

I'm not disagreeing with you that it's possible to get the correct support but I've got first hand experience of a child who was incredibly unpredictable, very strong and would use normal classroom resources as weapons.

You may get have to give that particular child a different type of writing implement and yes, the obvious strategy would be for him to have his own work station.

A proper risk assessment needs to be done by the SENCO as to whether 1:1 is going to be sufficient and what are the likely behaviours. I think that stronger male staff are suitable for the role of behaviour mentor.

I read about the crisis in education, but I didn't know that outreach services to give advice and SENCOs no longer exist. There is literature and training available to give advice on managing challenging behaviour.

Sherrystrull · 12/01/2023 20:21

Are you suggesting pencils aren't placed on tables?

I'm not disagreeing with you that it's possible to get the correct support but I've got first hand experience of a child who was incredibly unpredictable, very strong and would use normal classroom resources as weapons.

Diverseopinions · 12/01/2023 20:17

Sherrystrull · 12/01/2023 19:47

Anything can be a weapon in school. A sharp pencil, scissors, a book, a door stop, a chair...

Working with a child who is violent and unpredictable means you always have to be ready to pounce. It's exhausting and stressful. Sadly the wage for a 1:1 doesn't reflect this.

Don't let the child take a pair of scissors and try to stab someone with it. Yes. You do always need to be ready to manage challenging behaviour. You have to be attentive. That is the job. Specially trained staff from a pru could be seconded in. But it needs to be recognised that the ability to be vigilant is a requirement of the job of specialist behaviour mentor.

The child is unlikely to be on the verge of kicking off or attacking someone all if the time. The training for specialist behaviour mentoring covers recognising and anticipating the triggers for challenging outbursts and de-escalating behaviour - before it becomes a crisis. Staff should see an incident coming. In between incidents, children such as the one being described, often engage in activities in the usual way, so the 1: 1 support worker can be sitting, encouraging, but not primed to leap up.. Once you have the proper training and the environment has been risk-assessed and adapted, the job of the behaviour mentor becomes less stressful. Staff have to be physically fit, because working with challenging children is often active.

Really, is this the case, that scissors would be left accessible to a child who has previously attacked a peer with something similar?

Diverseopinions · 12/01/2023 20:05

Sleepyblueocean · 12/01/2023 19:55

"Could someone explain why 1:1 from a strong and trained adult is not enough to limit and de-escalate a child's behaviour?"

If physical intervention is required then 2:1 rather 1:1 is needed. Likewise if a child needs constant close watching to prevent dangerous behaviour.

Of course. The school or LA will have to provide 2: 1. I doubt if that would be needed for this child. It would usually be an out of control meltdown which would need more than 1 trained behaviour mentor to manage. Planning sounds the critical factor with this child. Don't let him enter school premises when carrying a weapon. Work out what he is going to allowed to do at breakdown and where he will be going, and plan and equip the session. Don't, for instance, just send him off to play with the other children, 'supervised' by an adult who is standing firmly in one place, watching sporadically from time to time. . A physically strong member of staff, trained to manage challenging behaviour should be adequate.

If strategies are put in place now, they can guide the management which other settings puts in place later. The younger the child, the easier it is to teach them alternative behaviours..

Having your behaviours anticipated and not being allowed the leeway to carry them out is a deterrent to most children who experience challenging issues. Children do change as a result of the application of tried and tested techniques, which unfortunately, the school isn't putting in place.

gravyriceandchips · 12/01/2023 19:58

@Diverseopinions
The teachers can't watch 30 children simultaneously. My dd teacher said this outright to me.

We are having very similar issues in my Dd class. She is 9.

One child is aggressive.

It's awful for all of them in that classroom at times. Teacher included.

I don't know what the answer is for any of it.

Diverseopinions · 12/01/2023 19:56

I wonder what the school's risk assessment has been?

Diverseopinions · 12/01/2023 19:55

Postapocalypticcowgirl · 12/01/2023 18:27

I'm very aware of this- it's part of the reason all education staff should be in a union and assert their rights in these cases. If a member of staff actually goes to the head with a union rep present and says they feel at risk of harm, the head can't just shrug it off.

A lot of primaries subject their staff to behaviour that would not be tolerated in secondaries, but there's no legal duty on primary schools to do this.

Staff need to be properly trained in physical restraint and management techniques and then you employ the suitable staff to be 1:1 support workers who can manage to apply the training and sustain close supervision of the child who displays aggression. You have to recruit the right people. You can't say 'Here is our complement of staff who want to work in this school, and they are all going to take turns working with this very challenging and aggressive child. ' Of course an untrained and physically unsuited person is going to feel vulnerable working with a child they lack the skills to work with.

The school is there to meet the needs of the children on roll, and if they haven't got anyone who can do the job, they need to recruit or tell the LA they cannot meet their needs, and it isn't safe to have them on site.