Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

How disruptive does a child have to be to be removed from Primary School?!

262 replies

Juggletits · 11/01/2023 10:43

Ongoing saga at our primary school. One child has been hugely disruptive since day one - attacking other children (stabbing with pencils, stamping on chests, stomach punches, facial damage with nails or sports equipment amongst many others), attacking teachers, throwing chairs, upending tables and regularly trying to escape.

Last term they brought a pocket knife in to school and showed it to other children, cut his own trousers and threatened other children that he "could stab them"

There is an ever growing list of assaults and incidents against many children and the parent community is absolutely baffled as to why the child has not been removed. They clearly need serious and ongoing support and our school is not set up for a child with such a level of additional needs.

The reason from the HT is that "certain thresholds haven't been met"

Does anyone know what these thresholds are from a legal/professional point of view?

It has reached the point that parents are keeping their children out of school because they are not safe in the classroom.

Multiple emails have been sent to the school, Academy Trust, Ofsted and MARU

What more can be done? An entire school is being disrupted by one child - this cannot be right?!

OP posts:
Emily3325 · 15/01/2023 20:05

Sherrystrull · 15/01/2023 20:03

Didn't you say your experience was 20 years ago?

Our 1:1 staff rotate who they work with throughout the day as some children are violent and it's not fair for the same member of staff facing that throughout every day.

Your comments about chilling for 30 minutes in assembly were particularly offensive. Supporting a child with ASD through a long assembly takes experience and skill, there is no 'chilling' involved.

Not to mention many don’t go into assembly due to the volume of interventions

Sherrystrull · 15/01/2023 20:03

Didn't you say your experience was 20 years ago?

Our 1:1 staff rotate who they work with throughout the day as some children are violent and it's not fair for the same member of staff facing that throughout every day.

Your comments about chilling for 30 minutes in assembly were particularly offensive. Supporting a child with ASD through a long assembly takes experience and skill, there is no 'chilling' involved.

Diverseopinions · 15/01/2023 19:54

Emily3325 · 15/01/2023 19:35

Staff being hit with chairs, head butted, kicked, punched, scratched hard enough to draw blood

What involvement is there from social services, when a child hits an adult with a chair and injures them?

Diverseopinions · 15/01/2023 19:53

Sherrystrull · 15/01/2023 19:35

Oh my goodness you have no idea what life is like for our 1:1 support staff. Please educate yourself before spouting such nonsense.

It's not nonesense, if I have first hand experience. Not all children who are assigned 1:1 staff experience challenging behaviour. Are you saying that all children with ASD in your school are violent? I'm not aware that the incidence of challenging behaviour, co-existing with SEN, has greatly increased. Are saying that all 1:1 support workers in your school are being assaulted?

Sherrystrull · 15/01/2023 19:35

Diverseopinions · 15/01/2023 19:26

Kids in secondary pupil referral units have 1:1s who are with them, at their side, all the time they are in school. The key worker starts a dialogue and negotiate goals and rewards. They use a style which isn't very authoritarian. This type of work could be started in Year 5 and 6, I think. It would be nice if the school OP writes about tried something at all to improve the situation.

I actually think 1:1 TA work is ok. There is plenty of time sitting down supervising the child, which is just looking and being encouraging, without expending a lot of energy. It isn't like working in a small community supermarket, being on the till, standing up, packing bags, and then, when it goes quiet, being sent to stack the shelves. That job looks to me to have no let up. You certainly don't get assemblies which involve sitting chilling, for thirty minutes.

When I worked as a TA, 20 years ago, it was a popular job, which staff enjoyed.

Oh my goodness you have no idea what life is like for our 1:1 support staff. Please educate yourself before spouting such nonsense.

Emily3325 · 15/01/2023 19:35

Diverseopinions · 15/01/2023 19:31

I do agree that a lot needs to be done to prevent injuries. I got hit in the mouth by a flying toy thrown through the air, by a child I was supporting, and had my lip split up. Luckily it healed, and doesn't show, but I was aware that it would have been different if it had been my eye. In that case the environment wasn't properly adapted, because I couldn't get out of the room I was in with them. That's important, constant risk assessment.

Staff being hit with chairs, head butted, kicked, punched, scratched hard enough to draw blood

Diverseopinions · 15/01/2023 19:31

Emily3325 · 15/01/2023 19:15

It makes me so angry how little regard people have for the safety of school staff

I do agree that a lot needs to be done to prevent injuries. I got hit in the mouth by a flying toy thrown through the air, by a child I was supporting, and had my lip split up. Luckily it healed, and doesn't show, but I was aware that it would have been different if it had been my eye. In that case the environment wasn't properly adapted, because I couldn't get out of the room I was in with them. That's important, constant risk assessment.

Emily3325 · 15/01/2023 19:27

Diverseopinions · 15/01/2023 19:26

Kids in secondary pupil referral units have 1:1s who are with them, at their side, all the time they are in school. The key worker starts a dialogue and negotiate goals and rewards. They use a style which isn't very authoritarian. This type of work could be started in Year 5 and 6, I think. It would be nice if the school OP writes about tried something at all to improve the situation.

I actually think 1:1 TA work is ok. There is plenty of time sitting down supervising the child, which is just looking and being encouraging, without expending a lot of energy. It isn't like working in a small community supermarket, being on the till, standing up, packing bags, and then, when it goes quiet, being sent to stack the shelves. That job looks to me to have no let up. You certainly don't get assemblies which involve sitting chilling, for thirty minutes.

When I worked as a TA, 20 years ago, it was a popular job, which staff enjoyed.

20 years ago it may well have been, what you described is nothing like the job currently

Diverseopinions · 15/01/2023 19:26

Kids in secondary pupil referral units have 1:1s who are with them, at their side, all the time they are in school. The key worker starts a dialogue and negotiate goals and rewards. They use a style which isn't very authoritarian. This type of work could be started in Year 5 and 6, I think. It would be nice if the school OP writes about tried something at all to improve the situation.

I actually think 1:1 TA work is ok. There is plenty of time sitting down supervising the child, which is just looking and being encouraging, without expending a lot of energy. It isn't like working in a small community supermarket, being on the till, standing up, packing bags, and then, when it goes quiet, being sent to stack the shelves. That job looks to me to have no let up. You certainly don't get assemblies which involve sitting chilling, for thirty minutes.

When I worked as a TA, 20 years ago, it was a popular job, which staff enjoyed.

Emily3325 · 15/01/2023 19:15

Reugny · 15/01/2023 19:10

There has already been a TA in the UK who had to get compensation for injuries that meant she can't work again due to an attack by a child.

It makes me so angry how little regard people have for the safety of school staff

Diverseopinions · 15/01/2023 19:14

Emily3325 · 15/01/2023 18:52

Where’s the money coming from?
No EHCP, no funding and even then schools must provide the first £10,000 of funding. You’d be hard pressed to find anyone who would be willing to do this job. People can argue about the adult watching the child at all times but that’s physically impossible, not to mention staff need breaks. Burnout amongst 1:1s is ridiculously high because having to be hyper vigilant for hours a day is exhausting

When a staff member has a break, somebody else takes over.

I always watched my son, at all times, when he was in my care, which was when he was not in school or at collegel, or with a carer, until he was 22 years of age. Now his support workers watch him all the time.

It is surely like what parents do with babies and children under the age of four. They are vigilant all the time and watch them, at all times, don't they, and know where the child is?

I did actually work as a TA in a primary school, , supporting children with ASD, one-to-one, when my son was at primary school. Because the environment is safe, you can sit down and be aware of where they are. But that is with ASD children who are also extremely focused on an activity when they enjoy it, and getting engrossed in it. They stand still at a play table or sit and do something for quite long periods, when not kicking off.

The child being described by OP, is different though. He isn't typically ASD, is he? His way of behaving is different. He isn't getting engrossed in one pursuit. He's interacting with other kids, inappropriately. He needs a male mentor. The mentor could engross him in a game of football or something and take control of the agenda, by appealing to the boy's interest and the fact that he is motivated by a hip young mentor and role model.

The school so need to demand funding. Funding is available, but schools and whoever need to know the processes to go through.

Keepfocused · 15/01/2023 19:14

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

JustKeepBuilding · 15/01/2023 19:13

Emily3325 · 15/01/2023 19:07

You’re saying all this with no clue how many many schools run at this current moment. You’re not going to find a member of staff willing to be physically assaulted. We’re heading towards the situation in the US where a teacher was shot with the lack of regards for staff safety

Yes I do. My post you quoted is fact, 2 of the 3 sentences based on the law. The LA can be forced to fund the provision at whatever level it takes to provide it. The pupil’s needs aren’t being met if it reaches the level of physical assault, if those needs are better met those times will reduce.

Reugny · 15/01/2023 19:10

Emily3325 · 15/01/2023 19:07

You’re saying all this with no clue how many many schools run at this current moment. You’re not going to find a member of staff willing to be physically assaulted. We’re heading towards the situation in the US where a teacher was shot with the lack of regards for staff safety

There has already been a TA in the UK who had to get compensation for injuries that meant she can't work again due to an attack by a child.

Emily3325 · 15/01/2023 19:07

JustKeepBuilding · 15/01/2023 18:57

No EHCP, no funding and even then schools must provide the first £10,000 of funding.

High needs top up funding doesn’t require an EHCP. An EHCP can be fully funded and legally the school do not have to fund the first £6k or £10k or whatever.


not to mention staff need breaks.

A well written EHCP will account for lunch and breaks.

You’re saying all this with no clue how many many schools run at this current moment. You’re not going to find a member of staff willing to be physically assaulted. We’re heading towards the situation in the US where a teacher was shot with the lack of regards for staff safety

JustKeepBuilding · 15/01/2023 18:57

No EHCP, no funding and even then schools must provide the first £10,000 of funding.

High needs top up funding doesn’t require an EHCP. An EHCP can be fully funded and legally the school do not have to fund the first £6k or £10k or whatever.


not to mention staff need breaks.

A well written EHCP will account for lunch and breaks.

Emily3325 · 15/01/2023 18:52

Diverseopinions · 15/01/2023 17:45

They shouldn't be female on minimum wage. It would be negligent of a senior management team to give the job of supporting an aggressive pupil to that profile of worker. They need to hire properly trained behaviour mentors who are very physically active and motivational to troubled youngsters. You recruit the staff to match the job, not match the pupils to the profile of those who currently want to work for 38 weeks in a school.

Where’s the money coming from?
No EHCP, no funding and even then schools must provide the first £10,000 of funding. You’d be hard pressed to find anyone who would be willing to do this job. People can argue about the adult watching the child at all times but that’s physically impossible, not to mention staff need breaks. Burnout amongst 1:1s is ridiculously high because having to be hyper vigilant for hours a day is exhausting

JustKeepBuilding · 15/01/2023 18:22

Parents can force LAs to “do something”. Yes it takes time, but it is possible, and this situation has clearly been going on some time. Schools who need more funding to provide support can apply for high needs top up funding.

As part of the EHCNA process advice from an EP must be sought - if the LA can’t do that in house within the statutory timescale they must commission an independent assessment.

Training, qualifications and experience can be specified in EHCPs.

Schools could follow due process and formally exclude.

TheHateIsNotGood · 15/01/2023 18:14

Having a bit of personal experience of a very similar situation, I do ask,as the disruptive dc in question has 2 older siblings, did they display similar behaviours in primary school too?

Then what you've been told about what the neighbours said about the parent's 'parenting skills' would have some merit.

x2boys · 15/01/2023 18:12

lumpofcomfort · 15/01/2023 18:03

Those saying "the LA must do something" - they do not!! It is impossible to get anyone from the local authority in. It takes months if not years. I haven't seen an Educational Psychologist in my school since before Covid. LAs used to have behaviour support specialists who would come in -these no longer exist due to funding cuts.

I have been teaching for 20 years and can say that IME children almost never get removed from primary school these days,
and those that do it will rarely be before years 5 or 6 when they are bigger and stronger and only if space can be found at specialist provision and parents are supportive.

We have many, many children with additional needs, far more than in previous years. Lots of children are coming into Reception with undiagnosed needs. It then takes months or years to get an EHCP and that will only be for the most severe needs. In that time the school has to fund 1:1 support for which there is no money and it is difficult to fund people willing to do the job. There is a crisis in TA recruitment. In my one form entry school we have four non-verbal ASD students in KS1. Two are no trouble and have 1:1 TAs but how much they learn is questionable as there is no training and virtually no access to specialist support from the LA, a real contrast to when I first started teaching.

The third child is mostly non-verbal, a lovely boy but extremely big and strong - too big to be safely physically restrained by an adult if needed (some have tried and been injured). He pushes past other children, jumps fences onto where younger children are playing, climbs furniture and jumps off it. It is very dangerous for the other children but we have no support from the LA for dealing with the risks- all rights are for the inclusion of the child with additional needs. Parents do not want him to attend specialist provision. We are just told to get the other children to move out of the way.

We have another non-verbal child who does nothing but scream and run around the school. He will kick and hit adults and other children, lie down in corridors etc screaming. Parents have no interest in the EHCP process and certainly no interest in specialist provision. They likely have additional needs themselves.

In addition to that we have several other pupils with severe SEMH or behavioural needs. They wil shout, swear, throw things, refuse to folow instructions, regularly leave the classroom. There is no funding for additional support. It is all left for teachers to deal with. It's completely draining and extremely disruptive to the rest of the class. I just wish the minister for Education would spend some time in schools and see what the reality of their funding cuts has been but fat chance.

I teach in a deprived area and I think we see more issues than in "leafy" areas, for a myriad of reasons. We certainly don't have parents that want to take their children out to home educate.

I realise my LEA,is luckier then most as we have two special needs primary schools and Two ASD,hubs,and same for secondary school,I simply can't imagine my own non verbal severely autistic child in a mainstream school,he's been in a special school since reception and he's in year 8 now

lumpofcomfort · 15/01/2023 18:03

Those saying "the LA must do something" - they do not!! It is impossible to get anyone from the local authority in. It takes months if not years. I haven't seen an Educational Psychologist in my school since before Covid. LAs used to have behaviour support specialists who would come in -these no longer exist due to funding cuts.

I have been teaching for 20 years and can say that IME children almost never get removed from primary school these days,
and those that do it will rarely be before years 5 or 6 when they are bigger and stronger and only if space can be found at specialist provision and parents are supportive.

We have many, many children with additional needs, far more than in previous years. Lots of children are coming into Reception with undiagnosed needs. It then takes months or years to get an EHCP and that will only be for the most severe needs. In that time the school has to fund 1:1 support for which there is no money and it is difficult to fund people willing to do the job. There is a crisis in TA recruitment. In my one form entry school we have four non-verbal ASD students in KS1. Two are no trouble and have 1:1 TAs but how much they learn is questionable as there is no training and virtually no access to specialist support from the LA, a real contrast to when I first started teaching.

The third child is mostly non-verbal, a lovely boy but extremely big and strong - too big to be safely physically restrained by an adult if needed (some have tried and been injured). He pushes past other children, jumps fences onto where younger children are playing, climbs furniture and jumps off it. It is very dangerous for the other children but we have no support from the LA for dealing with the risks- all rights are for the inclusion of the child with additional needs. Parents do not want him to attend specialist provision. We are just told to get the other children to move out of the way.

We have another non-verbal child who does nothing but scream and run around the school. He will kick and hit adults and other children, lie down in corridors etc screaming. Parents have no interest in the EHCP process and certainly no interest in specialist provision. They likely have additional needs themselves.

In addition to that we have several other pupils with severe SEMH or behavioural needs. They wil shout, swear, throw things, refuse to folow instructions, regularly leave the classroom. There is no funding for additional support. It is all left for teachers to deal with. It's completely draining and extremely disruptive to the rest of the class. I just wish the minister for Education would spend some time in schools and see what the reality of their funding cuts has been but fat chance.

I teach in a deprived area and I think we see more issues than in "leafy" areas, for a myriad of reasons. We certainly don't have parents that want to take their children out to home educate.

Diverseopinions · 15/01/2023 17:45

Emily3325 · 15/01/2023 17:37

By the time a child is in year 5 or 6 they’re a danger to adults. The vast majority of TAs are females on minimum wage. Why should they be stabbed and physically assaulted. The child needs to be removed from the school and placed in a specialist provision

They shouldn't be female on minimum wage. It would be negligent of a senior management team to give the job of supporting an aggressive pupil to that profile of worker. They need to hire properly trained behaviour mentors who are very physically active and motivational to troubled youngsters. You recruit the staff to match the job, not match the pupils to the profile of those who currently want to work for 38 weeks in a school.

Emily3325 · 15/01/2023 17:37

Diverseopinions · 11/01/2023 13:37

What more can be done is one-to-one support. Primary age children are relatively small. A well-built adult can easily manage their behaviour, given the correct training. As for not checking that the child doesn't have a sharp implement on them - this is very negligent.

The child needs structured play time activities. If there is a likelihood of him stamping on someone, his routines need to be managed and his activities diverted to something more positive. They need time with a mentor. All these ideas are very obvious and all headteachers would know about them.

Ask to see the behaviour policy and try to identify whether it is unfit for purpose, or not being followed.

You maybe need to go beyond the governor's and head and tell the LA that you want your child to go to another school. After all, if the school's behaviour policy is inadequate to manage one single under 11, how could they cope if two or three who had challenges joined at the same time?

By the time a child is in year 5 or 6 they’re a danger to adults. The vast majority of TAs are females on minimum wage. Why should they be stabbed and physically assaulted. The child needs to be removed from the school and placed in a specialist provision

WalkthisWayUK · 15/01/2023 16:26

That aggression is not well managed is very revealing, and quite shameful I think of our education system. There are probably lots of reasons for it, but I know retired teachers who say it has got worse over the years.

There are good examples of where aggression is low to non existent in both mainstream and SEN schools, because they have quality leadership, good practices, clear guidelines.

No child should have to go to school, a place where they have no choice to go, no agency, where they are exposed to harm. Incidents are rarely a surprise ‘one off’ like the OP describes, there is a known child who is a regular risk.

No child with aggression should be so unsupported that their aggression/outbursts continue, whether SEN or not. Again I do think there are very low expectations, children with SEN on the whole, with really good support are able to cope, manage emotions without harm to themselves or others.

Spikeyball · 13/01/2023 09:29

People should not deregister. If they do that the LA will do nothing to support the child and that is likely to last for years especially given the current wait time for Tribunals.
The parent needs to be constantly on the school and LA's case because the bigger 'nuisance' ( time wise) you are, the more likely the child will get the support they need.
Be the difficult parent. Put everything in writing, record all meetings, everything that is said to you verbally should be sent to them in an email as a record of what has been said. Know the law. Find and talk to like-minded parents. Never completely trust professionals. Ignore emotional blackmail.

If your child is getting very distressed then keep them off if you want to but keep them on roll and make complaints about the lack of suitable education being provided.

Swipe left for the next trending thread