Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

How disruptive does a child have to be to be removed from Primary School?!

262 replies

Juggletits · 11/01/2023 10:43

Ongoing saga at our primary school. One child has been hugely disruptive since day one - attacking other children (stabbing with pencils, stamping on chests, stomach punches, facial damage with nails or sports equipment amongst many others), attacking teachers, throwing chairs, upending tables and regularly trying to escape.

Last term they brought a pocket knife in to school and showed it to other children, cut his own trousers and threatened other children that he "could stab them"

There is an ever growing list of assaults and incidents against many children and the parent community is absolutely baffled as to why the child has not been removed. They clearly need serious and ongoing support and our school is not set up for a child with such a level of additional needs.

The reason from the HT is that "certain thresholds haven't been met"

Does anyone know what these thresholds are from a legal/professional point of view?

It has reached the point that parents are keeping their children out of school because they are not safe in the classroom.

Multiple emails have been sent to the school, Academy Trust, Ofsted and MARU

What more can be done? An entire school is being disrupted by one child - this cannot be right?!

OP posts:
JustKeepBuilding · 15/01/2023 22:40

Why don’t you support the parents whose DC need it to pursue lunch and break provision in s.F, via appeal if necessary? As it can and it is possible.

Sherrystrull · 15/01/2023 22:33

It may not be rare but it isn't my experience. My life would be much easier if it were.

JustKeepBuilding · 15/01/2023 22:16

The LA have to pay whatever it takes if the provision is specified and quantified in s.F. I have never come across a school unable to recruit if the funding is increased to the right level.

Having break and lunch covered in s.F isn’t rare. If you search MN you will see other posters mentioning it in their posts on previous threads.

fitzwilliamdarcy · 15/01/2023 22:04

My teacher friends all report same as @Emily3325. Never seen a second TA; getting one that’s prepared to accept any kind of wage to be persistently assaulted is hard enough. I know I’m going to get more responses about EHCPs now but it isn’t always possible to recruit to do this job. It just isn’t.

JustKeepBuilding · 15/01/2023 22:03

Sherrystrull · 15/01/2023 21:48

My school is the same as @Emily3325.
We cannot get enough staff so existing staff are used to cover breaks and lunches. It's an ongoing logistical and timetabling nightmare.

If the pupils in your school with EHCPs aren’t fully funded s.F must not be detailed, specified and quantified &/or the school haven’t forced the LA to fully fund. And if there’s not 1:1 for break and lunch written in to F it can be pursued.

If the EHCP is fully funded but the school can’t fill the 1:1 post(s) with the funding they have they can force the LA to fund the position(s) at a higher rate. I have helped several parents across different LAs force their LA to fund at a higher rate, including one at the level of the teaching MPS. Every time it has resulted in an appropriate appointment. DS3’s 1:1s are funded at HLTA level, not because they couldn’t appoint but because of the provision they need to support/provide and the experience/training/qualifications in his EHCP.

Sherrystrull · 15/01/2023 21:48

My school is the same as @Emily3325.
We cannot get enough staff so existing staff are used to cover breaks and lunches. It's an ongoing logistical and timetabling nightmare.

cabbageking · 15/01/2023 21:29

No one can say.

We do not know staffing levels, the child's needs, language, understanding, triggers, if others are involved, what has been tried, what is working, they may be making small steps, what options there are, what funding and support is in place, what any reports say and if they are a risk to others or not. There is no set threshold it depends on the child, school skills etc. If they are able to control their behaviour in some lessons but not others. Is their behaviour management up to par. Are their gaps in their record keeping. Are they multi disadvantaged. At risk from others and very vulnerable. Only the school have the full picture.

Marcipex · 15/01/2023 21:26

Sounds exactly like the village primary and nothing was ever done.

JustKeepBuilding · 15/01/2023 21:25

That doesn’t mean it is the same in other schools or that it can’t happen. Their EHCPs must not be detailed, specified and quantified &/or your school don’t know, as many don’t, EHCPs can be fully funded.

Emily3325 · 15/01/2023 21:22

JustKeepBuilding · 15/01/2023 21:16

No it’s not. Via MN and IRL I have supported many parents across the country to secure EHCPs and to also secure cover for break and lunchtime.

I can think of 2 children at my school who have a full days funding and that isn’t meaning a second 1:1. It’s another TA drafted in to cover

JustKeepBuilding · 15/01/2023 21:16

No it’s not. Via MN and IRL I have supported many parents across the country to secure EHCPs and to also secure cover for break and lunchtime.

Emily3325 · 15/01/2023 21:13

JustKeepBuilding · 15/01/2023 21:00

Err, no I’m not. It happens in schools up and down the country. For example, DS3 has 2 1:1s written in to his EHCP to ensure break and lunch is covered. The one that covers break and lunch has their break at a different time. It’s always been the same since he got his EHCP many years ago.

Parents may have to appeal, but getting an EHCP for a pupil displaying such behaviour is possible. I have supported many parents in similar situations to do just that.

Then your LA is a unicorn. That is in no way typical

JustKeepBuilding · 15/01/2023 21:06

When I had a violent child in my class they were never unsupported.

That’s as it should be. My post was in response to what should happen if the 1:1 needed a toilet break and there was absolutely no one else to provide 1:1 for the short period of time.


Suggesting a class teacher can adequately support a class and a child with significant and unpredictable needs alone is dangerous.

Again, my post was in response to the poster saying what about toilet breaks. I didn’t say a teacher on their own could adequately support the pupil needing 1:1 and the rest of the class. It was a suggestion when all else has failed so the pupil requiring 1:1 isn’t left unsupported and therefore more likely to become violent and thus the other anxious pupils more anxious. The risk is greater leaving the pupil unsupported.

Sherrystrull · 15/01/2023 21:02

JustKeepBuilding · 15/01/2023 20:53

The class teacher cannot support a child with specific needs that mean they could be violent. What happens if they are violent?

I have seen it work well, more than once. They are more likely to violent if left unsupported. The teacher supporting the pupil directly whilst the 1:1 is on a toilet break wouldn’t change how they dealt with the pupil becoming violent during that time compared to the teacher teaching the class as a whole and the pupil becoming violent whilst being unsupported. It would though reduce the chance of violence. If the pupil became violent whilst there is only the teacher in the classroom they handle the situation like they would any emergency if there wasn’t a pupil with 1:1 in the class.

There aren't tons of spare staff to cover breaks etc.

Again, break and lunch 1:1 can be written into EHCPs so a second 1:1 is funded.

There's no cash in school to provide the staff we need let alone anyone spare.

EHCPs can be fully funded.

The class teacher has a whole class to consider. When I had a violent child in my class they were never unsupported.

I could never just support them and focus on them while responsible for the rest of the class. There were many needs amongst the other children.

The class also included a few very anxious children who would get very upset when the child was violent, other children who given half a chance and a distracted teacher would cause havoc and a child who was did a runner when faced with danger.

Suggesting a class teacher can adequately support a class and a child with significant and unpredictable needs alone is dangerous.

JustKeepBuilding · 15/01/2023 21:00

Err, no I’m not. It happens in schools up and down the country. For example, DS3 has 2 1:1s written in to his EHCP to ensure break and lunch is covered. The one that covers break and lunch has their break at a different time. It’s always been the same since he got his EHCP many years ago.

Parents may have to appeal, but getting an EHCP for a pupil displaying such behaviour is possible. I have supported many parents in similar situations to do just that.

Emily3325 · 15/01/2023 20:57

JustKeepBuilding · 15/01/2023 20:53

The class teacher cannot support a child with specific needs that mean they could be violent. What happens if they are violent?

I have seen it work well, more than once. They are more likely to violent if left unsupported. The teacher supporting the pupil directly whilst the 1:1 is on a toilet break wouldn’t change how they dealt with the pupil becoming violent during that time compared to the teacher teaching the class as a whole and the pupil becoming violent whilst being unsupported. It would though reduce the chance of violence. If the pupil became violent whilst there is only the teacher in the classroom they handle the situation like they would any emergency if there wasn’t a pupil with 1:1 in the class.

There aren't tons of spare staff to cover breaks etc.

Again, break and lunch 1:1 can be written into EHCPs so a second 1:1 is funded.

There's no cash in school to provide the staff we need let alone anyone spare.

EHCPs can be fully funded.

You’re living on a different planet, there are no second 1:1s there just aren’t. Children who throw chairs at staff, bite them and head butt them. Constantly swear and threaten to kill staff and other children do not get these magical EHCPs. They’re bare bones, schools have to fight to get 30 minutes of lunch cover.

JustKeepBuilding · 15/01/2023 20:57

Emily3325 · 15/01/2023 20:51

In my school the deputy and senco are both teachers, the head is very rarely available to cover due to meetings etc.

PPA is protected and asking an adult the child may never have had much interaction with is setting up for a disaster. TAs are timetabled to be somewhere at all times, if a class has 31 children you need 2 adults in the room.

Perhaps 1:1s aren’t out at breaks or lunch time because the headteacher recognises the adult needs a break themselves? 10 minutes to get a drink and use the toilet.

1:1 written into EHCPs is also legally protected. PPA time could be given at a later date if necessary. Providing 1:1 with someone unknown may not have brilliant results but leaving the pupil unsupported is also more likely to set them up “for a disaster”.

if a class has 31 children you need 2 adults in the room.

Only in infants and only if none of the exceptions apply.


Perhaps 1:1s aren’t out at breaks or lunch time because the headteacher recognises the adult needs a break themselves?

Again, a second 1:1 can be written in to EHCPs and funded.

JustKeepBuilding · 15/01/2023 20:53

The class teacher cannot support a child with specific needs that mean they could be violent. What happens if they are violent?

I have seen it work well, more than once. They are more likely to violent if left unsupported. The teacher supporting the pupil directly whilst the 1:1 is on a toilet break wouldn’t change how they dealt with the pupil becoming violent during that time compared to the teacher teaching the class as a whole and the pupil becoming violent whilst being unsupported. It would though reduce the chance of violence. If the pupil became violent whilst there is only the teacher in the classroom they handle the situation like they would any emergency if there wasn’t a pupil with 1:1 in the class.

There aren't tons of spare staff to cover breaks etc.

Again, break and lunch 1:1 can be written into EHCPs so a second 1:1 is funded.

There's no cash in school to provide the staff we need let alone anyone spare.

EHCPs can be fully funded.

Emily3325 · 15/01/2023 20:51

JustKeepBuilding · 15/01/2023 20:40

I have seen it happen in practice so yes I do have an ‘idea’.

With an EHCP prep and paperwork time can be funded in addition to the time supporting their 1:1 pupil. I know it can as DS3’s 1:1s have this and I have supported numerous others to get in included in their DC’s EHCP.

You only have to read MN or even just this thread to see not all 1:1s are out at break and lunch with the pupil they are supporting. Many DC don’t have break and lunchtime funded, although they should.

For toilet breaks there’s many possibilities e.g. the HT, deputy, SENCO if not teaching, any TAs who aren’t working with a pupil with 1:1 specified and quantified in an EHCP, a member of staff on PPA... Failing the availability of another member of staff the class teacher should provide it after setting the class on a task they can complete independently.

In my school the deputy and senco are both teachers, the head is very rarely available to cover due to meetings etc.

PPA is protected and asking an adult the child may never have had much interaction with is setting up for a disaster. TAs are timetabled to be somewhere at all times, if a class has 31 children you need 2 adults in the room.

Perhaps 1:1s aren’t out at breaks or lunch time because the headteacher recognises the adult needs a break themselves? 10 minutes to get a drink and use the toilet.

Sherrystrull · 15/01/2023 20:44

The class teacher cannot support a child with specific needs that mean they could be violent. What happens if they are violent? The class teacher has the rest of the class to look after.

There aren't tons of spare staff to cover breaks etc. All staff are timetabled to the hilt with no room for manoeuvre. There's no cash in school to provide the staff we need let alone anyone spare.

JustKeepBuilding · 15/01/2023 20:40

Emily3325 · 15/01/2023 20:33

Where do you think all these staff are appearing from? There isn’t a back up 1:1 trained staff floating to cover prep and file time, TAs are out every single break and lunch with their 1:1. You honestly have no idea

I have seen it happen in practice so yes I do have an ‘idea’.

With an EHCP prep and paperwork time can be funded in addition to the time supporting their 1:1 pupil. I know it can as DS3’s 1:1s have this and I have supported numerous others to get in included in their DC’s EHCP.

You only have to read MN or even just this thread to see not all 1:1s are out at break and lunch with the pupil they are supporting. Many DC don’t have break and lunchtime funded, although they should.

For toilet breaks there’s many possibilities e.g. the HT, deputy, SENCO if not teaching, any TAs who aren’t working with a pupil with 1:1 specified and quantified in an EHCP, a member of staff on PPA... Failing the availability of another member of staff the class teacher should provide it after setting the class on a task they can complete independently.

Emily3325 · 15/01/2023 20:33

JustKeepBuilding · 15/01/2023 20:31

I don’t think 1:1s sit and do nothing. Far from it. However, breaks and lunches can be, and often are, covered by a second 1:1.

General classroom chaos and a member of staff needing a quick word shouldn’t mean leaving a pupil requiring 1:1 unsupported, especially if they have a history of challenging behaviour. Evidence gathering and writing up and filing should not be happening whilst working 1:1.

If a toilet break outside of break and lunchtime is necessary then if the pupil is volatile or a serious flight risk another member of staff should be called to provide 1:1 for the short duration to ensure the safety of all.

Where do you think all these staff are appearing from? There isn’t a back up 1:1 trained staff floating to cover prep and file time, TAs are out every single break and lunch with their 1:1. You honestly have no idea

JustKeepBuilding · 15/01/2023 20:31

I don’t think 1:1s sit and do nothing. Far from it. However, breaks and lunches can be, and often are, covered by a second 1:1.

General classroom chaos and a member of staff needing a quick word shouldn’t mean leaving a pupil requiring 1:1 unsupported, especially if they have a history of challenging behaviour. Evidence gathering and writing up and filing should not be happening whilst working 1:1.

If a toilet break outside of break and lunchtime is necessary then if the pupil is volatile or a serious flight risk another member of staff should be called to provide 1:1 for the short duration to ensure the safety of all.

Emily3325 · 15/01/2023 20:13

Sherrystrull · 15/01/2023 20:09

Exactly. Assembly time is a perfect time for interventions! We do tons in ours!

I’m baffled by the amount of people who think a 1:1 just sits watching the child all day long, occasionally encouraging and then jumping into action to stop the child as big as them harming someone in the room.

Files, breaks, evidence gathering and writing up, general chaos in the classroom, lunches, toilet breaks, a member of staff needing a quick word. None of these things happen apparently. Just sitting and watching

Sherrystrull · 15/01/2023 20:09

Exactly. Assembly time is a perfect time for interventions! We do tons in ours!