Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

How disruptive does a child have to be to be removed from Primary School?!

262 replies

Juggletits · 11/01/2023 10:43

Ongoing saga at our primary school. One child has been hugely disruptive since day one - attacking other children (stabbing with pencils, stamping on chests, stomach punches, facial damage with nails or sports equipment amongst many others), attacking teachers, throwing chairs, upending tables and regularly trying to escape.

Last term they brought a pocket knife in to school and showed it to other children, cut his own trousers and threatened other children that he "could stab them"

There is an ever growing list of assaults and incidents against many children and the parent community is absolutely baffled as to why the child has not been removed. They clearly need serious and ongoing support and our school is not set up for a child with such a level of additional needs.

The reason from the HT is that "certain thresholds haven't been met"

Does anyone know what these thresholds are from a legal/professional point of view?

It has reached the point that parents are keeping their children out of school because they are not safe in the classroom.

Multiple emails have been sent to the school, Academy Trust, Ofsted and MARU

What more can be done? An entire school is being disrupted by one child - this cannot be right?!

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
hiredandsqueak · 19/01/2023 08:41

@cabbageking parents should be encouraged to appeal to Tribunal to get EHCPs that are specified and quantified so that the school gets adequate fund in g to meet the provision. Just knowing that it's a level 4 EHCP tells me that it's most likely not specified or quantified and the provision can't be costed because the LA have just assigned a band to it.
I went to Tribunal after the SSEN to EHCP transfer left my dd with an EHCP not worth the paper it was written on with Band 1 funding. I think that was about £1500.
Following Tribunal with a specified and quantised EHCP costed provision was £46k the LA were responsible for funding the lot. This was mainstream secondary school.

cabbageking · 19/01/2023 01:24

There have been exclusions where a child has brought in the wrong bag, a fishing knife, a plastic knife, nail scissors, their dads Swiss army knife. None were brought in for any violent reasons but were initially recorded as knife incidents. There is often background info that completely changes the child's reasoning. We have several high level 4 EHCPs and only get about 12k for full time provision.

hiredandsqueak · 16/01/2023 20:43

Tbf I have been astounded at times by how little schools know. LA's ensure they are kept in the dark because it's another way to ration resources. It does make for tricky relationships though when a parent is well informed. I have noticed an influx of SENCos asking questions on parent support boards recently so maybe the worms are turning.

JustKeepBuilding · 16/01/2023 20:04

@Quisquam Me too. I just wasn’t sure what you meant.

@hiredandsqueak last week I heard a brilliant excuse. “We can’t apply for an EHCNA because X has been deferred.” X is a non-verbal child with GDD who should have had an EHCP long before now. That was a new one on me.

Quisquam · 16/01/2023 19:32

Do you mean if the child needs 1:1 or 1:1 and 2 other TAs in the classroom?

I meant 2:1. I have known countless parents, with a DC with SEN with 1:1 in mainstream.

thatparentandthatchild · 16/01/2023 18:41

My username pretty much says where I am coming from.

I was in that position. My child was the 'violent' child in a mainstream school. Although I said to the headteacher I didn't want to know, I know there were complaints and a petition about my child. However what the parents didn't know was that my child has a great long list of diagnoses and I had unsuccessfully been trying to persuade the LA that my child needed a special school for the past 2 and a half years. Amongst my child's great long list was the fact that they had absolutely no understanding whatsoever of the co sequences of their actions. The sort of school my child needed was very few and very far between. Almost all of the schools (SEMH specialist) are run by independent providers. They are also very, very expensive so in almost all circumstances, you'll ride up the street on your pet unicorn before you get a place in one of them. It's MUCH cheaper to keep a child in mainstream with 1-1

My husband and I used to call the school run the walk of shame for very good reasons. When your child is public enemy no1 it's absolutely soul destroying to have to do the school run twice a day knowing that everyone else on the playground hates you. For the posters who have suggested confronting the parent, dont do this. The parent is probably well aware of her child's difficulties already. Having to face irate parents in the playground demanding 'you sort the problem out' doesn't help anyone and is incredibly upsetting. In my case, one parent was spoken to by the police after they threatened violence.

Instead focus on what you CAN do to help. Petitions, evidence logs and the like make it look like you are doing something. You are almost certainly making a difficult situation worse. The school will be well aware of what is happening and will have their own internal log of events. Ask the local authority why SEND provision is so dreadful. Nag central government to actually properly fund children's education. Get information put in the next newsletter about where you can go if you need help because battling a system that's rotten to the core is damned hard work. Why not ask the parent directly if she is OK because chances are she won't be.

SEND education is absolutely dreadful. The system isn't fit for purpose, meets no-ones needs and is woefully underfunded. Although my child is now in a SEMH specialist school it took one hell of a battle to get there. Getting them in the school has left me broken, has hugely affected my health and my career went down the toilet a long time ago when I was forced to give up my job.

hiredandsqueak · 16/01/2023 18:08

JustKeepBuilding · 16/01/2023 17:20

From the PoV of provision specified and quantified in F and funding it is irrelevant whether the pupil is in MS or SS. The provision must be provided regardless of what is normally done, it can be fully funded and the LA must fund it to a level where it can be delivered.

1:1 is actually less common in SS due to the whole environment being better suited for their pupils.

IME schools are usually schooled in LA policy whereas the law is very different and what should be done and what is done is very different.

I completely agree. You only have to look at how many schools perpetuate the myths about needing to have a diagnosis, be 2+ years behind, already having £6k spent on them, 2 cycles of assess/plan/do/review… in order to get an EHCNA.

Exactly neither ds nor dd were ever behind academically and both had their SSEN/EHCP in place before they started nursery. Was much easier to secure when schools weren't involved.
The EHCP with costed provision of £46k was the one I appealed on SSEN to EHCP transfer had band 1 funding. The school had no idea they were being shafted by the LA and would have in turn shafted my dd as they couldn't have made the provision on the miserable funding LA proposed.

JustKeepBuilding · 16/01/2023 17:46

although if any child needed that kind of support, I would be wondering why they were in mainstream.

Do you mean if the child needs 1:1 or 1:1 and 2 other TAs in the classroom?

DS3 is thriving in MS secondary with full time 1:1 and multiple therapies and other interventions. SS isn’t the right place for him. Although he is only thriving because of his watertight EHCP. He isn’t the only one for whom MS with support is the best option to meet their needs.

Quisquam · 16/01/2023 17:28

This is a specialist school not a mainstream primary barely meeting staffing levels

Nobody gave it to us on a plate; and they had continual staffing problems due to being in the countryside, in a very expensive area.

If it’s specified in the EHCP, then it has to be provided - although if any child needed that kind of support, I would be wondering why they were in mainstream. However, if all the local specialist provision were full, and the parents did not have the resources to take it to tribunal to argue, the presence of one more did not affect the efficient education of the rest; then such a child could remain in mainstream, I guess, at least at primary.

JustKeepBuilding · 16/01/2023 17:20

From the PoV of provision specified and quantified in F and funding it is irrelevant whether the pupil is in MS or SS. The provision must be provided regardless of what is normally done, it can be fully funded and the LA must fund it to a level where it can be delivered.

1:1 is actually less common in SS due to the whole environment being better suited for their pupils.

IME schools are usually schooled in LA policy whereas the law is very different and what should be done and what is done is very different.

I completely agree. You only have to look at how many schools perpetuate the myths about needing to have a diagnosis, be 2+ years behind, already having £6k spent on them, 2 cycles of assess/plan/do/review… in order to get an EHCNA.

Emily3325 · 16/01/2023 17:10

Quisquam · 16/01/2023 14:39

You’re living on a different planet, there are no second 1:1s there just aren’t.

DD1 was in a specialist school, in a class of 6 students with a teacher and two TAs. The LA funded her for 1:1 support in class, in addition to the three adults already there, as per the Tribunal decision. Admittedly not because of her behaviour; but to keep her focused on the task in hand. It all cost six figures; but the Tribunal’s attitude was that was the only way to meet her SEN, so the cost was irrelevant.

This is a specialist school not a mainstream primary barely meeting staffing levels

hiredandsqueak · 16/01/2023 14:52

My son had a TA who supported him the majority of the day and a second TA who covered the first hour of the afternoon so that his TA could have lunchtime. It worked well because if his TA was ever off unwell or had an appointment the second TA would cover so it wasn't somebody unfamilliar.
My dd's EHCP came with £46k costed provision after SENDIST, LA were responsible for funding the whole lot.
IME schools are usually schooled in LA policy whereas the law is very different and what should be done and what is done is very different. Schools can help by pointing parents in the direction of IPSEA and SOSSEN.

Quisquam · 16/01/2023 14:39

You’re living on a different planet, there are no second 1:1s there just aren’t.

DD1 was in a specialist school, in a class of 6 students with a teacher and two TAs. The LA funded her for 1:1 support in class, in addition to the three adults already there, as per the Tribunal decision. Admittedly not because of her behaviour; but to keep her focused on the task in hand. It all cost six figures; but the Tribunal’s attitude was that was the only way to meet her SEN, so the cost was irrelevant.

Staffielove23 · 16/01/2023 13:55

That’s shocking. Don’t really have any advice but hope you find a solution.

JustKeepBuilding · 16/01/2023 10:43

@solidaritea I wish the system was different too. DC whose parents know the system, can advocate and enforce their rights get better support. It shouldn’t be like that, but it isn’t going to change any time soon, sadly.

Local support varies considerably from helpful to harmful. Some areas have a local independent organisation with a better reputation, it’s worth seeing whether you do. For example, in my LA SENDIASS and the parent carer service are in the LA’s pocket, but there is a much better truly independent service. For full disclosure I work a few hours a week for them.

Enforcing provision specified and quantified in F (presumably it is as you say legally entitled) is one of the most straightforward to help with. Not easy, but straightforward.

In the first instance send the Director of Children’s Services this IPSEA model letter. I amend the second to last paragraph to explicitly state if the provision isn’t provided you (when written from the perspective of the parents)/the parents will be forced to pursue judicial review proceedings (I do this as the mere mention of JR often means the LA listen) and remove the section about contacting the complaints department as SOSSEN advise, in most cases, not to go down the complaints route as it acknowledges there’s an alternative remedy to JR. If possible it is best if you can get it to come from the parents as the LA are more likely to take the threat of JR seriously.

If that doesn’t work don’t get drawn into going back and forth. It rarely works and isn’t up for discussion. The LA need to see you/the parents are serious about enforcing rights as this is when they often concede. Direct parents to SOSSEN for help with a pre-action letter. This mostly works, only a minority actually get to a hearing. Apologies if you already know this.

I understand the above might not go down well with the powers that be in your school as they may be named in any proceedings e.g. as an interested party, and, depending on specifics, the school not following the EHCP could result in parents pursuing a disability discrimination case, but in the long run it will make everyone’s life easier.

BTW I know what it is like for the LA to be fed up of you for not allowing them to act unlawfully. It has advantages, with my own 2 with EHCPs and if I’m supporting another parent they know I know the law and won’t be fobbed off. On the other hand DS3’s school (DS1 has EOTAS) love me as his EHCP is excellent and fully funded and I have helped/am helping others get the same.

solidaritea · 16/01/2023 07:00

I don't say you did, or think you did, want me to spend every second of my life fighting with the LA, and I apologies if it came across like that.

The reality of my school currently is that 25 families aren't even receiving what they are legally entitled to. I have to prioritize this and am probably flagged as a trouble maker for it. I have signposted these families to local support but none of them have had a change in outcome because of it. I will try signposting to different agencies too as I know you're right - most want what their child needs, they just don't feel confident in getting it.

I see the work you do to support parents on here - you're an amazing advocate - and wish that some of our parents could take advantage so we didn't feel we were failing their children. The parent of the child in the OP might be similar, and just accepts that their child won't get the support they need. I wish the system just listened the first time...

Sherrystrull · 16/01/2023 06:35

Things have changed massively in the last few years. Massively. My experiences of school 20 years ago mirror yours.

Staff working with children who require a 1:1 need to know the reality of what life will be like. There's no point pretending otherwise. We've had so many problems when the staff have joined to work with a child and it be much harder than they envisaged.

JustKeepBuilding · 16/01/2023 00:17

Having supported many (at least a few hundred) parents through the process over the years I am more than aware for many reasons some parents struggle to appeal, which is why I said they should be supported. In my experience the majority of parents who to the outside world don’t seem to want to appeal are scared, unsure of how to, have poor MH/SEN of their own, or don’t think they can do it and instead of going into their reasons state they don’t want to. The right support can overcome this 99% of the time. That’s not to say it’s easy or the first kind of support is the right one for that particular family.

I am aware a minority of parents don’t want an EHCP, but I was discussing those who have applied/already have one.

Forever42 · 16/01/2023 00:11

Many EHCPs are initially not worth the paper they are written on. This is why it’s important parents are supported to appeal. Same goes for refusals to assess and refusals to issue.

This assumes that the parents are willing and capable to fight for an EHCP. This is far from the case everywhere. You sound extremely knowledgeable and pro-actice but, believe me, there are many parents out there who either don't want the hassle, don't see the point or can't see the importance, no matter how hard you work to support them with the process. Some parents actively don't want an EHCP as they see it as labelling. They just assume the school will magically deal with their child.

Diverseopinions · 15/01/2023 23:56

fitzwilliamdarcy · 15/01/2023 22:04

My teacher friends all report same as @Emily3325. Never seen a second TA; getting one that’s prepared to accept any kind of wage to be persistently assaulted is hard enough. I know I’m going to get more responses about EHCPs now but it isn’t always possible to recruit to do this job. It just isn’t.

When I worked in a primary school as a 1:1 support worker, there would be children who joined the school and who would hit out at staff and kick, but their behaviour completely calmed down, after a while, thanks to the effectiveness of the strategies being used, and, often they achieved good things, afterwards. A couple I remember, who were difficult, started mainstream secondary school, and got themselves there, independently, and by the bus. I think that often schools can ameliorate behaviour. That is when there is some outreach support.

JustKeepBuilding · 15/01/2023 23:54

solidaritea · 15/01/2023 23:36

What charities and services?

Every EHCP we are granted, after the 20+ hours of compiling paperwork, is crap. We have to fight to even get them and can't spend every second of our lives fighting with the LA. If someone else could do it for us, that would be great.

I listed some in one of my pp, in case you missed them and more - IPSEA, SOSSEN, NAS, Contact, Support SEND kids, NFIS, Parents in Need… SENDIASS and local parent carer services if your LA’s are any good. More informally there are numerous Facebook pages and MN SN boards are helpful. Also, informing parents Legal Aid is available for those who qualify.

Many EHCPs are initially not worth the paper they are written on. This is why it’s important parents are supported to appeal. Same goes for refusals to assess and refusals to issue.

I didn’t say you had to spend every second of your live fighting with the LA.

Diverseopinions · 15/01/2023 23:51

Sherrystrull · 15/01/2023 20:03

Didn't you say your experience was 20 years ago?

Our 1:1 staff rotate who they work with throughout the day as some children are violent and it's not fair for the same member of staff facing that throughout every day.

Your comments about chilling for 30 minutes in assembly were particularly offensive. Supporting a child with ASD through a long assembly takes experience and skill, there is no 'chilling' involved.

I mentioned that I am not only the mother of an autistic child, but I have worked as a TA supporting a child with ASD, that is with different children. I am referring to my own experience.

Children with ASD are not challenging for all of the time, as a rule. It was , indeed, quite relaxing down time' for me to sit while the children listened to the assembly, because my charges were not difficult, at all times. I would keep my eyes trained on them, but often no response was needed. And this is the nature of the job: there are times of being very active and times when it is more about being attentive, but allowing the child to explore, in their learning.

This is getting silly, because many people apply to work as TAs, in many areas, and the job is not unrelenting misery. Nor would the presentations of ASD have changed across the population, since I worked in schools as an LSA. It can't be the case that children who display challenging behaviour are in crisis, continuously, now in 2023, when they were not when I last worked in school.

. Children with ASD do sit quietly, for some of the time. As a TA, you will be skilled and experienced, and there will be periods of down time, relatively speaking. Relative that is, to other jobs, such as working in a small supermarket or a cafe, where you would be constantly serving or arranging stock, and constantly on the go. . That is the nature of the caring role, that there are times of intense activity and times when your input is not required, on a minute to minute basis.

It is possible, that more children with SEN are being taught in mainstream than previously. But, I think management and knowing how to support learners is important, wherever children are taught.. In my son's special school, there were challenges, but the staff, by and large enjoyed working there, and if they didn't, it had more to do with the management style, than the behaviour of the children. Staff had been working in that setting for more than 20 years. They felt that they belonged to a team and that they had support from colleagues. They were suited to the work. Some of them had children or nephews with ASD, and so they knew what to expect and had understanding.

Of course staff rotate. That would be good practice.

In your place if work, do you really say: 'This child is violent'? Do you not express it: 'This child may display behaviour which challenges?' Much has changed, perhaps.

solidaritea · 15/01/2023 23:36

JustKeepBuilding · 15/01/2023 22:43

It would make your life easier in the long run. Even if you just mentioned to parents it is possible at their next AR and signposted them to charities and services who can support them further.

What charities and services?

Every EHCP we are granted, after the 20+ hours of compiling paperwork, is crap. We have to fight to even get them and can't spend every second of our lives fighting with the LA. If someone else could do it for us, that would be great.

JustKeepBuilding · 15/01/2023 22:43

It would make your life easier in the long run. Even if you just mentioned to parents it is possible at their next AR and signposted them to charities and services who can support them further.

Sherrystrull · 15/01/2023 22:41

JustKeepBuilding · 15/01/2023 22:40

Why don’t you support the parents whose DC need it to pursue lunch and break provision in s.F, via appeal if necessary? As it can and it is possible.

I'll add it to my list.