Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Getting rejected for houses because we have dc

192 replies

Whatsthestitch · 10/01/2023 23:17

Little bit of a click bait but partly true

Me and dp currently live with an abusive parent and we are trying to leave. I have had dc so can't work and am on uc. Dp works full time. Even though we have money for a depoist and holding depoist I still don't understand how we can afford to move out!

Has anyone had experience of moving out on housing benefit? How did it work for you. I can't see any landlord accepting our situation and as our budget is so small (900pcm) most flats we see say they aren't family/children suitable. I didn't even think of the possibility of landlords/ladies discriminating against children. Surely a family of 3 living in a 1 bedroom isn't that overcrowded or absurd given the current climate. I'm willing to get a part time job but even that will only be about 2 days max as it will be family looking after dc for free childcare.

Help! Seeking advice and posting for traffic

OP posts:
Pearlygates · 11/01/2023 10:12

@tattygrl I don't read daily mail (like NEVER) and I did advise OP to get a job even if its only evenings! I thought that was decent advice?

Salome61 · 11/01/2023 10:12

I was turned down for a private rental and was very surprised - but then I found out the agency had used a 'formula' to see if I could afford it on my income. It's in the range of 30 x rent.

This calculator might help you to see what you need to earn to get a place with the space you need.

rentright.co.uk/calcrent/

toddlermom99 · 11/01/2023 10:09

Whatsthestitch · 10/01/2023 23:29

@Babyroobs you aren't allowed to claim UC whilst on housing benefit. It's why I have to cancel my uc claim now to make us eligible for housing

I'm confused?

I'm on UC. I get full entitled housing cost element (up to £625 is the max based on my area, DC etc) and also get my universal credit (standard allowance + child element)

It's all paid in one chunk and then I pay my landlord out of that.

You can most definitely get housing costs within universal credit. That's what universal credit is - basically a bunch of benefits merged into one payment.

Teateaandmoretea · 11/01/2023 10:07

@OhMonDieux so what do you think social housing is actually for if it isn’t for young families who can’t afford private rentals?

Squamata · 11/01/2023 10:07

For a landlord, the key things they could worry about would be:

  • you currently live with a parent - no history showing you're a good tenant
  • you only have one income so more risk if you lose job etc
  • your baby could start to draw on walls/be sick on carpet/pull things down
  • your baby could cause noise nuisance
  • you probably would move out fairly soon
  • you sound like a young couple - you could break up, father goes off and you can't pay the rent, landlord is left having to evict a mother and child and lose rent income
  • a child is more likely to injure themselves and bring a claim against the landlord

You'd probably be in a better position if you have two incomes and have a rental history - even if it means renting somewhere you're not that keen on in a location you don't like.

mindutopia · 11/01/2023 10:02

Not discrimination, just that landlords want tenants who look like they can manage financially. If you would struggle to afford nursery costs, you would surely struggle to afford rent? And people renting a 1br would be looking to rent to a couple, not a couple with a small child, as they are unlikely to be long-term tenants (a 3 year old in a 1br is not the same as a 1 year old for most people).

That and it's shit out there at the moment. We moved out of rented a year ago. Our landlord jacked the rent up to £1600pcm and people (most of them single people - this was a 4br house) were falling over themselves to get in for a viewing. In the end, he rented to a family with 4 children, who were being homeschooled, only 1 parent working outside the home. How they were affording that, I have no idea, but I think he definitely had a soft spot for them knowing they would struggle to find anywhere else.

Squamata · 11/01/2023 10:01

Are you quite young, OP? You seem to be looking at this as if the system should be designed to give you a break. Maybe it should, but it isn't.

Housing isn't approached as a human right, but as a market place and providers are free to choose their tenants as they wish, so long as they keep to the law and don't discriminate against things like race, sexuality etc (even then it's quite hard to prove). If a landlord doesn't want to do business with you, they don't have to.

I've seen what kids can do to a rental place, from a landlord's perspective letting to a couple is better than squeezing in a family of three, as pp have said.

You don't say how the parent you're living with is abusive, is it possible you're just all frustrated and you're expecting too much and need to adjust your expectations? Allowing a child, their partner and grandchild to live with you is a big ask. I can't tell the full situation from what you've said.

I'd get along to CAB for detailed advice on your benefits situation, then make a plan for the next few years that gets you where you want to go. It might be worth taking some hours of a job you don't like much now to stand you in better stead for a better job when you get more childcare hours when DC is 3.

Overall you sound quite passive, you live with one parent, have the offer of free childcare from another. It's not the worst of all worlds. It's fine to want more but it's not just going to fall into your lap.

OhMonDieux · 11/01/2023 09:50

@tattygrl Really? You accuse people of being 'Daily Mail readers ' and an offence to suggest parents support the child they chose to have? And scuttle off the the CAB to see if they can get council housing?

So somehow it's wrong to suggest ways for parents support their own kids?

EndlessRain1 · 11/01/2023 09:46

You title is misleading. You aren't being rejected because you have a child, you just don't have enough money for suitable accomodation. It is not discrimination for a landlord to consider it inappropriate for 3 people to live in a one bed appartment - it causes more damage and like others say you are more likely to move out sooner.

That said, I am sure some LLs do discriminate against more "difficult" or stable tenants. Of course it's better for a landlord to have a professional couple where both work as it's greater financial secuirty and less chance of damage than a one income family with 5 kids and 3 dogs.

Lastly, I think if you really wanted to work you could find a way. What do you think most people with kids who rely on 2 incomes do?

Dixiechickonhols · 11/01/2023 09:45

What hours does dp work? Easiest way is to work around him so you don’t need much childcare.
If he is 9-5 Lots of jobs would be happy with availability 2 full days a week, 2 full weekend days. Or evenings or early mornings. Supermarkets, fast food. My dc works around college and puts in her availability at McDonald’s she does 5-11pm or weekend shifts. Our big Tesco has evening shelf stackers.

tattygrl · 11/01/2023 09:43

Teateaandmoretea · 11/01/2023 08:07

AIBU isn’t the right place for this OP. Just the daily mail mob telling you to work harder. This won’t help really because even if you manage to get a 2 bed the landlord can then evict you again at any time they fancy.

The reality is that this is exactly what social housing is for. Go to CAB/ real mumsnetters with experience often suggest contacting Shelter for advice.

This. Already seen a few "there's no excuse", might as well get my bingo card out for a few "people don't want to work any more"s and "I used to work 12 hours a day then my partner would work the next 12 hours with no childcare, we made it work".

Also don't rely on this forum for benefits info.

You need to go to Citizen's Advice and explain your situation, and see what the reality of your options are in your area. Any advice given here will likely not be useful for your specific situation and location.

Good luck.

OhMonDieux · 11/01/2023 09:42

Surely a family of 3 living in a 1 bedroom isn't that overcrowded or absurd given the current climate.

You say LLs have discriminated against you but at the same time you say you can only afford £900pm. Presumably that is for a 1-bed flat.

Are you being rejected for properties you view?

Your child is 1. In a year or less they will be in a bed, not a cot.
How do you intend to do that in a 1-bed flat?
How would this work longer term?
Your child would need to be 3 before you qualify for free childcare.

You need to get a job depending on your qualifications - supermarkets, doing the evening shift, care work, cleaning, admin work from home (if you have the skills), bar and restaurant work.
There are hundreds and thousands of vacancies. Businesses are crying out for staff.

Bijou23 · 11/01/2023 09:41

Chantelle302412 · 11/01/2023 01:07

I claim UC, I began my claim with UC 3 months before I got my flat and they just added the housing element on and in October they added the childcare element on for my 1 year old where they pay 85% of my childcare costs so I pay £40/60 on top of what they do to send my child to a childminder 2 days every week. So I’m sure you’d be able to do that if you and your partner aren’t earning totally enough to support you it’s worth checking out.

and nobody in the right mind would let you move into a one bed with a one year old it’s one crowded even the council wouldn’t move you into a one bedroom flat as a family of 3. Xx

Council have put many people in one bed flats with one child or more...: and still do to this day unfortunately, that happened to us once, was a nightmare. Never again.

NameChangePoP · 11/01/2023 09:40

Of course you can work. If you qualify for Housing Benefit then you will qualify for Universal Credit. That will cover the rent element as well as up to 85% of your childcare costs.
Childminders are cheaper than nurseries and are more flexible with hours.
As much as I'd have loved to have been a stay at home Mum, I couldn't afford it and went back to work. It's what you have to do if you want to move out and get your own home?

Lilyhop · 11/01/2023 09:40

Would the person you live with throw you out ? If they inform the council, you will then be homeless and given accommodation. It could be a hostel or even a bed and breakfast to start with, but they have to help you.
go on the council list? Would you be prepared to move out of your area if there is more chance of you securing a home?
Also, if you do work and you claim UC, you will be better off. You will get a lot of money off the childcare bill!

Bijou23 · 11/01/2023 09:38

Whatsthestitch · 10/01/2023 23:29

@Babyroobs you aren't allowed to claim UC whilst on housing benefit. It's why I have to cancel my uc claim now to make us eligible for housing

Housing benefit would get switched over to your uc as uc is all in one now, you should be able to claim still & shouldn't of closed it.

Dinoswearunderpants · 11/01/2023 09:38

ClubhouseGift · 11/01/2023 09:33

It’s a landlords market. So of course they’re going to pick the best people for their property: two working adults, no pets, no DC. The latter two complicate matters.

They’re not a charity and they don’t have a responsibility to house you.

I personally would rather rent to a family and we're fine with pets (reasonable pets of course). I think it's nice knowing the property is a family home and generally families want to take better care of the space.

Two working parents or one good earner is ideal though.

Bijou23 · 11/01/2023 09:37

Babyroobs · 10/01/2023 23:22

It's likely not discrimination it's just that in many areas there is a severe shortage of rental properties so landlords, if faced with the choice will likely go with a couple where both are working and with no kids rather than reliant partly on benefits and with a young child who could cause damage etc to the property or if it's a flat could cause noise etc to neighbours. So at the moment landlords can likely choose between many tenants as multiple people clamour for properties.

So could the people that work though? They could cause damage just as much as someone who claimed housing benefit? Just because they may work doesn't make them any better of a personHmm

FriedEggChocolate · 11/01/2023 09:35

Whare area of the country arer you in @Whatsthestitch ?

workinmums · 11/01/2023 09:34

I'm not a LL but if I were, I would only take on tenants who could pass the affordability check and preferably no children depending on the size of the property and most likely professionals.

I would be very very selective when it came to the tenants I choose.

LL's are in the business to make money, they're not a charity (A LL actually told me this many years ago when I was renting after I complained about her increasing the rent) I didn't understand it then, but I do now!

DivorcedAndDelighted · 11/01/2023 09:34

Since June 2019 there has been a legal restriction on the amount of deposit landlords can hold, only 5 weeks' rent. The penalties for even accidentally taking more than this are severe. This has changed the rental market because often the landlord can't hold enough deposit to be adequately protected against the possible damage. Add to that the fact that, if the tenant simply stops paying rent, it generally takes at least 6 months and more commonly a year to get the property back, plus several thousand pounds in legal fees. During all this time the landlord still has to pay the property costs eg mortgage. It means that accepting tenants who are on low incomes etc is now more of a financial risk, so agents tend to recommend stringent checks.

I was happy to have tenants have tenants on HB/UC because if it's paid direct, you know the rent will be paid. But the tenant can start out this way then ask for the benefit to be paid direct to themselves and say they'll pay the landlord. The landlord can't stop this. Or the tenant can tell you their claim is in process, but not do it. I had tenants do a runner owing several thousand in rent, leaving the property in an awful state needing repairs costing £5k. I was still not even able to find new tenants until processes had been gone through to legally establish that the previous tenants had abandoned the tenancy. Because even though they'd not paid most of their rent for some time, and even though they'd clearly done a runner after trashing the place, they had a right to return unless due legal process had been gone through, and that takes time and money.
It's a really tough one - we can all understand why tenant protections are there, but every time there is a new legal restriction or a local council brings in its own requirements for minimum space per occupant etc, it has the effect of reducing availability, and taking more properties out of the private rental market. This probably benefits those looking to buy by increasing supply, but it makes things harder for those who, right now, need to rent.

ClubhouseGift · 11/01/2023 09:33

It’s a landlords market. So of course they’re going to pick the best people for their property: two working adults, no pets, no DC. The latter two complicate matters.

They’re not a charity and they don’t have a responsibility to house you.

OhMonDieux · 11/01/2023 09:30

Did you think all of this through before having a child?

Most responsible parents would ensure that one of them was earning enough to support a child if the other parent didn't work.

Or, you would have a job that paid enough to allow you to fund child care.

Why go ahead and have a child when you are not living independently in the first place?

I'm sorry but it looks as if you didn't predict your financial circumstances and expect to rely on benefits.

All you can do it work when your partner is able to look after your child.

That means evening and weekend work, or some kind of work where you can work from home.

@SchrodingersKettle By a family of 3, the OP means 2 adults and one child.

BeeDavis · 11/01/2023 09:30

”I have had dc so can't work” - you lost me at this comment. You can work. You’re choosing not to. Millions of parents work. Did you not know how much childcare was going to be when you decided to have a child? Poor planning. You need an evening/weekend job to fit around your OH’s hours if you don’t want to have childcare costs.

bringmetheheadofpastaalfredo · 11/01/2023 09:28

You can't get a jobe because you have one young child? What do you think everyone else does?
Get a job, use childcare, earn more money and you will be able to rent.

Swipe left for the next trending thread