Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Unfair to stop friendship due to mental illness?

117 replies

dragondepressed · 10/01/2023 21:42

Over the years I have had people who I thought were my friends sever contact due to my mental illness. Five years ago I was voluntarily admitted into a psychiatric hospital for about three weeks. Then in 2019, I was sectioned for two weeks then I had a psychotic episode in the same year which led to me sending rambling emails to people, thinking I was being accused of horrible things and crimes and going to be killed with machetes and wanting to kill myself before this happened so I would die less painfully. The last 13 years of my life have been ruined by mental illness. One psychiatrist suggested I had Complex PTSD, another mentioned Borderline Personality Disorder, a different one then suggested I suffer from Paranoid Schizophrenia. Throughout all this, I have had 'friends' sever contact and end the friendship I thought we had. I have no friends and I'm probably going to end up like that woman who died in her flat and nobody bothered/cared so her body wasn't discovered for two years. Do people not want to be friends with people going through mental illness?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
scrumpf · 28/02/2023 19:02

jumanjigertrude · 26/02/2023 22:17

What 90% of responses make clear. Lessons to be learnt.

  1. It is detrimental to be friends with someone with a mental illness.
  2. Being upfront about your past mental health problems will scare people away.
  3. People suffering from mental illnesses are a burden on friends.
  4. Being friends with someone with a mental illness can be too intense for most people.
  5. The negativity and danger around extreme behaviours during a psychiatric episode are unacceptable. Of course, any dangerous situations that one has been put in are unforgivable.
  6. The bad times outweigh the good times when it comes to dealing with friends with mental health problems.
  7. Mental illnesses can make people selfish and attention-seeking.
  8. People going through psychiatric episodes are unable to keep boundaries in most cases.
  9. It is too draining to deal with a friend who has mental health problems.
10. Any support given by the mentally ill friend to the other friend is negated by their mental illness, as it is too draining. 11. It is too much pressure to deal with someone mentally unstable, especially if one has their own problems in life to deal with. 12. There is the very real, possible danger of mentally ill friends dragging you down with them. 13. People with mental illnesses tend to be abusive and use others. 14. It is too much hard work to be friends with someone with a mental illness. 15. To protect one's own mental health, it is best to avoid being friends with someone with mental health issues. It's not just about them. 16. Only confide in mental health professionals and mental health helplines. DO NOT CONFIDE IN FRIENDS ABOUT YOUR SUICIDAL FEELINGS AND STRUGGLES. 17. FIRST SEEK HELP FROM MEDICAL PROFESSIONALS TRAINED IN MENTAL HEALTH PROBLEMS AND SUICIDAL FEELINGS: FRIENDS AND FAMILY ARE NOT TRAINED TO DEAL WITH THIS. IT CAN JUST MAKE THINGS WORSE AS THEY WILL BE FRIGHTENED.

I have MH difficulties. I'm not equipped to deal with the struggles of others.

XenoBitch · 26/02/2023 23:38

jumanjigertrude · 26/02/2023 22:17

What 90% of responses make clear. Lessons to be learnt.

  1. It is detrimental to be friends with someone with a mental illness.
  2. Being upfront about your past mental health problems will scare people away.
  3. People suffering from mental illnesses are a burden on friends.
  4. Being friends with someone with a mental illness can be too intense for most people.
  5. The negativity and danger around extreme behaviours during a psychiatric episode are unacceptable. Of course, any dangerous situations that one has been put in are unforgivable.
  6. The bad times outweigh the good times when it comes to dealing with friends with mental health problems.
  7. Mental illnesses can make people selfish and attention-seeking.
  8. People going through psychiatric episodes are unable to keep boundaries in most cases.
  9. It is too draining to deal with a friend who has mental health problems.
10. Any support given by the mentally ill friend to the other friend is negated by their mental illness, as it is too draining. 11. It is too much pressure to deal with someone mentally unstable, especially if one has their own problems in life to deal with. 12. There is the very real, possible danger of mentally ill friends dragging you down with them. 13. People with mental illnesses tend to be abusive and use others. 14. It is too much hard work to be friends with someone with a mental illness. 15. To protect one's own mental health, it is best to avoid being friends with someone with mental health issues. It's not just about them. 16. Only confide in mental health professionals and mental health helplines. DO NOT CONFIDE IN FRIENDS ABOUT YOUR SUICIDAL FEELINGS AND STRUGGLES. 17. FIRST SEEK HELP FROM MEDICAL PROFESSIONALS TRAINED IN MENTAL HEALTH PROBLEMS AND SUICIDAL FEELINGS: FRIENDS AND FAMILY ARE NOT TRAINED TO DEAL WITH THIS. IT CAN JUST MAKE THINGS WORSE AS THEY WILL BE FRIGHTENED.

Is this a way of calling out people who genuinely struggle with the mental ill heath of others? And saying to those with MH issues that no one but professionals care about them.. because that is simply untrue.

jumanjigertrude · 26/02/2023 22:17

What 90% of responses make clear. Lessons to be learnt.

  1. It is detrimental to be friends with someone with a mental illness.
  2. Being upfront about your past mental health problems will scare people away.
  3. People suffering from mental illnesses are a burden on friends.
  4. Being friends with someone with a mental illness can be too intense for most people.
  5. The negativity and danger around extreme behaviours during a psychiatric episode are unacceptable. Of course, any dangerous situations that one has been put in are unforgivable.
  6. The bad times outweigh the good times when it comes to dealing with friends with mental health problems.
  7. Mental illnesses can make people selfish and attention-seeking.
  8. People going through psychiatric episodes are unable to keep boundaries in most cases.
  9. It is too draining to deal with a friend who has mental health problems.
10. Any support given by the mentally ill friend to the other friend is negated by their mental illness, as it is too draining. 11. It is too much pressure to deal with someone mentally unstable, especially if one has their own problems in life to deal with. 12. There is the very real, possible danger of mentally ill friends dragging you down with them. 13. People with mental illnesses tend to be abusive and use others. 14. It is too much hard work to be friends with someone with a mental illness. 15. To protect one's own mental health, it is best to avoid being friends with someone with mental health issues. It's not just about them. 16. Only confide in mental health professionals and mental health helplines. DO NOT CONFIDE IN FRIENDS ABOUT YOUR SUICIDAL FEELINGS AND STRUGGLES. 17. FIRST SEEK HELP FROM MEDICAL PROFESSIONALS TRAINED IN MENTAL HEALTH PROBLEMS AND SUICIDAL FEELINGS: FRIENDS AND FAMILY ARE NOT TRAINED TO DEAL WITH THIS. IT CAN JUST MAKE THINGS WORSE AS THEY WILL BE FRIGHTENED.
pattihews · 14/01/2023 16:33

I'm sorry to hear about how bad things are for you, Jammi. I don't know your situation, but if you work for an organisation that offers staff health support, can they refer you to a suitable professional?

You say you don't want to talk to a stranger, but there's safety in talking to someone who doesn't know you and whom you won't have to meet again if you don't want to. I wish you the best.

JammiDodgers · 14/01/2023 16:23

I feel like I am very much hijacking the OPs thread and apologies for this- I probably will start my own thread.
My mental health is hanging by a thread as it is. I do not trauma dump or discuss on a regular basis with anyone any thoughts that may be difficult for them to deal with . Absolutely not. I was just asking a question, that was all.

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 14/01/2023 14:20

Suzi89 · 14/01/2023 12:47

But genuinely, what are suicidal people MEANT to do? Not talk about it?

What use is trauma dumping on people around you going to do? It’s not going to improve your mental health.

I agree with this.

Suicidal people should talk about their feelings, absolutely - but with the right people, who can give practical support and answers, and who they aren’t making feel uncomfortable or helpless

pattihews · 14/01/2023 14:05

But genuinely, what are suicidal people MEANT to do? Not talk about it?

I'd suggest the best thing you can do is talk to people who are distanced from you and trained to cope with the emotional stress of having someone with suicidal thoughts confide in them. Family and friends are often too close and emotionally unprepared to cope with the revelation that someone is suicidal. I'd suggest you talk to a professional for your own sake — because the professionals will know the best way to support you — and for the sake of your friends and family, who can be so easily overloaded.

When you tell friends and people close to you that you're suicidal a high proportion of them are likely to feel that you're asking them to save you from yourself and that's very difficult to cope with. I'd suggest that if you are going to tell friends, @JammiDodgers, try and be clear about what you hope to get out of telling them. Are you looking for relief, for practical help, for understanding? I think you need to be really clear with them that you're not expecting to be rescued, because I think a lot of people hear a cry for help and feel that they're being asked to take responsibility for something too big and scary to cope with.

Have you thought about speaking to a psychotherapist, Jammi? You pay them to listen and to cope with the emotional burden of your feelings and to support you professionally. They may be able to support you to talk to the people around you in a way that won't leave them feeling overburdened. I wish you well and hope you find the support you need.

Suzi89 · 14/01/2023 12:47

But genuinely, what are suicidal people MEANT to do? Not talk about it?

What use is trauma dumping on people around you going to do? It’s not going to improve your mental health.

Disabrie22 · 14/01/2023 10:26

I suffer from mental illness but have had therapy, medicated and when things start to tilt - I go back and get more medication/help. As my condition is genetic, my childhood was difficult because one of my parents had the same condition but there wasn’t the medical support, innovation that there is now. It was awful managing their health as a child and now adult as they’ve never been on the right path medically.
My siblings also have the same condition and I’ve had to step back after twenty years with one of them to force them to do what O do. Sounds awful but their illness makes everyone’s lives a misery, the support the need - despite my best efforts is 24/7 and there was a point where I had to give up to get some joy out of life. Now they are on the path at least.
OP, I’m so sorry you are lonely - the more treatment you get, the more support you get, the more your life will improve and your friendships will get easier. It’s not your fault, but people just aren’t equipped always to be the friend you need. I wish you huge luck with recovery and I promise you - you will have friends and it will get better.

Bigbadfish · 14/01/2023 10:16

JammiDodgers · 12/01/2023 22:52

But genuinely, what are suicidal people MEANT to do? Not talk about it?

Talking about it has been widely discussed and pushed and all mental health professionals/ charities / helplines etc advocate it strongly with slogans such as “ talking saves lives” etc etc

Not many people ( me for one ) feel comfortable talking to random strangers at all on helplines etc and so may choose , with huge fear of the reaction, to confide in someone they know and trust.

Yet reading this . Again, my heart sinks as not taking away from the OP , but I rarely discuss or disclose the full , quite serious details of my thoughts and have been pondering sharing them for a while. Now however, I doubt I will
share . Not suggesting I am suicidal myself or anything.

So yes, back to my original question, what are suicidal people meant to do??

What do you expect a layperson to do?
What tools do you think they have to navigate the burden of keeping someone alive?
What about their life and their stresses?
Their work, children, their hobbies for the goodness of their mental health?

AndyWarholsPiehole · 13/01/2023 00:21

So yes, back to my original question, what are suicidal people meant to do??

Seek help from those trained to deal with suicidal people. Doctors, mental health team, A and E, Samaritans and various other help lines are the people/ places you'll get help from.

It's not fair to burden untrained peope with the stress of feeling responsible for making sure you don't kill yourself . It is too much and it is selfish to put that on others.

XenoBitch · 12/01/2023 23:05

JammiDodgers · 12/01/2023 22:52

But genuinely, what are suicidal people MEANT to do? Not talk about it?

Talking about it has been widely discussed and pushed and all mental health professionals/ charities / helplines etc advocate it strongly with slogans such as “ talking saves lives” etc etc

Not many people ( me for one ) feel comfortable talking to random strangers at all on helplines etc and so may choose , with huge fear of the reaction, to confide in someone they know and trust.

Yet reading this . Again, my heart sinks as not taking away from the OP , but I rarely discuss or disclose the full , quite serious details of my thoughts and have been pondering sharing them for a while. Now however, I doubt I will
share . Not suggesting I am suicidal myself or anything.

So yes, back to my original question, what are suicidal people meant to do??

Seek professional help.
For years, I was a huge burden on my friends... offloading my suicidal thoughts and intentions onto them. I lost a few in the process, but the ones that really helped were the ones who called the emergency services.
Being actively suicidal is an emergency. You would not ask a friend to help if you were having a heart attack or stroke.
Unless they have done some sort of reading up on suicide, or did training, your average person will feel well out of their depth when you mention to them your darkest thoughts.

JammiDodgers · 12/01/2023 22:52

daybroke · 10/01/2023 23:21

Someone being actively suicidal and having to support them through that is very very draining.

But genuinely, what are suicidal people MEANT to do? Not talk about it?

Talking about it has been widely discussed and pushed and all mental health professionals/ charities / helplines etc advocate it strongly with slogans such as “ talking saves lives” etc etc

Not many people ( me for one ) feel comfortable talking to random strangers at all on helplines etc and so may choose , with huge fear of the reaction, to confide in someone they know and trust.

Yet reading this . Again, my heart sinks as not taking away from the OP , but I rarely discuss or disclose the full , quite serious details of my thoughts and have been pondering sharing them for a while. Now however, I doubt I will
share . Not suggesting I am suicidal myself or anything.

So yes, back to my original question, what are suicidal people meant to do??

Consufed · 11/01/2023 22:04

This is a powerful but true post.

Thank you Flowers

pattihews · 11/01/2023 14:34

This is a powerful but true post.

No, reality is much more complicated than that. I've know someone with BPD come off their meds because they felt flat and wanted the high they got from the manic stage of their illness. They ended up becoming floridly manic (I think that was the term the psychiatrist used), music blaring day and night from their flat, threatening neighbours and council workers who tried to intervene. My friend Jo's schizophrenic son refused medication that seemed to be helping him on numerous occasions, usually just at the point when it seemed to be working. He preferred to rely on alcohol and illegal drugs and died in his 40s of an overdose. I think self-destructive behaviour is quite common. It's not lazy but it can be a choice.

In my attempt to learn more about BPD I read the memoirs of Kay Jamison, who is a US professor who suffers from BPD and has made its research her life's work. She talks about the temptation to come off her meds in order to live life on a high — and there have been periods of her life in which she has consciously chosen not to medicate in her desire to try and capture a long-lasting high.

She's a heroine in some quarters and seems like a good woman, but I do wonder what life is like for those around her. Family, colleagues, students, friends: I'd like to see their take on it.

ShakespearesBlister · 11/01/2023 13:20

dragondepressed · 11/01/2023 12:50

Maybe I thought too much of the friendships, because they haven't just been one-sided and I have made an effort with people and gone out of my way to do things for them in the past. However, reciprocity doesn't matter when someone feels on edge or scared due to someone else's behaviour during a psychotic episode. Hopefully, I can make new friends in the future and keep people at a distance. It's been nearly four years since my last episode.

You don't necessarily need to keep people at a distance. It's more about knowing when to allow them some distance. Obviously if you are in the middle of an episode you may not be able to read the situation very well and not see when it is time to allow people to have space. With my friend she tends to get more and more needy when she's not doing well and almost treats people like her therapist rather than her friends, and that is when it can get exhausting but she's not able to see it herself so I create that distance myself by just not answering all of her calls. I always say to my friend to ask herself if her expectations might be a bit too high. Often she will phone repeatedly and expect you to just drop everything and spend hours on the phone, then gets upset if you can't because she thinks it means her friends don't have time for her. But the thing is she's asking for too much time too frequently from people which they just can't humanly give because it's not possible, they have lives too and can't just sit around listening to her on the phone all the time. It's about balance I think. Being a friend can mean different things to different people. To me being a friend doesn't mean being stuck on the phone listening to someone offloading for hours, but to my friend that's exactly what a friend is meant to do.

JammiDodgers · 11/01/2023 13:16

Consufed · 11/01/2023 13:09

Regarding getting help and trying harder, usually people do make as much effort as they possibly can to get better. However, there is no sure fix. Sometimes there is no medication which helps enough (in treatment resistant illness). And while long term therapy may help somewhat (if the sufferer can afford anything more than what little the NHS can give), it doesn't always make much difference.

Yes, of course it's OK to have boundaries. You can only do what you can do, within reason. However I think people can be a bit too quick to think sufferers are lazy, don't want to recover, etc.Unfortunately recovery can seem an impossible goal, because a symptom of some mental illnesses is 'knowing' everything is dreadfully wrong and can never be made right.

No-one wants to be having horrific thoughts, to lose all their friends, to feel their life is worth nothing, to lose their job, to be told they aren't trying hard enough. It is degrading, unbelievably painful and BTW it can affect the nicest, kindest and most wonderful people.

Illness doesn't 'make them selfish', they aren't deliberately putting themselves before you. They are terrorised by their illness and it takes over their thoughts. If someone had a broken arm, would it be 'selfish' of them to not play tennis with you?

I understand that people have their own lives to lead but that is enough. There isn't any need to try to justify that with thoughtless comments about people with mental health difficulties being supposedly selfish and lazy.

This is a powerful but true post.

CarmenBizet · 11/01/2023 13:15

ScramblePud · 10/01/2023 21:49

Kindly, people don’t want to be friends with people who are more detrimental to their life than they are positive. The reason doesn’t really come into it. Your mental illness, whilst not your fault, is awful for the people you’re friends with. People don’t want to receive nasty emails or be accused of things that they didn’t do. You’ll get there. You sound as though you’re resilient and reflective and making strides to recover. And, when you do, you’ll have friendships like the rest of the world - keeping in mind that we all have fewer friends than it would seem looking at films and TV shows and social media.

Lots of people are friends with people who have media illnesses but your behaviour sounds very extreme. Your behaviour hurt other people and caused them distress and anxiety and may well have been detrimental to their mental health. Your behaviour is the problem, not your mental health innately. When your mental health is in a place where your behaviour is more positive then the situation will be different.

Good luck OP, and get well soon.

I don't know why people are responding badly to this. It's a balanced, supportive comment. Better than a facile 'people will like you for you OP don't worry'

In a perfect world we'd all have the skills, training, experience and desire to be friends with people even if their actions are causing us distress or stress. We don't live in that world. People will only tolerate friends who are detrimental to their wellbeing for so long, and that's okay. It's okay for people to decide whether they want to remain friends with someone or not. It's never reasonable to think you're entitled to another person's friendship.

It's not that people don't want to be friends with people with a mental illness (some are like that, usually due to misunderstanding, but not the majority). They don't want to be friends with people who are demanding/tiresome/draining over a period of time. And I imagine it's scary for the layperson to receive emails about machetes and being killed.

Consufed · 11/01/2023 13:09

Regarding getting help and trying harder, usually people do make as much effort as they possibly can to get better. However, there is no sure fix. Sometimes there is no medication which helps enough (in treatment resistant illness). And while long term therapy may help somewhat (if the sufferer can afford anything more than what little the NHS can give), it doesn't always make much difference.

Yes, of course it's OK to have boundaries. You can only do what you can do, within reason. However I think people can be a bit too quick to think sufferers are lazy, don't want to recover, etc.Unfortunately recovery can seem an impossible goal, because a symptom of some mental illnesses is 'knowing' everything is dreadfully wrong and can never be made right.

No-one wants to be having horrific thoughts, to lose all their friends, to feel their life is worth nothing, to lose their job, to be told they aren't trying hard enough. It is degrading, unbelievably painful and BTW it can affect the nicest, kindest and most wonderful people.

Illness doesn't 'make them selfish', they aren't deliberately putting themselves before you. They are terrorised by their illness and it takes over their thoughts. If someone had a broken arm, would it be 'selfish' of them to not play tennis with you?

I understand that people have their own lives to lead but that is enough. There isn't any need to try to justify that with thoughtless comments about people with mental health difficulties being supposedly selfish and lazy.

SleeplessInEngland · 11/01/2023 12:56

Most adults are quite busy, with many concerns. Friendships are usually seen as an outlet, a momentary escape from those concerns. It's nice when they're something more, but often they're not. I would try to be understanding of anyone who doesn't feel they have the capacity to support you as a friend in that way.

dragondepressed · 11/01/2023 12:50

Maybe I thought too much of the friendships, because they haven't just been one-sided and I have made an effort with people and gone out of my way to do things for them in the past. However, reciprocity doesn't matter when someone feels on edge or scared due to someone else's behaviour during a psychotic episode. Hopefully, I can make new friends in the future and keep people at a distance. It's been nearly four years since my last episode.

OP posts:
Ladyzfactor · 11/01/2023 10:43

Glad to see some more level headed viewpoints coming through. I was cringing at some showering praise on OP, calling her strong and brave. Before you tear me a new one, she is. But the way it's said implies that she doesn't need help, that she doesn't have to change or try to get better. Because it's always someone else's fault. It like telling a morbidly obese person that they're beautiful. True, but they will still die without change or help. It's ok to be scared, it's ok to be weak. That's how you get help. But it's never anyone's else's responsibility to put themselves on fire to keep you warm.

EndlessRain1 · 11/01/2023 10:30

OP I am really sorry for your experiences.

Like others have said though, often when someone is really adversely impacted by a friendship they may, for their own sake and wellbeing, have to distance themselves from it. That's really sad of course, for both parties, but is true.

I say this knowing what it's like. My brother suffers from Schizophrenia too. He doesn't have many friends which makes me sad for him, but I have also been exposed to his behaviour over the years which, if he wasn't family, would likely have caused me to not continue a relationship with him. In fact there have been times where I have kept a distance during particularly difficult periods (like when he was addicated to/ self mediated with heroin, acted completely irrationally and stole from everyone in the family) to protect myself and my family.

pattihews · 11/01/2023 10:24

This isn't really a friendship you're describing, is it? It looks to me as if perhaps it started as a friendship but degenerated into a one-sided support relationship in which one party (your former friend) was dependent on you.

There are loads of people on MN who post about letting unrewarding friendships slide, even if there are no MH issues involved. Friendships need to be rewarding for both sides. Spending time with a person who only ever needs help, only ever talks about themselves — that's not a friendship.

Aria2015 · 11/01/2023 10:11

@dragondepressed I'm so sorry you've been through so much and have lost friends. I have a lot of empathy for your situation. I was hospitalised in my teens in a psychiatric facility and so have some idea of what it's like to struggle with mental health problems.

I have also have friends that have struggled. I endeavour to always be there for friends and support them, and I have been, but I have had one instance where I have had to step away from a friendship due to that persons mental health issues.

I suspect this friend has borderline personality disorder but is undiagnosed. I tried for many years to support them (I'm talking 10+ years) but in the end it became too much for me.

They probably think I'm an awful person for backing away, but they were so consumed by their own issues (understandable, to a degree) that they had no capacity to see the friendship from my side or to notice I had a lot to deal with in my own life (multiple pregnancy losses, referral for mental health struggles because of said losses, SEN diagnosis for one of my children). When I had the capacity to support them I have and it's mostly been one-sided (me supporting them) and I've done it out of love, but when I didn't have that capacity, I had to step back because I can't give what I don't have and I had to protect my own mental health.

I don't know your friends, but it's possible some have stepped back for similar reasons maybe? It might feel unfair to you, but constant and unwavering support can be hard to give when nearly everyone has their own issues (known or not known to you) to contend with. In my case it's not been done with malice, it's self preservation. Also, I'm my case, I've been hurt by the way this friend has treated me. In my head I know it's down to her mental illness but I'm too sensitive a person to ignore it and it upsets me. I'm maybe not the right friend for her anyway, because of that.

Swipe left for the next trending thread