Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Self employed issue

63 replies

Moonshild · 10/01/2023 21:25

I have worked for the same person/company for over 25 years. When I started I was asked if I would be self employed - I wasn't very keen but at the time I was very keen to do the job. It was during the recession in the 1990's.

Over the years I have done a mixture of full and part time - due to having children. I am now divorced and although my kids are older - I have one woking and one at Uni - I am the parent who does everything for them financially.
As my job is quite physical - it is getting harder as I get older and I am now in my 50's.
I love my job BUT I don't get paid very well - he sets the amount that I get paid per hour, what I do and where/when I work.
Before lockdown my hourly rate wasn't too bad but I did bar work to boost my income. My pay was frozen during lockdown and eventually went up 1% last February.
I am really struggling but every time I broach the subject of a pay increase - he fobs me off. I have tried asking if he will employ me properly - so I get sick pay, holiday pay and have my tax etc done at source BUT he doesn't want to. He says I will be worse off.

I am trying not to be unreasonable about needing a pay increase but I'm really struggling. I need to be able to present him with what is a reasonable amount to pay me.

What do other people charge as an hourly rate for self employed?

Just for context - I get paid £10 per hour and work 35-40 hours per week depending on what work we have.

That has to cover my tax, national insurance, pension, any time off (sick or holiday), my rent, bills food etc.

I have tried looking for other work in my field but there is very little and I think my age now probably counts against me.

I desperately need advise 🙏🏻

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
userxx · 11/01/2023 21:20

Patapouf · 11/01/2023 10:00

That's less than minimum wage!!

That's self-employment for you!

MilkshakesBringAllTheCoosToTheYard · 11/01/2023 11:17

ghjklo · 11/01/2023 10:05

i would get some legal advice, and if it is possible, get a big chunk of money if he owes it! also if you are truly self employed you have every right to ask for an increase in pay which he can either accept or not. If you get a load of cash, leave and use it as a cash backup, then get some proper self employed work where the pay is better!!! Freelancers charge a lot more and for good reason, even for fairly basic jobs.

He doesn't owe her anything though - he'll owe the Inland Revenue a ton of PAYE and NI, but her rate is her rate - can't imagine there'll be any way she can force him to back pay an increased hourly rate. That's why I think she should move on, there's actually nothing to be gained here.

BitOutOfPractice · 11/01/2023 11:02

OP if you look on this page on the government web site there's a link to an online check to see if your employment status is right

Believ · 11/01/2023 10:58

@FairyBatman ok so I think you're just talking about the holidays affecting it being paid or unpaid?

But my figures are still very different to yours. If only thinking about the benefit of paid annual leave and BH, the hourly rate would need to be £10.95 compared to the £9.75. £10.95 and then taking the 28 days unpaid per year works out the same as £9.75 and 28 days paid.

Moonshild · 11/01/2023 10:19

Thank you again - this is all very helpful. I have tried to apply for super market jobs in the past to ‘get out’ but I never get a response! You have to fill in forms online and it is not as straightforward as people think.

I am lucky that I do a job I enjoy but I would like to get paid properly so I can get through each month without panicking that I have enough money - which has got harder as the cost of living goes up.
I am going to contact ACAS for advice.

OP posts:
newtb · 11/01/2023 10:08

Also OP being self-employed means you can claim for all your Travel to work at hmrc rates, or if the mileage rates don't cover costs you can claim Real rates but, for that, you need to Split costs on the basisbof personal/ private:use. You can go back 6 tax years, too.

ghjklo · 11/01/2023 10:05

i would get some legal advice, and if it is possible, get a big chunk of money if he owes it! also if you are truly self employed you have every right to ask for an increase in pay which he can either accept or not. If you get a load of cash, leave and use it as a cash backup, then get some proper self employed work where the pay is better!!! Freelancers charge a lot more and for good reason, even for fairly basic jobs.

Patapouf · 11/01/2023 10:00

That's less than minimum wage!!

pigsinoodies · 11/01/2023 09:49

MilkshakesBringAllTheCoosToTheYard · 11/01/2023 09:31

She doesn't set her own hours or rates, use her own equipment and I bet she couldn't send a sub. That's three 'fails' from her posts alone. I agree in some IR35 relationships it's almost impossible to tell the difference but this is not that.

The OP doesn't mention whether she uses her own equipment or not. The rates charged are invoiced as 'agreed' with her main 'client' and aren't necessarily a pointer against self-employment and while your 'bet' may well be correct we don't know that she hasn't the right to send a substitute.

Any mention of IR35 is a complete irrelevance unless the OP is working through a limited company.

MilkshakesBringAllTheCoosToTheYard · 11/01/2023 09:35

@raspberrymeringue I do think you're right. Reporting him won't lead him to raise her rate and could lead to a lot of unpleasantness. I think she should report him, but from the safety of a new job!

OP honestly you'd be better off in a supermarket than working for this guy but that said, signwriting is really skilled. Could you go elsewhere? Transition into the office (elsewhere!). Teach at your local college? Get a driving job or a job in facilities management?

When someone's been ripping the piss out of you for 20-odd the years the best answer isn't to get your rate up a bit, it's to go elsewhere.

ChildminderMum · 11/01/2023 09:34

Moonshild · 10/01/2023 22:34

Thank you all - I now have more information to do something.
I invoice him weekly and pay my own tax and national insurance but it’s a struggle. I very occasionally work for other people but it is only occasionally as he makes it difficult for me to do so.
I have tried contacting the Citizens Advice and have sent several emails that I have not had replies from and tried calling but there is never any response.

Call ACAS and at least find out where you stand.

MilkshakesBringAllTheCoosToTheYard · 11/01/2023 09:31

pigsinoodies · 11/01/2023 07:58

Depending on exactly how OP operates it's entirely possible that they may pass the tests for self-employment. It's also entirely possible that they don't. Nobody has bothered to establish the pertinent facts before jumping to the conclusion that OP is an employee.

She doesn't set her own hours or rates, use her own equipment and I bet she couldn't send a sub. That's three 'fails' from her posts alone. I agree in some IR35 relationships it's almost impossible to tell the difference but this is not that.

raspberrymeringue · 11/01/2023 09:27

@Butchyrestingface I agree and having another job lined up would give her leverage in the current one. Still no guarantee. It depends how expendable her current employer thinks she is. As she’s sucked it up for 25 years he probably thinks he doesn’t have to try to hard.

blondieminx · 11/01/2023 09:23

You also need to urgently look at your state pension contributions - don’t stick your head in the sand, have a read of this and check your state pension record to ensure you will get as much as possible

Martin Lewis Money Saving Expert article on pensions

State pension checker

Butchyrestingface · 11/01/2023 09:21

raspberrymeringue · 11/01/2023 09:15

@pigsinoodies That’s true. But she works for a small firm, not Amazon or Tesco with a reputation to protect. She has contact with her boss on a regular basis. She reports him to HMRC and he quite rightly gets in lots of trouble, owes thousands in undeclared ni and taxes etc, and she keeps her job in a lovely happy work environment, on paye with higher pay plus holiday etc. Can you honestly imagine that happening? That’s all I’m saying.

He'll sack her or simply tell her that her self-employed (har-de-har) services are not needed anymore. But since she'd be better off working on the checkouts at Waitrose, it hardly feels like a huge loss. I appreciate OP may not see it that way.

raspberrymeringue · 11/01/2023 09:20

I suppose OP could report him anonymously and hmrc might investigate. But that could take ages and still might not have the desired outcome.

raspberrymeringue · 11/01/2023 09:15

@pigsinoodies That’s true. But she works for a small firm, not Amazon or Tesco with a reputation to protect. She has contact with her boss on a regular basis. She reports him to HMRC and he quite rightly gets in lots of trouble, owes thousands in undeclared ni and taxes etc, and she keeps her job in a lovely happy work environment, on paye with higher pay plus holiday etc. Can you honestly imagine that happening? That’s all I’m saying.

pigsinoodies · 11/01/2023 09:00

@raspberrymeringue the situation is rather different from anybody in a PAYE job - the OP earns less than NLW, and presumably receives no holiday pay.

raspberrymeringue · 11/01/2023 08:55

Hi Op. I voted that you are not being unreasonable but, you’ve had a lot of useful information and advice on here but they miss the point of your original question, which was how can I get him to pay me more. The answer is that you can’t. You can go to Acas , Hmrc, maybe get him in a lot of trouble with the revenue etc, but will that get you more pay ? It might get you a one off lump sum of arrears and if that’s your aim go for it. You can find comparable jobs and show them to him, but if he says he can’t pay a higher rate your options seem to be suck it up or get a different job. I don’t mean to be mean, but in all likelihood if you do some of the things suggested and he ends up paying the hmrc loads in backdated employers ni etc (and maybe quite rightly) that might be great as an up yours, last hurrah , but I can’t see it leading to higher pay whilst continuing the job you’re doing. Why don’t you look for a better paid job with proper benefits elsewhere? Whilst your situation is unusual and potentially you could get him in a lot of trouble, otherwise the fact that the pay isn’t what you deserve or need isn’t different from many other people in paye jobs.

Kinnorafron · 11/01/2023 08:53

TheHateIsNotGood · 10/01/2023 22:15

Apols OP - it's not known as IR35 anymore - but use the CEST (as now known) online tool to determine/advise on your employment status.

Then of course you need to check if you're in one of the Special Rules occupations (link below).

Seems now that those that do best out of employment are those that seek the best T&Cs from working, not those that are best at working at the jobs that they do.

www.gov.uk/hmrc-internal-manuals/employment-status-manual/esm4000

FFS it is still IR35 and still only applies if OP is a director of their own limited company. Why do people who know so little post on here?

MrsJackRackham · 11/01/2023 08:48

@userxx what sort of reference? If they are paying CG through SA the payment reference should be on their online Personal Tax Account. It begins with an X and is 14 or 15 digets long.

FairyBatman · 11/01/2023 08:30

Sorry maybe the above wasn't really clear.

A PAYE employee earning £9.75 ph and working 35 hours per week will bring home net salary of £16,950 pa. Included in that will be 20 days holiday plus bank holidays.

A self-employed person on £10 ph 35 hours per week and assuming the same holidays will bring home £12,474 net of taxes and NI

To bring home the equivalent of an employee earning minimum wage you need to be paid a rate of just over £13 per hour. £13 would result in a net income of £16,072.

Some things like expenses, pensions might change the figures.

pigsinoodies · 11/01/2023 08:23

Yes, substitution, plus level of control over how the work is carried out, investment in equipment (a van maybe?), mutuality of obligation, etc.

It's also entirely possible to meet the tests for self-employment while still passing the tests for a 'worker' - i.e. to be responsible for SE tax and NI but to be treated as a 'worker' with regards to minimum wage and holiday pay entitlement.

Aprilx · 11/01/2023 08:10

pigsinoodies · 11/01/2023 07:58

Depending on exactly how OP operates it's entirely possible that they may pass the tests for self-employment. It's also entirely possible that they don't. Nobody has bothered to establish the pertinent facts before jumping to the conclusion that OP is an employee.

Established beyond all doubt, maybe not. But there is a lot in what OP has said to indicate that this should have been treated as employment. The other party sets the pay rate, determines when the work is done and where, she works more or less exclusively for the one “employer” etc.

Yes there are other tests to explore. I like the substitution one, OP, could you send somebody else along in your place if you wished?

arethereanyleftatall · 11/01/2023 08:08

Op, as he asked you to be SE, it is you who sets your salary, not him. So. It's you who says, my rates are £13 ph, it is then his choice if he chooses to use you or not.

You need to be prepared to walk away from this job. He has exploited you for years. Working ANYWHERE legal will give you more pay than this - Tesco, McDonald's,etc all crying out for staff at the moment.

I would have a quick check round my area to see if there is a job you can move to, and if yes, tell him your rates are now £13 ph and he can take it or leave it.

Whilst he might use, 'you won't find anywhere else' against you, you can use 'you won't find anyone to work for the pay you offer' against him.

Swipe left for the next trending thread